This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Aug 2015 8.18pm
Quote nickgusset at 05 Aug 2015 6.14pm
Interesting figures from channel 4 regarding asylum seekers taken in by different EU countries. If anything it shows how some can wildly overestimate we take in. Do you think that there should be any immigration controls. If so, why do we need them and what should they be? Immigration Controls are irrelevant to Asylum which is managed under the UK's obligation to the UN Charter on Refugees. You could have a no migration situation, and that still wouldn't prevent citizenship and temporary residency for asylum seekers.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnfirewall at 05 Aug 2015 4.33pm
Quote nickgusset at 05 Aug 2015 4.25pm
Quote johnfirewall at 05 Aug 2015 4.23pm
Quote nickgusset at 05 Aug 2015 4.08pm
Quote johnfirewall at 05 Aug 2015 3.43pm
Quote nickgusset at 05 Aug 2015 3.33pm
If all expats decided to come home at once, how would you feel about allowing them in if we are already overcrowded? Legally it depends if they're still citizens doesn't it, but it's fair to assume they left for a reason as have the migrants. You seem to favour those with families here. That would likely apply to most expats.
They're not going to be ripping the fences down are they. Thay can all re-integrate immediately, likely have accommodation in the UK and won't be entitled to benefits.
That's quite similar to foreign nationals here claiming for children outside of the UK, except this actually happens. There are limits for how long you can be away, which are significantly shorter than the length of time it'd take to be considered even a de facto expat. Or do you mean a pension which someone has already paid in to? UK Benefits, if you're not a citizen, have to be paid in for. Most foreign nationals need to have worked for at least 3 years to be entitled to welfare payments as a foreign national. Personally I don't believe anyone not resident in the UK, should be able to claim any kind of benefit from the state, except for pension and student subsidies. Those leaving the UK, who have 'worked the requisite period to qualify for benefits' should be paid off based on their tax payments during their time in the UK.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Aug 2015 10.29am
Do you think that there should be any immigration controls. If so, why do we need them and what should they be? Yes, I think there should be immigration controls on non-asylum cases. These should be based on skill, demand for skills, student visas, employment history, criminal history and capacity for self provision in terms of long term immigration. In terms of short term migration controls, non-migration, the capacity for self sufficiency for the period of their stay and visa, legal documentation etc - bearing in mind most short term immigration relates to tourism. Asylum should be defined on the risk to the individual from the state in which they're claiming asylum from, and the history of that state.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Not sure what I'm reading here. "Yesterday I realised that the people in this camp don't WANT to come to England. They have no choice."
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
What concerns me more about those on the 'Stop them all now' is the lack of sympathy for asylum seekers, and the willingness to immediately assume that they're out to rip the UK off, and aren't genuine or that its an acceptable loss to send 'them all back'. These are people who voluntarily left their home and country, and now live in makeshift shacks and camps in Calais. Similarly those drowning in the med, these are desperate and lost people.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Aug 2015 11.22am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Aug 2015 10.51am
Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Aug 2015 10.29am
Do you think that there should be any immigration controls. If so, why do we need them and what should they be? Yes, I think there should be immigration controls on non-asylum cases. These should be based on skill, demand for skills, student visas, employment history, criminal history and capacity for self provision in terms of long term immigration. In terms of short term migration controls, non-migration, the capacity for self sufficiency for the period of their stay and visa, legal documentation etc - bearing in mind most short term immigration relates to tourism. Asylum should be defined on the risk to the individual from the state in which they're claiming asylum from, and the history of that state. At last, an answer from the left on these questions - good for you Jamie. I would agree with most of your controls, although the sheer numbers is a major problem. But would like to know why you think we need controls. Presumably you welcome Cameron's attempts (if they are genuine) to introduce such controls on EU immigration? Would also agree with your controls on asylum-seekers. I would be happy to receive genuine refugees, but the current 'system' is riddled with abuse. There is a political party called UKIP that shares many of your views on controls, perhaps you should consider joining them? Edited by leggedstruggle (06 Aug 2015 11.58am) I've been against EU worker migration for as long as its been around, as it undermined the supply and demand factor for wages and fundamentally weakened the position of low skill working class people. The difference is that I don't have an issue with the migrants, but a policy that allows employers to profit at the detriment of society (both here, and in home countries). UKIP offer no solution to the underlying problems either, they just address the symptom that people have identified (migrants), not the underlying financial exploitation of those migrants and the UK working class. I don't remember them talking about making the minimum wage a real UK wage. Like the conservatives, their problem with it being 'financially benefical' to be on welfare compared to working, was cutting benefits (when the real problem was that benefits were tied to the cost of living and wages were not). Controls on any system are necessary to protect the existing status quo. Migration per se isn't a problem but the failure of the government to migrate unemployed within the UK into areas where employment demands existed, rather than opting for the cheap solutions of migrant labour. However, as far as the EU goes, other than the 'right to work where ever' I don't have an issue with the EU or the ECHR etc. I also don't believe the system is riddled with 'abuse', I am yet to be convinced.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.