Quote The White Horse at 17 May 2014 7.23pm
Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 6.36pm
I consider the entire EU and its workings a farce, whatever system they employ. But if your figures are correct for first past the post, fine (nice to see the Liberals on 'Nil Points', perhaps Clegg should grow a beard and put a dress on).
Then just say that, rather than starting debates about what "democracy" is by criticising proportional representation.
Quote kangel at 17 May 2014 6.36pm
I also consider PR to be undemocratic, as I suspect the majority of UK voters do, and I will certainly continue to criticise it at every opportunity.
Are the EU Commissioners, who run the whole racket anyway, appointed by any sort of PR system?
I think there's a difference between proposing legislation and "running the whole racket". They can only pass laws if a majority of MEPs (themselves elected by PR) vote for them. The MEPs also have the power to sack the entire Commission and must vote to ratify their appointment in the first place.
Not really where the EU is concerned.
Are you telling us that MEPs actually authorised the appointment of Neil Kinnock? Surely a good reason to lose all faith in the 'institution'.
The obvious point to make is that the UK government's executive is also indirectly elected, but people don't seem to mind about that. Also, in the UK the leader of the executive can be selected in any number of ways, whereas in the EU they must be elected by all MEPs, rather than MEPs of a particular party.