This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I haven't been in a cabinet meeting, but I have been in many committee and board meetings, often in the chair. The principals seem the same to me. The chairman leads the discussions, others make reports and proposals in their area of responsibility, which either get discussed and then voted on, or just accepted unanimously. It's in those meetings that members of the government vote with their conscience. Once done, the majority view prevails. I suspect it would be unusual, but not impossible, for a Minister's proposals to be completely rejected, but modifications, after input from other affected Ministries, more frequent. Once decided that's the collective decision of the government and all members are bound by it. If they cannot, in all conscience, accept that then they must resign and voice their objections from the backbenches. So the same expectation to use your conscience to vote applies to every MP. Just in different ways.
Yep. Just keep spinning to try and prove your point. Here's a flash. It's nonsense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Yep. Just keep spinning to try and prove your point. Here's a flash. It's nonsense.
So here's an alternative flash. You've run out of nits to pick!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
A musical interlude There's a few threads I could post this on.
|
|
|
[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3754752] Perhaps you might like to read it too. Quote
"Impact?
You constantly accuse others of conspiracy theories and 'far right' views, and how narrow minded they are, but never see your own obsessions. Like Trump, Brexit etc&etc. Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (26 Oct 2022 10.33pm) Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (26 Oct 2022 10.34pm) Oh I read it. Picking out one line amongst many as if that disproves anything is nonsense. There are many that suggests that this was anything other than just a conspiracy theory, including from our own security services. For those really willing to look at the substantial evidence, which is presented in a measured, balanced and unemotional way by the government, just read the whole thing, and not selected snippets:- It raised many questions, especially about the lack of oversight by the major social media platforms, and provided few definite answers but the over-riding conclusion is crystal clear. The Brexit result was compromised and ought not be trusted.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
So here's an alternative flash. You've run out of nits to pick! My patience is inexhaustible. None of your defence of a hugely outdated dogma adds up. You claim we elect MPs to make decisions for us according to their conscience based on the unachievable promises they make to get elected but then add the rider that this doesn't include those actually responsible for those decisions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Oh I read it. Picking out one line amongst many as if that disproves anything is nonsense. There are many that suggests that this was anything other than just a conspiracy theory, including from our own security services. For those really willing to look at the substantial evidence, which is presented in a measured, balanced and unemotional way by the government, just read the whole thing, and not selected snippets:- It raised many questions, especially about the lack of oversight by the major social media platforms, and provided few definite answers but the over-riding conclusion is crystal clear. The Brexit result was compromised and ought not be trusted. As with all conspiracy theories, "those really willing to look at the substantial evidence, which is presented in a measured, balanced and unemotional way" will believe what they want to believe. Just like you have here. The conclusion of the report from HMG, which I already posted, was that there was no influence from outside forces. It says so in the link you provided. Yet it is you who accuse others of fearing "reds under the bed".
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
My patience is inexhaustible. None of your defence of a hugely outdated dogma adds up. You claim we elect MPs to make decisions for us according to their conscience based on the unachievable promises they make to get elected but then add the rider that this doesn't include those actually responsible for those decisions. The above is the dogma! It's not outdated at all. It is our long established, tried and tested, system. I have no problem with those who wish our MPs to become delegates rather than representatives, even if I disagree and think it to be impossible to find a way of ascertaining what the people as a whole think about every issue. However, if that is your opinion, then campaign for change and vote in a Parliament who agree with you. The debate would be interesting and expose the paucity of the arguments in favour of change. Bring it on and good luck. Until then what we have, is what we have now. MPs don't get elected on unachievable promises. No-one is ever in a position to really promise anything other than to do their utmost to deliver what they say they want to do. That people choose to think otherwise is obviously unfortunate, and is politically exploited, but doesn't change the facts. Manifestos offering guarantees, and making promises, must be seen in their context. Unforeseen events are bound to alter timetables. Big failures result in PMs changing, as we have seen. Manifestos have to be treated with as large a dose of salt, as Del Boy offering you a Rolex for a tenner. If you expect to ever have, whatever system we use, a situation in which everything announced during a campaign is rigorously adhered to throughout the 5 year term of a government, then you are in dreamland. It would not be wise either. We need to react to events. Just imagine if we had voted in a Truss government and had to carry out that plan, come what may. As I explained, every MP, backbencher or part of the government, makes conscientious decisions. Just not always in the same way.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The above is the dogma! It's not outdated at all. It is our long established, tried and tested, system. I have no problem with those who wish our MPs to become delegates rather than representatives, even if I disagree and think it to be impossible to find a way of ascertaining what the people as a whole think about every issue. However, if that is your opinion, then campaign for change and vote in a Parliament who agree with you. The debate would be interesting and expose the paucity of the arguments in favour of change. Bring it on and good luck. Until then what we have, is what we have now. MPs don't get elected on unachievable promises. No-one is ever in a position to really promise anything other than to do their utmost to deliver what they say they want to do. That people choose to think otherwise is obviously unfortunate, and is politically exploited, but doesn't change the facts. Manifestos offering guarantees, and making promises, must be seen in their context. Unforeseen events are bound to alter timetables. Big failures result in PMs changing, as we have seen. Manifestos have to be treated with as large a dose of salt, as Del Boy offering you a Rolex for a tenner. If you expect to ever have, whatever system we use, a situation in which everything announced during a campaign is rigorously adhered to throughout the 5 year term of a government, then you are in dreamland. It would not be wise either. We need to react to events. Just imagine if we had voted in a Truss government and had to carry out that plan, come what may. As I explained, every MP, backbencher or part of the government, makes conscientious decisions. Just not always in the same way. Expecting everything in a manifesto to happen isn't the same as accepting being lied to by politicians.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
[quote=Teddy Eagle;3754 789] Expecting everything in a manifesto to happen isn't the same as accepting being lied to by politicians.
If you believe, as I do, that MPs must always vote with their conscience then my view is that they failed, as a group, to do so. I expect to see this become a live issue again as the current whispers about rejoining become a clamour.
Who's going to lead this rejoin charge? Starmer said this week that the Labour party aren't interested in going back in.
|
|
|
I think Liz just had the edge on Cameron ... Edited by Henry of Peckham (27 Oct 2022 4.33pm)
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Who's going to lead this rejoin charge? Starmer said this week that the Labour party aren't interested in going back in. Time will tell who leads it, but the whispers are in all the parties, and elsewhere. Only when it becomes a clamour would a political leader want to lead it. Cue Johnson! His commitment to Brexit was tenuous at best and much more to do with political opportunity than conviction. So if he saw a personal opportunity.....? Mind you that would mean admitting he was wrong, so actually unlikely. Unless the security services trade in conspiracy theories, the allegations of foreign interference in the Brexit referendum, isn't one.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Time will tell who leads it, but the whispers are in all the parties, and elsewhere. Only when it becomes a clamour would a political leader want to lead it. Cue Johnson! His commitment to Brexit was tenuous at best and much more to do with political opportunity than conviction. So if he saw a personal opportunity.....? Mind you that would mean admitting he was wrong, so actually unlikely. Unless the security services trade in conspiracy theories, the allegations of foreign interference in the Brexit referendum, isn't one. Let's see how many votes Gina Miller's party gathers before deciding if there is any clamour.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
The British Public might occasionally win a battle but they will never win the war. We need a modern electoral system not this prehistoric 'first party past the post' $hit. Apparently Truss wanted a lectern made of wood from all four countries in the UK, what she got was some strange homage to jenga. Irony abounds
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Apparently Truss wanted a lectern made of wood from all four countries in the UK, what she got was some strange homage to jenga. Irony abounds It's certainly different ... a bit like her Premiership. I hope it doesn’t end up as firewood although I don't mind if she's recycled into something useful! Edited by Henry of Peckham (28 Oct 2022 9.49am)
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Let's see how many votes Gina Miller's party gathers before deciding if there is any clamour. It won't come from there, or in that way. Clamour is probably the wrong term. Realism and an acceptance that we need to improve our relationship is what seems more likely, in the short term. There will be some wanting of us to fully re-join tomorrow. Me included, if it was a practical proposition, but it probably isn't yet. So a renegotiation of our "deal" looks to be a sensible first step.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It won't come from there, or in that way. Clamour is probably the wrong term. Realism and an acceptance that we need to improve our relationship is what seems more likely, in the short term. There will be some wanting of us to fully re-join tomorrow. Me included, if it was a practical proposition, but it probably isn't yet. So a renegotiation of our "deal" looks to be a sensible first step. Doesn't seem likely to happen, a least for a few years, when neither party wants to take the lead. There is also the issue of adopting the Euro which will deter a lot of people.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.