You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Calais migrant trouble
November 22 2026 2.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Calais migrant trouble


Page 35 of 51 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >
matt_himself Flag Matataland 10 Aug 15 10.01am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 9.41am

What Fascism is and isn't

[Link]

A good starting point.

Its often a mistake to see National Socialism (Nazism and Communism as fascist).


I view Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela and Zimbabwe as totalitarian states who use many of the methods and theories described in your link. I am sure you will draw on subtle differences between the states and totalitarianism in its pure, theoretic terms but broad brushing it, you have to admit that the above States operate in a style and mechanism akin to fascism.

Therefore, what is the difference in practice between a left wing and right extremist single party state?

People get massacred in both. Democracy is purged in both. Individualism and liberty of thought is purged. Power is concentrated to a circle of the elite. The institutions of such a country become the tools of the government to use to suppress opposition. The economy is centrally planned and controlled. Free enterprise is deemed as a parasitic endeavour in both.

Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 10.15am)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 10 Aug 15 10.20am

Quote legaleagle at 10 Aug 2015 9.36am

Quote leggedstruggle at 10 Aug 2015 9.07am

Quote legaleagle at 10 Aug 2015 9.00am

Quote leggedstruggle at 10 Aug 2015 8.26am

Quote legaleagle at 09 Aug 2015 11.27pm

No,I just think people who would not live next to anyone of a different religion,race or ethnicity to them on principle (regardless of what they are like as people) are correctly described as spouting the obnoxious mutterings of extreme neanderthals

Though to be fair to you,it seems you make no distinction between actual immigrants and those who have been born here.

The question is not why we need border (including immigration) controls of some type or other since you agree with some form of them in principle and so do I (as you would know from my post earlier today).The question is rather what form such controls should take, and why, and causal factors. That is where we very much differ and I very much doubt anything I could write would change your distinctive viewpoint (or vice versa).

We also differ plainly in our attitudes towards people of a different religion,race and ethnicity to each of us living here (and indeed likely born here).We further differ on what might be done to reduce outward migration from countries in crisis.

In short,we differ.

Edited by legaleagle (10 Aug 2015 12.05am)

Neanderthalphobia again - surely that is a hate crime in this day and age. So you restate that we are Fascists if we chose to move house or don't have a diverse, vibrant person of African heritage in the spare room. How long before you have us standing in front of a telescreen for two minutes hate of Farage as the clock strikes thirteen?

You say that you agree with some form of immigration control, yet say the question is not why we need them. That is precisely the question. If you have no reasons for controls why would you go to the trouble and cost of having them? Unless you are completely lacking in common sense, you must have some reasons for wanting "controls of some type or other". We merely want to know what those reasons are - why so coy?


ho hum...

Ho hum? Is he the leader of some failed Communist state? or it that your reason for wanting immigration controls "of some type or other"?

Ho hum referring to your first para which once again ducks and/or misses and/or wilfully distorts my point

Farage (whom I disagree with strongly and regard as a classic politician type) does not so far as I'm aware think it appropriate to booby trap the home of a family which has immigrated here, or to refrain from living near anyone of a different religion,ethnicity or race to him as a matter of principle.

It is legitimate IMO for a state/entity to regulate (or not) to a greater or lesser degree the flow of people and goods in and out of its borders.Reasons for the degree of any such regulation might be political,economic or social (encompassing humanitarian) or in combination. I have posted yesterday in reasonable detail the policies (pretty middle of the road) I think are appropriate within that.

You would aspire to zero immigration if possible:I disagree

You would like (I infer) ethnicity,race or religion,to be a part of criteria regarding admissibility for immigration: I disagree.

You (I infer) would like us not to comply with the 1951 convention:I disagree

You would like us not to have free movement of goods,services and labour for EU member countries (or to withdraw from the EU):I disagree.

You would like each and every potential migrant arriving in Europe during the present humanitarian crisis to be "sent back":I disagree

You see no role for us/Europe in doing anything to assist in sorting out crises which have exacerbated "push" factors for "boat people" fleeing to Europe:I disagree.

You I suspect would not see equality for all who are already living here regardless of race,religion or ethnicity,as a desirable thing to aspire to.If so,I would disagree.

You disagree with Farage - wow, who would have thought that - and he is a "politician" - not much gets past you does it.

You keep saying that I would booby trap the homes of immigrants. Can you say where I have ever said this? Would you like to apologise for making such an outrageous accusation.

You say there are "political,economic or social" reasons for having immigration controls. How about some examples of these reasons. What exactly are the problems that your immigration controls would seek to address?

Yes, I do aspire to zero immigration as near as is practicable and in our interests.

No, you infer incorrectly - your knee-jerk politically correct prejudices once again; I would not have ethnicity, race or religion part of criteria regarding admissibility for immigration.

We should withdraw from any convention that hinders our ability to control our own borders or is detrimental to our interests.

I would not be in the EU so would not be party to the shambles that is their 'free movement'.

Yes, I would repatriate all illegal immigrants.

To counter the 'push' factors I would encourage policies that facilitate the growth of proper democracies and the downfall of appalling governments like Zimbabwe's.

Of course there should be equality for all who are already living here regardless of race, religion or ethnicity. That equality should of course include such things as the freedom for bakeries to refuse to support same sex marriage,freedom of speech to criticise belief systems, immigration policy etc. People should also be free to move home without being called a Fascist for doing so.

Edited by leggedstruggle (10 Aug 2015 12.37pm)

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Aug 15 11.12am

Simple question if you own a house, paid for with your own hard earned cash, why should you be made to hand it over to an immigrant, refugee, asylum seeker etc etc. Even if it is your home in the country thatyou onlyuse once in a while.

Imagine your at home, a knock on the door it's a copper with one of the above in tow, right sir you have two cars out front, this immigrant doesn't have one, so he's having your wifes car that she hardley uses.

FCUK RIGHT OFF OUT OF IT.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Aug 15 11.18am

Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 10.01am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 9.41am

What Fascism is and isn't

[Link]

A good starting point.

Its often a mistake to see National Socialism (Nazism and Communism as fascist).


I view Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela and Zimbabwe as totalitarian states who use many of the methods and theories described in your link. I am sure you will draw on subtle differences between the states and totalitarianism in its pure, theoretic terms but broad brushing it, you have to admit that the above States operate in a style and mechanism akin to fascism.

Therefore, what is the difference in practice between a left wing and right extremist single party state?

People get massacred in both. Democracy is purged in both. Individualism and liberty of thought is purged. Power is concentrated to a circle of the elite. The institutions of such a country become the tools of the government to use to suppress opposition. The economy is centrally planned and controlled. Free enterprise is deemed as a parasitic endeavour in both.

Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 10.15am)

The ideology and the rhetoric. Cuba, for example, and for whatever view you may personally have of it in terms of freedom, places a very significant emphasis on the provision of its people, as opposed to the nation state (standards of health provision and education in Cuba massively exceed that of most similar third world countries).

Cuba, spent most of its existence as part of the Soviet satellite state, and engages in internationalism which isn't typically a fascist trait - Nationalism isn't that much of a tennet in Soviet or Cuban politics.

Communism and fascism (and especially National Socialism) have a lot of shared ideology (as fascism originated as a response to the appeal of communism), what tends to differ is the organization of the state and itsbody politic, the political rhetoric and probably most notably how those bodies of state function, rather than its actions. Both Fascism and Socialism place great emphasis on the power of unions as a means of protecting the working class, the difference is that in socialism, those organizations are formed and directed for the working class, where as in fascism they serve the state directly.

Whilst it can seem that's the same thing, its worth remembering that in Poland the rise of Solidarity stems from the Unions against the Polish communist state - similarly Union and state factions in both Hungary and Chechslovakia were instrumental in the both famous uprisings.

In Zimbabwe, there was the movement of reclaiming land, not for the state, but for the black farmers from private ownership (a disaster).

In the way that the term fascism gets used in general life, somewhat ignorantly, it could be applied to both Soviet style communism, Chinese State communism, Spanish Falangism, Pan Arabic Baathism or Argentinian Juntas; but there are very significant differences (notably in the internal politics and power structure). Also, traditionally both Communism and Fascism are 'opposed forces'.

Similarly one could look a Capitalist Democracies and label them the same, but when you look internally you see a big difference in terms of structure and organization, as well as orientation, whilst obstentially championing many of the same causes and ideals.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Aug 15 11.24am

Quote dannyh at 10 Aug 2015 11.12am

Simple question if you own a house, paid for with your own hard earned cash, why should you be made to hand it over to an immigrant, refugee, asylum seeker etc etc. Even if it is your home in the country thatyou onlyuse once in a while.

Imagine your at home, a knock on the door it's a copper with one of the above in tow, right sir you have two cars out front, this immigrant doesn't have one, so he's having your wifes car that she hardley uses.

FCUK RIGHT OFF OUT OF IT.

You shouldn't. However if there is an empty house, should it remain empty, or be provided to those who are homeless.

Shelter is a fundamental human need - Probably third in terms of importance after food and water. Second and third homes are fine, once the homeless are housed. I don't really care if people rent properties out to migrant workers or asylum seekers or national workers. The only issue is where people are without access to reasonable accommodation and shelter.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Aug 15 11.33am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 11.24am

Quote dannyh at 10 Aug 2015 11.12am

Simple question if you own a house, paid for with your own hard earned cash, why should you be made to hand it over to an immigrant, refugee, asylum seeker etc etc. Even if it is your home in the country thatyou onlyuse once in a while.

Imagine your at home, a knock on the door it's a copper with one of the above in tow, right sir you have two cars out front, this immigrant doesn't have one, so he's having your wifes car that she hardley uses.

FCUK RIGHT OFF OUT OF IT.

You shouldn't. However if there is an empty house, should it remain empty, or be provided to those who are homeless.

No, not if its owned by someone, what you are proposing is government sponsered Theft of property to house the homeless, never going to happen in a million years, so pointless even debating it really.

Shelter is a fundamental human need - Probably third in terms of importance after food and water. Second and third homes are fine, once the homeless are housed. I don't really care if people rent properties out to migrant workers or asylum seekers or national workers. The only issue is where people are without access to reasonable accommodation and shelter.

Whilst it may be a human need, it is not (rightly or wrongly) a god given right.

If you own your property you can do with it what you wish. Should you wish to rent it out to Mr and Mrs Eastern European, that’s your choice, you shouldn’t be pressurised, coerced, or be offered incentives to do so, as to offer incentives to landlords to house immigrants over our own homeless is positive discrimination is it not ?

I do though concede that getting on the property ladder in England is almost impossible for young people these days, and I do find that disgraceful.


Edited by dannyh (10 Aug 2015 11.37am)

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Aug 15 11.55am

Quote dannyh at 10 Aug 2015 11.33am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 11.24am

Quote dannyh at 10 Aug 2015 11.12am

Simple question if you own a house, paid for with your own hard earned cash, why should you be made to hand it over to an immigrant, refugee, asylum seeker etc etc. Even if it is your home in the country thatyou onlyuse once in a while.

Imagine your at home, a knock on the door it's a copper with one of the above in tow, right sir you have two cars out front, this immigrant doesn't have one, so he's having your wifes car that she hardley uses.

FCUK RIGHT OFF OUT OF IT.

You shouldn't. However if there is an empty house, should it remain empty, or be provided to those who are homeless.

No, not if its owned by someone, what you are proposing is government sponsered Theft of property to house the homeless, never going to happen in a million years, so pointless even debating it really.

Shelter is a fundamental human need - Probably third in terms of importance after food and water. Second and third homes are fine, once the homeless are housed. I don't really care if people rent properties out to migrant workers or asylum seekers or national workers. The only issue is where people are without access to reasonable accommodation and shelter.

Whilst it may be a human need, it is not (rightly or wrongly) a god given right.

If you own your property you can do with it what you wish. Should you wish to rent it out to Mr and Mrs Eastern European, that’s your choice, you shouldn’t be pressurised, coerced, or be offered incentives to do so, as to offer incentives to landlords to house immigrants over our own homeless is positive discrimination is it not ?

I do though concede that getting on the property ladder in England is almost impossible for young people these days, and I do find that disgraceful.


Edited by dannyh (10 Aug 2015 11.37am)

It is a British right, provided you have an address and fulfill the somewhat labyrinthian nightmare of rules required to qualify for welfare and housing benefit (ie those that effectively disqualify the homeless from being eligible).

Personally I don't think you ever need to get to the point of repossession of spare housing, but that implementing rent controls tied to wages, and an increase in state owned properties (similar to hotels or university residencies) used to provide cheap or even free housing for workers in an area (allowing you to relocate unemployed in the UK form areas of low and near zero unemployment, to fill low income wage work).

Then tie rent controls and 'this free housing' to the minimum wage and the minimum wage to inflation.

I don't have an issue with people making money on the rental market, however rents are excessive in many parts of the country, and that's a concern for low income workers and welfare (in Reading, if you're talking about a two child family, on welfare, the biggest cost to the Welfare budget is the housing costs which will be in excess of 12k pa, which is half of the maximum benefit cap).

1200 per month is the average rent for a two bedroom house in an okish area of town where I live.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

johnfirewall Flag 10 Aug 15 1.13pm

It certainly isn't helped by the fact that at the very bottom landlords can rent out every single damp cupboard for 400 hundred quid because the council are paying for it. Anyone with the means and dignity to pay for something better is immediately forced in to a much higher bracket and anyone wanting anything half decent like a room in a house with an en-suite bathroom is paying £800 pcm for a bedroom with a shower in the corner.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 10 Aug 15 2.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 11.18am

Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 10.01am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 9.41am

What Fascism is and isn't

[Link]

A good starting point.

Its often a mistake to see National Socialism (Nazism and Communism as fascist).


I view Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela and Zimbabwe as totalitarian states who use many of the methods and theories described in your link. I am sure you will draw on subtle differences between the states and totalitarianism in its pure, theoretic terms but broad brushing it, you have to admit that the above States operate in a style and mechanism akin to fascism.

Therefore, what is the difference in practice between a left wing and right extremist single party state?

People get massacred in both. Democracy is purged in both. Individualism and liberty of thought is purged. Power is concentrated to a circle of the elite. The institutions of such a country become the tools of the government to use to suppress opposition. The economy is centrally planned and controlled. Free enterprise is deemed as a parasitic endeavour in both.

Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 10.15am)

The ideology and the rhetoric. Cuba, for example, and for whatever view you may personally have of it in terms of freedom, places a very significant emphasis on the provision of its people, as opposed to the nation state (standards of health provision and education in Cuba massively exceed that of most similar third world countries).

Cuba, spent most of its existence as part of the Soviet satellite state, and engages in internationalism which isn't typically a fascist trait - Nationalism isn't that much of a tennet in Soviet or Cuban politics.

Communism and fascism (and especially National Socialism) have a lot of shared ideology (as fascism originated as a response to the appeal of communism), what tends to differ is the organization of the state and itsbody politic, the political rhetoric and probably most notably how those bodies of state function, rather than its actions. Both Fascism and Socialism place great emphasis on the power of unions as a means of protecting the working class, the difference is that in socialism, those organizations are formed and directed for the working class, where as in fascism they serve the state directly.

Whilst it can seem that's the same thing, its worth remembering that in Poland the rise of Solidarity stems from the Unions against the Polish communist state - similarly Union and state factions in both Hungary and Chechslovakia were instrumental in the both famous uprisings.

In Zimbabwe, there was the movement of reclaiming land, not for the state, but for the black farmers from private ownership (a disaster).

In the way that the term fascism gets used in general life, somewhat ignorantly, it could be applied to both Soviet style communism, Chinese State communism, Spanish Falangism, Pan Arabic Baathism or Argentinian Juntas; but there are very significant differences (notably in the internal politics and power structure). Also, traditionally both Communism and Fascism are 'opposed forces'.

Similarly one could look a Capitalist Democracies and label them the same, but when you look internally you see a big difference in terms of structure and organization, as well as orientation, whilst obstentially championing many of the same causes and ideals.

I think you are lookin at things through your red glasses and your obvious admiration for 'benevolent' Cuba is at odds with the reality of the regimes treatment of the 'people'.

The fact is that the 'people's regime' is just a glossy veneer which hides the fact that the tolatarian regime suppressed and murdered at will yet dressed it up as a Workers Paradise to give it credibility with and receive sympathy from those around the World who swallow this.

This is just the same glossy veneer the Nazi's sold to elements of the European aristocracy in the 1930's.

To me they are two sides of he same coin and no sane person would support or defend either murderous regime, regardless of the rhetorical or ideological spin either was dressed up as.


Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 2.26pm)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 10 Aug 15 2.31pm

The Socialist Utopia of Cuba.

[Link]

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

ghosteagle Flag 10 Aug 15 2.44pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 2.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 11.18am

Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 10.01am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 9.41am

What Fascism is and isn't

[Link]

A good starting point.

Its often a mistake to see National Socialism (Nazism and Communism as fascist).


I view Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela and Zimbabwe as totalitarian states who use many of the methods and theories described in your link. I am sure you will draw on subtle differences between the states and totalitarianism in its pure, theoretic terms but broad brushing it, you have to admit that the above States operate in a style and mechanism akin to fascism.

Therefore, what is the difference in practice between a left wing and right extremist single party state?

People get massacred in both. Democracy is purged in both. Individualism and liberty of thought is purged. Power is concentrated to a circle of the elite. The institutions of such a country become the tools of the government to use to suppress opposition. The economy is centrally planned and controlled. Free enterprise is deemed as a parasitic endeavour in both.

Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 10.15am)

The ideology and the rhetoric. Cuba, for example, and for whatever view you may personally have of it in terms of freedom, places a very significant emphasis on the provision of its people, as opposed to the nation state (standards of health provision and education in Cuba massively exceed that of most similar third world countries).

Cuba, spent most of its existence as part of the Soviet satellite state, and engages in internationalism which isn't typically a fascist trait - Nationalism isn't that much of a tennet in Soviet or Cuban politics.

Communism and fascism (and especially National Socialism) have a lot of shared ideology (as fascism originated as a response to the appeal of communism), what tends to differ is the organization of the state and itsbody politic, the political rhetoric and probably most notably how those bodies of state function, rather than its actions. Both Fascism and Socialism place great emphasis on the power of unions as a means of protecting the working class, the difference is that in socialism, those organizations are formed and directed for the working class, where as in fascism they serve the state directly.

Whilst it can seem that's the same thing, its worth remembering that in Poland the rise of Solidarity stems from the Unions against the Polish communist state - similarly Union and state factions in both Hungary and Chechslovakia were instrumental in the both famous uprisings.

In Zimbabwe, there was the movement of reclaiming land, not for the state, but for the black farmers from private ownership (a disaster).

In the way that the term fascism gets used in general life, somewhat ignorantly, it could be applied to both Soviet style communism, Chinese State communism, Spanish Falangism, Pan Arabic Baathism or Argentinian Juntas; but there are very significant differences (notably in the internal politics and power structure). Also, traditionally both Communism and Fascism are 'opposed forces'.

Similarly one could look a Capitalist Democracies and label them the same, but when you look internally you see a big difference in terms of structure and organization, as well as orientation, whilst obstentially championing many of the same causes and ideals.

I think you are lookin at things through your red glasses and your obvious admiration for 'benevolent' Cuba is at odds with the reality of the regimes treatment of the 'people'.

The fact is that the 'people's regime' is just a glossy veneer which hides the fact that the tolatarian regime suppressed and murdered at will yet dressed it up as a Workers Paradise to give it credibility with and receive sympathy from those around the World who swallow this.

This is just the same glossy veneer the Nazi's sold to elements of the European aristocracy in the 1930's.

To me they are two sides of he same coin and no sane person would support or defend either murderous regime, regardless of the rhetorical or ideological spin either was dressed up as.


Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 2.26pm)


Who needs history and facts when you have an opinion eh? Keep up the good work.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Aug 15 2.56pm

No one should be in any doubt the sheer murderous nature of the 'revolutionary' regime in Cuba. There is much evidence on the net for this regime.

Meet the new boss.....He's actually worse for you than the old boss.

The Castro revolution was a disaster for most Cubans.

[Link]

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 10 Aug 15 2.57pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 Aug 2015 10.43pm

Oh the irony.A lecture on tolerance from FUE.

You have proposed booby trapping a home occupied by migrants (and likely their kids) and to send the SAS over (I think with you joining them)to mow down all the would-be migrants (all necessarily including kids) in Calais.These struck me as fascistic-like sentiments.

Your partner in tolerance LS (as Derben his red-carded predecessor) suggested he'd move away on principle if people of a different religion,race or ethnicity to him moved in near him (regardless of what they were like as people).The very essence of tolerance, ho hum.

Somewhat different to simply disagreeing with anyone with a different view to me about immigration controls,the EU,the 1951 Convention or migration,no?

How ridiculous of me to be so intolerant by not exhibiting due tolerance towards such sentiments (and,heaven forbid, even viewing them as exhibiting fascistic-like sentiments)and in so doing not realise my views themselves constitute the essence of fascism.

But ,if FUE said so ,it must be true and I'll happily withdraw it.

Instead,such sentiments as FUE's and LS' strike me as the obnoxious mutterings of extreme neanderthals.

Is that ok corkery or does it still make me a horseshoe?

This is exactly the garbage that I talk about. Absolute poppycock.

The rubbish you come out with strikes me as the mutterings of a Liberal fool who hates his country and it's past. Such self loathing results in this outpouring of drivel.

Nice to hear the Tories finally saying what the sensible majority of us think about 'these marauding African immigrants' who are an absolute menace, who take jobs away from our own and who drive wages down. Maybe now we can see some action.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2015 11.15pm)


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Aug 15 3.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Aug 2015 2.56pm

No one should be in any doubt the sheer murderous nature of the 'revolutionary' regime in Cuba. There is much evidence on the net for this regime.

Meet the new boss.....He's actually worse for you than the old boss.

The Castro revolution was a disaster for most Cubans.

[Link]

WTF has this got to do with calais.

A diverson tactic if ever I saw one.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Aug 15 3.09pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Aug 2015 2.56pm

No one should be in any doubt the sheer murderous nature of the 'revolutionary' regime in Cuba. There is much evidence on the net for this regime.

Meet the new boss.....He's actually worse for you than the old boss.

The Castro revolution was a disaster for most Cubans.

[Link]

I can't work out whether the Cuban revolution was ultimately good or bad for Scarface?

 


Red and Blue Army!

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 10 Aug 15 3.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Aug 2015 3.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Aug 2015 2.56pm

No one should be in any doubt the sheer murderous nature of the 'revolutionary' regime in Cuba. There is much evidence on the net for this regime.

Meet the new boss.....He's actually worse for you than the old boss.

The Castro revolution was a disaster for most Cubans.

[Link]

WTF has this got to do with calais.

A diverson tactic if ever I saw one.


Send them all to Cuba that's the answer.....Solve our problem would it not???

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Aug 15 3.20pm

Quote susmik at 10 Aug 2015 3.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Aug 2015 3.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Aug 2015 2.56pm

No one should be in any doubt the sheer murderous nature of the 'revolutionary' regime in Cuba. There is much evidence on the net for this regime.

Meet the new boss.....He's actually worse for you than the old boss.

The Castro revolution was a disaster for most Cubans.

[Link]

WTF has this got to do with calais.

A diverson tactic if ever I saw one.


Send them all to Cuba that's the answer.....Solve our problem would it not???

In overmanned, unsafe boats? perghaps we can charge them for this service too...

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Aug 15 3.30pm

Quote susmik at 10 Aug 2015 3.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Aug 2015 3.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Aug 2015 2.56pm

No one should be in any doubt the sheer murderous nature of the 'revolutionary' regime in Cuba. There is much evidence on the net for this regime.

Meet the new boss.....He's actually worse for you than the old boss.

The Castro revolution was a disaster for most Cubans.

[Link]

WTF has this got to do with calais.

A diverson tactic if ever I saw one.


Send them all to Cuba that's the answer.....Solve our problem would it not???

I don't think Nick would last long in Cuba.....I could be wrong though.....Those latin rhythms.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 10 Aug 15 3.36pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Aug 2015 3.20pm

Quote susmik at 10 Aug 2015 3.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Aug 2015 3.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Aug 2015 2.56pm

No one should be in any doubt the sheer murderous nature of the 'revolutionary' regime in Cuba. There is much evidence on the net for this regime.

Meet the new boss.....He's actually worse for you than the old boss.

The Castro revolution was a disaster for most Cubans.

[Link]

WTF has this got to do with calais.

A diverson tactic if ever I saw one.


Send them all to Cuba that's the answer.....Solve our problem would it not???

In overmanned, unsafe boats? perghaps we can charge them for this service too...

Never thought of that Nick......A Great idea!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Aug 15 3.55pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 2.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 11.18am

Quote matt_himself at 10 Aug 2015 10.01am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Aug 2015 9.41am

What Fascism is and isn't

[Link]

A good starting point.

Its often a mistake to see National Socialism (Nazism and Communism as fascist).


I view Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela and Zimbabwe as totalitarian states who use many of the methods and theories described in your link. I am sure you will draw on subtle differences between the states and totalitarianism in its pure, theoretic terms but broad brushing it, you have to admit that the above States operate in a style and mechanism akin to fascism.

Therefore, what is the difference in practice between a left wing and right extremist single party state?

People get massacred in both. Democracy is purged in both. Individualism and liberty of thought is purged. Power is concentrated to a circle of the elite. The institutions of such a country become the tools of the government to use to suppress opposition. The economy is centrally planned and controlled. Free enterprise is deemed as a parasitic endeavour in both.

Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 10.15am)

The ideology and the rhetoric. Cuba, for example, and for whatever view you may personally have of it in terms of freedom, places a very significant emphasis on the provision of its people, as opposed to the nation state (standards of health provision and education in Cuba massively exceed that of most similar third world countries).

Cuba, spent most of its existence as part of the Soviet satellite state, and engages in internationalism which isn't typically a fascist trait - Nationalism isn't that much of a tennet in Soviet or Cuban politics.

Communism and fascism (and especially National Socialism) have a lot of shared ideology (as fascism originated as a response to the appeal of communism), what tends to differ is the organization of the state and itsbody politic, the political rhetoric and probably most notably how those bodies of state function, rather than its actions. Both Fascism and Socialism place great emphasis on the power of unions as a means of protecting the working class, the difference is that in socialism, those organizations are formed and directed for the working class, where as in fascism they serve the state directly.

Whilst it can seem that's the same thing, its worth remembering that in Poland the rise of Solidarity stems from the Unions against the Polish communist state - similarly Union and state factions in both Hungary and Chechslovakia were instrumental in the both famous uprisings.

In Zimbabwe, there was the movement of reclaiming land, not for the state, but for the black farmers from private ownership (a disaster).

In the way that the term fascism gets used in general life, somewhat ignorantly, it could be applied to both Soviet style communism, Chinese State communism, Spanish Falangism, Pan Arabic Baathism or Argentinian Juntas; but there are very significant differences (notably in the internal politics and power structure). Also, traditionally both Communism and Fascism are 'opposed forces'.

Similarly one could look a Capitalist Democracies and label them the same, but when you look internally you see a big difference in terms of structure and organization, as well as orientation, whilst obstentially championing many of the same causes and ideals.

I think you are lookin at things through your red glasses and your obvious admiration for 'benevolent' Cuba is at odds with the reality of the regimes treatment of the 'people'.

The fact is that the 'people's regime' is just a glossy veneer which hides the fact that the tolatarian regime suppressed and murdered at will yet dressed it up as a Workers Paradise to give it credibility with and receive sympathy from those around the World who swallow this.

This is just the same glossy veneer the Nazi's sold to elements of the European aristocracy in the 1930's.

To me they are two sides of he same coin and no sane person would support or defend either murderous regime, regardless of the rhetorical or ideological spin either was dressed up as.


Edited by matt_himself (10 Aug 2015 2.26pm)

Not really, I just know more about Cuba than I do about North Korea and Zimbarbwe, so I used it to illustrate the difference between Communism and Fascism, rather than a defense of the Cuba regime

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 35 of 51 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Calais migrant trouble