This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
He is 30 years old.
If he is top 6 why has none of them come in for him as soon as it was known he would be a free agent you would expect rather then go out spending they would sign him on a free. Wilf does not have a hugh impact in positive way look at his stats they are not great and in negative way is correct with his laziness and moaning/losing temper. Top players do not stay at a club like Palace for 8 years. He has 0 European football experience and even his National team record is not great. If he was surrounded by 3/4 defenders as you claim Palace should be walking to ball in for goals you are thinking of old Wilf. (The current Wilf gives the ball away a lot of the time and has no interest in evening having assists last season he had only 2 the year before 1) Palace need to move on from him If they did retain him 2 year deal at the most and either the same money is is currently on or a reduction even 130 grand a week is too much. We don't know if any of the top 6 has come in for him to be honest. We don't really know anything, it's all guesswork and clickbait reports. Also, stats don't tell the whole story so that's not exactly the best way of looking at his career at Palace.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
We absolutely would be buzzing about it. He quite clearly wouldn't walk into the top 6 sides, hence the lack of interest. All the big clubs have at least 2 top left forwards. I don't think the issue is that people don't want him or respect him, but: 200k/4 years is a lot, especially for a 30yr old He is showing zero desire to resign for us. And ultimately we want players to want to play for us When there are options out there like a 22yr old Hudson-Odoi that feels like a more exciting long term prospect Yeah I get that the outlook from the fans is that he doesn't want to re-sign for us because he seems to be holding out for better. No one knows though because we're not told and not going to be told. I believe Wilf has earned the right to see what else is out there before potentially committing to us. If we want him, and we clearly do, then £200k a week for 4 years (if offered) puts us in the top 3/4 offers he is likely to receive. If it was £150k for 2 years, I'd say we don't have a chance. I have no doubt though that the board and Parish have costed up the risk/reward of this and clearly can afford to pay him that from our current budget. There is no transfer fee for him too so that probably plays a factor, as if we were to replace him - that could cost us around £30-40m for the transfer fee. When you sign a free agent you have to offer a contract that is bloated because there is no transfer fee. All clubs will do the same thing so it bloats the market. That's all that is happening here
|
|
|
Originally posted by SurbsEagle
We don't know if any of the top 6 has come in for him to be honest. We don't really know anything, it's all guesswork and clickbait reports. Also, stats don't tell the whole story so that's not exactly the best way of looking at his career at Palace.
Zaha makes too many poor choices and has been said in other posts, too often loses the ball these days. He also slows the play down when we fans are willing him to pass the ball quickly to players who are in promising positions. I'm sorry but the Zaha you seem to be promoting was a player at his peak and that is no longer the case. He's been a great player for us but he owes us nothing and neither do we owe him anything. Time to move on for both parties. Edited by doombear (06 Jul 2023 3.02pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Lets be honest we would all be happy if zaha was to sign for us. Let's be honest, You're wrong
|
|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
Let's be honest, You're wrong I think there's two considerations here: 1. Wilf will always be known as a Palace player, a local lad who has been with us (albeit not through choice) throughout one of our most sustained, successful spells ever. He's been an absolutely brilliant player that we've been lucky to keep ahold of for a number of reasons and there is evidence to suggest we were almost solely dependant on him for our PL survival for long periods. Therefore the thought of a Wilf-less Palace, even if not logical, is very daunting for some of us coupled with the very real suggestion we may not/will not be able to replace him. He has been our talisman and figurehead. 2. The logical business case that Wilf is not the player he once was, perhaps more prone to injury now, we have a much better squad and the finances involved are unjustified especially when they could be used elsewhere. Add to that he seems to be holding us to ransom and both actively and publicly looking elsewhere, emotion can turn against him. I happen to be in the first camp, and feel comfortable justifying it, however I also hold nothing against and understand those in the second and their position. I suppose we will see how this will all pan out but I do fear the longer it plays out the more detrimental it will become all round. Edited by Nicholas91 (06 Jul 2023 3.51pm)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Zaha makes too many poor choices and has been said in other posts, too often loses the ball these days. He also slows the play down when we fans are willing him to pass the ball quickly to players who are in promising positions. I'm sorry but the Zaha you seem to be promoting was a player at his peak and that is no longer the case. He's been a great player for us but he owes us nothing and neither do we owe him anything. Time to move on for both parties. Edited by doombear (06 Jul 2023 3.02pm) For me, I agree with Arsenal. I did say possibly not Arsenal when I referenced the top 6. I personally don't agree that Wilf gives the ball away too much, I think that's a cheap assessment of his game. Wilf, along with other flair players, will often try things that others can't. As a result is more likely to lose the ball, but if he gets it right could result in 1 or 3 points for the team. He only has to get it right once, doesn't matter too much how many times he gets it wrong because the team is built to allow for that. I appreciate people have different opinions, that's football and that's why we love it. For me, Wilf is the greatest player to pull on the red and blue and it would be a real shame to see him leave. Then again, I was sad when Speroni hung the gloves up and that probably happened 4 seasons too late! Edited by SurbsEagle (06 Jul 2023 3.53pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
Let's be honest, You're wrong So , Im not alone thinking we are better off without him then .
