Quote Pussay Patrol at 08 May 2015 2.13pm
The very notion of being anti austerity is ridiculous anyway. If you racked up debt on a credit card and had large interest payments, you wouldn't be anti paying it back.
If you have a strong economy, strong growth and a low or no deficit you can invest properly in public services. It's common sense and what the public have voted for, not massive borrowing and higher taxes.
But austerity isn't that, is it? Austerity is the idea that the way to reduce a deficit is to cut back on public spending. More like if you are running yourself in to debt, austerity is saying 'right, I'll start going without heating and food a couple of days a week' rather than saying 'I'll start earning more money to make up for it'. Except the analogy doesn't really work because fiscal austerity translates in to people not being able to pay their rent, having their benefits slashed, using food banks etc. because of external economic decisions made by the government.
Japan has been using austerity measures for ages and is back in recession. The EU's austerity measures have left many member states on the brink of bankruptcy. After the 1st and 2nd world wars, when national debt was much higher than it is now, Keynesian approaches to deficit reduction (ie. public spending, borrowing and taxation) lead to boom years far greater than what we have now, and with far less inequality.
All of this is also a pretty ludicrous argument to be having given that the Tories have barely even implemented austerity (yet). They borrowed more in 3 years than Labour did in 13, the deficit has barely moved in the last couple, and taxes are pretty similar to what they were when they took over. All they've done is sold off public assets, and you can't hope to just keep doing that, because soon there'll be nothing left!
So that's a pretty simplified argument against austerity, if Labour gave that, why is everyone so convinced they'd lose? Because the electorate is too stupid to understand it?
Edited by serial thriller (08 May 2015 2.31pm)
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|