Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am
My initial point was about market towns in the country. I didn't say every market town. You say you live in one but don't say where?? (You know where I live and it's pretty diverse, unlike where you do I imagine!)
Rule one of the internet; don't tell strangers where you live. You initiated combat in this debate by defining two weapons, one being living in a market town. You can't take that weapon off the table now you realise that I am holding it. By your own definition, my opinion is more legitimate than yours.
Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am
And you've missed the point re Boston! If you lived in a market town affected by a huge influx of Eastern Europeans like that has happened there which has impacted your life then you would be bothered. But it hasn't happened in your town so you don't care about other people, do you? Living in a bubble and to hell with anybody else's concerns or worries as you are ok, right?
Delicious irony in a right-winger using this argument! I care about people who are unemployed, hence why I support things like promising long-term unemployed people a guaranteed job from the state.
My argument is that immigration actually increases employment by enhancing the economy and the public finances, so it's less about not caring about the problem, more disagreeing that immigration is causing it.
Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am
Your dismissive nature to people who have concerns about drastic changes in demographics is just as arrogant as Gordon Brown's to "bigoted" Gillian Duffy. And the same as the main party leaders who don't care. Why do you think Farage has become popular? Why do you think rightly or wrongly, they have focused their ad campaign on immigration. There's a reason for it!
The reason is that people think immigration is the source of social problems. I, like Gordon Brown, disagree with that statement. Gillian Duffy was a cretin and the only issue I have with Gordon Brown is that he didn't tell her that to her face.
Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am
So the economy is is more important, in your view. However, it doesn't mean we should not discuss immigration
It's not more important in my view, I wouldn't put either issue in my top two, but that's pretty irrelevant to the discussion.
Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am
And immigration is the biggest issue affecting the EU debate with the Euro elections coming up. You and the chattering classes like to brush chat of immigration under the carpet "It's not important".
I don't want to brush anything under the carpet. Surely if this debate demonstrates one thing, it's that I'm happy to discuss immigration. I just think the EU has a positive effect upon immigration as I think it has a positive effect upon our economy, so I'm unlikely to have the same level of interest in these areas as a right-winger.
Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am
Well it is. And it's the Westminster parties' fault for not talking about it that has led to the rise of UKIP and the debate.
The Tories ran a general election campaign heavily based on the immigration debate in 2001/2005 (I can't remember which) and lost. The old "are you thinking what we're thinking on immigration" nonsense. In the leaders' debates last time, it was discussed a fair bit, Cameron even made a pretty bold pledge. It's been a major political issue for decades.
Quote Penge Eagle at 17 May 2014 12.07am
Farage didn't join UKIP because he was fed up with the immigrants in his town - because there aren't any in Sevenoaks. He did it because he disagreed with the political union! So your analogy simply does not work.
Wasn't aware I was making an analogy. I agree with political union, so surely my view is as valid as his?
"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee
|