This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 10.01am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 9.41am
What Fascism is and isn't A good starting point. Its often a mistake to see National Socialism (Nazism and Communism as fascist).
Therefore, what is the difference in practice between a left wing and right extremist single party state? People get massacred in both. Democracy is purged in both. Individualism and liberty of thought is purged. Power is concentrated to a circle of the elite. The institutions of such a country become the tools of the government to use to suppress opposition. The economy is centrally planned and controlled. Free enterprise is deemed as a parasitic endeavour in both. Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 10.15am) The ideology and the rhetoric. Cuba, for example, and for whatever view you may personally have of it in terms of freedom, places a very significant emphasis on the provision of its people, as opposed to the nation state (standards of health provision and education in Cuba massively exceed that of most similar third world countries). Cuba, spent most of its existence as part of the Soviet satellite state, and engages in internationalism which isn't typically a fascist trait - Nationalism isn't that much of a tennet in Soviet or Cuban politics. Communism and fascism (and especially National Socialism) have a lot of shared ideology (as fascism originated as a response to the appeal of communism), what tends to differ is the organization of the state and itsbody politic, the political rhetoric and probably most notably how those bodies of state function, rather than its actions. Both Fascism and Socialism place great emphasis on the power of unions as a means of protecting the working class, the difference is that in socialism, those organizations are formed and directed for the working class, where as in fascism they serve the state directly. Whilst it can seem that's the same thing, its worth remembering that in Poland the rise of Solidarity stems from the Unions against the Polish communist state - similarly Union and state factions in both Hungary and Chechslovakia were instrumental in the both famous uprisings. In Zimbabwe, there was the movement of reclaiming land, not for the state, but for the black farmers from private ownership (a disaster). In the way that the term fascism gets used in general life, somewhat ignorantly, it could be applied to both Soviet style communism, Chinese State communism, Spanish Falangism, Pan Arabic Baathism or Argentinian Juntas; but there are very significant differences (notably in the internal politics and power structure). Also, traditionally both Communism and Fascism are 'opposed forces'. Similarly one could look a Capitalist Democracies and label them the same, but when you look internally you see a big difference in terms of structure and organization, as well as orientation, whilst obstentially championing many of the same causes and ideals.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 10 Aug 2015 11.12am
Simple question if you own a house, paid for with your own hard earned cash, why should you be made to hand it over to an immigrant, refugee, asylum seeker etc etc. Even if it is your home in the country thatyou onlyuse once in a while. Imagine your at home, a knock on the door it's a copper with one of the above in tow, right sir you have two cars out front, this immigrant doesn't have one, so he's having your wifes car that she hardley uses. FCUK RIGHT OFF OUT OF IT. You shouldn't. However if there is an empty house, should it remain empty, or be provided to those who are homeless. Shelter is a fundamental human need - Probably third in terms of importance after food and water. Second and third homes are fine, once the homeless are housed. I don't really care if people rent properties out to migrant workers or asylum seekers or national workers. The only issue is where people are without access to reasonable accommodation and shelter.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 10 Aug 2015 11.33am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 11.24am
Quote dannyh at 10 Aug 2015 11.12am
Simple question if you own a house, paid for with your own hard earned cash, why should you be made to hand it over to an immigrant, refugee, asylum seeker etc etc. Even if it is your home in the country thatyou onlyuse once in a while. Imagine your at home, a knock on the door it's a copper with one of the above in tow, right sir you have two cars out front, this immigrant doesn't have one, so he's having your wifes car that she hardley uses. FCUK RIGHT OFF OUT OF IT. You shouldn't. However if there is an empty house, should it remain empty, or be provided to those who are homeless. No, not if its owned by someone, what you are proposing is government sponsered Theft of property to house the homeless, never going to happen in a million years, so pointless even debating it really. Shelter is a fundamental human need - Probably third in terms of importance after food and water. Second and third homes are fine, once the homeless are housed. I don't really care if people rent properties out to migrant workers or asylum seekers or national workers. The only issue is where people are without access to reasonable accommodation and shelter. Whilst it may be a human need, it is not (rightly or wrongly) a god given right. If you own your property you can do with it what you wish. Should you wish to rent it out to Mr and Mrs Eastern European, that’s your choice, you shouldn’t be pressurised, coerced, or be offered incentives to do so, as to offer incentives to landlords to house immigrants over our own homeless is positive discrimination is it not ? I do though concede that getting on the property ladder in England is almost impossible for young people these days, and I do find that disgraceful.