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
So , Im not alone thinking we are better off without him then . No you are not alone, although I wouldn’t necessarily say better off without him, but possibly better off with £200k per week to spend elsewhere. That is of course as long as it is actually used to improve the team and not to improve the owners holiday funds. If he goes and the money is not invested in the team then yes we will be a lot worse off.
|
|
|
aye Originally posted by Nicholas91
I think there's two considerations here: 1. Wilf will always be known as a Palace player, a local lad who has been with us (albeit not through choice) throughout one of our most sustained, successful spells ever. He's been an absolutely brilliant player that we've been lucky to keep ahold of for a number of reasons and there is evidence to suggest we were almost solely dependant on him for our PL survival for long periods. Therefore the thought of a Wilf-less Palace, even if not logical, is very daunting for some of us coupled with the very real suggestion we may not/will not be able to replace him. He has been our talisman and figurehead. 2. The logical business case that Wilf is not the player he once was, perhaps more prone to injury now, we have a much better squad and the finances involved are unjustified especially when they could be used elsewhere. Add to that he seems to be holding us to ransom and both actively and publicly looking elsewhere, emotion can turn against him. I happen to be in the first camp, and feel comfortable justifying it, however I also hold nothing against and understand those in the second and their position. I suppose we will see how this will all pan out but I do fear the longer it plays out the more detrimental it will become all round. Edited by Nicholas91 (06 Jul 2023 3.51pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Forget its Wilf, He is a 30 year old, possibly injury prone past his best, free agent, similar to Willian, would any body be happy if we signed him on a 4 year contract, on say 130k a week, everyone would think we had lost the plot, and dont say Zaha is better than Willian, because he wasn't. In all honesty , i really do think the team as a whole lifted their game when he wasnt playing. They looked relieved and tried to prove a point and they did . Pure madness to give a player lets face it he will be 31 in 4 months a 4 year contract. Dont get me wrong he has been fantastic for us in the past but it just doesnt make good busnisses sense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Unlike others I’m surprised that the top 6 don’t appear to be interested in Zaha and I may have to sadly re-appraise my ability to judge a player from positive to negative. While Zaha may now be on the wane I don’t believe he’ll fall off a cliff and his Premier League record can be scrutinised favourably against the likes of Sancho, Antony, Pulisic, Zyech, Richarlison, Nunes, Trossard and Havertz who have all featured heavily for top 6 clubs. He’s not a Mane or Salah in terms of his goals, but is versatile and can play anywhere across a front 3, or in a 451 or a 442. In fact there is a part of me that wished he had joined Man City a few years ago as I believe Pep could have improved him as a player as he has done with so many others. I think you are remembering a Wilf of two years ago, and no fan has not enjoyed and appreciated his contribution, But, as Croydon-Trucker says we are a better team NOW when he dosent play
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I think you are remembering a Wilf of two years ago, and no fan has not enjoyed and appreciated his contribution, But, as Croydon-Trucker says we are a better team NOW when he dosent play I wouldn't say were a better team when he doesn't play. I would say 2 years ago, when Zaha didn't play, we were awful to watch and probably easy to play against. The fact we are now a better all round team is skewing fans into thinking we don't need Wilf. He was our top scorer last season until Roy came back in and revitalised Ebs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I know it is all about opinions, but i would rather have Willian on a one year deal, or Hudson Odoi on a 4/5 year deal than wilf on a 4 year deal, neck and millstone come to mind Is just an opinion but I think a fair one.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I know it is all about opinions, but i would rather have Willian on a one year deal, or Hudson Odoi on a 4/5 year deal than wilf on a 4 year deal, neck and millstone come to mind On reflection,we are frankly better off without this ill,disciplined,petulant, Edited by Jacey (06 Jul 2023 5.56pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.