Quote matt_himself at 08 May 2015 3.30pm
Quote serial thriller at 08 May 2015 3.21pm
Quote matt_himself at 08 May 2015 2.56pm
The people that voted for 'credible' TUSC, would have voted in the past for Respect, the Communists, SWP, Left Unity, etc. The only reason that TUSC got 36,000 votes I their first election is because those 36,000 votes were previously going to the left parties that were there previously. This isn't a gain for the left. It is the left receiving the same votes as previously under a new guise.
I repeat. The Scotland vote is a rebound from th referendum. It has nothing to do with Austerity. The same with Plaid Cymru, they will have their core support that won't change. The Greens maybe latched onto the Austerity vote but when you talk to a lot of Green supporters, they are more motivated by ecological issues than the communist leaning of its leadership. I believe that most Green's vote for the part because of the environment, not 'anti austerity'. If they were solely motivated by 'anti austerity', then they would vote 'credible' TUSC.
The right aren't rewriting history. You cannot accept that your message has been categorically rejected.
He left have a lot of thinking to do.
That really is incredible. Purely for self-validation you have concluded that 4 parties - united under one major policy - have all experienced upsurges in votes for reasons totally exclusive to that policy.
Scramble these words Matt: In Elephant Room The.
And you're point about TUSC would make a lot more sense if most of the parties you listed weren't still active, and in the case of Left Unity, weren't also a new oerganisation!
ST, whilst I could continue this jousting all day, you need to accept a few things from the result.
The fact is that the numbers of people voting for far left countries has barely changed in the past twenty years.
The four parties aren't united under one policy - they hdifferent policies - and as you know and have no doubt experienced, the left is splintered and loves nothing more than slagging off those splintered in different directions. The 'anti austerity' message simply isn't carried across all leftie parties. I can tell you now, I know of people in the City earning six figure salaries who vote Green because of ecological issues and despise the communist overtones of its leadership. They, however, believe that the ecological reasons to vote Green outweigh the political differences they have on other policies. You simply cannot categorise all people voting for the same reasons.
The elephant in the room is that you believe what you want to believe and not the reality of the situation.
The left have had probably their worst day since 1979. It is the left wot lost it. Deal with this simple fact.
Edited by matt_himself (08 May 2015 3.31pm)
I am in no way arguing that the left has done anything more than miserably. Milliband's loss will almost certainly leave the door open for another Blarite (Umunna, for example) to take over and for Labour to sway to the right again. That means that the top 4 parties in England for the next 5 years will all be right wing, which is incredibly depressing as I believe that the left still has so much to offer to all forms of public debate in this country.
BUT
The point I'm making is that to totally dismiss the left would be an innacurate reading of what has happened. Since the Blair years I'd say there has been a divergence of much of the mainstream and far-left away from Labour membership and towards new grassroots organisations. In this election, I think we saw the results of that, with the Greens, the SNP and to an extent TUSC (still very much a minority party) all making significant gains in votes off the back of a rhetoric which has previously been sectioned off to activist politics.
There are huge differences between, say, TUSC and the Scot Nats, but the one major policy which unites them is their anti-austerity message. In contrast to the last election that message has gained a voice, not a huge one, but a significant one nonetheless considering well over 3 million people voted for anti-austerity parties. For the record, I didn't vote for any of them because my views are probably further to the left than any of them bar TUSC, who have some serious internal issues they need to sort out, and who I couldn't vote for. But I always remain optimistic, and for that reason I have an inkling of hope that writing off the left in this country is premature. A move to PR, coupled with a swathe of the labour left looking elsewhere, and who knows whatcould happen in 2020.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|