It is a British right, provided you have an address and fulfill the somewhat labyrinthian nightmare of rules required to qualify for welfare and housing benefit (ie those that effectively disqualify the homeless from being eligible). Personally I don't think you ever need to get to the point of repossession of spare housing, but that implementing rent controls tied to wages, and an increase in state owned properties (similar to hotels or university residencies) used to provide cheap or even free housing for workers in an area (allowing you to relocate unemployed in the UK form areas of low and near zero unemployment, to fill low income wage work). Then tie rent controls and 'this free housing' to the minimum wage and the minimum wage to inflation. I don't have an issue with people making money on the rental market, however rents are excessive in many parts of the country, and that's a concern for low income workers and welfare (in Reading, if you're talking about a two child family, on welfare, the biggest cost to the Welfare budget is the housing costs which will be in excess of 12k pa, which is half of the maximum benefit cap). 1200 per month is the average rent for a two bedroom house in an okish area of town where I live.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| leggedstruggle |
|
|---|---|
|
The Socialist Utopia of Cuba.
mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 2.24pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 11.18am
Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 10.01am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 9.41am
What Fascism is and isn't A good starting point. Its often a mistake to see National Socialism (Nazism and Communism as fascist).
Therefore, what is the difference in practice between a left wing and right extremist single party state? People get massacred in both. Democracy is purged in both. Individualism and liberty of thought is purged. Power is concentrated to a circle of the elite. The institutions of such a country become the tools of the government to use to suppress opposition. The economy is centrally planned and controlled. Free enterprise is deemed as a parasitic endeavour in both. Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 10.15am) The ideology and the rhetoric. Cuba, for example, and for whatever view you may personally have of it in terms of freedom, places a very significant emphasis on the provision of its people, as opposed to the nation state (standards of health provision and education in Cuba massively exceed that of most similar third world countries). Cuba, spent most of its existence as part of the Soviet satellite state, and engages in internationalism which isn't typically a fascist trait - Nationalism isn't that much of a tennet in Soviet or Cuban politics. Communism and fascism (and especially National Socialism) have a lot of shared ideology (as fascism originated as a response to the appeal of communism), what tends to differ is the organization of the state and itsbody politic, the political rhetoric and probably most notably how those bodies of state function, rather than its actions. Both Fascism and Socialism place great emphasis on the power of unions as a means of protecting the working class, the difference is that in socialism, those organizations are formed and directed for the working class, where as in fascism they serve the state directly. Whilst it can seem that's the same thing, its worth remembering that in Poland the rise of Solidarity stems from the Unions against the Polish communist state - similarly Union and state factions in both Hungary and Chechslovakia were instrumental in the both famous uprisings. In Zimbabwe, there was the movement of reclaiming land, not for the state, but for the black farmers from private ownership (a disaster). In the way that the term fascism gets used in general life, somewhat ignorantly, it could be applied to both Soviet style communism, Chinese State communism, Spanish Falangism, Pan Arabic Baathism or Argentinian Juntas; but there are very significant differences (notably in the internal politics and power structure). Also, traditionally both Communism and Fascism are 'opposed forces'. Similarly one could look a Capitalist Democracies and label them the same, but when you look internally you see a big difference in terms of structure and organization, as well as orientation, whilst obstentially championing many of the same causes and ideals. I think you are lookin at things through your red glasses and your obvious admiration for 'benevolent' Cuba is at odds with the reality of the regimes treatment of the 'people'. The fact is that the 'people's regime' is just a glossy veneer which hides the fact that the tolatarian regime suppressed and murdered at will yet dressed it up as a Workers Paradise to give it credibility with and receive sympathy from those around the World who swallow this. This is just the same glossy veneer the Nazi's sold to elements of the European aristocracy in the 1930's. To me they are two sides of he same coin and no sane person would support or defend either murderous regime, regardless of the rhetorical or ideological spin either was dressed up as.
Not really, I just know more about Cuba than I do about North Korea and Zimbarbwe, so I used it to illustrate the difference between Communism and Fascism, rather than a defense of the Cuba regime
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.