You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 30 of 44 < 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Dec 18 1.27pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

85% of our buys have been great! You are very glass half empty. A bit more depth would be nice but our quality has improved over the last 5 years.
I happen to like selhurst park as it is, the ethiad was borring and soulless.

I am a happy realistic palace fan, sorry your not.

You’ll notice what we’ve achieved and how far we’ve come if or when we’re relegated. After 2 seasons, or probably 1, you wouldn’t think we’d even been in the premier league. That should be Parish’s measure of how good a chairman he’s been long term and at the end of his reign, rather than announcing himself as the best chairman and owner we’ve ever had. Build a stand before trying to claim that.

 


COYP

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 29 Dec 18 1.58pm

Originally posted by steve1984

Except for our continued presence in it.


Good shout Steve.

Which promoted team has ever 'achieved' any kind of singular or instant success since the Prem started?
Swansea, Portsmouth, Wigan, Leicester? A handful, and most are now languishing elsewhere.

It's a gravy train and the mere fact that the top teams continue to smash old records just goes to show what a closed shop it is. The rich just keep getting richer.
Hell, even a spot in Europe is now seen as detrimental to one's league performances.

Average 25,000+ crowds, never before known at Selhurst, some fun scalps of the big boys, international players, MOTD and Sky coverage as a given, relative credibility at work among our armchair United & Liverpool fans, a Cup Final, apparent solvency.... things could certainly be a lot worse. And it's not all down to luck.

 


Spirit of 1974

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Dec 18 2.15pm

Originally posted by bifffabazz


Good shout Steve.

Which promoted team has ever 'achieved' any kind of singular or instant success since the Prem started?
Swansea, Portsmouth, Wigan, Leicester? A handful, and most are now languishing elsewhere.

It's a gravy train and the mere fact that the top teams continue to smash old records just goes to show what a closed shop it is. The rich just keep getting richer.
Hell, even a spot in Europe is now seen as detrimental to one's league performances.

Average 25,000+ crowds, never before known at Selhurst, some fun scalps of the big boys, international players, MOTD and Sky coverage as a given, relative credibility at work among our armchair United & Liverpool fans, a Cup Final, apparent solvency.... things could certainly be a lot worse. And it's not all down to luck.

We’re not talking about success, instant or otherwise. We’re talking about having something to show for it. Something to make and keep us competitive, again, like proper scouting, youth set up and transfer policies, because so far the only thing has been having the 9th highest wage bill with, ahem, 25,000 crowds and silence over this new stand. Hopefully we’re going to get it right but January is only a year back.

 


COYP

steve1984 29 Dec 18 3.34pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Won’t be tangible if we’re relegated, and I think we know what we’re talking about.

I think there are only about 6 PL clubs that can be considered safe from the threat of relegation.

Just out of curiosity which clubs have finished in the top 12 of the PL in say 4 of the last 5 seasons? Chelsea, Spuz, Arsenal, the 2 Manchester clubs, Liverpool and maybe Everton. Haven't the remaining 5 places gone to a whole load of different clubs?

Edited by steve1984 (29 Dec 2018 3.41pm)

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 29 Dec 18 5.18pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You’ll notice what we’ve achieved and how far we’ve come if or when we’re relegated. After 2 seasons, or probably 1, you wouldn’t think we’d even been in the premier league. That should be Parish’s measure of how good a chairman he’s been long term and at the end of his reign, rather than announcing himself as the best chairman and owner we’ve ever had. Build a stand before trying to claim that.

Who's desperate for a new stand? I'm not!

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 29 Dec 18 5.27pm

Only 9 teams have never been relegated from the prem, we have been in it about a quarter of it since it started. Not to shabby!!

 

est1905 Flag 29 Dec 18 5.34pm

Originally posted by OhSouthLondon!

I don’t think you can fault too many of the players efforts. Tomkins had a poor game but he usually gives 110%.

The main problem as we all know is a lack of a striker. BUT we have known about this problem since the summer and yet we didn’t buy a goal scorer. We have absolutely nothing to aim at up top and time and time again it costs us.

Is that Roy’s fault or the boards?

Edited by Midlands Eagle (05 Dec 2018 7.51am)

All Roy can do is identify the weaknesses in his team/squad and the players he feels will solve that problem. I imagine as a go between Freedman will compile a list of affordable targets that RH will approve/veto and then its up to the board to come up with the money and convince the player to come and his club to sell.
Of course its 100% down to the board. Managers haven't really been responsible for signing players for years. Only identifying those that they want.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Dec 18 6.08pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Who's desperate for a new stand? I'm not!

It’s the revenue and the competitiveness it brings that you should want because the current tin shed puts us at a disadvantage.

 


COYP

Den1923 Flag 29 Dec 18 6.40pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’s the revenue and the competitiveness it brings that you should want because the current tin shed puts us at a disadvantage.

Surely, it is being in the PL that brings in the revenue, first you need a team that can secure that position and the revenue, then the shed should follow and not the other way round?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Dec 18 6.57pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Surely, it is being in the PL that brings in the revenue, first you need a team that can secure that position and the revenue, then the shed should follow and not the other way round?

If it were the case that just being in the Prem brought in revenue then we wouldn’t have West Ham gazumping us on players.

If we were waiting for a team to make a new stand worthwhile then it may never happen. Every club redevelops with a plan in place with the team to follow. It’s how you do it and how you grow any business. You don’t wait for sales or success first because it doesn’t land for you like that.

 


COYP

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 Dec 18 8.50pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If it were the case that just being in the Prem brought in revenue then we wouldn’t have West Ham gazumping us on players.

If we were waiting for a team to make a new stand worthwhile then it may never happen. Every club redevelops with a plan in place with the team to follow. It’s how you do it and how you grow any business. You don’t wait for sales or success first because it doesn’t land for you like that.

We are gazumped by Wet Spam because they were handed a new ground on a plate and they don’t have to worry about ground improvements any more.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Dec 18 9.13pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We are gazumped by Wet Spam because they were handed a new ground on a plate and they don’t have to worry about ground improvements any more.

They had more money than us at Upton Park too. So does every club with bigger attendances.

 


COYP

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 29 Dec 18 9.35pm

Think there's a few Arsenal and Everton fans out there tonight who'd be over the moon with Roy and a solid, well organised set up that keeps the ball and doesn't give away a lot of goals.

Arsenal were a wishy washy shower of sh!t. Dick Emery could do better.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 29 Dec 18 11.36pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We are gazumped by Wet Spam because they were handed a new ground on a plate and they don’t have to worry about ground improvements any more.


They wasn't handed anything it was good business move from the owners planning out the future.


Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

They had more money than us at Upton Park too. So does every club with bigger attendances.


True they did have more funds because of the owners who are much better business men then ours and willing to pump funds into the club.

attendances have nothing to do with it that is just a little extra on the side in the grand scheme of things.

Edited by grumpymort (29 Dec 2018 11.38pm)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Dec 18 11.44pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


True they did have more funds because of the owners who are much better business men then ours and willing to pump funds into the club.

attendances have nothing to do with it that is just a little extra on the side in the grand scheme of things.

Edited by grumpymort (29 Dec 2018 11.38pm)

Attendance revenue, merchandising and sponsorship can have everything to do with it. It can be a £20 million edge in our half of the table. Why do you think Spurs want a 60,000 stadium if ‘it has nothing to do with it and it’s just a little bit extra?’ Quite amusing.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 30 Dec 18 1.49am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Attendance revenue, merchandising and sponsorship can have everything to do with it. It can be a £20 million edge in our half of the table. Why do you think Spurs want a 60,000 stadium if ‘it has nothing to do with it and it’s just a little bit extra?’ Quite amusing.


I said attendances nothing about those others you tried to add in their together.

Why did spurs want a 60 thousand ground it's not to do with just football go look at the figures attendances regarding football really do not matter much at all.

They wanted 60 for other reason which would be like holding other events remember they signed deal with American football.

[Link]

tv and sponsorship is the big money stuff.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 30 Dec 18 4.22am

It boils down to this, if in May we are relegated, for whatever reason, would we have anything to show for it?

After 6 years of TV money do we have a better:

Youth Academy?

Training Ground?

Scouting network?

Stadium (wether it be bars, lounge, corporate etc)

This is why Cardiff only spent 30 mil and why Huddersfield spent around 50 mil each year. Because if they went down, it's not the end of the world and parachute payments are a huge incentive and wouldn't be wasted on fees.

So let's look at 2013 to now..

30 mil, 30 mil, 25 mil, 90 mil, 44 mil, 10 mil.

It's obvious at the 4th season, we didn't or hadn't invested properly and went against our sensible 'budget' and back tracked. But what is the real reason for this? Well, after 3 years and 4 managers you are bound to have an uneven squad, managers come in and want to slowly build their squad over 3 windows. Sam Alardyce needed to put out the fire and did what he felt was necessary, we've been paying for it since.
It wouldn't have been too bad if we had sold someone last summer, but we didn't and couldn't - long contracts, players that other prem clubs aren't really interested in and players that if we sold, we would have to replace and spend probably more.

Imagine the scenario that Holloway was a good fix and we survived, he gets another 50 mil to invest, we survive and and get another 50, that's a sensible and realistic way. But when you panic, splash out that's when the money goes.

 


This was once a quality forum....

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 30 Dec 18 7.39am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Please explain.

I'm with you there, makes no sense to me Holloway said himself that he left because of pressure and not being up to the job

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 30 Dec 18 7.47am

Originally posted by Painter

Parish is first and foremost a businessman and profit is the main inspiration, this is the same for any other Premier owner.
It cant be denied that he has overseen the most sustained successful period in Palaces history. He has had some luck on the way and made some mistakes, but the positives far outweigh the negatives.
Smug fans who think they know how a club should be run, think its easy. If a constant spend on players isn't forth coming they demand he sells up. Why would he do that? He knows the club is unable to progress any further without a bigger income stream ( enhanced stadium ) and thriving academy, which Jordan abandoned after the Bostock saga. Building up an academy takes time, so does improving the Stadium, but some think it should be done in an instant.
Reality is difficult for some to grasp.

He is also a Palace fan, has been for years before he bought the club, seems to me its an advantage to have an Owner Fan,

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 30 Dec 18 7.54am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Does that include paying £8m for a centre forward that the selling club had bought just a few months earlier for £400,000 plus a Polish central defender that most think is lower division class plus the infamous Erdal Rakip who we had on loan and who never once set foot on the hallowed turf of Selhurst Park.

No it doesn't, but it does include just about eevery other 1st team player and most of the bench, players we could only dream about a few years ago.

 

Page 30 of 44 < 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?