You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 36 of 65 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Apr 19 1.05pm

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme

While this season might seem a bit 'meh' we nevertheless have the highest points tally we have had after 31 games since promotion (with the exception of Pardew's first season, where we had 39). I am disappointed to a degree, as I think we could be doing better. But to say that we are definitely dreadful under Roy is just nonsense and, while I DO think we should be looking to improve year on year, we really have to be wary of just expecting top half finishes. Rather, we should be happy with such a finish if that makes sense.

I think we are probably achieving parity with Roy. I think we wouldn't go down with him in charge but I also don't think we'd break the top 8.

The idea that relegation is a certainty if we get rid of Roy now, on the other hand, is laughable. We could put a chimp in charge and stay up currently.

Possibly true but Roy does deal with Parish’s shoddy and negligent at times transfer policies, or lack of, quite well. Things like one keeper, one striker, no striker, for however many games. Right now we’re underperforming without those problems but we’ve probably forgotten how Roy copes with the problems. I think we miss Sakho a lot. We did defending v Brighton and did v Huddersfield bringing the ball out and passing to Bissaka unmarked after Dann passed to the opposition 15 yards further up the field.

I’ll go further with this and say a small amount of big players or signings hide the inadequate way the club is handled and because they cost so much, therein has been part of the problem.

 


COYP

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 02 Apr 19 1.14pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

I just don't think the facts bear you out, unless I misunderstand what you mean by the script. PVA has gone missing many times this season and never gets dropped. AWB went missing for Watford's second goal and didn't get dropped. Who do you think got dropped for not doing as he was told?

I do agree that Roy likes to play a specific shape and wants players to fit into that (and most of ours do perchance) but that seems to be the case with a lot of managers. Difference for me is that better quality players can adapt to a managers style and I think many of ours are lacking in that respect.

You are misunderstanding what I'm saying.

I completely agree that underperforming players are being picked: they are picked because they stick to his tactics (script) rigidly. To Roy, obedience is more important than performance.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 02 Apr 19 1.41pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

You are misunderstanding what I'm saying.

I completely agree that underperforming players are being picked: they are picked because they stick to his tactics (script) rigidly. To Roy, obedience is more important than performance.

So who has he dropped because they didn't stick to the script?

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 02 Apr 19 1.43pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Possibly true but Roy does deal with Parish’s shoddy and negligent at times transfer policies, or lack of, quite well. Things like one keeper, one striker, no striker, for however many games. Right now we’re underperforming without those problems but we’ve probably forgotten how Roy copes with the problems. I think we miss Sakho a lot. We did defending v Brighton and did v Huddersfield bringing the ball out and passing to Bissaka unmarked after Dann passed to the opposition 15 yards further up the field.

I’ll go further with this and say a small amount of big players or signings hide the inadequate way the club is handled and because they cost so much, therein has been part of the problem.

I was referring to this season where we find ourselves 8pts clear (almost 9 if you count GD) with 7 games remaining. As in, if Roy went now, we wouldn't go down this season. But to clarify: I think it's worth sticking with Roy, since our board have really made some questionable decisions with managers (before then getting it right after an expensive rebuild/pay off). That sounds like damning with faint praise, but I think a mid-table finish this season and a quarter final in the FA Cup would probably have been taken by most fans in advance. I hope we can progress on that next season, but midtable + cup run remains a solid goal for next season.

As for next season, I really think it depends, as you say, whether we can get our transfer policy right. Our squad is decent but we still haven't fully solved our striker problem (Batshuayi is only a loanee after all), we haven't quite adequately replaced RLC and Cabaye (as strong as our midfield can be on a good day) and we are a bit thin in some areas. One place where we seem solid is at the back, with 4 decent CBs when everyone is fit. Even then, we lose AWB we are down to Ward (who is a great servant to the club and a good stand-in but he isn't a long-term solution). The other side is a strange one too, with Schlupp preferred in midfield.

We have been unlucky for a number of seasons in that we haven't had a chance to consistently play our best XI for a run of games due to injuries. This year, we only had a strikeforce by the end of January. I think this has had a knock-on effect on Roy knowing his best team (and exposes some transfer failings). If we signed Batshuayi and kept Benteke and Wickham and got them both fully fit, that would be a half-decent strikeforce, with big signings balanced with depth. Those, however, are some big ifs. I have faith in Meyer but he hasn't QUITE hacked it yet... perhaps some work in pre-season to see how we can balance his lack of physicality with his undeniable talent.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Apr 19 2.58pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

So who has he dropped because they didn't stick to the script?

And if the script is start slowly, sit behind the ball first half, at home, against s**t teams, and try and catch them on the break.....they all seem to be sticking to the script pretty well.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 02 Apr 19 4.18pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

And if the script is start slowly, sit behind the ball first half, at home, against s**t teams, and try and catch them on the break.....they all seem to be sticking to the script pretty well.

Yes, exactly my point.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Apr 19 6.34pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

And if the script is start slowly, sit behind the ball first half, at home, against s**t teams, and try and catch them on the break.....they all seem to be sticking to the script pretty well.

That didn't answer the question as to who was dropped for '' not following the script ''

Edited by NEILLO (02 Apr 2019 6.35pm)

 


Old, Ungifted and White

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Apr 19 8.14pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

That didn't answer the question as to who was dropped for '' not following the script ''

Edited by NEILLO (02 Apr 2019 6.35pm)

No it didn't. ..

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 02 Apr 19 8.59pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

That didn't answer the question as to who was dropped for '' not following the script ''

Edited by NEILLO (02 Apr 2019 6.35pm)

It'more a question of who hasn't been dropped for following the script.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Apr 19 10.20pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

It'more a question of who hasn't been dropped for following the script.

[Link]


Lewington: He is not really strict and he doesn't let issues linger. He doesn't scream and shout, he just says: 'This is what we are doing and if anyone doesn't do it, we will get someone else.'
If they are not doing the things they are told to do, they are not for us. You can still play badly as long as you are trying to do the right thing - but if you want to do it your way, go somewhere else.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 03 Apr 19 2.04am

Correcto! We have a squad that has above par quality players but below par results. The sum total of the club is less than the individual sum of the plyaers. That points to an issue with management. If not addressed we will lose our choice players as players want to play for higher winning ideals. if not they move on or ask to be paid what other players of their calibre are being paid elsewhere.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Apr 19 9.57am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

[Link]


Lewington: He is not really strict and he doesn't let issues linger. He doesn't scream and shout, he just says: 'This is what we are doing and if anyone doesn't do it, we will get someone else.'
If they are not doing the things they are told to do, they are not for us. You can still play badly as long as you are trying to do the right thing - but if you want to do it your way, go somewhere else.

Cherry picked from a feature in which Hodgson is highly praised by Gary Neville and, of all people, Chris Sutton, for his coaching methods.

In any walk of life, when you are managing people you have your own ideas about how things should be done. And you take a dim view of those that don't follow your instructions. Because as the manager, the buck stops with you.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Apr 19 10.15am

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

Correcto! We have a squad that has above par quality players but below par results. The sum total of the club is less than the individual sum of the plyaers. That points to an issue with management. If not addressed we will lose our choice players as players want to play for higher winning ideals. if not they move on or ask to be paid what other players of their calibre are being paid elsewhere.

I think this season has been a disappointment in that we haven't gathered as many points as we could have done from our home matches. In my opinion it's down to the failure to convert a higher percentage of chances created.

I think you are over estimating the strength of the squad. From September until January we only had a mis-firing Ayew as a recognised striker. Without Wilf we struggle and he's had spells out. At the moment we are missing Sakho in defence.

From the way some on here perceive Hodgson's management style, we would have a queue of players wanting to leave. Has that happened ? Has there even been a hint of it ??

Your point about wages is naïve at best. Take a look at our wage bill. Our guys are doing just fine I think you will find.

Then take a look at the clubs above us in the table. Like it or not, Watford are there on merit and have arguably over achieved this season. Wolves have had an exceptional first season. And spent big - and well. Everton, West Ham - pay high wages and £100m+ transfer outlays. If we overtake Bournemouth and finish 12th., I think that is roughly where we currently belong in this league.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 03 Apr 19 10.21am

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

Correcto! We have a squad that has above par quality players but below par results. The sum total of the club is less than the individual sum of the plyaers. That points to an issue with management. If not addressed we will lose our choice players as players want to play for higher winning ideals. if not they move on or ask to be paid what other players of their calibre are being paid elsewhere.

You could argue that the system we play is what kept us up last season and has helped us maintain our Premiership status this season.
You could argue that some players are playing better
due to the system .
Most top teams will play the same system pretty much every game as the players are used to the system and
any player coming into the team know exactly what role is expected of them.
The better players you can afford the more more attacking/exciting you can be.
We rely on discipline because we do not have the calibre of players as the top six and we are above teams like Newcastle and below due to our system.
You do do not change a system to accommodate the likes of Max Meyer as has been suggested in other threads.Max Meyer if he was very good would fit into the role he is asked to do.

OK some times it may be boring , but football is an unpredictable sport especially when it comes to providing entertainment and you tend watch a lot more dross than you you do great games , it's not like the the cinema or the theatre when you have a good idea of whether the film will be to your taste or not.

At the end of the day I support Crystal Palace and I found the 2-0 win against Huddersfield a lot more satisfying than the '4-3' thriller defeat at Anfield.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Apr 19 11.26am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

It'more a question of who hasn't been dropped for following the script.

You said he drops players that disobey him. Your words.

I'm merely asking you to name them.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 03 Apr 19 11.50am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think this season has been a disappointment in that we haven't gathered as many points as we could have done from our home matches. In my opinion it's down to the failure to convert a higher percentage of chances created.

I think you are over estimating the strength of the squad. From September until January we only had a mis-firing Ayew as a recognised striker. Without Wilf we struggle and he's had spells out. At the moment we are missing Sakho in defence.

From the way some on here perceive Hodgson's management style, we would have a queue of players wanting to leave. Has that happened ? Has there even been a hint of it ??

Your point about wages is naïve at best. Take a look at our wage bill. Our guys are doing just fine I think you will find.

Then take a look at the clubs above us in the table. Like it or not, Watford are there on merit and have arguably over achieved this season. Wolves have had an exceptional first season. And spent big - and well. Everton, West Ham - pay high wages and £100m+ transfer outlays. If we overtake Bournemouth and finish 12th., I think that is roughly where we currently belong in this league.

Perfect summary.
With Batshuayi instead of the mis-firing Ayew from September to January we'd have 4-5 more points that would see us comfortably midtable.
The only small disappointment to me is the FA Cup, as we were so close to Wembley, and lost our chance, although they were home and so had the biggest chance to go through.

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

FinchleyEagle Flag 03 Apr 19 10.07pm

We need to give Roy a dignified goodbye, thank him for his service and do much, much better in manager recruitment.

With the exception of the shambles that was De Boer, all our managers have been the same - good enough to keep us up but that's it.

Roy has to go because he simply can't get the best out of the players. Look at our squad, we should be doing a lot better. Only Wilf & Luka are playing anywhere near their potential. Benteke has been turned to rubbish and we haven't been able to get anything out of Meyer. The rest are just under-performing.

We need a hungry, dynamic, able manager. Easy to say, hard to get of course, but we have to do better than just staying up by now and the football this season has been absolutely dire a lot of the time, especially at home.

We play on the ground a lot but where are the quick 1-2's and triangles around the box?? It can't be that hard to do and this is how you open teams up, yet we are so predictable in our approach. All down to the manager.

So please Parish, be brave twice. Thank Roy and say goodbye then work your nuts off to get a manager that can take us forward, as this season we've gone backwards.

Edited by FinchleyEagle (03 Apr 2019 10.08pm)

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 03 Apr 19 10.16pm

Can't imagine defending this any more. Serving up dross here and playing like pussies. All our counter attacking threat is gone. He's turned us into a nothing side.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Apr 19 11.02pm

Originally posted by FinchleyEagle

We need to give Roy a dignified goodbye, thank him for his service and do much, much better in manager recruitment.

With the exception of the shambles that was De Boer, all our managers have been the same - good enough to keep us up but that's it.

Roy has to go because he simply can't get the best out of the players. Look at our squad, we should be doing a lot better. Only Wilf & Luka are playing anywhere near their potential. Benteke has been turned to rubbish and we haven't been able to get anything out of Meyer. The rest are just under-performing.

We need a hungry, dynamic, able manager. Easy to say, hard to get of course, but we have to do better than just staying up by now and the football this season has been absolutely dire a lot of the time, especially at home.

We play on the ground a lot but where are the quick 1-2's and triangles around the box?? It can't be that hard to do and this is how you open teams up, yet we are so predictable in our approach. All down to the manager.

So please Parish, be brave twice. Thank Roy and say goodbye then work your nuts off to get a manager that can take us forward, as this season we've gone backwards.

Edited by FinchleyEagle (03 Apr 2019 10.08pm)

I agree with everything you’ve said apart from finding a replacement before saying goodbye to Roy. However, with Parish I don’t see a proactive manager search during his part ownership so wishful thinking.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Apr 19 11.05pm

Be careful what you wish for.

 

Page 36 of 65 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread