You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 36 of 44 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.48pm

Originally posted by 7mins

They voted to strike of safety issues, they are losing thousands and they will never get that money back... all for safety... hardly arrogant. Southern management refused talks, so drivers voted for industrial action... I think that is arrogant.

Could it be, that you don't know what your talking about?

^don't be offended, it's just a question...I'm trying to gauge your level of knowledge

There is no evidence of safety issues. It has been proved by an independent board, and the guards will still be there. Albeit not solely as guards. That stinks of "jobs for the boys". And I don't doubt Southern's duplicity in this. But they are merely providing a poor service. Not no service.

And try not to be so condescending with your "You don't know what you are talking about" comments. It's tedious.

The union will give them some of their wages too, unlike the commuters who work in the real world.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (19 Dec 2016 11.50pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Dec 16 11.52pm

Originally posted by 7mins

It's almost like this dispute is about safety...who'd a thunk it huh?

So, you agree that the safety trained staff keep their jobs, where is the safety issue?

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (19 Dec 2016 11.52pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.58pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096515]

There is no evidence of safety issues. It has been proved by an independent board, and the guards will still be there. Albeit not solely as guards. That stinks of "jobs for the boys". And I don't doubt Southern's duplicity in this. But they are merely providing a poor service. Not no service.

And try not to be so condescending with your "You don't know what you are talking about" comments. It's tedious.

The union will give them some of their wages too, unlike the commuters who work in the real world.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (19 Dec 2016 11.50pm)

You are wrong... the guards will not still be there, they will have no safety responsibilities at all.
The RSSB has a board of directors... one is Charles Horton, the current CEO of Southern... That isn't independent... Read the thread... When I worked for Southern we had Birchall in charge, and we struggled to get stuff past RSSB, then Horton becomes CEO, and bingo... he gets stuff past RSSB.

The RSSB said DOO is safe IF the relevant TOC have put in place their own safety procedures...have you seen the cctv images on here?
Not fit for purpose.

Jobs for boys??? Why would drivers give up thousands of pounds for guards they hardly ever met.... would you give up £1000's for another department in your company?

If it's about jobs for boys, why didn't drivers strike for platform/gateline/ticket office?

Would it be possible for you to answer my points.
Ta muchly

 

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 16 11.59pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096518]

So, you agree that the safety trained staff keep their jobs, where is the safety issue?

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (19 Dec 2016 11.52pm)

No...the safety trained staff lose their safety jobs... they then get non safety jobs.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 20 Dec 16 12.16am

Originally posted by 7mins

You are wrong... the guards will not still be there, they will have no safety responsibilities at all.
The RSSB has a board of directors... one is Charles Horton, the current CEO of Southern... That isn't independent... Read the thread... When I worked for Southern we had Birchall in charge, and we struggled to get stuff past RSSB, then Horton becomes CEO, and bingo... he gets stuff past RSSB.

The RSSB said DOO is safe IF the relevant TOC have put in place their own safety procedures...have you seen the cctv images on here?
Not fit for purpose.

Jobs for boys??? Why would drivers give up thousands of pounds for guards they hardly ever met.... would you give up £1000's for another department in your company?

If it's about jobs for boys, why didn't drivers strike for platform/gateline/ticket office?

Would it be possible for you to answer my points.
Ta muchly

You said there will be no redundancies.So the guards are still employed. What will they be doing? Safety stuff maybe? Just guessing, as I am obviously a fool.

Are these drivers who are striking the same ones whose very likelihood depends on the the needless guards they have hardly ever met? And, as you said, the other jobs mentioned are low skill jobs, so expendable. (Like you say. In your earlier post.)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 20 Dec 16 12.23am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096500]

I don't relish people losing jobs, but if they are obsolete, they are necessary.

What do prisons have to do with this strike?

Prison workers cannot strike by law. One of the consequences of this is that they are rendered toothless if any issues arise. One of the issues is that in order to save money / increase dividends a large number of staff went. As we saw in Birmingham jail at the weekend, 2 guards failed to control 150 inmates. Now if those communists in the unions had the option of strike action they may have used the threat in order to negotiate and compromise with g4s serco or whoever (notice how often those names crop up)and there would have been a much more safe ratio of guards to prisoners. It may be that what happened at the weekend.

Let's be thankful that these drivers can take action when they feel that what they are being asked to do is unsafe but they are still liable.

If you haven't taken the time to read the thread I suggest you do.

I can't imagine what a pain in the arse this strike has been. It shows what an important job these drivers and guards do keep the city moving. They want to work, but safely.

And yes you've got someone gobbing off about bringing down the government, but there always will be. It's the left ffs.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 6.28am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3096521]

You said there will be no redundancies.So the guards are still employed. What will they be doing? Safety stuff maybe? Just guessing, as I am obviously a fool.

Are these drivers who are striking the same ones whose very likelihood depends on the the needless guards they have hardly ever met? And, as you said, the other jobs mentioned are low skill jobs, so expendable. (Like you say. In your earlier post.)

Guards are being changed in to OBS's. With NO safety responsibilities AT ALL.

 

cardiff eagle Flag 20 Dec 16 6.38am

Originally posted by 7mins

Guards are being changed in to OBS's. With NO safety responsibilities AT ALL.

Assume this also means that legally they cannot do the safety stuff even if they know how to also? So whilst some would still have the skills (albeit diminish over time due to lack of refreshers), they wouldn't be able to act on them without breaching policy. Which is almost like they don't have the skills.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 7.09am

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Assume this also means that legally they cannot do the safety stuff even if they know how to also? So whilst some would still have the skills (albeit diminish over time due to lack of refreshers), they wouldn't be able to act on them without breaching policy. Which is almost like they don't have the skills.

Southern have explicitly told guards that are trained in safety procedures that when they become OBS's on Jan 1st, they are never to use the safety procedures, as they aren't covered by insurance, and if they attempted to help, they'd be no legal protection from company.

I'm gonna be vague here on purpose, as I don't want to offend any of the people involved.

A few years ago on a rural route, a train driver killed a middle aged man in front of his wife and daughter on a farm crossing. It wasn't suicide, the guy stepped out on track, while being distracted. That train driver had to comfort the mans wife and child while guard arranged emergency services (the man didn't die on impact). Without that guard, the wife and daughter would have been left alone with their husband/dad as he slowly died from massive injuries.

The train driver never drove a train again after that night.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 20 Dec 16 7.21am

That's a very sad story and I'm not convinced that an unlikely one off tragic event should be used to justify current union action so I'll not respond to that and leave my thoughts and deepest condolences with that family.

What I would ask is whether people think that the current stalemate, preventing key staff from getting to Europes biggest financial heartbeat is healthy at a time when a lot of the large companies in the City are considering their future in the U.K following Brexit? (And please don't bang on about Brexit - I'm just interested if people think an unreliable and strike ridden transport infrastructure could make a few minds up and seal a number of companies (and therefore lots of employees - who have done nothing but try to get to work - fate)?

 

cardiff eagle Flag 20 Dec 16 7.30am

Originally posted by Helmet46

That's a very sad story and I'm not convinced that an unlikely one off tragic event should be used to justify current union action so I'll not respond to that and leave my thoughts and deepest condolences with that family.

What I would ask is whether people think that the current stalemate, preventing key staff from getting to Europes biggest financial heartbeat is healthy at a time when a lot of the large companies in the City are considering their future in the U.K following Brexit? (And please don't bang on about Brexit - I'm just interested if people think an unreliable and strike ridden transport infrastructure could make a few minds up and seal a number of companies (and therefore lots of employees - who have done nothing but try to get to work - fate)?

I don't think it's acceptable but am unsure as to what other option they have. Strikes are usually last course of action when talks have either not been engaged with or not been successful.

They believe passenger safety is a real issue and aren't willing to put that at risk. The talks or non talks have failed. What else could they possibly do?

For me, the failing is with southern management for not engaging and with government for letting this happen. Have to look at cause and effect and not blame those who are merely reacting

 

7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 8.06am

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

I don't think it's acceptable but am unsure as to what other option they have. Strikes are usually last course of action when talks have either not been engaged with or not been successful.

They believe passenger safety is a real issue and aren't willing to put that at risk. The talks or non talks have failed. What else could they possibly do?

For me, the failing is with southern management for not engaging and with government for letting this happen. Have to look at cause and effect and not blame those who are merely reacting

Southern wrote letters to all drivers saying that there is no negotiation.

I'm not sure what other option drivers had after that.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 8.08am

Originally posted by Helmet46

That's a very sad story and I'm not convinced that an unlikely one off tragic event should be used to justify current union action so I'll not respond to that and leave my thoughts and deepest condolences with that family.

What I would ask is whether people think that the current stalemate, preventing key staff from getting to Europes biggest financial heartbeat is healthy at a time when a lot of the large companies in the City are considering their future in the U.K following Brexit? (And please don't bang on about Brexit - I'm just interested if people think an unreliable and strike ridden transport infrastructure could make a few minds up and seal a number of companies (and therefore lots of employees - who have done nothing but try to get to work - fate)?

Fatalities on the railway are a common problem. In my time we had some particular nasty ones, including a mother jumping in front of a train while holding a child.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 20 Dec 16 8.44am

Originally posted by 7mins

"Drivers on Southern Railway have overwhelmingly voted to strike in a dispute over driver-only trains.

The move raises the prospect of further travel disruption on Southern over the holiday period.

Members of the ASLEF union backed walkouts by 87% and other forms of action by 95%, with a turnout of 77%."


[Link]

Thanks for that.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 20 Dec 16 8.48am

Originally posted by nickgusset

Yep, from what I can gather southern accept this is the case but refuse to guarantee it will happen. That's the sticking point for the unions (well it was yesterday)

Yeah, I get that - what I was suggesting is that it seems that the unions accept it's safe on certain lengths of train, but not on the longer ones (I get that argument). On my "arse end of nowhere" line we have a few 8 or 12 car trains in peak times - many of the off peak or shuttle services are 4 or even 2 cars, so why will the union not allow those to be DOO? They seem to be demanding a guarantee there will always be a guard on all services, which I just don't understand.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 9.08am

Originally posted by npn

Yeah, I get that - what I was suggesting is that it seems that the unions accept it's safe on certain lengths of train, but not on the longer ones (I get that argument). On my "arse end of nowhere" line we have a few 8 or 12 car trains in peak times - many of the off peak or shuttle services are 4 or even 2 cars, so why will the union not allow those to be DOO? They seem to be demanding a guarantee there will always be a guard on all services, which I just don't understand.

My take is the unions don't trust TOCs. Unions agreed DOO on mainline on anything up to a 8 car and only at staffed stations. The company then enforces 12 car at unstaffed stations. Thin end of the wedge.
Also with franchises, you're dealing with different managers every 4 years. When the union agreed partial DOO on BML, the manager I worked for was extremely grateful to the unions, and kept his word... it worked fine. Then new franchise with new management, say all deals made with old managers are off, and we want to extend DOO, and we're not willing to discuss it.
Result is no trust.

Chris Birchall was a great CEO. A honourable man. He (mostly) kept the company in check, and if he gave his word he kept it. (I think going to court over the Paddington rail crash changed him)

Charles Horton... although I've never worked for, has a history as a hard nosed business man. My ex colleagues don't seem to impressed with his management style.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 20 Dec 16 9.17am

Originally posted by 7mins

My take is the unions don't trust TOCs. Unions agreed DOO on mainline on anything up to a 8 car and only at staffed stations. The company then enforces 12 car at unstaffed stations. Thin end of the wedge.
Also with franchises, you're dealing with different managers every 4 years. When the union agreed partial DOO on BML, the manager I worked for was extremely grateful to the unions, and kept his word... it worked fine. Then new franchise with new management, say all deals made with old managers are off, and we want to extend DOO, and we're not willing to discuss it.
Result is no trust.

Chris Birchall was a great CEO. A honourable man. He (mostly) kept the company in check, and if he gave his word he kept it. (I think going to court over the Paddington rail crash changed him)

Charles Horton... although I've never worked for, has a history as a hard nosed business man. My ex colleagues don't seem to impressed with his management style.

I accept trust is in issue - in all directions.

Unions don't trust the companies, the companies don't trust the unions, and the suffering public don't trust either of them. The problem is a "boy who cried wolf" one - pretty much every dispute in my 30+ years of rail commuting has had the word "safety" thrown in at some point, so surely you can understand why commuters find it hard to take on face value when they are told "yes, the claim that reducing ticket office staff would impact safety was bullsh*t, but this time we really mean it".

I see the safety issues with this one and am leaning on that side of the argument, but the unions would tell me it's all because of a Jedi mind trick if they thought that would help their cause (as would Southern). Commuters are merely pawns in these games.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 9.19am

Originally posted by npn

I accept trust is in issue - in all directions.

Unions don't trust the companies, the companies don't trust the unions, and the suffering public don't trust either of them. The problem is a "boy who cried wolf" one - pretty much every dispute in my 30+ years of rail commuting has had the word "safety" thrown in at some point, so surely you can understand why commuters find it hard to take on face value when they are told "yes, the claim that reducing ticket office staff would impact safety was bullsh*t, but this time we really mean it".

I see the safety issues with this one and am leaning on that side of the argument, but the unions would tell me it's all because of a Jedi mind trick if they thought that would help their cause (as would Southern). Commuters are merely pawns in these games.


Southern drivers haven't had a strike in 20years.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 20 Dec 16 9.28am

Originally posted by 7mins


Southern drivers haven't had a strike in 20years.

I predate the franchises! I remember British Rail, and don't forget this is an RMT/ASLEF action, and they certainly HAVE had action (train and tube)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 9.46am

Originally posted by npn

I predate the franchises! I remember British Rail, and don't forget this is an RMT/ASLEF action, and they certainly HAVE had action (train and tube)

Right, if you're speaking about separate unions and companies that have had industrial action in other parts of the country then I will bow to your superior knowledge.

But, drivers on southern (and previous incarnations) haven't been on strike in 20years. Which makes you think, that they're not the militants that the Tory government say they are.
I'd also guess that a fair proportion of drivers are Tory voters. Given that train drivers are in the top 10% of earners

 

Page 36 of 44 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong