You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 33 of 44 < 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Dec 18 6.51pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Wonder if townsend would be better than wilf up front in his own. He's a very energetic player and willing to shoot from anywhere.

No. He would have his back to goal and doesn't have the physical presence to hold the ball up.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 31 Dec 18 7.39pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

When I saw Newcastle do that against Chelsea and predictably lose I said I hoped I never saw a Palace team show so little enterprise, spirit and positivity at 0 - 0.

Well that was worse.

I feel Chelsea are simply just too good for us and Newcastle nothing to do with our performances, Chelsea just made us play that way.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 31 Dec 18 8.14pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

I feel Chelsea are simply just too good for us and Newcastle nothing to do with our performances, Chelsea just made us play that way.

Complete garbage.

 


COYP

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 31 Dec 18 11.24pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Complete garbage.

Well that's interesting...

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 01 Jan 19 8.23am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

No probs mate game of opinions.

The point I was trying to make is that Wickham is the only CF we have available who is near good enough but he isn’t ready to start games. Our opponents know we’re unlikely to have a target man or little physical / aerial threat from the outset and have luxury of setting up accordingly.

I’ve read a lot of people saying after the game that we should have taken the game to Chelsea, and I agree we were very unadventurous, but who are the players that are going to do this apart from Zaha ? When we played them last year we were forced to improvise by Benteke’s injury and took them by surprise playing Wilf (who was returning from injury) and Townsend up front.

I take your point, but wickham will never get fit if we don't keep playing him, its surly going to take quite a few games after such a long lay off.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 01 Jan 19 8.28am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Yes I would prefer Wickham in this role.
It totally negates Zaha’s strengths to,play him there.
Zaha could have taken a wide role if Roy wanted to play a 5 in midfield.
Mcarthur, Kouyate and Luka already were providing enough defensive cover in midfield.
I find this constant reference to not having enough options irritating and not an adequate excuse for playing people in incorrect positions.

But Roy can't START Wickham after just having a few minutes of playing time, well he could do,but he wouldn't last until half time

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 01 Jan 19 9.57am

I was at the game on Sunday and lucky enough to be sitting in the directors box. The anger towards SP was so clear with supporters screaming at him to sign a striker and he could clearly hear it.

Likewise supporters were shouting at Roy to bring on Wickham and Meyer as soon as Chelsea scored and he just stood there biting his nails...

Who’s to blame... both!

What must Roy be seeing in the training that 20 odd thousand fans on a match day are not seeing, that makes him keep the faith with this shocking system. Surely he needs to start with Wickham now even if he only lasts half a game. At least we would have wilf in his best position and we could go at the opposition from the first whistle.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Jan 19 10.27am

The FA Cup game against Grimsby on Saturday, is the equivalent of England v Iceland, and we know what happened there. The manager needs to get this right and play a decent squad to absolutely batter them.

At the moment I blame both parties, the board for not getting the transfer policy right and Roy for not picking a team to win a game. It’s been well documented that he leaves substitutions till it’s too late. If he leaves it till 10 minutes from time before Connor Wickham comes on how on earth can he influence a game or get match sharpness.

We can’t piss about anymore...

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Jan 19 10.41am

Originally posted by DenTyler

I was at the game on Sunday and lucky enough to be sitting in the directors box. The anger towards SP was so clear with supporters screaming at him to sign a striker and he could clearly hear it.

Likewise supporters were shouting at Roy to bring on Wickham and Meyer as soon as Chelsea scored and he just stood there biting his nails...

Who’s to blame... both!

What must Roy be seeing in the training that 20 odd thousand fans on a match day are not seeing, that makes him keep the faith with this shocking system. Surely he needs to start with Wickham now even if he only lasts half a game. At least we would have wilf in his best position and we could go at the opposition from the first whistle.

Where was this anger for SP to sign a striker coming from? The Stephenson’s Lounge seats, the Glaziers seats section, the family section or way over atvthe Holmesdale which most would’ve heard at that level?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Jan 19 10.48am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

The FA Cup game against Grimsby on Saturday, is the equivalent of England v Iceland, and we know what happened there. The manager needs to get this right and play a decent squad to absolutely batter them.

At the moment I blame both parties, the board for not getting the transfer policy right and Roy for not picking a team to win a game. It’s been well documented that he leaves substitutions till it’s too late. If he leaves it till 10 minutes from time before Connor Wickham comes on how on earth can he influence a game or get match sharpness.

We can’t piss about anymore...

What makes you think Roy will change what he’s been doing for ages? Last year we and he got away with it with a very good return of points, but it was noticed by me the frustrating methods on the field and touch line, but if the results are happening then for a club like us everything else is okay. This was always going to happen if results weren’t that good or failure. The other issue is very disappointing home performances because of instructions but better away results.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 01 Jan 19 10.54am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

No. He would have his back to goal and doesn't have the physical presence to hold the ball up.

Neither does Zaha, but I think townsend would work harder in that role. And will shoot from distance, whereas zaha gets crowded out trying to beat 3 players.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Jan 19 11.14am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Neither does Zaha, but I think townsend would work harder in that role. And will shoot from distance, whereas zaha gets crowded out trying to beat 3 players.

Which means neither are suitable in that role. I agree totally about having a pop from distance, working the opposition's keeper is crucial in getting the crowd involved - and who knows, it might even fly in!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Jan 19 11.29am

Originally posted by DenTyler

I was at the game on Sunday and lucky enough to be sitting in the directors box. The anger towards SP was so clear with supporters screaming at him to sign a striker and he could clearly hear it.

Likewise supporters were shouting at Roy to bring on Wickham and Meyer as soon as Chelsea scored and he just stood there biting his nails...

Who’s to blame... both!

What must Roy be seeing in the training that 20 odd thousand fans on a match day are not seeing, that makes him keep the faith with this shocking system. Surely he needs to start with Wickham now even if he only lasts half a game. At least we would have wilf in his best position and we could go at the opposition from the first whistle.

This is true about wickham.
If he tires and comes off we then resume to type as against chelsea.
At least the opposition will set up differently and maybe not be able to play against our to type set up due to who they started with.

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Jan 19 11.34am

It surprises me that Roy is being let off so easily for the Chelsea performance.
Pulis and Allardyce are noted for being defensive and negative coaches but I don’t recall them sending a Palace team out like the one against Chelsea.
Pulis used Jerome and Chamakh at the front with Bolassie and Puncheon down the flanks.
Allardyce used Zaha, Benteke and Townsend in the front positions.
Against Chelsea we had 10 behind the ball with Zaha as an ineffectual front man.
In the Brighton game at 2-0 they went down to 10 men during the first half.
Roy didn’t seek to capitalise on the extra man advantage until well into the second half when he threw on an extra forward.
He seems to see success as a narrow defeat and keeping the score down.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Jan 19 11.43am

Originally posted by PatrickA

It surprises me that Roy is being let off so easily for the Chelsea performance.
Pulis and Allardyce are noted for being defensive and negative coaches but I don’t recall them sending a Palace team out like the one against Chelsea.
Pulis used Jerome and Chamakh at the front with Bolassie and Puncheon down the flanks.
Allardyce used Zaha, Benteke and Townsend in the front positions.
Against Chelsea we had 10 behind the ball with Zaha as an ineffectual front man.
In the Brighton game at 2-0 they went down to 10 men during the first half.
Roy didn’t seek to capitalise on the extra man advantage until well into the second half when he threw on an extra forward.
He seems to see success as a narrow defeat and keeping the score down.

I wish this forum had a "like" tab. Top post, absolutely spot on. Hodgson is negative in all aspects. I note, as in his time with England, he spends a lot of time looking at the patch of grass by his shoes and looking over to RL for advice. Well past the sell by date I'm afraid.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Jan 19 11.44am

Originally posted by cryrst

This is true about wickham.
If he tires and comes off we then resume to type as against chelsea.
At least the opposition will set up differently and maybe not be able to play against our to type set up due to who they started with.

If RH does that then Eagles good defensive record will go to pot and we will get relegated.

I's the ones who ship loads of goals who invariably go down.

I would be surprised if RH is not more successful this time in getting 2 strikers aboard.

IRWT - In Roy we trust...…

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Jan 19 11.53am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

What makes you think Roy will change what he’s been doing for ages? Last year we and he got away with it with a very good return of points, but it was noticed by me the frustrating methods on the field and touch line, but if the results are happening then for a club like us everything else is okay. This was always going to happen if results weren’t that good or failure. The other issue is very disappointing home performances because of instructions but better away results.

Well if he puts out an under strength side against Grimsby and we go out like we did to Borough in the League Cup,expect the s***e to hit the fan. This is the perfect opportunity for Connor to start, if he doesn’t do against Wolves midweek.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Jan 19 12.08pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Well if he puts out an under strength side against Grimsby and we go out like we did to Borough in the League Cup,expect the s***e to hit the fan. This is the perfect opportunity for Connor to start, if he doesn’t do against Wolves midweek.

I suspect he will give some fringe players a chance against Grimsby.

If we are defeated, perhaps supporters will not be too deflated in the circumstances given that we accept that the PL is the priority and with our squad we cannot risk injuries to key players in such a game.

Grimsby are a form team winning 6 of their last 8 games.


Edited by Willo (01 Jan 2019 12.09pm)

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Jan 19 2.39pm

Originally posted by Willo

I suspect he will give some fringe players a chance against Grimsby.

If we are defeated, perhaps supporters will not be too deflated in the circumstances given that we accept that the PL is the priority and with our squad we cannot risk injuries to key players in such a game.

Grimsby are a form team winning 6 of their last 8 games.


Edited by Willo (01 Jan 2019 12.09pm)

If we are defeated,I think the fans will go ape s***! I didn’t see too much of the Premiership priority against Chelsea on Sunday, it was abysmal.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Jan 19 2.56pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

If we are defeated,I think the fans will go ape s***! I didn’t see too much of the Premiership priority against Chelsea on Sunday, it was abysmal.

I happen to believe that this will be the reaction of supporters if Hodgson plays key players and Zaha,for instance, gets injured and is out for a while.

 

Page 33 of 44 < 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?