You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 22 2026 12.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 32 of 44 < 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 >
Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Dec 16 4.46pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I think the CCTV is substandard. I can understand why drivers are worried about using it, especially if they're the ones going to prison if they kill someone.

So the images posted on here, would you be happy to rely on them if you were a driver?

As I said in previous posts, if you look at your original image compared to the video it came from, they are very different in quality.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 4.51pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

As I said in previous posts, if you look at your original image compared to the video it came from, they are very different in quality.

I've posted 7 different images on this thread. Would you be happy to rely on this to close the doors ? Remember your job and liberty depend on it.

IMG_1813.JPG Attachment: IMG_1813.JPG (100.88Kb)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Dec 16 5.34pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I've posted 7 different images on this thread. Would you be happy to rely on this to close the doors ? Remember your job and liberty depend on it.

Why show that image and not one of the screen underneath where it would appear the driver has a lot more images?

I am obviously not qualified to answer whether 8 images ar enough but the in terms o f quality of image then they look fine to me.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 6.23pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Why show that image and not one of the screen underneath where it would appear the driver has a lot more images?

I am obviously not qualified to answer whether 8 images ar enough but the in terms o f quality of image then they look fine to me.

Each image represents one coach, so if one image isn't working, the driver can't see the doors on the aforementioned coach.

Fair play for admitting you don't have the required knowledge to have a informed opinion.


Some people don't have any knowledge, but offer theories as fact. So kudos for admitting there is gaps in your knowledge, and it would be foolhardy to offer a opinion on the complexities of the strike.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 6.27pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Why show that image and not one of the screen underneath where it would appear the driver has a lot more images?

I am obviously not qualified to answer whether 8 images ar enough but the in terms o f quality of image then they look fine to me.

The middle coach of that 3 car train is obscured. That means 2 sets of doors are not visible to the driver.

This picture shows one coach out of four is obscured. The driver had zero ability to see if the doors are clear.

IMG_1673.JPG Attachment: IMG_1673.JPG (1,192.41Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 6.30pm

This picture shows a complete CCTV failure on a 8 car train, the problem was when the trains were coupled, the coupling block was damaged by a birdstrike on the Ouze valley viaduct (we have lots of problems there as they breed pheasants there.

IMG_1282.JPG Attachment: IMG_1282.JPG (2,242.55Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 6.32pm

This CCTV has low lighting problems, if you look closely you can see the "low light" warnings. Very common problem.

IMG_1660.JPG Attachment: IMG_1660.JPG (1,869.71Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 6.33pm

Another one with a "low light" warning

IMG_1815.JPG Attachment: IMG_1815.JPG (59.89Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 6.34pm

This image is showing someone walking with a suitcase, pretty poor quality, I think even the most anti union type would agree.

IMG_1820.JPG Attachment: IMG_1820.JPG (36.97Kb)

 

Only 10 a year!! Flag 18 Dec 16 6.40pm

So at present is it the guard that says it is safe to go? What equipment does he use?

 

Part Time James Flag 18 Dec 16 6.49pm

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

So at present is it the guard that says it is safe to go? What equipment does he use?

Well, as a commuter I have seen a guard lean out of a train once or twice and yell "STAND AWAY" and when they don't they shout it another time to be fair to them and then just shut the doors muttering "idiot" under their breath. I for once sleep easy knowing that if I ever try to jump through the shutting doors of a train someone will yell at me and quite rightly call me an idiot when I ignore him.

 




7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 6.54pm

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

So at present is it the guard that says it is safe to go? What equipment does he use?

Eyes.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 18 Dec 16 10.02pm

Originally posted by 7mins

.


Yeah but we all know that's bollox, as it's the Company's Insurer that pays out the compensation for loss, damage or injury to a third party. And they ARE insured and they do not pay as much as the first million pounds of every loss.

Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 10.02pm)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 10.24pm

Originally posted by Helmet46


Yeah but we all know that's bollox, as it's the Company's Insurer that pays out the compensation for loss, damage or injury to a third party. And they ARE insured and they do not pay as much as the first million pounds of every loss.

Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 10.02pm)

How much did the family in Liverpool get?

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 18 Dec 16 10.41pm

Originally posted by 7mins

How much did the family in Liverpool get?


There was a full payout after Paddington - which was a rail incident. The point being, of course, that you can chuck in as many little photos as you want, lots of little comments from drivers, from ASLEF, the RMT, Southern etc - but the bottom line is that the unions and Southern are making it s***e for us all. All your constant poacher turned gamekeeper defence of only one side ignores the main issue.
Avoiding that by saying "but look at the cctv" and all the other stuff doesn't change that. And they are all responsible for this situation.


Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 10.51pm)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 11.11pm

Originally posted by Helmet46


There was a full payout after Paddington - which was a rail incident. The point being, of course, that you can chuck in as many little photos as you want, lots of little comments from drivers, from ASLEF, the RMT, Southern etc - but the bottom line is that the unions and Southern are making it s***e for us all. All your constant poacher turned gamekeeper defence of only one side ignores the main issue.
Avoiding that by saying "but look at the cctv" and all the other stuff doesn't change that. And they are all responsible for this situation.

Drivers raised issues with CCTV, Southern refuse to even discuss these, they wrote letters in November and December (latest letter dated 12th Dec) saying they have no intention of dialogue regarding the drivers concerns.

^ that is factually correct.

There are your reasons for the strike.

Even a indication that they would speak about CCTV would have been enough to stop ASLEF asking their members to vote for strike.

^ my opinion based on professional experience.

My personal conclusion is, if you refuse communication with your workforce over their safety concerns, you are to blame for any industrial action.

Edited by Helmet46 (18 Dec 2016 10.51pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Dec 16 8.42am

Originally posted by 7mins

Each image represents one coach, so if one image isn't working, the driver can't see the doors on the aforementioned coach.

Fair play for admitting you don't have the required knowledge to have a informed opinion.


Some people don't have any knowledge, but offer theories as fact. So kudos for admitting there is gaps in your knowledge, and it would be foolhardy to offer a opinion on the complexities of the strike.


Why because I don't know the technicalities of some of the pictures you post?

I know that parts of the rail network has operated for over 30 yrs without guards.

I also know that when these train drivers have issues with cameras and visibility, there are set procedures to follow to allow the safe despatch of a train.

What I don't know and no one has been able to explain is why Southern routes should be so different.


 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 8.52am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch


Why because I don't know the technicalities of some of the pictures you post?

I know that parts of the rail network has operated for over 30 yrs without guards.

I also know that when these train drivers have issues with cameras and visibility, there are set procedures to follow to allow the safe despatch of a train.

What I don't know and no one has been able to explain is why Southern routes should be so different.



What are the set procedures when DOO equipment fails?
DOO on Thameslink was brought in at manned stations when passenger numbers were 30% of what they are now and were meant for only 4 and 8 car trains.

Do you dispute any of the above?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Dec 16 9.06am

Originally posted by 7mins


What are the set procedures when DOO equipment fails?
DOO on Thameslink was brought in at manned stations when passenger numbers were 30% of what they are now and were meant for only 4 and 8 car trains.

Do you dispute any of the above?

You keep shifting the argument. I don't know (and why would I) what the procedures are but they have them. Are you disputing that? Also worth noting these will be DCO trains not DOO

Passenger numbers, I will take you word for it but does it matter whether 100 or 300 are getting on a train?

12 carriage trains? Probably one area where I would want reassurances

One thing that you seem to miss is that when the guards role changes, they won't be mute. They will still be able to communicate with the driver if they see something untoward.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

IMpalace Flag London 19 Dec 16 9.33am

Are we just ignoring that the President of the RMT has said the number one rule of the union should be "strike to bring down the Tory government."

Responding to a story suggesting the RMT and other unions were coordinating strike action to hurt the government his response : "Shock horror. Guess what? We are!"

Post all the pictures of CCTV and pretend like this has anything to do with safety as much as you like, we (and I assume deep down you) know that's a load of crap.

[Link]

Edited by IMpalace (19 Dec 2016 9.37am)

 

Page 32 of 44 < 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong