Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Oct 2014 11.48pm
[
So Bush went to war in Iraq so Cheney could make some money? That's a bit weak legal don't you think? A connection isn't evidence for causation.
I don't and have never denied that once the war was decided upon that Bush and co looked to have their friends take up contracts.....Security and arms firms made money....No doubt about it.
But oil....Na...If it were they didn't do the contracts properly.....If oil were the real reason for the war then those contracts would have been water or rather oil tight. 
But be in no doubt.....No twin towers, no war.
The Bush doctrine wasn't pre-planned.....The neo cons won their war with Bush for understandable reasons.
Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Oct 2014 11.57pm) ....................................................... Of course the invasion of Iraq in 2003 would not have happened were it not for 9/11 and public support for "fighting back". The thing was Iraq had nothing to do with 9/11 or salafist jihadism. Rather, it was conveniently lumped in as part of the "war on terror" to get public and international support for invading Iraq.
I have shown you quotes from the former head of the Federal Reserve Bank and a senior US military officer that oil was a prime motivating factor re going into Iraq. Are they both deluded?
You rely on statistics showing that post the invasion US dominance of the Iraq oil industry has not been what therefore might have been thought. That is in no way inconsistent with what I've argued about the pre-invasion motivation.
Yes, the Iraqi government has made substantial revenue from oil post 2003.Yes,many contracts have gone to non-US external contracts.
But, many US companies have done very very nicely thank you from the exercise (hence my statistic about the vast amounts made by US oil services company Halliburton), some contracts have gone to US allies who supported the invasion, and a close look at many of the non US external contracts shows major US oil sector company involvement (and thus revenue) at the subcontracting level.
Before the war, the entire industry in Iraq was nationalised.
If none of the above makes any impression on you, let's leave it with 3 more quotes from those more informed than either you or me.
Chuck Hagel, the current United States Secretary of Defense, while speaking at the Catholic University of America Columbus School of Law in 2008 said: "People say we're not fighting for oil. Of course we are."
General John Abizaid, CENTCOM commander from 2003 until 2007, said of the Iraq war during a round table discussion at Stanford University in 2008, "Of course it's about oil, we can't really deny that."
In July 2003, the Polish foreign minister, Wlodzimierz Cimoszewicz, said, "We have never hidden our desire for Polish oil companies to finally have access to sources of commodities." This remark came after a group of Polish firms had just signed a deal with Kellogg, Brown and Root, a subsidiary of Halliburton. Cimoszewicz stated that access to Iraq's oilfields "is our ultimate objective". The Polish Government had been a loyal supporter of the Bush Administration's invasion of Iraq and by 2005 had 2,500 troops in Iraq.
Edited by legaleagle (12 Oct 2014 8.48am)
|