You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 2.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 33 of 187 < 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 >
The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 3.14pm

Quote Rudi Hedman at 17 May 2014 11.21am

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 12.42am

I care about people who are unemployed, hence why I support things like promising long-term unemployed people a guaranteed job from the state.

My argument is that immigration actually increases employment by enhancing the economy and the public finances, so it's less about not caring about the problem, more disagreeing that immigration is causing it.


This is true if the immigrants are creating positions. This is not the case. Unfortunately most, which is what UKIP and plenty of us on here are opposed to, the huge quantity of immigrants, come to the UK taking up jobs that were advertised whether they were here or not. What plenty have done is keeping prices down of a few pence on supermarket fruit and veg and providing cheaper labour in construction because plenty are prepared to share a 1 bed flat between 3 and possibly do that for a few years before going back home with the money. Apart from a few East European deli-markets and a few more fine dining type Indian restaurants, this is pretty much the case.

So they're filling the same positions a Brit would fill and overall paying less tax and NI. If Labour had nudged a few people into job searching as the tories have done and into some of the positions they've filled and clamped down on supermarket-farmer pressure on prices then they would've gone a long way to addressing this.

Sunday Times Rich List is out tomorrow I believe. Bet there are loads of immigrants. Coming over here, creating our jobs. I'd be interested to see any evidence for your less tax and NI claim.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Stirlingsays Flag 17 May 14 3.22pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 3.14pm

Sunday Times Rich List is out tomorrow I believe. Bet there are loads of immigrants. Coming over here, creating our jobs. I'd be interested to see any evidence for your less tax and NI claim.

No one ever moans about rich immigrants Horsey.

Well....Ok....Apart from the resultant property prices in London they don't.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 3.25pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 17 May 2014 3.22pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 3.14pm

Sunday Times Rich List is out tomorrow I believe. Bet there are loads of immigrants. Coming over here, creating our jobs. I'd be interested to see any evidence for your less tax and NI claim.

No one ever moans about rich immigrants Horsey.

Well....Ok....Apart from the resultant property prices in London they don't.

Always amuses my when right-wing Evening Standard columnists complain about high house prices as if they actually give a sh*t about ordinary people

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

luckybuck Flag 17 May 14 3.31pm

Interesting to see The Sun call Farage a racist today. They peddle similar views for the most part.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 17 May 14 3.31pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 17 May 2014 2.58pm

Quote serial thriller at 17 May 2014 2.55pm
Z
[Link]

This made me chuckle. Farage absolutely decimated on LBC.


He was reduced by 10%???

He was made less dense in a photograph?


[Link]

(We can all play the 'double meanings of words' game)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

kangel Flag 17 May 14 4.06pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 3.02pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 10.13am

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 12.54am

We live in a representative democracy, where you elect an MP and they make decisions on your behalf. You can't just pick and choose the type of democracy you have based upon whether it reflects your views at a particular time.

Not in the EU we don't. Not only do you have to vote for a party en bloc regardless of whether you like or dislike a candidate within that party block, your choice of party is then downgraded if that party is too popular.

This isn't strictly true. Votes are of roughly equal weight, but the best way to get results where the share of the vote is close to equal each party's share of the vote is to use quite a complicated formula (that you described). Look at the London results last time:

Conservative - 479,037 - 3
Labour - 372,590 - 2
Liberal Democrats - 240,156 - 1
Green Party - 190,589 - 1
UK Independence Party 188,440 - 1

The most popular party (the Tories) got an MEP for every 159,679 votes cast, whereas Labour got an MEP for every 186,295 votes and you can see above that the 3 parties with 1 MEP took even more votes to get one MEP elected.

Essentially with 8 MEPs, it wouldn't make sense to give MEPs out on the basis of how many eighths of the vote they have, because that would have been about 220,000 votes and you'd just have had 2 Tories, a Labour MEP and a Lib Dem MEP.

It's a slightly complicated system, but it's impossible for a party to get fewer votes than another at the constituency level and end up with fewer MEPs. If you dislike the candidate(s) in the block, don't vote for the party, simple as that.

Edited by The White Horse (17 May 2014 3.15pm)

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say. It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike. The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 May 14 4.15pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 3.25pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 17 May 2014 3.22pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 3.14pm

Sunday Times Rich List is out tomorrow I believe. Bet there are loads of immigrants. Coming over here, creating our jobs. I'd be interested to see any evidence for your less tax and NI claim.

No one ever moans about rich immigrants Horsey.

Well....Ok....Apart from the resultant property prices in London they don't.

Always amuses my when right-wing Evening Standard columnists complain about high house prices as if they actually give a sh*t about ordinary people


You're properly right.....I haven't regularly read the ES since I left London.

I'm feeling vaguely nostalgic.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

kangel Flag 17 May 14 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 17 May 14 5.01pm

Quote serial thriller at 17 May 2014 3.31pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 17 May 2014 2.58pm

Quote serial thriller at 17 May 2014 2.55pm
Z
[Link]

This made me chuckle. Farage absolutely decimated on LBC.


He was reduced by 10%???

He was made less dense in a photograph?


[Link]

(We can all play the 'double meanings of words' game)


From 'decus', meaning ten.

It's ok, it's a common mistake. A bit like the blurring between 'imply' and 'infer'.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 17 May 14 5.06pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.


Allocating seats according to the number of votes cast seems like a pretty good idea to me and certainly more representative.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

kangel Flag 17 May 14 5.14pm


Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

[quote

How do I vote for my preferred Tory and my preferred Labour candidates then?

 

luckybuck Flag 17 May 14 5.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.


As much as I strongly dislike the BNP, if many thousands of people vote for them and they are then represented, it's neither a fiddle nor undemocratic. I find them 'undesirable' too but that's just my individual view. My view shouldn't be able to stamp out peoples' right to a say.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 17 May 14 5.27pm

Quote luckybuck at 17 May 2014 5.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.


As much as I strongly dislike the BNP, if many thousands of people vote for them and they are then represented, it's neither a fiddle nor undemocratic. I find them 'undesirable' too but that's just my individual view. My view shouldn't be able to stamp out peoples' right to a say.

It's funny how people who supposedly cherish democracy get all uptight when candidates who are not to their liking actually get elected.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 5.57pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 5.14pm

How do I vote for my preferred Tory and my preferred Labour candidates then?

Pick between them. Very few electors would cherish the opportunity of being able to vote for multiple candidates/parties and often this leads to a situation where the most popular party simply ends up with several representatives while others have none.

Take Penge and Cator Ward in Bromley as an example. Each Labour candidate gets 15% of the votes cast (collectively getting 45%), yet the 3 of them end up with all of the representation. It's nice you've got more choice, but is it actually more democratic?

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

kangel Flag 17 May 14 5.58pm

Quote luckybuck at 17 May 2014 5.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.


As much as I strongly dislike the BNP, if many thousands of people vote for them and they are then represented, it's neither a fiddle nor undemocratic. I find them 'undesirable' too but that's just my individual view. My view shouldn't be able to stamp out peoples' right to a say.

I have merely said that it is an unfortunate effect of the EU PR system that extremist parties can gain seats.

PR for UK elections was rejected by a referendum in 2011. Yet the EU have imposed their dubious PR system on us.

 

kangel Flag 17 May 14 6.00pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 5.57pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 5.14pm

How do I vote for my preferred Tory and my preferred Labour candidates then?

Pick between them. Very few electors would cherish the opportunity of being able to vote for multiple candidates/parties and often this leads to a situation where the most popular party simply ends up with several representatives while others have none.

Take Penge and Cator Ward in Bromley as an example. Each Labour candidate gets 15% of the votes cast (collectively getting 45%), yet the 3 of them end up with all of the representation. It's nice you've got more choice, but is it actually more democratic?

We should be able to vote for individual candidates to represent us as we do in UK parliamentary elections.

 

The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 6.04pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.

They got 6.2% of the vote in an election that elects 72 representatives. With 2 MEPs, they actually only ended up with 2.8% of the seats when an exactly proportional system would have given them 4 seats.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 17 May 14 6.05pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 5.58pm

Quote luckybuck at 17 May 2014 5.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.


As much as I strongly dislike the BNP, if many thousands of people vote for them and they are then represented, it's neither a fiddle nor undemocratic. I find them 'undesirable' too but that's just my individual view. My view shouldn't be able to stamp out peoples' right to a say.

I have merely said that it is an unfortunate effect of the EU PR system that extremist parties can gain seats.

PR for UK elections was rejected by a referendum in 2011. Yet the EU have imposed their dubious PR system on us.

No it wasn't, the Alternative Vote system (not a proportional voting system) was.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 17 May 14 6.07pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 5.58pm

Quote luckybuck at 17 May 2014 5.20pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.59pm

Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 4.43pm

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say.

I'd say most people would understand if they watched this 3 minute clip:

[Link]

Besides, I don't think it really matters whether people understand the voting system. If anything, understanding the voting system leads to tactical voting. Just tell people to vote for what they want and let the long dead Me d'Hondt make sure the number of MEPs reflects the shares of the vote.

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike.

That's not so much 'undemocratic', I'd say it's just a slightly different variation of democracy. Do you vote in the London Assembly elections? It's a very similar system. Also, presumably the Prime Minister is someone who you might not intend to vote for, do you think that makes parliamentary elections undemocratic?

Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 4.06pm

The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.

If people are voting for them in sufficient numbers, then why is that a bad thing? Democracy in action, I'd argue.

People are not voting for them in 'sufficient numbers'. They get a small proportion of the vote and end up with seats due to the EU PR system. Non-democratic fiddle, I'd call it.


As much as I strongly dislike the BNP, if many thousands of people vote for them and they are then represented, it's neither a fiddle nor undemocratic. I find them 'undesirable' too but that's just my individual view. My view shouldn't be able to stamp out peoples' right to a say.

I have merely said that it is an unfortunate effect of the EU PR system that extremist parties can gain seats.

PR for UK elections was rejected by a referendum in 2011. Yet the EU have imposed their dubious PR system on us.


Why is it 'unfortunate'? Because there was an outcome you didn't like?

PR wasn't an option in the 2011 referendum. Instead, it was some needlessly complicated and spazzy alternate-vote system that nobody understood.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 33 of 187 < 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic