This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As I not aware whether the surrounding countries follow the same international protocols as us, I don’t know. Egypt is a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its subsequent amendments, so there is no get out clause for them. I’m looking forward to a subsequent march through London by thousands of people demanding that Egypt opens its border to refugees from Gaza, as there doesn’t seem to be a ‘refugees welcome here’ stance in that country. Strange.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Egypt is a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its subsequent amendments, so there is no get out clause for them. I’m looking forward to a subsequent march through London by thousands of people demanding that Egypt opens its border to refugees from Gaza, as there doesn’t seem to be a ‘refugees welcome here’ stance in that country. Strange. I too also thought this, 'why won't the Arab countries take the Palestinians'. So I looked into it. The Arab countries have taken Palestinians. Combined, over the decades, there are millions of them living in several of them. Some might say why don't they take all the ones who want to cross the border. When you look into it the answers are there. The reasons differ for the different Arab states but I'll mention some of them. I'll provide two general reasons before citing one specific one, but in reality there are more. Principally, there is the commitment to the Palestinian 'right of return', which obviously the Arabs want but that Israel knows would destroy its country (but that's fine for Europe apparently)...but never mind that old chestnut. Essentially the Arabs know that the best chance for the Palestinians to get their land back is not to abandon it. So they are hardly going to do Israel a favour. The other reason is purely economic. While rich states like Qatar or Saudi could afford it the closest states to the Palestinians of Egypt, Lebanon and Iran would face economic disruption with taking on hundreds of thousands.....I won't even mention the Shia/Sunni aspects....which between countries is obviously the cause of serious enmity between Arab states. A specific reason is that the Palestinians are heavily connected to the Muslim Brotherhood.....which the leader of Egypt deposed in a take over and executed many.....So taking in a population who are going to agitate against him isn't something he wants. However, having said all that if Israel force the Gazans out then they will have to go somewhere......this is obviously going to cause serious issues. Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2023 8.08am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I too also thought this, 'why won't the Arab countries take the Palestinians'. So I looked into it. The Arab countries have taken Palestinians. Combined, over the decades, there are millions of them living in several of them. Some might say why don't they take all the ones who want to cross the border. When you look into it the answers are there. The reasons differ for the different Arab states but I'll mention some of them. I'll provide two general reasons before citing one specific one, but in reality there are more. Principally, there is the commitment to the Palestinian 'right of return', which obviously the Arabs want but that Israel knows would destroy it's country (but that's fine for Europe apparently)...but never mind. Essentially the Arabs know that the best chance for the Palestinians to get their land back is not to abandon it. So they are hardly going to do Israel a favour. The other reason is purely economic. While rich states like Qatar or Saudi could afford it the closest states to the Palestinians of Egypt, Lebanon and Iran would face economic disruption with taking on hundreds of thousands.....I won't even mention the Shia/Sunni aspects....which between countries is obviously the cause of serious enmity between Arab states. A specific reason is that the Palestinians are heavily connected to the Muslim Brotherhood.....which the leader of Egypt deposed in a take over and executed many.....So taking in a population who are going to agitate against him isn't something he wants. However, having said all that if Israel force the Gazans out then they will have to go somewhere......this is obviously going to cause serious issues. Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2023 8.07am) I find it interesting that economics and politics trumps the UN Convention. Yet Braverman gets slaughtered when she attempts to restrict arrivals here. I know that the UK is a richer country than Egypt, but how much is Egypt spending on supporting Ukraine and what is the cost to them of meeting net zero by the 2030s? The cynic in me thinks Egypt wants to prolong the suffering of the Gaza population as part of a wider Arab stance to discredit Israel even more so that eventually its Western allies turn against it.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I too also thought this, 'why won't the Arab countries take the Palestinians'. So I looked into it. The Arab countries have taken Palestinians. Combined, over the decades, there are millions of them living in several of them. Some might say why don't they take all the ones who want to cross the border. When you look into it the answers are there. The reasons differ for the different Arab states but I'll mention some of them. I'll provide two general reasons before citing one specific one, but in reality there are more. Principally, there is the commitment to the Palestinian 'right of return', which obviously the Arabs want but that Israel knows would destroy its country (but that's fine for Europe apparently)...but never mind that old chestnut. Essentially the Arabs know that the best chance for the Palestinians to get their land back is not to abandon it. So they are hardly going to do Israel a favour. The other reason is purely economic. While rich states like Qatar or Saudi could afford it the closest states to the Palestinians of Egypt, Lebanon and Iran would face economic disruption with taking on hundreds of thousands.....I won't even mention the Shia/Sunni aspects....which between countries is obviously the cause of serious enmity between Arab states. A specific reason is that the Palestinians are heavily connected to the Muslim Brotherhood.....which the leader of Egypt deposed in a take over and executed many.....So taking in a population who are going to agitate against him isn't something he wants. However, having said all that if Israel force the Gazans out then they will have to go somewhere......this is obviously going to cause serious issues. Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2023 8.08am) I was in Jordan earlier this year, they already have circa 3m Syrian refugees in camps, I'm not sure they would be keen to take even more.
One more point |
|
|
[Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
[Link] What point are you making here? Are all Palestinians fair game to be massacred because of that video? 3000+ children are dead who weren't even born when that video was recorded - is that acceptable to you because of that video?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
What point are you making here? Are all Palestinians fair game to be massacred because of that video? 3000+ children are dead who weren't even born when that video was recorded - is that acceptable to you because of that video? Nope but how many American flags not being burned in that video or Israeli flags at the current marches. Says a lot when only one side is presumed to be wronged.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I was in Jordan earlier this year, they already have circa 3m Syrian refugees in camps, I'm not sure they would be keen to take even more. Indeed, they are in a difficult position as their population is obviously anti semitic but the leadership class there is reasonably pro western ....which for them isn't the same as pro Israeli. Well, maybe 'pro western' isn't quite right, pro staying in power and avoiding wars is probably a better way to put it. Similar situation for Egypt.....it's a significant problem for them both internally and externally. Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2023 5.45pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Nope but how many American flags not being burned in that video or Israeli flags at the current marches. Says a lot when only one side is presumed to be wronged. I have no idea what you're getting at. Literally everybody has acknowledged that Israel were wronged - the entire international community, every political leader - it's the first thing asked of any pro-Palestinian commentator on any interview; 'do you condemn the actions of Hamas'. It is entirely about Palestine specifically - if this level of killing took place anywhere on the planet, people would justifiably be outraged.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I have no idea what you're getting at. Literally everybody has acknowledged that Israel were wronged - the entire international community, every political leader - it's the first thing asked of any pro-Palestinian commentator on any interview; 'do you condemn the actions of Hamas'. It is entirely about Palestine specifically - if this level of killing took place anywhere on the planet, people would justifiably be outraged. And they are, so why arnt Hamas giving up their weapons to protect Gaza and their people. Let the hostages go and maybe Israel may see a way forwards with less bombing. It won’t happen though as the terrorists want the carnage and death. They don’t live anywhere near the bombing as their families don’t either. Why would they be bothered about gazans.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
And they are, so why arnt Hamas giving up their weapons to protect Gaza and their people. Let the hostages go and maybe Israel may see a way forwards with less bombing. It won’t happen though as the terrorists want the carnage and death. They don’t live anywhere near the bombing as their families don’t either. Why would they be bothered about gazans. Because they are terrorists - they don’t give a s*** about civilians in Gaza. Your solution is basically ‘the terrorists should stop being terrorists’. You’ve also just made a mockery of the entire premise of the massacre you’re justifying - if neither Hamas nor their families are anywhere near the areas being bombed, you’re arguing the Israeli’s are knowingly bombing civilians, and you’re still fine with that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Because they are terrorists - they don’t give a s*** about civilians in Gaza. Your solution is basically ‘the terrorists should stop being terrorists’. You’ve also just made a mockery of the entire premise of the massacre you’re justifying - if neither Hamas nor their families are anywhere near the areas being bombed, you’re arguing the Israeli’s are knowingly bombing civilians, and you’re still fine with that. Well the occasional hamas terrorist gets it. Ok let’s agree to an Israeli ceasefire. Then in a week Hamas attacks again. Hypothetical but what should Israel do then ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Are people still comfortable defending Isreal's conduct in Gaza? A refugee centre was bombed yesterday reported to have killed over 100 civilians. Reports of 3000+ Palestinian children dead since October 7th. Israel have dropped more bombs in Gaza in the last few weeks than the US did in any single year of their Afghanistan campaign.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If he flattens all of it they certainly can't sleep on rubble. To be honest I can't really quite believe what I'm witnessing. What we are seeing represents a seismic shift. The logical conclusion is war with Iran....will that happen? If so does it expand? Both sides will have wargamed this many times since Oct 7th. One prediction I would be pretty sure about is that the US will lose its bases in the middle east. We are witnessing history.....and it's not great that we are being ruled by such low quality. Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2023 2.47am) I wouldn't put it past Biden and the Democrats wanting war with Iran. It would obviously be madness to invoke the fury of the Islamic world. But, like you, I can't get my head around this escalation.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The Pentagon says there are no limits on how Israel uses US-provided weapons in their attacks in Gaza. A spokesperson said it's up to the IDF how it uses the weapons. That would seem to most people to be an insane thing to permit. Israel-Hamas war live: Palestinian death toll climbs to 9,061, including 3,760 children, says Gaza health ministry, it can't be very far wrong. GBUs (guided bomb units) are precision-guided air-to-surface weapon systems, they are part of the Israeli arsenal provided by the USA, they appear to have been used at the Jelabia refugee camp against a defenceless civilian population. The USA is culpable in genocide, it finances Israel and arms it, without apparently any control or responsibility. To think Biden is now coming round to a 'humanitarian pause'. Blood on his hands. Is it one commander you have eliminated today Israel, for all this? Or two, or more and aren't they replaceable anyway? That's if we believe you at all. Netanyahu you are not eliminating Hamas, you are creating a new one. And the Gaza health ministry is actually Hamas. The death toll the other day from a rocket started at 600 dead. By the end of the day it was less than 50. Yup 50 too many granted but do you see the point. Of course the terrorists will ramp up the figures. Israel hasn’t from what I’ve seen listed an amount of dead soldiers who are going into Gaza. They are dying but I doubt you will pray for their souls. Every life is precious, if it wears your colours!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.