You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 35 of 44 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 9.43pm

Nobody is going to lose their job, so what are the guards going to be doing if it goes ahead? Maybe they can also inspect tickets whilst the train is moving, and look down the six carriages from the middle of the train and inform the driver of a safety issue on 12 carriage trains at stations with bends. Southern/GTR won't be getting rid of ticket inspectors, so why can this not be a solution?

Obviously none of the "intellectuals" of the organisations want to back down, but how about considering it?

Edit: Oh, and they can do all the H&S stuff if the driver dies too. Give them a bonus for it even.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (19 Dec 2016 9.45pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 10.00pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096470]

Nobody is going to lose their job, so what are the guards going to be doing if it goes ahead? Maybe they can also inspect tickets whilst the train is moving, and look down the six carriages from the middle of the train and inform the driver of a safety issue on 12 carriage trains at stations with bends. Southern/GTR won't be getting rid of ticket inspectors, so why can this not be a solution?

Obviously none of the "intellectuals" of the organisations want to back down, but how about considering it?

Edit: Oh, and they can do all the H&S stuff if the driver dies too. Give them a bonus for it even.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (19 Dec 2016 9.45pm)


The long term plan is to get rid of 90% OBS's, to do that you need to get rid of their "safety critical" duties.

At the moment guards are "need to have" Southern want to make that they're a "Nice to Have". If they have any kind of safety role it makes it incredibly hard to get rid of them.

Just texted a ex colleague... results were
93.7 % industrial action short of a strike
87.1% industrial action including strike.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 10.11pm

Originally posted by 7mins


The long term plan is to get rid of 90% OBS's, to do that you need to get rid of their "safety critical" duties.

At the moment guards are "need to have" Southern want to make that they're a "Nice to Have". If they have any kind of safety role it makes it incredibly hard to get rid of them.

Just texted a ex colleague... results were
93.7 % industrial action short of a strike
87.1% industrial action including strike.

That may well be "the long term plan", but you cannot argue that ticket inspectors are being phased out. You said yourself that they need revenue to hit targets for bonuses. If the ticket inspectors job becomes the guards job, then the ticket inspectors job, as it is, will become redundant. So they will eventually become excess to requirements, the said reduction of workforce (90%)?) will reduce, and safety remains at it's current level.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 10.25pm

Originally posted by npn

Still haven't seen a source, which is what I was after. As I said, I don't necessarily doubt it, but without a source it's just a number on a message board.

I'm not expecting she knows the full story from all angles, as, I imagine, neither do you. I'm leaning towards the union point of view slightly, but Southern, ASLEF, and the RMT can ALL go f**k themselves, bluntly. A plague on all their houses

"Drivers on Southern Railway have overwhelmingly voted to strike in a dispute over driver-only trains.

The move raises the prospect of further travel disruption on Southern over the holiday period.

Members of the ASLEF union backed walkouts by 87% and other forms of action by 95%, with a turnout of 77%."


[Link]

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 10.29pm

Originally posted by 7mins

"Drivers on Southern Railway have overwhelmingly voted to strike in a dispute over driver-only trains.

The move raises the prospect of further travel disruption on Southern over the holiday period.

Members of the ASLEF union backed walkouts by 87% and other forms of action by 95%, with a turnout of 77%."


[Link]

Sack them, and there will be a queue round the block for applicants! Feckers don't know where their bread is buttered! Cnuts!

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 10.30pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096482]

That may well be "the long term plan", but you cannot argue that ticket inspectors are being phased out. You said yourself that they need revenue to hit targets for bonuses. If the ticket inspectors job becomes the guards job, then the ticket inspectors job, as it is, will become redundant. So they will eventually become excess to requirements, the said reduction of workforce (90%)?) will reduce, and safety remains at it's current level.

Ticket inspectors are not needed, nor are ticket offices at some stations, I'm not against people losing their jobs (as sad as it is). Guards are needed, they are safety trained (SCB/TCOC/Dets/Isolation/ETC), that's why i'm against them being phased out... the CCTV isn't up to standard, any emergency or assistance protection (safety procedures) will involve drivers leaving a train unattended on the tracks with over 1200 people on it.
There are too many questions unanswered for me (and 94% of drivers) to think this is in any way safe.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 10.33pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096489]

Sack them, and there will be a queue round the block for applicants! Feckers don't know where their bread is buttered! Cnuts!

If you did that, you would have no trains for 18 months. Also drivers train new drivers. Also I can understand someone being against the strikes, but calling someone a cnut for giving up thousands in the name of safety, makes you look a bit thick/chavvy/drunk

Delete as appropriate

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Dec 16 11.01pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096482]

That may well be "the long term plan", but you cannot argue that ticket inspectors are being phased out. You said yourself that they need revenue to hit targets for bonuses. If the ticket inspectors job becomes the guards job, then the ticket inspectors job, as it is, will become redundant. So they will eventually become excess to requirements, the said reduction of workforce (90%)?) will reduce, and safety remains at it's current level.

One could be forgiven for thinking you'd relish people losing their jobs. Particularly those that happen to be in a union. Brilliant. No more pesky workers holding employers to account.

I wonder what would happen.

Maybe like in the prison service where the union couldn't strike.
What happened in Birmingham Prison at the weekend was a result of the union being rendered toothless in their complaints about staffing levels.

But like the railways there's profits and dividends involved so H+S goes out of the window, probably helped by the health and safety gone mad narrative of the last couple of decades.


Yeah you've really thought it through.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.15pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Ticket inspectors are not needed, nor are ticket offices at some stations, I'm not against people losing their jobs (as sad as it is). Guards are needed, they are safety trained (SCB/TCOC/Dets/Isolation/ETC), that's why i'm against them being phased out... the CCTV isn't up to standard, any emergency or assistance protection (safety procedures) will involve drivers leaving a train unattended on the tracks with over 1200 people on it.
There are too many questions unanswered for me (and 94% of drivers) to think this is in any way safe.

You said they are needed so that Southern hit bonus targets. Make your mind up.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.16pm

Originally posted by 7mins

If you did that, you would have no trains for 18 months. Also drivers train new drivers. Also I can understand someone being against the strikes, but calling someone a cnut for giving up thousands in the name of safety, makes you look a bit thick/chavvy/drunk

Delete as appropriate

I was being flippant. But I think they are being arrogant.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.18pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

One could be forgiven for thinking you'd relish people losing their jobs. Particularly those that happen to be in a union. Brilliant. No more pesky workers holding employers to account.

I wonder what would happen.

Maybe like in the prison service where the union couldn't strike.
What happened in Birmingham Prison at the weekend was a result of the union being rendered toothless in their complaints about staffing levels.

But like the railways there's profits and dividends involved so H+S goes out of the window, probably helped by the health and safety gone mad narrative of the last couple of decades.


Yeah you've really thought it through.

I don't relish people losing jobs, but if they are obsolete, they are necessary.

What do prisons have to do with this strike?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.25pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096500]

I don't relish people losing jobs, but if they are obsolete, they are necessary.

What do prisons have to do with this strike?

That's why I said I have no problem with ticket office etc losing their job.

Guards are safety trained, If Southern want rid, they should employ more platform staff to help with dispatch and upgrade the in cab cctv.

That's the minimum they should have done.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.27pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096499]

I was being flippant. But I think they are being arrogant.

Arrogant???
Explain pls?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.29pm

Originally posted by 7mins

That's why I said I have no problem with ticket office etc losing their job.

Guards are safety trained, If Southern want rid, they should employ more platform staff to help with dispatch and upgrade the in cab cctv.

That's the minimum they should have done.

Can't the retained guards do that? Or is it beneath them?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.32pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096504]

Can't the retained guards do that? Or is it beneath them?

Yes they could, and I have no idea if the guards think it is beneath (thought it a silly question to be honest)

But the above is a moot point, as Southern have no intention to retrain them.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.33pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Arrogant???
Explain pls?

Arrogance. Thinking you are better than you are, or know better than others. A bit like Alan Pardew is accused of. So they vote to inflict misery on thousands. Without facing the hardship.

Actually, a bit like yourself. You think you know better, because you worked there, but in reality, you were party to next to no information, apart from what you did for a job. You didn't like what you did, so you left. Now you have a chip on your shoulder. Did you leave? Or were you pushed?

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (19 Dec 2016 11.39pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.39pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096507]

Arrogance. Thinking you are better than you are, or know better than others. A bit like Alan Pardew is accused of. So they vote to inflict misery on thousands. Without facing the hardship.

They voted to strike of safety issues, they are losing thousands and they will never get that money back... all for safety... hardly arrogant. Southern management refused talks, so drivers voted for industrial action... I think that is arrogant.

Could it be, that you don't know what your talking about?

^don't be offended, it's just a question...I'm trying to gauge your level of knowledge

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.41pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Yes they could, and I have no idea if the guards think it is beneath (thought it a silly question to be honest)

But the above is a moot point, as Southern have no intention to retrain them.

They said there will be no redundancies. Do you choose to disbelieve them, or do you have evidence?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.47pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096511]

They said there will be no redundancies. Do you choose to disbelieve them, or do you have evidence?

There will be no redundancies... I absolutely believe them.
They will move all guards over to OBS's and no jobs will be lost, but as I have repeatedly said... job losses are of no concern to me.

What is of concern to me, is cutting back on safety trained staff...let them sack off all the gateline/ticket office staff they want... I don't think they should get rid safety trained staff... my point of view has never been based on staff losing their jobs.... s*** happens, but you can't get rid of saftey critical trained staff.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.48pm

It's almost like this dispute is about safety...who'd a thunk it huh?

 

Page 35 of 44 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong