You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 22 2026 12.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 34 of 44 < 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 >
Stuk Flag Top half 19 Dec 16 4.24pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Don't upset Stuk by posting one sides argument. Apparently RMT press releases are irrelevant and all lies (despite no evidence to back this up or if it's even been read)

Upset... yeah right.

He wasn't replying to me. And I said anything from them is biased, which obviously they are, rather than irrelevant or lies. But we know you read and hear what you want to, rather than what's actually written or stated.


 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 4.30pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Upset... yeah right.

He wasn't replying to me. And I said anything from them is biased, which obviously they are, rather than irrelevant or lies. But we know you read and hear what you want to, rather than what's actually written or stated.


At least I read stuff, even if it is a bit long.

Of course it's biased, it's one side of the argument, you could counter it by offering up what the other side says to balance it out if you want.

Edited by nickgusset (19 Dec 2016 4.31pm)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 19 Dec 16 4.37pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

It was a rabble rousing speech in front of union members. I hear the rhetoric at many meetings. But that's all it is, rhetoric.

So you don't mind them talking bollocks and lying to your face then?

Normally you'd say they've let the cat out of the bag, but in this case it's just what everyone suspected anyway.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 19 Dec 16 4.39pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

At least I read stuff, even if it is a bit long.

Of course it's biased, it's one side of the argument, you could counter it by offering up what the other side says to balance it out if you want.

Edited by nickgusset (19 Dec 2016 4.31pm)

I don't have the time nor inclination. They've been lying all the long that "it's all about safety" and no amount of waffling from them will change that. I said from the start that they'd get further by telling the truth, that they're worried about jobs and kicking the conservatives at the same time is a bonus to them.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 5.02pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I don't have the time nor inclination. They've been lying all the long that "it's all about safety" and no amount of waffling from them will change that. I said from the start that they'd get further by telling the truth, that they're worried about jobs and kicking the conservatives at the same time is a bonus to them.

So even though you haven't read it you are convinced it is lies. Any other evidence to back your assertion that the union is lying?

 

IMpalace Flag London 19 Dec 16 5.12pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

So even though you haven't read it you are convinced it is lies. Any other evidence to back your assertion that the union is lying?

How about the fact that their leader told a room full of people it wasn't about safety last week? That work?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 5.54pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

How about the fact that their leader told a room full of people it wasn't about safety last week? That work?

What's your source for this gem?

 

IMpalace Flag London 19 Dec 16 5.59pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

What's your source for this gem?

President of RMT said his union were coordinating strikes with others to "hurt the working class hating Tory government"

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 6.01pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

President of RMT said his union were coordinating strikes with others to "hurt the working class hating Tory government"

Source? Context? Audience?

 

IMpalace Flag London 19 Dec 16 6.18pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Source? Context? Audience?

Source: Every news organisation in the country
Context: said by the president of the RMT, not sure what more context you want
Audience: per bbc "numerous speeches including a speech to the NSSN"

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 6.30pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

Source: Every news organisation in the country
Context: said by the president of the RMT, not sure what more context you want
Audience: per bbc "numerous speeches including a speech to the NSSN"

The same sources that said Corbyn stormed out of a party because they played Things can only get better, although it transpires he left way before the song was played?

What else did he say other than Hurt the anti working class Tory government.

Perhaps that is his wish, Id go along with it, but I wouldn't use it as a reason to strike.

However, Co ordinating with other unions over strike days is a good tactical move.


Did you know that all of the strikes we are hearing about have happened because the company refused to sit around the negotiation table with the unions.

Wad that reported in your news sources?

 

elgrande Flag bedford 19 Dec 16 6.35pm

1979 all over again.....ha ha ha.and it was reported him saying that.
Yeah a guy on well over100k a year wants to hurt the very people he supposedly represents....reminds me of all the well to do lefties preaching about more homes,then as soon as theysay they are gonna build 200 new homes near their village they protest.think it's called hypocrisy.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

IMpalace Flag London 19 Dec 16 6.42pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

The same sources that said Corbyn stormed out of a party because they played Things can only get better, although it transpires he left way before the song was played?

What else did he say other than Hurt the anti working class Tory government.

Perhaps that is his wish, Id go along with it, but I wouldn't use it as a reason to strike.

However, Co ordinating with other unions over strike days is a good tactical move.


Did you know that all of the strikes we are hearing about have happened because the company refused to sit around the negotiation table with the unions.

Wad that reported in your news sources?

Not sure what any of the Corbyn stuff has to do with anything. Are you suggesting the quotes are fabricated? If we're working on the assumption that the entire British media is fabricating quotes then probably no point in discussing any of this.

Yep, southern refusing to negotiate is widely reported in the media I read (which is accross the political spectrum) and is undoubtedly a factor in the strikes, one which I also find infuriating, but that's not what we're talking about. We're talking about the cause of the strikes from a union perspective.

The leader of the union has stated they are politically motivated. When the leader of a union states strikes are being coordinated to hurt the government, I perhaps foolishly assume that the strikes are being coordinated to hurt the government. You seem to be taking a different view somehow?

"Not a reason to strike but I'd go along with it". What does that mean? Are you honestly trying to justify a union for workers of a train network striking and disrupting wide swathes of the public on a daily basis for months and months because they don't like the elected government? Unreal.

Edited by IMpalace (19 Dec 2016 6.46pm)

 

npn Flag Crowborough 19 Dec 16 7.00pm

Just received an email reply from my MP in response to my pleadings to get it sorted. I was tempted to bold some pieces I found particularly interesting, but have chosen to leave it raw so you can all make your own minds up. Interested in thoughts from both sides of the argument.

Thank you for contacting me about Southern.

I am truly sorry for the pain you have borne so stoically and unfairly for months because of this situation. Whether a strike day or a non-strike day, the service you receive does not deserve the name “service”.

The situation regarding Southern is both a complicated one and a simple one. On the one hand, the fault lies in many places. Network Rail deserve blame for failures on the track which occur far too often, causing cancellations, delays and gridlock. Southern have failed to run a service, to manage their staff or to communicate with passengers. The unions have abused their right to strike for political purposes, with a few hundred people holding hundreds of thousands of people to ransom.

But while the number of interested parties makes it complicated, at its heart is a simple failure of judgement. Because the day-to-day problems of Southern cannot be addressed until the operator is allowed to focus on those problems, rather than on the intransigence of the unions. Those at the top of the unions have decided to pick a fight over driver only operation, which they accept as safe and allow on other networks.

They do not want the introduction of a driver only operated service on this network. This is despite the fact that, today and tomorrow, ASLEF’s drivers will continue to drive driver only operated trains on the Thameslink service. This is despite the fact that the independent rail safety inspector has declared that this system, which has been in operation on Britain’s rail network for thirty years, is perfectly safe. This is despite the fact that not one of the unions’ members are at risk of losing their job, or losing pay.

My sympathy for the passengers who have faced hell is limitless. I have held surgeries on this issue, spoken about it on local and national media, and raised it with ministers and with GTR, who operate Southern, every week. I have also called publicly, on the BBC this weekend, for the Government to consider legislation to stop public services being held to ransom. My sympathy for the unions who continue this unfounded strike without concern for the passengers who they are unjustifiably victimising is at an end.

The base salary of a train driver working for GTR is £49,660, rising to as much as £60,000. The salary of the average teacher who can’t get to work because that driver doesn’t turn up is little more than half that.

The unions are holding this region to ransom, with no cause. I can assure you that we are doing everything we can do; it is up to the unions to stop driving this vendetta and start driving some trains.

Thank you, once again, for taking the trouble to contact me.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 7.59pm

Originally posted by npn

Just received an email reply from my MP in response to my pleadings to get it sorted. I was tempted to bold some pieces I found particularly interesting, but have chosen to leave it raw so you can all make your own minds up. Interested in thoughts from both sides of the argument.

Thank you for contacting me about Southern.

I am truly sorry for the pain you have borne so stoically and unfairly for months because of this situation. Whether a strike day or a non-strike day, the service you receive does not deserve the name “service”.

The situation regarding Southern is both a complicated one and a simple one. On the one hand, the fault lies in many places. Network Rail deserve blame for failures on the track which occur far too often, causing cancellations, delays and gridlock. Southern have failed to run a service, to manage their staff or to communicate with passengers. The unions have abused their right to strike for political purposes, with a few hundred people holding hundreds of thousands of people to ransom.

But while the number of interested parties makes it complicated, at its heart is a simple failure of judgement. Because the day-to-day problems of Southern cannot be addressed until the operator is allowed to focus on those problems, rather than on the intransigence of the unions. Those at the top of the unions have decided to pick a fight over driver only operation, which they accept as safe and allow on other networks.

They do not want the introduction of a driver only operated service on this network. This is despite the fact that, today and tomorrow, ASLEF’s drivers will continue to drive driver only operated trains on the Thameslink service. This is despite the fact that the independent rail safety inspector has declared that this system, which has been in operation on Britain’s rail network for thirty years, is perfectly safe. This is despite the fact that not one of the unions’ members are at risk of losing their job, or losing pay.

My sympathy for the passengers who have faced hell is limitless. I have held surgeries on this issue, spoken about it on local and national media, and raised it with ministers and with GTR, who operate Southern, every week. I have also called publicly, on the BBC this weekend, for the Government to consider legislation to stop public services being held to ransom. My sympathy for the unions who continue this unfounded strike without concern for the passengers who they are unjustifiably victimising is at an end.

The base salary of a train driver working for GTR is £49,660, rising to as much as £60,000. The salary of the average teacher who can’t get to work because that driver doesn’t turn up is little more than half that.

The unions are holding this region to ransom, with no cause. I can assure you that we are doing everything we can do; it is up to the unions to stop driving this vendetta and start driving some trains.

Thank you, once again, for taking the trouble to contact me.

Nice bit of impartiality from yer mp there!

The fact he has glossed over the DOO issue, it's far more complex, as seen in the evidence in this thread, than 'oh they do it on other lines' rebuttal to the issues.

'Holding the region to ransom with no cause' Erm, yes there is major concern from 94% of drivers (of which a small percentage may want to bring down the government) that they and their passengers will not be safe if what Southern propose goes through.

Those who are anti the union are effectively saying they want the rail service to be less safe so that dividends are higher.

I stand by the comments that the 'Tories are anti working class'

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 8.00pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

Not sure what any of the Corbyn stuff has to do with anything. Are you suggesting the quotes are fabricated? If we're working on the assumption that the entire British media is fabricating quotes then probably no point in discussing any of this.

Yep, southern refusing to negotiate is widely reported in the media I read (which is accross the political spectrum) and is undoubtedly a factor in the strikes, one which I also find infuriating, but that's not what we're talking about. We're talking about the cause of the strikes from a union perspective.

The leader of the union has stated they are politically motivated. When the leader of a union states strikes are being coordinated to hurt the government, I perhaps foolishly assume that the strikes are being coordinated to hurt the government. You seem to be taking a different view somehow?

"Not a reason to strike but I'd go along with it". What does that mean? Are you honestly trying to justify a union for workers of a train network striking and disrupting wide swathes of the public on a daily basis for months and months because they don't like the elected government? Unreal.

Edited by IMpalace (19 Dec 2016 6.46pm)


No, I meant it would be good to get rid of this Tory government.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 19 Dec 16 8.07pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Nice bit of impartiality from yer mp there!

The fact he has glossed over the DOO issue, it's far more complex, as seen in the evidence in this thread, than 'oh they do it on other lines' rebuttal to the issues.

'Holding the region to ransom with no cause' Erm, yes there is major concern from 94% of drivers (of which a small percentage may want to bring down the government) that they and their passengers will not be safe if what Southern propose goes through.

Those who are anti the union are effectively saying they want the rail service to be less safe so that dividends are higher.

I stand by the comments that the 'Tories are anti working class'

To be fair, she's not supposed to be impartial - I want her to be on MY side.

The DOO issue: I saw a comment earlier (apologies, can't remember who from) that it works on Thameslink because they only have 6 or 8 car trains. If that's the case, are we saying that it would be a sufficient guarantee if Southern said they would guarantee a gard on any train above a certain number of cars?

Also, I'm not doubting you, but do you have a source for the 94% figure (the only one I can find is in a tube dispute)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 9.23pm

Originally posted by npn

To be fair, she's not supposed to be impartial - I want her to be on MY side.

The DOO issue: I saw a comment earlier (apologies, can't remember who from) that it works on Thameslink because they only have 6 or 8 car trains. If that's the case, are we saying that it would be a sufficient guarantee if Southern said they would guarantee a gard on any train above a certain number of cars?

Also, I'm not doubting you, but do you have a source for the 94% figure (the only one I can find is in a tube dispute)

94% of Southern drivers voted for industrial action because of DOO and 87% wanted withdrawal of labour. I'm assuming the 94% wanted the O/T ban first.

Your MP knows nothing, unions threatened strikes if there was extension of DOO, under...

*Labour
* Coalition
* Tories.

Southern knew the strike was coming, hence this unique franchise with no financial exposure to industrial action.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 19 Dec 16 9.33pm

Originally posted by 7mins

94% of Southern drivers voted for industrial action because of DOO and 87% wanted withdrawal of labour. I'm assuming the 94% wanted the O/T ban first.

Your MP knows nothing, unions threatened strikes if there was extension of DOO, under...

*Labour
* Coalition
* Tories.

Southern knew the strike was coming, hence this unique franchise with no financial exposure to industrial action.

Still haven't seen a source, which is what I was after. As I said, I don't necessarily doubt it, but without a source it's just a number on a message board.

I'm not expecting she knows the full story from all angles, as, I imagine, neither do you. I'm leaning towards the union point of view slightly, but Southern, ASLEF, and the RMT can ALL go f**k themselves, bluntly. A plague on all their houses

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 9.36pm

Originally posted by npn

To be fair, she's not supposed to be impartial - I want her to be on MY side.

The DOO issue: I saw a comment earlier (apologies, can't remember who from) that it works on Thameslink because they only have 6 or 8 car trains. If that's the case, are we saying that it would be a sufficient guarantee if Southern said they would guarantee a gard on any train above a certain number of cars?

Also, I'm not doubting you, but do you have a source for the 94% figure (the only one I can find is in a tube dispute)

Yep, from what I can gather southern accept this is the case but refuse to guarantee it will happen. That's the sticking point for the unions (well it was yesterday)

 

Page 34 of 44 < 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong