You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > General Election 2015 thread
November 22 2026 2.20am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

General Election 2015 thread


Page 36 of 40 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >
crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 09 May 15 12.36am

Quote imbored at 09 May 2015 12.15am

Quote crystal balls at 09 May 2015 12.10am

Quote imbored at 08 May 2015 8.33pm

Quote TUX at 08 May 2015 8.16pm

Quote crystal balls at 08 May 2015 8.05pm

Quote Willo at 08 May 2015 7.36pm

Quote derben at 08 May 2015 7.33pm

Quote Willo at 08 May 2015 6.49pm

My compassion leads me to think about all those who lost their seats through no fault of their own. It must have been devastating for the vanquished particularly those with sizeable majorities who would have expected to keep their seats.Politics can be very cruel.

And even though I am a devout Conservative who campaigned tirelessly in marginals, I take my hat off to Miliband and Ed Balls for the magnanimous and respectful way they accepted defeat and the same could probably be said of many,many others. It cannot be easy to make such gracious speeches and at such times.

Edited by Willo (08 May 2015 6.50pm)

'marginals', are they some sort of trousers?

LOL !

A Tory friend of advanced years refers to them as "Slacks" !


Congratulations, Willo, your assessment of the situation was correct, more so than most of the polls. "I doff my hat".

[Link]

Did he post it here previously or are you purely relying on the 'say so' of man who walks the streets and annoys people. Much like a Jehovah Witness?


Indeed. Willo is 'devout' and very much treats his allegiance to the tories as a religion. In a future election where there's a Labour win, this isn't a man who's going to be predicting it. A broken clock is right twice a day .

Yes he was always confident of a Tory majority, even when I and many others were sceptical of his assessment of the outcome. Obviously, a broken clock is right twice a day, but he showed great faith even when his opinion was open to ridicule by many of us, so fair play to him.

He has earned the kudos of actually canvassing on behalf of his party, knocking on doors etc. as opposed to being a keyboard observer, so he deserves credit, even though I personally disagree with his views.

What I'm saying is that he's so passionate about the Conservatives and towing the party line, he'd have said that regardless, anything else would be self defeating. Don't get me wrong, I think people with that attitude are of huge benefit to the party they are dedicated to, I'm just saying that it wasn't so much a canny prediction as it was an unfaltering display of loyalty.


Edited by imbored (09 May 2015 12.16am)

Of course, but faith in what you believe to be right counts for something, even when most people don't share that belief. He was right in the end, so even if he was just spouting party sound bites, he genuinely believed what he was doing.

I'd like to think that I'd get credit if I was right in having faith in what I believed in.

 


I used to be immortal

imbored Flag UK 09 May 15 12.51am

Quote crystal balls at 09 May 2015 12.36am

Quote imbored at 09 May 2015 12.15am

Quote crystal balls at 09 May 2015 12.10am

Quote imbored at 08 May 2015 8.33pm

Quote TUX at 08 May 2015 8.16pm

Quote crystal balls at 08 May 2015 8.05pm

Quote Willo at 08 May 2015 7.36pm

Quote derben at 08 May 2015 7.33pm

Quote Willo at 08 May 2015 6.49pm

My compassion leads me to think about all those who lost their seats through no fault of their own. It must have been devastating for the vanquished particularly those with sizeable majorities who would have expected to keep their seats.Politics can be very cruel.

And even though I am a devout Conservative who campaigned tirelessly in marginals, I take my hat off to Miliband and Ed Balls for the magnanimous and respectful way they accepted defeat and the same could probably be said of many,many others. It cannot be easy to make such gracious speeches and at such times.

Edited by Willo (08 May 2015 6.50pm)

'marginals', are they some sort of trousers?

LOL !

A Tory friend of advanced years refers to them as "Slacks" !


Congratulations, Willo, your assessment of the situation was correct, more so than most of the polls. "I doff my hat".

[Link]

Did he post it here previously or are you purely relying on the 'say so' of man who walks the streets and annoys people. Much like a Jehovah Witness?


Indeed. Willo is 'devout' and very much treats his allegiance to the tories as a religion. In a future election where there's a Labour win, this isn't a man who's going to be predicting it. A broken clock is right twice a day .

Yes he was always confident of a Tory majority, even when I and many others were sceptical of his assessment of the outcome. Obviously, a broken clock is right twice a day, but he showed great faith even when his opinion was open to ridicule by many of us, so fair play to him.

He has earned the kudos of actually canvassing on behalf of his party, knocking on doors etc. as opposed to being a keyboard observer, so he deserves credit, even though I personally disagree with his views.

What I'm saying is that he's so passionate about the Conservatives and towing the party line, he'd have said that regardless, anything else would be self defeating. Don't get me wrong, I think people with that attitude are of huge benefit to the party they are dedicated to, I'm just saying that it wasn't so much a canny prediction as it was an unfaltering display of loyalty.


Edited by imbored (09 May 2015 12.16am)

Of course, but faith in what you believe to be right counts for something, even when most people don't share that belief. He was right in the end, so even if he was just spouting party sound bites, he genuinely believed what he was doing.

I'd like to think that I'd get credit if I was right in having faith in what I believed in.


It certainly counts for something, I'm not arguing that. Only saying that someone telling us that a party is going to win, who would likely say that in all but an incredibly negative scenario, is not making a stunning prediction, they are instead displaying loyalty.

Much like diehards for Labour, Lib Dems and UKIP it's essentially your job to think that the very best case scenario is the one you're on the brink of and that things are going your way. Case in point Nick Clegg was confident that the Lib Dems were going to be 'the surprise story' of the election based on what he was seeing on the ground. Of course he was right, but for the opposite reason he expected.

But yes, I commend Willo for showing passion for what he believes in beyond typing on a keyboard .

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 May 15 1.54am

Quote JL85 at 08 May 2015 8.16pm

Does anyone know why the last 2 elections were 5 years apart and the previous 2 4 years?


Google "Fixed Term Parliament Act"

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

matt_himself Flag Matataland 09 May 15 3.50am

Class War got 65 votes in Croydon South.

Keep reaching for that rainbow, boys!

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 09 May 15 5.14am

.

Edited by Bubbs (09 May 2015 5.19am)

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 09 May 15 5.18am

Quote JL85 at 08 May 2015 8.16pm

Does anyone know why the last 2 elections were 5 years apart and the previous 2 4 years?


This was the first election that was a fixed 5 year term, which means that the date of the election is set in stone 5 years after the last one.

Previous elections were up to the discretion of the incumbent Government. They could call an election anytime they wanted within the 5 year limit.

Obviously, Governments would wait for the optimum moment to call one when they thought their stock was highest. Very much a game of poker.

When Tony Blair stepped down and let Brown in as PM, 2 years into his term; there was strong speculation that Brown, for credibility and fairness as he was unelected by the country, would call an election to get the mandate of the people. He was in his honeymoon period with the public and would almost certainly had won. He decided not to.

Roll on a year, and the banking crisis and suddenly his popularity plummeted; so he stretched out his term to the 5 year limit in the hope that his fortunes could turn.

He must look back on his decision not to go to the country in 2007/8 and kick himself.

Edited by Bubbs (09 May 2015 5.23am)

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

JL85 Flag London,SE9 09 May 15 6.20am

Quote Bubbs at 09 May 2015 5.18am

Quote JL85 at 08 May 2015 8.16pm

Does anyone know why the last 2 elections were 5 years apart and the previous 2 4 years?


This was the first election that was a fixed 5 year term, which means that the date of the election is set in stone 5 years after the last one.

Previous elections were up to the discretion of the incumbent Government. They could call an election anytime they wanted within the 5 year limit.

Obviously, Governments would wait for the optimum moment to call one when they thought their stock was highest. Very much a game of poker.

When Tony Blair stepped down and let Brown in as PM, 2 years into his term; there was strong speculation that Brown, for credibility and fairness as he was unelected by the country, would call an election to get the mandate of the people. He was in his honeymoon period with the public and would almost certainly had won. He decided not to.

Roll on a year, and the banking crisis and suddenly his popularity plummeted; so he stretched out his term to the 5 year limit in the hope that his fortunes could turn.

He must look back on his decision not to go to the country in 2007/8 and kick himself.

Edited by Bubbs (09 May 2015 5.23am)


Thanks Bubbs.

I liked Brown, he was a s***e PM but a rather genuine guy. I spent the best part of 6 years working at both the Treasury and Foreign Office and had the displeasure of meeting a fair few MP's and Blair himself.


Blair was a t***, as was David Miliband. Brown was alright. Always polite and friendly and would often sit and have breakfast amongst the workers.

Also remember Ed Balls and thinking he was a a bit of a nob. Probably because of his surname, but I was 17 at the time.

Edited by JL85 (09 May 2015 6.38am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 May 15 8.22am

Quote imbored at 09 May 2015 12.51am

But yes, I commend Willo for showing passion for what he believes in beyond typing on a keyboard .

That's very kind of you.Thank you very much.


 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 15 9.28am

Quote serial thriller at 08 May 2015 3.24pm

Quote Lyons550 at 08 May 2015 2.51pm

Quote serial thriller at 08 May 2015 11.07am

Quote matt_himself at 08 May 2015 6.02am

Quote serial thriller at 08 May 2015 12.09am

Unbelievably depressing. Even as someone who didn't vote, I can appreciate how terrible a Tory/UKIP/DUP coalition would be.

I might have to take up smoking again.


You have no grounds to complain if you did t vote.


Why, do you think my vote could've swayed it?


Seeing as certain seats were won with as small a margin as 45 votes...quite easily


Then that's the party's fault for not providing a better platform for my views, thus not gaining my vote.

That's the thing about democracy, it makes those in power accountable, rather than those who are voting, who hold all the cards.


Gutless

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 09 May 15 11.58am

Quote JL85 at 09 May 2015 6.20am

Quote Bubbs at 09 May 2015 5.18am

Quote JL85 at 08 May 2015 8.16pm

Does anyone know why the last 2 elections were 5 years apart and the previous 2 4 years?


This was the first election that was a fixed 5 year term, which means that the date of the election is set in stone 5 years after the last one.

Previous elections were up to the discretion of the incumbent Government. They could call an election anytime they wanted within the 5 year limit.

Obviously, Governments would wait for the optimum moment to call one when they thought their stock was highest. Very much a game of poker.

When Tony Blair stepped down and let Brown in as PM, 2 years into his term; there was strong speculation that Brown, for credibility and fairness as he was unelected by the country, would call an election to get the mandate of the people. He was in his honeymoon period with the public and would almost certainly had won. He decided not to.

Roll on a year, and the banking crisis and suddenly his popularity plummeted; so he stretched out his term to the 5 year limit in the hope that his fortunes could turn.

He must look back on his decision not to go to the country in 2007/8 and kick himself.

Edited by Bubbs (09 May 2015 5.23am)


Thanks Bubbs.

I liked Brown, he was a s***e PM but a rather genuine guy. I spent the best part of 6 years working at both the Treasury and Foreign Office and had the displeasure of meeting a fair few MP's and Blair himself.


Blair was a t***, as was David Miliband. Brown was alright. Always polite and friendly and would often sit and have breakfast amongst the workers.

Also remember Ed Balls and thinking he was a a bit of a nob. Probably because of his surname, but I was 17 at the time.

Edited by JL85 (09 May 2015 6.38am)

Wow, that's some job to have as a youngster being exposed to that.

That was the sad thing about Brown: he let his spin doctors dictate how he should present himself and it just came out all wrong. They should've just let him act naturally and it would've come across so much better. The smiling thing was painful to watch.

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 09 May 15 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

matt_himself Flag Matataland 09 May 15 12.30pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2015 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.


Not to mention five years of Facebook bleating about 'desperate' kids and 'impoverished' OAP's.

The fact that on Facebook most lefties appear to want to replace democracy with a system whereby they, and only they, can choose the government, is alarmingly akin to fascism.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

legaleagle Flag 09 May 15 12.58pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2015 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.


Maybe exceeded only by ceaseless battering of the "vulnerable"

 

derben Flag 09 May 15 1.27pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 12.58pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2015 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.


Maybe exceeded only by ceaseless battering of the "vulnerable"

How could the electorate be so stupid, or knowingly wicked, to vote for a government that will ceaselessly batter the vulnerable (isn't that in contravention of one of the many clauses of the Human Rights Act?)

Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.27pm)

 

DanH Flag SW2 09 May 15 1.31pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 1.27pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 12.58pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2015 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.


Maybe exceeded only by ceaseless battering of the "vulnerable"

How could the electorate be so stupid, or knowingly wicked, to vote for a government that will ceaselessly batter the vulnerable (isn't that in contravention of one of the many clauses of the Human Rights Act?)

Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.27pm)


The Human Rights Act which was in the Tory manifesto to scrap?

 

derben Flag 09 May 15 1.37pm

Quote DanH at 09 May 2015 1.31pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 1.27pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 12.58pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2015 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.


Maybe exceeded only by ceaseless battering of the "vulnerable"

How could the electorate be so stupid, or knowingly wicked, to vote for a government that will ceaselessly batter the vulnerable (isn't that in contravention of one of the many clauses of the Human Rights Act?)

Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.27pm)


The Human Rights Act which was in the Tory manifesto to scrap?

Good - they are going to replace it with a British Bill of Rights (no doubt with a clause in it to stop ceaseless battering of the vulnerable.


Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.38pm)

 

DanH Flag SW2 09 May 15 1.47pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 1.37pm

Quote DanH at 09 May 2015 1.31pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 1.27pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 12.58pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2015 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.


Maybe exceeded only by ceaseless battering of the "vulnerable"

How could the electorate be so stupid, or knowingly wicked, to vote for a government that will ceaselessly batter the vulnerable (isn't that in contravention of one of the many clauses of the Human Rights Act?)

Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.27pm)


The Human Rights Act which was in the Tory manifesto to scrap?

Good - they are going to replace it with a British Bill of Rights (no doubt with a clause in it to stop ceaseless battering of the vulnerable.


Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.38pm)


What part of the current Human Rights Act is so terrible out of interest?

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 09 May 15 1.49pm

Quote Bubbs at 09 May 2015 11.58am

Quote JL85 at 09 May 2015 6.20am

Quote Bubbs at 09 May 2015 5.18am

Quote JL85 at 08 May 2015 8.16pm

Does anyone know why the last 2 elections were 5 years apart and the previous 2 4 years?


This was the first election that was a fixed 5 year term, which means that the date of the election is set in stone 5 years after the last one.

Previous elections were up to the discretion of the incumbent Government. They could call an election anytime they wanted within the 5 year limit.

Obviously, Governments would wait for the optimum moment to call one when they thought their stock was highest. Very much a game of poker.

When Tony Blair stepped down and let Brown in as PM, 2 years into his term; there was strong speculation that Brown, for credibility and fairness as he was unelected by the country, would call an election to get the mandate of the people. He was in his honeymoon period with the public and would almost certainly had won. He decided not to.

Roll on a year, and the banking crisis and suddenly his popularity plummeted; so he stretched out his term to the 5 year limit in the hope that his fortunes could turn.

He must look back on his decision not to go to the country in 2007/8 and kick himself.

Edited by Bubbs (09 May 2015 5.23am)


Thanks Bubbs.

I liked Brown, he was a s***e PM but a rather genuine guy. I spent the best part of 6 years working at both the Treasury and Foreign Office and had the displeasure of meeting a fair few MP's and Blair himself.


Blair was a t***, as was David Miliband. Brown was alright. Always polite and friendly and would often sit and have breakfast amongst the workers.

Also remember Ed Balls and thinking he was a a bit of a nob. Probably because of his surname, but I was 17 at the time.

Edited by JL85 (09 May 2015 6.38am)

Wow, that's some job to have as a youngster being exposed to that.

That was the sad thing about Brown: he let his spin doctors dictate how he should present himself and it just came out all wrong. They should've just let him act naturally and it would've come across so much better. The smiling thing was painful to watch.

Apprentice maintenance engineer

Someone's got to unblock their s***ters


Edited by JL85 (09 May 2015 1.50pm)

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 09 May 15 2.04pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 1.37pm

Quote DanH at 09 May 2015 1.31pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 1.27pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 12.58pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2015 12.08pm

BBC Any Questions going on about the poor and disabled having to 'despair'.

That's one guarantee of a tory majority: ceaseless bleating about the 'vulnerable'.

Not sure I can take 5 years of it.


Maybe exceeded only by ceaseless battering of the "vulnerable"

How could the electorate be so stupid, or knowingly wicked, to vote for a government that will ceaselessly batter the vulnerable (isn't that in contravention of one of the many clauses of the Human Rights Act?)

Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.27pm)


The Human Rights Act which was in the Tory manifesto to scrap?

Good - they are going to replace it with a British Bill of Rights (no doubt with a clause in it to stop ceaseless battering of the vulnerable.


Edited by derben (09 May 2015 1.38pm)


We've had a Bill of Rights for over 300 years.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 09 May 15 2.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 May 2015 4.47pm

Bennett has just confirmed she's staying on as leader of the greens!

They really are clueless.


Should read "Useless"

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Page 36 of 40 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > General Election 2015 thread