This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I would suggest from his behaviour and comments that it's unlikely he has "age, health or disability reason for not wearing a face covering". Therefore it is a requirement to wear one, and also they are not obliged to allow him to travel and can be fined. His childlike paddy held up other people who wanted to travel. He's declaring himself as special or exempt 'just because'. Fine, then he can do so on his own time but on a journey where his behaviour and disregard for the law impacts others. and I would say that is why we have the law to start off with, because "suggesting" and "knowing" are two entirely different things.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
and I would say that is why we have the law to start off with, because "suggesting" and "knowing" are two entirely different things. The health exemption relies on people being honest regarding their health status, and it designed not to bog down the NHS. Where people are possibly being dishonest or displaying anti social behaviour, no doubt the police display a judgement call. In all likelihood, based on the guys behaviour I cannot blame a police officer for reaching a conclusion that he just didn't want to wear a mask. Which by the way is essentially what he said. No doubt the police had been called, holding up the train and he had refused to either already wear a mask or leave the train. There is no automatic right to travel if you can't abide by the rules. Since it would appear that he had already refused to wear a mask, not give any reason why, and refused to leave the train he had clearly exhausted their patience. If the vast majority of others make an effort he's not so special that he can ignore that without consequence. He can take his self importance elsewhere and let others get on with their day.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
The health exemption relies on people being honest regarding their health status, and it designed not to bog down the NHS. Where people are possibly being dishonest or displaying anti social behaviour, no doubt the police display a judgement call. In all likelihood, based on the guys behaviour I cannot blame a police officer for reaching a conclusion that he just didn't want to wear a mask. Which by the way is essentially what he said. No doubt the police had been called, holding up the train and he had refused to either already wear a mask or leave the train. There is no automatic right to travel if you can't abide by the rules. Since it would appear that he had already refused to wear a mask, not give any reason why, and refused to leave the train he had clearly exhausted their patience. If the vast majority of others make an effort he's not so special that he can ignore that without consequence. He can take his self importance elsewhere and let others get on with their day. This is a pretty pointless argument, however it is clear as day that you can hear the guy saying, " I do not have to wear a mask" and "you do not have the right to challenge me on this point". He is 100% correct on both points here if he is entitled not to wear one. So you are basing your entire argument on the fact that he is lying and can tell that just from his attitude. The Police Officer started the rough tactics, not the passenger. I wouldn't want you to be on the jury on any case I'm involved in if you make decisions based on what you think might have happened.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
and I would say that is why we have the law to start off with, because "suggesting" and "knowing" are two entirely different things. If he takes issue with how he's been treated then that would be the time where he'd been able to state his case. Since he's unlikely to actually have one, I very much doubt that has or will happen.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You have the right to make that decision. In my view you don't have the right to force others to. Many of us don't agree with the need for compulsory masks. I regard people being physically attacked for not wearing a mask as a huge infringement of civil liberties. I still don’t understand why some people are so against it, if it has a positive effect on keeping the virus under control then surly it’s a good thing.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
This is a pretty pointless argument, however it is clear as day that you can hear the guy saying, " I do not have to wear a mask" and "you do not have the right to challenge me on this point". He is 100% correct on both points here if he is entitled not to wear one. So you are basing your entire argument on the fact that he is lying and can tell that just from his attitude. The Police Officer started the rough tactics, not the passenger. I wouldn't want you to be on the jury on any case I'm involved in if you make decisions based on what you think might have happened. Again it's basically an honestly based system. If due to age of health status you have an issue with masks you do not have to obtain permission from your doctor to travel without one. Now if someone wants to try their luck when they do not have any history of breathing problems or legitimate reason to not wear one, and they have been thrown off a train, or fined or arrested if they kick off, they will quickly find that their self important fantasy land logic is trumped by reality. As I stated, if the guy has a legitimate medical issue then I would expect him to take action. The guy refused to leave a train and resisted arrest. 'Rough tactics'. The completely laughable contrast between 'should've obey the law' when there are wild escalations stateside resulting in death, and the attitude here that people should pretty much do as they please when it comes to following the law is priceless. He had plenty of options. Leave the train, wear a mask, calmly state why he's not doing so. Community involves people working together. He put himself in that situation through his own stupid behaviour and had numerous opportunities to avoid what happened. Edited by BlueJay (04 Sep 2020 3.37pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
I still don’t understand why some people are so against it, if it has a positive effect on keeping the virus under control then surly it’s a good thing. Were you wearing masks beforehand with flu killing thousands of people a year? As I said, if you choose to treat what the government dictates as your rulebook then fine I have no objection to your compliance. This is being treated like the black death when it has a death rate comparable to a bad flu. The government and media will do anything to avoid the blame for the massive over-reactions they took....they control the narrative to convince others their actions were justified. You buy it, I don't. I just stress the point that making others wear a mask under threat of force is an huge overstepping into civil liberties. Due to advancements in treatment while this virus will increase in the winter due to more time in housing the death rates won't be anywhere as high. Wearing masks makes no significant difference outside of exceptional conditions...mostly work ones. This should have always have been guidance not compulsion....as in Sweden. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Sep 2020 3.49pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Whoa careful this is not a police state, yet.... But it is getting close. He coughed in the face of two people.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
I still don’t understand why some people are so against it, if it has a positive effect on keeping the virus under control then surly it’s a good thing. There's still a lot we don't know about covid-19 long term. Heart injury appears to be more commonplace than originally thought, even in athletes so we learn more over time. While I'm all people people deciding their own level of risk in terms of going out, as I too decide, for many use of public transport is something they have to do, not an option like going out to the pub. As such its common courtesy to wear a mask in such a confined community environment unless there is a clear health reason not to. The more data the emerges it becomes clear that even bog standard masks make a decent difference, and quality ones offer significant protection. Where people elect not to people either turn a blind eye or they report it and let the individual explain why they are so much more important than those around them. I've found that the vast majority of people just get on with it like adults, because they're community minded rather than self important. The only 'incident' I've seen was passing through Crawley the other week. The only bloke on the train without a mask started having a go at a woman with her child who's folded up pram was slightly extended beyond her seat as he was on his way to the toilet. An OTT reaction to something he saw as an obstruction to his journey. Funny that he assumed everything anyone else did had to be perfect and to benefit him, when personally he just did as he pleased. The classic selfish mentality.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Were you wearing masks beforehand with flu killing thousands of people a year? As I said, if you choose to treat what the government dictates as your rulebook then fine I have no objection to your compliance. This is being treated like the black death when it has a death rate comparable to a bad flu. The government and media will do anything to avoid the blame for the massive over-reactions they took....they control the narrative to convince others their actions were justified. You buy it, I don't. I just stress the point that making others wear a mask under threat of force is an huge overstepping into civil liberties. Due to advancements in treatment while this virus will increase in the winter due to more time in housing the death rates won't be anywhere as high. Wearing masks makes no significant difference outside of exceptional conditions...mostly work ones. This should have always have been guidance not compulsion....as in Sweden. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Sep 2020 3.49pm) There are so many factors though, I’m not scared of dying from covid. I think the I fear is the amount of ICU beds, ventilators and dialysis machines required to treat people with covid on top of the flu patients would leave the NHS unable to cope.
|
|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
There are so many factors though, I’m not scared of dying from covid. I think the I fear is the amount of ICU beds, ventilators and dialysis machines required to treat people with covid on top of the flu patients would leave the NHS unable to cope.
You are obviously of good intent....I suppose I just differ from you as to where the line is for state control of personal autonomy in regards to threat level. If this were the black death or even close to it I would probably agree with you. None of the makeshift hospitals they created were required.....They miscalculated. I still think they were right to make them due to unknowns at the time but the point still needs to be made that they were wrong. I'm not saying you have said this but I'll say this about the flu vaccine. I think many people regard 'vaccines' as silver bullets when they aren't. For example I remember reading that the flu vaccine is about 2/3 effective due to flu diversity and how weak the person is. So while I also hope for a vaccine I know that this virus is with us and isn't going away....In time, survival rates will continue to improve and people will come to accept it. Eventually people will realise that masks were apart of that collective hysteria that a segment of society are always willing to buy into.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You are obviously of good intent....I suppose I just differ from you as to where the line is for state control of personal autonomy in regards to threat level. If this were the black death or even close to it I would probably agree with you. None of the makeshift hospitals they created were required.....They miscalculated. I still think they were right to make them due to unknowns at the time but the point still needs to be made that they were wrong. I'm not saying you have said this but I'll say this about the flu vaccine. I think many people regard 'vaccines' as silver bullets when they aren't. For example I remember reading that the flu vaccine is about 2/3 effective due to flu diversity and how weak the person is. So while I also hope for a vaccine I know that this virus is with us and isn't going away....In time, survival rates will continue to improve and people will come to accept it. Eventually people will realise that masks were apart of that collective hysteria that a segment of society are always willing to buy into. I will never believe anything our so called experts tell us after originally telling us that masks or face coverings were of zero help and were actually more likely to cause a problem. Now they are telling us the complete opposite, how TF are we supposed to make a reasoned decision based on that load of bollux. I wear a mask because it makes other people happy, no other reason.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I will never believe anything our so called experts tell us after originally telling us that masks or face coverings were of zero help and were actually more likely to cause a problem. Now they are telling us the complete opposite, how TF are we supposed to make a reasoned decision based on that load of bollux. I wear a mask because it makes other people happy, no other reason. Yep, I hear you. There's an old Japanese saying, 'the stake that sticks out gets hammered down'. There's always a self righteous Karen, curtain twitcher or bedwetter out there eager to shop you. If you aren't wearing a mask they become Donald Sutherland in the last scene of 'invasion of the body snatchers'. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Sep 2020 11.10pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
There are so many factors though, I’m not scared of dying from covid. I think the I fear is the amount of ICU beds, ventilators and dialysis machines required to treat people with covid on top of the flu patients would leave the NHS unable to cope.
It sounds like you’re in the crowd that’ll do this every winter or even all the time because Japan do or something. Hopefully most people won’t. I will have had enough of London if this happens, possibly Britain.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Eden Eagle
Went out for lunch today - had temperature taken at the entrance and given a rule card which contained the following (amongst the usual SD stuff) Anyone who is deemed to break the guidelines will be asked to leave and may result in permanent exclusion from the premises and reported to the police. Meanwhile our hospitals stand empty awaiting the “second wave” I would’ve left like I do in any places demanding masks or I walk round an empty shop or stand on a sticker in an empty shop. I’ve told and walked out of a few, and they’re empty. I wonder if they’ve worked it out yet. I went past costa coffee and it’s packed, probably because they know custom means their shop and jobs don’t go down the toilet with a disposable mask left in the Pan.
COYP |
|
|
An interesting take on the situation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
It sounds like you’re in the crowd that’ll do this every winter or even all the time because Japan do or something. Hopefully most people won’t. I will have had enough of London if this happens, possibly Britain. Blimey Rudi! Give it some time yet mate
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
It would be useful for the author to point of that based on antibody data around 5% of the population may have had covid-19. Therefore an article based on the premise that it's only killed x amount of the population is a very arbitrary way of looking at the situation, being that if a vaccine doesn't materalise around 90%+ of people will eventually be infected. Realistically that's probably 150,000+ dead and an indeterminate number of long term health consequences. It can be said that efforts to reduce covid dead, sadly result in resources being cut off for others, such as cancer patients for instance. It's hard to argue with that, in what is an impossible balancing act. That in turn also has to be balanced against the potential long term impact of covid. A worrying number of athletes appear to be having covid related heart issues right now for instance. Influenza-related cardiac issues with influenza falls at about 10%. The studies so far on show covid heart damage present in almost 80% of patients including those with only otherwise mild symptoms. Studies at 2 and 3 months points have so far showed no significant improvement, but who knows beyond that. Larger studies are clearly needed. This is why data is vital and why the pick a side politics approach to deciding how to 'feel' about a pandemic is useless. The maskless halfwit on a train mentality. At the end of the day nobody has a scooby right now about aspects such as this because it's too early to know other than emerging indications. It's not all about the body count though. While I'm basically just getting on with life as normal because I don't think people or society are really built to shut down, it doesn't follow that we should fool ourselves into believing the oft uttered 'it's just the flu' because it very obviously isn't.
Do you have any links to studies that confirm that 80% of those infected have heart damage? Not sure I agree with you that it is an “impossible balancing act” with regard to care and denying this to those ill with other non CV19 issues - the hospitals are now virtually empty, the number of people being hospitalised with CV19 is tiny, the number dying whilst being infected is tiny yet we focus on case counts created by inaccurate testing? Thanks.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.