You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 31 of 44 < 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 >
7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 2.15am

.

IMG_1673.JPG Attachment: IMG_1673.JPG (1,192.41Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 2.16am

.

IMG_1820.JPG Attachment: IMG_1820.JPG (36.97Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 2.16am

.

IMG_1760.JPG Attachment: IMG_1760.JPG (1,553.18Kb)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 18 Dec 16 7.32am

Originally posted by nickgusset

See my previous post.


Which is not really relevant to my point (as, quite obviously, I used the cctv example as that was the bit that was topical in those posts).
I'm saying (and I do not mean this disrespectfully) that you would back the union whatever the circumstances and 7 mins is anti-southern regardless and again would back anyone against them.
I'm simply stating that no one is really looking at the whole pie and that's the problem. All sides are so entrenched in their own positions that if this entire situation were reversed you'd still back the same horse (so to speak) and do a complete u-turn on your reasons.

Or wouldn't you? If this entire situation were reversed would you support Southern on the issue of safety and against the union?

Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 7.47am)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Dec 16 8.35am

Originally posted by Helmet46


Which is not really relevant to my point (as, quite obviously, I used the cctv example as that was the bit that was topical in those posts).
I'm saying (and I do not mean this disrespectfully) that you would back the union whatever the circumstances and 7 mins is anti-southern regardless and again would back anyone against them.
I'm simply stating that no one is really looking at the whole pie and that's the problem. All sides are so entrenched in their own positions that if this entire situation were reversed you'd still back the same horse (so to speak) and do a complete u-turn on your reasons.

Or wouldn't you? If this entire situation were reversed would you support Southern on the issue of safety and against the union?

Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 7.47am)

I very much doubt that would happen.

I've looked at all sides of the story. Southern have lied about staff sickness being a reason trains haven't run in the last few months.

I believe on reason they got the contract was to bust the unions and the Company don't care about trains not running as they get paid anyway.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 18 Dec 16 9.02am

Originally posted by nickgusset

I very much doubt that would happen.

I've looked at all sides of the story. Southern have lied about staff sickness being a reason trains haven't run in the last few months.

I believe on reason they got the contract was to bust the unions and the Company don't care about trains not running as they get paid anyway.


But again none of that is relevant to the reason they are striking (according to them). Or is it? And that would be some common ground we share. I don't disagree as to why they got the contract and that they are trying to break the union. Conversely I do think the union are entrenched and are not going to be busted and, to that end, the strike is purely political (irrespective of how many little pictures get posted on here), with safety, doors, CCTV, Guards etc simply being a convenient battle ground. I'm just a fan of honesty as, with the number of D.O.O trains about at the moment, not too many people really buy the s***e that the union peddle about safety.

I think you've looked at all sides of the story apart from one - mine. The humble passenger who is getting royally shafted by both the unions and the Company!!

Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 9.27am)

 

Hoof Hearted 18 Dec 16 10.40am

Originally posted by Helmet46


But again none of that is relevant to the reason they are striking (according to them). Or is it? And that would be some common ground we share. I don't disagree as to why they got the contract and that they are trying to break the union. Conversely I do think the union are entrenched and are not going to be busted and, to that end, the strike is purely political (irrespective of how many little pictures get posted on here), with safety, doors, CCTV, Guards etc simply being a convenient battle ground. I'm just a fan of honesty as, with the number of D.O.O trains about at the moment, not too many people really buy the s***e that the union peddle about safety.

I think you've looked at all sides of the story apart from one - mine. The humble passenger who is getting royally shafted by both the unions and the Company!!

Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 9.27am)


Exactly.... the longer this goes on, the more the general public will become hostile to both the unions and Southern.

The humble passenger is being treated as a pawn in a game of political chess.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Dec 16 10.47am

Originally posted by 7mins

.

You keep posting photos like they prove something.

They don't. Unless you add some context they're completely irrelevant

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Dec 16 11.41am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

You keep posting photos like they prove something.

They don't. Unless you add some context they're completely irrelevant

The images look hard to see. Perhaps the chap is showing that CCTV has its drawbacks and to counter whoever said the others looked clear.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Dec 16 12.08pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

The images look hard to see. Perhaps the chap is showing that CCTV has its drawbacks and to counter whoever said the others looked clear.

Quite but as I am sure you know, taking a photo of a screen will always be ropey. Particularly as I doubt that the screens are exactly HD. If the photo was taken in the dark, an old device etc this would also impact the quality of the image.

As per the video still it can be very misleading though I am sure that's not 7mins intention.

BTW what do you make of the alleged comments made by the President of the RMT?
[Link]

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Dec 16 12.23pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Quite but as I am sure you know, taking a photo of a screen will always be ropey. Particularly as I doubt that the screens are exactly HD. If the photo was taken in the dark, an old device etc this would also impact the quality of the image.

As per the video still it can be very misleading though I am sure that's not 7mins intention.

BTW what do you make of the alleged comments made by the President of the RMT?
[Link]

I think that bringing down a Tory government type rhetoric is typical rabble rousing stuff you get at these sort of meetings.

As for the images, they look very unclear. How big are the screens that the driver looks at?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Dec 16 1.40pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

I think that bringing down a Tory government type rhetoric is typical rabble rousing stuff you get at these sort of meetings.

As for the images, they look very unclear. How big are the screens that the driver looks at?

I would normally agree but given both this and Whelan's comments have been relatively quickly followed by industrial action, I am not sure you can just dismiss it.

I don't know, that's my point about context. Those photos tell us nothing posted as they have been. I and I suspect everyone else learn nothing from them.

When you compare the original image he posted to the video you can see the difference, that may well apply with subsequent photos

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Dec 16 2.30pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

I would normally agree but given both this and Whelan's comments have been relatively quickly followed by industrial action, I am not sure you can just dismiss it.

I don't know, that's my point about context. Those photos tell us nothing posted as they have been. I and I suspect everyone else learn nothing from them.

When you compare the original image he posted to the video you can see the difference, that may well apply with subsequent photos

The industrial action has been brewing. The DFT are complicit in failing to listen to the unions concerns about a guarantee of a second person to deal with train despatch. Southern have already said they're needed but won't guarantee there will be one. The guarantee is the sticking point

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 4.10pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

You keep posting photos like they prove something.

They don't. Unless you add some context they're completely irrelevant

The CCTV is pretty poor, nor is it real time. In 2009 a guard used CCTV to close the doors instead of getting out on to the platform at Horley. Company disciplined him. They said he cut corners on safety.
I am genuinely surprised that customers/passengers think the CCTV is safe, I can understand them disagreeing with the strike, but to say the CCTV is fine genuinely shocks me.
Maybe Southern are the good guys, maybe it's just me. I'm open to having my mind changed... but as things stand, I've not seen anyone put forward any kind of counter argument as to why using the in cab CCTV in class 377 trains is safe.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 4.12pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

The industrial action has been brewing. The DFT are complicit in failing to listen to the unions concerns about a guarantee of a second person to deal with train despatch. Southern have already said they're needed but won't guarantee there will be one. The guarantee is the sticking point

Southern have also muffed up by telling drivers it won't negotiate. They shouldn't have put this in writing, if this is there stance... use line managers to deliver the message, not a letter that can be posted on twitter/Facebook

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Dec 16 4.21pm

Originally posted by 7mins

The CCTV is pretty poor, nor is it real time. In 2009 a guard used CCTV to close the doors instead of getting out on to the platform at Horley. Company disciplined him. They said he cut corners on safety.
I am genuinely surprised that customers/passengers think the CCTV is safe, I can understand them disagreeing with the strike, but to say the CCTV is fine genuinely shocks me.
Maybe Southern are the good guys, maybe it's just me. I'm open to having my mind changed... but as things stand, I've not seen anyone put forward any kind of counter argument as to why using the in cab CCTV in class 377 trains is safe.

I don't think anyone will say Southern are good guys.

Because the public see them being used on other lines and perhaps because they trust the unions as much as they like Southern?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 4.28pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

I don't think anyone will say Southern are good guys.

Because the public see them being used on other lines and perhaps because they trust the unions as much as they like Southern?

So you think the CCTV is adequate?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Dec 16 4.33pm

I am open to persuasion either way.

I am not against it that's for sure.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 4.37pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

I am open to persuasion either way.

I am not against it that's for sure.

I think the CCTV is substandard. I can understand why drivers are worried about using it, especially if they're the ones going to prison if they kill someone.

So the images posted on here, would you be happy to rely on them if you were a driver?

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 4.38pm

.

IMG_1830.JPG Attachment: IMG_1830.JPG (128.84Kb)

 

Page 31 of 44 < 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong