Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 3.02pm
Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 10.13am
Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 12.54am
We live in a representative democracy, where you elect an MP and they make decisions on your behalf. You can't just pick and choose the type of democracy you have based upon whether it reflects your views at a particular time.
Not in the EU we don't. Not only do you have to vote for a party en bloc regardless of whether you like or dislike a candidate within that party block, your choice of party is then downgraded if that party is too popular.
This isn't strictly true. Votes are of roughly equal weight, but the best way to get results where the share of the vote is close to equal each party's share of the vote is to use quite a complicated formula (that you described). Look at the London results last time:
Conservative - 479,037 - 3
Labour - 372,590 - 2
Liberal Democrats - 240,156 - 1
Green Party - 190,589 - 1
UK Independence Party 188,440 - 1
The most popular party (the Tories) got an MEP for every 159,679 votes cast, whereas Labour got an MEP for every 186,295 votes and you can see above that the 3 parties with 1 MEP took even more votes to get one MEP elected.
Essentially with 8 MEPs, it wouldn't make sense to give MEPs out on the basis of how many eighths of the vote they have, because that would have been about 220,000 votes and you'd just have had 2 Tories, a Labour MEP and a Lib Dem MEP.
It's a slightly complicated system, but it's impossible for a party to get fewer votes than another at the constituency level and end up with fewer MEPs. If you dislike the candidate(s) in the block, don't vote for the party, simple as that.
Edited by The White Horse (17 May 2014 3.15pm)
"slightly complicated" indeed - incomprehensible to many voters I would say. It is not democratic to deny people the ability to vote for members of different parties. You might really like a particular Tory candidate and a particular Labour candidate but you cannot vote for both of them. Even if you decide just to vote for say the Tory who is bottom of their list, then your vote contributes to the possible success of the Tory at the top of the list, who you may particularly dislike. The 'system' also results in the 'election' of such undesirables as the BNP.