This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I guess I did. I kind of thought that a Government by definition commands a majority in the Commons. And that the nature of Government is that you lead the country. My mistake. Before the last election did the Government have a majority?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
What did you mistake your a&se for? If a Government wants to implement change it can provided it operates a three line whip. Unless its own people object to the change that is. Providing the House of Lords agree surely?
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Her behaviour goes well beyond 'in with the wrong crowd' so I have no heartfelt desire to see her come back. I don't demand that anyone is draped in the flag, but if your lack of allegiances reaches the level hers did, then I can't see a route back. Her two friends are thought to be dead not because they made a silly teenage choice, but because they made a catastrophic decision. If she had never left this country and bought into warped ideology here then fair enough it's our problems to unravel. Once you're on your merry way though, I don't think a return ticket is in our interests. Yep
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
She could be switched off. But that would be easier where she is now. No way will she get a life sentence, I am not sure, given our justice system, that she will get a custodial sentence “ she was only a child, misguided. She has already been incarcerated so that is enough”. Cue book/film, will make a fortune.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Providing the House of Lords agree surely? Well, no. The House of Lords cannot prevent a Bill from being passed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Her behaviour goes well beyond 'in with the wrong crowd' so I have no heartfelt desire to see her come back. I don't demand that anyone is draped in the flag, but if your lack of allegiances reaches the level hers did, then I can't see a route back. Her two friends are thought to be dead not because they made a silly teenage choice, but because they made a catastrophic decision. If she had never left this country and bought into warped ideology here then fair enough it's our problems to unravel. Once you're on your merry way though, I don't think a return ticket is in our interests. I cannot find a single thing to fault in that what so ever but I still believe she should be returned to UK juristriction, all be it intially at a military base. She was under the age of agreed majority in this country. Therefore the state owes her a duty of care, despite every single one of your well reasoned and argued points. My belief that she should be returned is nothing to do with her as an individual. But we either have 18 as the agreed point at which an individual becomes 100% accountable for their actions or we do not. She was under that age when she made the choices she does. The country owes it to itself to offer a second chance, no matter how much that sticks in the craw. And trust me, I write none of this with anything other than a heavy heart. But we have to be better than those IS savages. We cannot sink to their level. We have a rule of law and a common law principle of duty of care. For me that is worth more than just one very very stupid girl.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Before the last election did the Government have a majority? Yes, it bought it off the DUP. And it had a majority from 2015 to 2017.
|
|
|
Just use the Dag Hamerskjold 'plane crash' method. Make sure the rest of the people on board have parachutes.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Well, no. The House of Lords cannot prevent a Bill from being passed. Technically but they can delay and delay can they not?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Technically but they can delay and delay can they not?
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
I cannot find a single thing to fault in that what so ever but I still believe she should be returned to UK juristriction, all be it intially at a military base. She was under the age of agreed majority in this country. Therefore the state owes her a duty of care, despite every single one of your well reasoned and argued points. My belief that she should be returned is nothing to do with her as an individual. But we either have 18 as the agreed point at which an individual becomes 100% accountable for their actions or we do not. She was under that age when she made the choices she does. The country owes it to itself to offer a second chance, no matter how much that sticks in the craw. And trust me, I write none of this with anything other than a heavy heart. But we have to be better than those IS savages. We cannot sink to their level. We have a rule of law and a common law principle of duty of care. For me that is worth more than just one very very stupid girl.
I do have a degree of respect for your perspective, as it could be said that my view is partially coming from a point of emotion rather than structure or rule of law. The more we deviate from that the more we drift towards, as you say, the very mindsets we should be differentiating ourselves from to begin with. If she was still a child now I'd likely have more sympathy for her, though of course at the time she was, so that for some will be the pertinent fact. She has come across as rather dim in her interviews, which is probably what led her to make such a disastrous decision rather than anything darker. But if someone can get drawn into this stuff once, and isn't that bright, could something similar happen with them again? With so many unknowns, I guess I settled on the idea that it primarily becomes complex if and when she returns, rather than if we don't allow her to. Though the decision is made now it seems!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
I cannot find a single thing to fault in that what so ever but I still believe she should be returned to UK juristriction, all be it intially at a military base. She was under the age of agreed majority in this country. Therefore the state owes her a duty of care, despite every single one of your well reasoned and argued points. My belief that she should be returned is nothing to do with her as an individual. But we either have 18 as the agreed point at which an individual becomes 100% accountable for their actions or we do not. She was under that age when she made the choices she does. The country owes it to itself to offer a second chance, no matter how much that sticks in the craw. And trust me, I write none of this with anything other than a heavy heart. But we have to be better than those IS savages. We cannot sink to their level. We have a rule of law and a common law principle of duty of care. For me that is worth more than just one very very stupid girl.
I see where you are coming from, although she was “grown up” enough to use her sister’s passport to leave the U.K. and to carry off the deception at the airport. Once she has returned she will never leave as she has no other citizenship. Personally I feel she should be tried as an adult and take the necessary punishment. Don’t forget her husband is Dutch so it would not surprise me to see him in the U.K., living at taxpayers expense very soon
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I see where you are coming from, although she was “grown up” enough to use her sister’s passport to leave the U.K. and to carry off the deception at the airport. Once she has returned she will never leave as she has no other citizenship. Personally I feel she should be tried as an adult and take the necessary punishment. Don’t forget her husband is Dutch so it would not surprise me to see him in the U.K., living at taxpayers expense very soon Should be an interesting accommodation needed advert.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I see where you are coming from, although she was “grown up” enough to use her sister’s passport to leave the U.K. and to carry off the deception at the airport. Once she has returned she will never leave as she has no other citizenship. Personally I feel she should be tried as an adult and take the necessary punishment. Don’t forget her husband is Dutch so it would not surprise me to see him in the U.K., living at taxpayers expense very soon I thought he was brown bread?
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I thought he was brown bread? Isn’t he hiding somewhere? Is the marriage legal anyway since she was only 15 when it happened.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Isn’t he hiding somewhere? Is the marriage legal anyway since she was only 15 when it happened. Was she 15 when got married? I don’t know. Knowing our rules could probably get in as common- law partner. I must admit I thought he was back in Holland.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Was she 15 when got married? I don’t know. Knowing our rules could probably get in as common- law partner. I must admit I thought he was back in Holland. Yes, it was 10 days after she got to Syria.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.