You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 2.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 31 of 187 < 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 May 14 12.33am

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.15am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 12.09am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2014 11.43pm

Even the Left want out of Europe, with the likes of the No2EU party campaigning to get out. I find it strange how Lefties on here don't seem to agree.


I'll be honest and say I'm not sure what we should do. It would be good to get a balanced view on the ins and outs of being in or out. Not really seen one anywhere, have you?

I thought you would have known about the No2EU group? If not, then you should considering your activism. If they had any backing then they could have united with UKIP and made a difference!

The trouble is the far Left would rather act in an aggressive, negative way by hollering abuse and attacking Farage on his travels instead of being positive and debating and forming a credible opposition .

Of course I know about No2EU. To be fair there's no way they'd join with UKIP as Farage's lot seem to be made up of xenophobes and people who think the tories aren't right wing enough. Beyond the EU question, UKIP want to erode worker's rights and proliferate the neoliberal agenda - No2EU have polar opposite views on why we should be out of the EU.

However, knowing about the different parties and their stances is entirely different to having a balanced view presented by the media of the pros and cons.

 

The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 12.42am

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am

My initial point was about market towns in the country. I didn't say every market town. You say you live in one but don't say where?? (You know where I live and it's pretty diverse, unlike where you do I imagine!)

Rule one of the internet; don't tell strangers where you live. You initiated combat in this debate by defining two weapons, one being living in a market town. You can't take that weapon off the table now you realise that I am holding it. By your own definition, my opinion is more legitimate than yours.

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am

And you've missed the point re Boston! If you lived in a market town affected by a huge influx of Eastern Europeans like that has happened there which has impacted your life then you would be bothered. But it hasn't happened in your town so you don't care about other people, do you? Living in a bubble and to hell with anybody else's concerns or worries as you are ok, right?

Delicious irony in a right-winger using this argument! I care about people who are unemployed, hence why I support things like promising long-term unemployed people a guaranteed job from the state.

My argument is that immigration actually increases employment by enhancing the economy and the public finances, so it's less about not caring about the problem, more disagreeing that immigration is causing it.

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am

Your dismissive nature to people who have concerns about drastic changes in demographics is just as arrogant as Gordon Brown's to "bigoted" Gillian Duffy. And the same as the main party leaders who don't care. Why do you think Farage has become popular? Why do you think rightly or wrongly, they have focused their ad campaign on immigration. There's a reason for it!

The reason is that people think immigration is the source of social problems. I, like Gordon Brown, disagree with that statement. Gillian Duffy was a cretin and the only issue I have with Gordon Brown is that he didn't tell her that to her face.

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am

So the economy is is more important, in your view. However, it doesn't mean we should not discuss immigration

It's not more important in my view, I wouldn't put either issue in my top two, but that's pretty irrelevant to the discussion.

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am

And immigration is the biggest issue affecting the EU debate with the Euro elections coming up. You and the chattering classes like to brush chat of immigration under the carpet "It's not important".

I don't want to brush anything under the carpet. Surely if this debate demonstrates one thing, it's that I'm happy to discuss immigration. I just think the EU has a positive effect upon immigration as I think it has a positive effect upon our economy, so I'm unlikely to have the same level of interest in these areas as a right-winger.

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am

Well it is. And it's the Westminster parties' fault for not talking about it that has led to the rise of
UKIP and the debate.

The Tories ran a general election campaign heavily based on the immigration debate in 2001/2005 (I can't remember which) and lost. The old "are you thinking what we're thinking on immigration" nonsense. In the leaders' debates last time, it was discussed a fair bit, Cameron even made a pretty bold pledge. It's been a major political issue for decades.

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am

Farage didn't join UKIP because he was fed up with the immigrants in his town - because there aren't any in Sevenoaks. He did it because he disagreed with the political union! So your analogy simply does not work.

Wasn't aware I was making an analogy. I agree with political union, so surely my view is as valid as his?

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 12.54am

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.23am

To White Horse. We both completely disagree on this. However, we live in a democracy and the people need to decide about the in/out question in a referendum. I suspect you don't even want that in case people say OUT!

We live in a representative democracy, where you elect an MP and they make decisions on your behalf. You can't just pick and choose the type of democracy you have based upon whether it reflects your views at a particular time.

If you want to argue for some sort of Swiss model of referendums via some sort of democratic petitioning mechanism, I'd probably be all for it, I think generally speaking the public are fairly poorly served by the current system.

But you're not, you're arguing for a brief switch to direct democracy on an issue that matters to you, then a return to representative democracy. Do you want a vote on the renationalisation of the railways, or utilities, or the post office? When was the last time the British public had their democratic say on those issues, eh?

If you're fed up with MPs not voting to leave the EU, vote UKIP in the general election, don't pointlessly "protest" a year before a general election each time and then go back to voting Tory. The reason the issues of immigration and the EU aren't more prominent is that people keep voting for parties who don't really give a toss about those issues.

Last time UKIP's vote was 16.5% and then went straight back to 3.1%, Cameron isn't totally thick and will realise that his supporters don't have the balls to vote UKIP again. And therein lies the basic problem for the referendum-wanting voter. Ultimately, the party most likely to give you a referendum simply won't win a general election. And even the second most likely party probably won't either.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

matt_himself Flag Matataland 17 May 14 6.44am

Nigel Farage is a Palace fan!

[Link]

This is joyous!

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

kangel Flag 17 May 14 10.13am

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 12.54am

Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.23am

To White Horse. We both completely disagree on this. However, we live in a democracy and the people need to decide about the in/out question in a referendum. I suspect you don't even want that in case people say OUT!

We live in a representative democracy, where you elect an MP and they make decisions on your behalf. You can't just pick and choose the type of democracy you have based upon whether it reflects your views at a particular time.

Not in the EU we don't. Not only do you have to vote for a party en bloc regardless of whether you like or dislike a candidate within that party block, your choice of party is then downgraded if that party is too popular. The following is from an electoral commission website:

In a given region the allocated seats are awarded using a quota system. The quota is the total number of votes received by a party or independent candidate divided by the number of seats already gained in that region +1.

So, for a party with no seats the number of votes received is divided by one, and so stays the same. If the party already has one seat then its number of votes is divided by two, if it has two seats it is divided by three, and so on.

This means that the more seats you have already won, the harder it is to gain extra seats, so the overall allocation of seats is more proportional to the number of votes received.

The first seat that a party wins goes to the first person on its list, the second seat to the second person, and so on, until the party has either not won any more seats or has run out of names on its list. An independent candidate is treated as though he or she were a party with only one name on its list.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 May 14 10.17am

Quote matt_himself at 17 May 2014 6.44am

Nigel Farage is a Palace fan!

This is joyous!

I think he went to 'Dulwich College' and lives near Biggin Hill.
Perhaps UKIP stands for :
U Know I'm Palace !

 

kangel Flag 17 May 14 10.27am

Quote Willo at 17 May 2014 10.17am

Quote matt_himself at 17 May 2014 6.44am

Nigel Farage is a Palace fan!

This is joyous!

I think he went to 'Dulwich College' and lives near Biggin Hill.
Perhaps UKIP stands for :
U Know I'm Palace !

In 2001 when it became known that Osama Bin Laden was an Arsenal fan who had atteneded several games at Highbury, an Arsenal FC spokesman said: "Clearly he wouldn't be welcome at Highbury in the future." I expect they banned him from their on-line forums too (or maybe not).

 

Hoof Hearted 17 May 14 11.05am

Quote matt_himself at 17 May 2014 6.44am

Nigel Farage is a Palace fan!

[Link]

This is joyous!


Get in!!!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 May 14 11.21am

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 12.42am

I care about people who are unemployed, hence why I support things like promising long-term unemployed people a guaranteed job from the state.

My argument is that immigration actually increases employment by enhancing the economy and the public finances, so it's less about not caring about the problem, more disagreeing that immigration is causing it.


This is true if the immigrants are creating positions. This is not the case. Unfortunately most, which is what UKIP and plenty of us on here are opposed to, the huge quantity of immigrants, come to the UK taking up jobs that were advertised whether they were here or not. What plenty have done is keeping prices down of a few pence on supermarket fruit and veg and providing cheaper labour in construction because plenty are prepared to share a 1 bed flat between 3 and possibly do that for a few years before going back home with the money. Apart from a few East European deli-markets and a few more fine dining type Indian restaurants, this is pretty much the case.

So they're filling the same positions a Brit would fill and overall paying less tax and NI. If Labour had nudged a few people into job searching as the tories have done and into some of the positions they've filled and clamped down on supermarket-farmer pressure on prices then they would've gone a long way to addressing this.

 


COYP

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 May 14 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

 

Hoof Hearted 17 May 14 11.32am

Why is everybody so obsessed about the effect on the economy with immigration?

Surely the more worrying aspect is the effect on our infrastructure?

It's bad enough here in Bristol, but in the south east it must be unbearable trying to get places by road or rail, see a doctor, get your child in a local school, buy a house etc etc.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 May 14 11.42am

Immigration isn't the only thing to blame for problems in this country but I don't see the benefit in adding more and more people to the country when it is a problem and there are other problems to address. It is also mind boggling how we let the population grow, with the help of immigration, without having any sort of plan or action in providing housing and space to cater for everyone. All whilst plenty of pro-immigration voters live in countryside utopia.

 


COYP

kangel Flag 17 May 14 11.47am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

Shock-horror - George Chesterton, production editor for the Guardian as well as a blogger for the Guardian's Comment is Free and the New Statesman, doesn't like UKIP - who would have thought it.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 May 14 11.51am

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 11.47am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

Shock-horror - George Chesterton, production editor for the Guardian as well as a blogger for the Guardian's Comment is Free and the New Statesman, doesn't like UKIP - who would have thought it.


So you'll criticise the author but not what he's written. Does this mean you agree with it? If not, what in particular do you disagree with in the article and why?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 May 14 11.59am

[Link]
BNP accuses UKIP of racism!


UKIP's immigration policy discriminates against white Europeans, whereas our immigration policy is non-discriminatory. We don't pick on white people from Europe: we don't care where you come from, black or Asian or white, we don't want you. We think that is a non-racist position.

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 17 May 14 12.09pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 11.47am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

Shock-horror - George Chesterton, production editor for the Guardian as well as a blogger for the Guardian's Comment is Free and the New Statesman, doesn't like UKIP - who would have thought it.

"Exchange rule by the elite for rule by the mob"

That is exactly right and the potential has always been there. After Enoch Powell's Rivers of Blood speech Richard Crossman noted that the reaction among ordinary people was a genuine uprising by the industrial proletariat against the accepted norms of the intelligencia. The truth of the matter is that none of the main political parties actually represent the views of the average Sun or Daily Mail reader. The political chattering classes have nothing but contempt for the simple minded views of the "man on the street".
UKIP have tapped into that constituency and it is now a race to the bottom to see how the main parties adapt their policies to get those votes back.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

kangel Flag 17 May 14 12.16pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.51am

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 11.47am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

Shock-horror - George Chesterton, production editor for the Guardian as well as a blogger for the Guardian's Comment is Free and the New Statesman, doesn't like UKIP - who would have thought it.


So you'll criticise the author but not what he's written. Does this mean you agree with it? If not, what in particular do you disagree with in the article and why?

Which particular parts of the general abuse of UKIP and its supporters, and the frantic attempts to divert from the core issue of UKIP - being in the EU - would you like addressed? (Or perhaps the bit about how Labour would fix everything?)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 May 14 12.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 12.16pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.51am

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 11.47am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

Shock-horror - George Chesterton, production editor for the Guardian as well as a blogger for the Guardian's Comment is Free and the New Statesman, doesn't like UKIP - who would have thought it.


So you'll criticise the author but not what he's written. Does this mean you agree with it? If not, what in particular do you disagree with in the article and why?

Which particular parts of the general abuse of UKIP and its supporters, and the frantic attempts to divert from the core issue of UKIP - being in the EU - would you like addressed? (Or perhaps the bit about how Labour would fix everything?)

Labour sold their soul to the devil years ago, they won't do jack. What about ukip beyond the European question?

the public expressions of the UKIP hierarchy reveal a passion for complete deregulation of the workforce, even deeper cuts to benefits and social services, the end of maternity leave, the end of all renewable energy investment and the privatisation of the NHS.

How do these policies help the man in the street?

Edited by nickgusset (17 May 2014 12.25pm)

 

kangel Flag 17 May 14 12.23pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 12.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 12.16pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.51am

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 11.47am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

Shock-horror - George Chesterton, production editor for the Guardian as well as a blogger for the Guardian's Comment is Free and the New Statesman, doesn't like UKIP - who would have thought it.


So you'll criticise the author but not what he's written. Does this mean you agree with it? If not, what in particular do you disagree with in the article and why?

Which particular parts of the general abuse of UKIP and its supporters, and the frantic attempts to divert from the core issue of UKIP - being in the EU - would you like addressed? (Or perhaps the bit about how Labour would fix everything?)

Labour sold their soul to the devil years ago, they won't do jack.

Who do you support (other than Palace - we have at least that in common) then?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 May 14 12.27pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 12.23pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 12.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 12.16pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.51am

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 11.47am

Quote nickgusset at 17 May 2014 11.27am

[Link]

Some food for thought...

Shock-horror - George Chesterton, production editor for the Guardian as well as a blogger for the Guardian's Comment is Free and the New Statesman, doesn't like UKIP - who would have thought it.


So you'll criticise the author but not what he's written. Does this mean you agree with it? If not, what in particular do you disagree with in the article and why?

Which particular parts of the general abuse of UKIP and its supporters, and the frantic attempts to divert from the core issue of UKIP - being in the EU - would you like addressed? (Or perhaps the bit about how Labour would fix everything?)

Labour sold their soul to the devil years ago, they won't do jack.

Who do you support (other than Palace - we have at least that in common) then?


I think the Greens sit closely with my philosophies, as do the TUSC - however as a fledgling party they will make no mark.

 

Page 31 of 187 < 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic