You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 5.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 361 of 753 < 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Oct 20 10.34pm

The whole testing and reporting is flawed for so many reasons. What are they going to do when they’ve tested all the students? (The top places for positive results were all student postcodes) Just keep testing them all again, over & over as they gradually all get Covid away from the rest of the city they’re in? What then happens is already tested positive means positive again and again.

I’ve heard of double counting, recording people as positive when they weren’t and positive when they didn’t turn up.

You’ve dismissed the UK test picking up false positives. Well we’re in Autumn when it will pick up these false positives. And a little odd the document saying flu and Covid will be in the same reports.

Apparently in Holland they count your household individually as positives if you are positive. Sure there’s a chance that’s true, but it isn’t a given.

The whole thing is crooked to put fear into the nation to get them to comply. Problem is many know that it’s flawed, crooked or spun the way they want.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Oct 20 10.35pm

This guy has challenged and asked questions to Hancock, Whitty, (Vallance He’s worked with) and Sage but with no response. He was head of respiratory diseases at Pfizer and years in doctor medicine and letters as long as his name.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Oct 20 10.43pm

Just see this. Same on sky news last night.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Oct 20 10.44pm

First of many?

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 13 Oct 20 10.48pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The whole testing and reporting is flawed for so many reasons. What are they going to do when they’ve tested all the students? (The top places for positive results were all student postcodes) Just keep testing them all again, over & over as they gradually all get Covid away from the rest of the city they’re in? What then happens is already tested positive means positive again and again.

I’ve heard of double counting, recording people as positive when they weren’t and positive when they didn’t turn up.

You’ve dismissed the UK test picking up false positives. Well we’re in Autumn when it will pick up these false positives. And a little odd the document saying flu and Covid will be in the same reports.

Apparently in Holland they count your household individually as positives if you are positive. Sure there’s a chance that’s true, but it isn’t a given.

The whole thing is crooked to put fear into the nation to get them to comply. Problem is many know that it’s flawed, crooked or spun the way they want.

Well no that's not actually happened, as I've repeatedly said that there are false positives. I've also highlighted reasons why in all likelihood large amounts of people who have or had covid are not part of any stats because they haven't been tested. Therefore, again, we have to weigh all of this up when making an assessment. You appear to be arguing with yourself rather than anyone else. It's a bit more complicated the having a mantra of reasons why you simply must be right about something that is multifacteed. I stated my personal view on why I think that despite the flaws in testing, it is useful as part of our strategy:

"The tests are useful at least in so much that as the percentage of positive tests are increasing dramatically of late we can safely say that the situation is getting worse and pinpoint that some areas need more focus than others (which would appear to be a good thing to avoid a nationwide lockdown). Plus often people getting tests are self selecting (have symptoms) and so who exactly could blame them for wanting what is a 'very good idea' of knowing whether they have covid-19 or not and isolating accordingly if they do? So yes, as flawed and whack-a-mole as testing may be, it certainly makes more sense than not bothering with it."

If you're going to keep looking for things to latch onto and totally ignore being on the same page at times that's not very worthwhile. I'd prefer that you buy a stressball.


Edited by BlueJay (13 Oct 2020 10.50pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Oct 20 10.54pm

Completely calm, old man. That’s the point.

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 13 Oct 20 11.07pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Completely calm, old man. That’s the point.

Why is my age important? As I said, the one tone need to represent one view while ignoring anything that doesn't isn't helpful. Nor is your sweeping aside most of what people say to simply latch onto one or two sentences that you can use as your launchpad. You haven't been in the least bit 'calm'.

I've already highlighted to that we're actually in agreement on strategy in various regards, but you ignore all of that, and in fact repeatedly ignored my broad reasons for supporting testing even though I posted in multiple times. Fine, why let commonalities and varied perspectives get in the way of endlessly telling people how right you are.


Edited by BlueJay (14 Oct 2020 12.45am)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 14 Oct 20 12.00am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Well no that's not actually happened, as I've repeatedly said that there are false positives. I've also highlighted reasons why in all likelihood large amounts of people who have or had covid are not part of any stats because they haven't been tested. Therefore, again, we have to weigh all of this up when making an assessment. You appear to be arguing with yourself rather than anyone else. It's a bit more complicated the having a mantra of reasons why you simply must be right about something that is multifacteed. I stated my personal view on why I think that despite the flaws in testing, it is useful as part of our strategy:

"The tests are useful at least in so much that as the percentage of positive tests are increasing dramatically of late we can safely say that the situation is getting worse and pinpoint that some areas need more focus than others (which would appear to be a good thing to avoid a nationwide lockdown). Plus often people getting tests are self selecting (have symptoms) and so who exactly could blame them for wanting what is a 'very good idea' of knowing whether they have covid-19 or not and isolating accordingly if they do? So yes, as flawed and whack-a-mole as testing may be, it certainly makes more sense than not bothering with it."

If you're going to keep looking for things to latch onto and totally ignore being on the same page at times that's not very worthwhile. I'd prefer that you buy a stressball.


Edited by BlueJay (13 Oct 2020 10.50pm)

As Rudi has stated, repeatedly, the tests are flawed. What part of flawed makes them "useful"?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 20 12.11am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3565093]

As Rudi has stated, repeatedly, the tests are flawed. What part of flawed makes them "useful"?

He’ll say because the rate of positives has gone up. Of course it has. They’ve just tested students all over built up student areas. Everyone knows students stay within their own area and community and those areas dominate the areas in the highest cases (positive tests) and the highest rates of increase.

They’re getting good at this, but you can see through it. If it wasn’t during social media times we’d barely know it was happening, but because it’s during social media times we can see the falsifying and self fulfilling results that’s going on.

2E5B97D8-A5CE-49A5-ABC2-70A3F8C2C612.jpeg Attachment: 2E5B97D8-A5CE-49A5-ABC2-70A3F8C2C612.jpeg (181.92Kb)

 


COYP

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 14 Oct 20 12.13am

As some one eloquently put it recently the average death toll weekly since March is approx 51 Deaths a week.
Each one tragic in it's own right & especially If it's a friend or family, but & it's a big BUT, It's not a good enough reason to close down the economy

 


Pro USA & Israel

BlueJay Flag UK 14 Oct 20 12.22am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3565093]

As Rudi has stated, repeatedly, the tests are flawed. What part of flawed makes them "useful"?


I have already stated, repeatedly, where and why I believe that they have uses:

"The tests are useful at least in so much that as the percentage of positive tests are increasing dramatically of late we can safely say that the situation is getting worse and pinpoint that some areas need more focus than others (which would appear to be a good thing to avoid a nationwide lockdown). Plus often people getting tests are self selecting (have symptoms) and so who exactly could blame them for wanting what is a 'very good idea' of knowing whether they have covid-19 or not and isolating accordingly if they do? So yes, as flawed and whack-a-mole as testing may be, it certainly makes more sense than not bothering with it."

Of course something can be flawed and still useful. It's hardly 'out there' outside of this increasingly absurd thread to believe that testing has its place. Washing your hands is flawed because you can still breathe in the virus, wearing a quality mask is flawed if you don't handle it properly, social distancing is flawed if you touch surfaces then your face or are in a small enclosed environment where people are sick, testing is flawed because there is a small chance you may get a false positive (and a much greater chance that you won't, so it can be used to build a picture of community spread, problem areas, and you know, little things like getting near confirmation of your status if you're ill to protect the lives of those around you). If you developed symptoms and wanted to best protect those around you, I'm sure you'd suddenly discover a usefulness to the test.

So it's still worth having these tools in the toolbag, especially in combination. Are you suggesting that we shouldn't bother with any of it because its all 'flawed'? There's not much in health and indeed life that isn't in one respect or another a flawed approach.


Edited by BlueJay (14 Oct 2020 2.33am)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 14 Oct 20 12.33am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

He’ll say because the rate of positives has gone up. Of course it has. They’ve just tested students all over built up student areas. Everyone knows students stay within their own area and community and those areas dominate the areas in the highest cases (positive tests) and the highest rates of increase.

They’re getting good at this, but you can see through it. If it wasn’t during social media times we’d barely know it was happening, but because it’s during social media times we can see the falsifying and self fulfilling results that’s going on.


Haha, so even when the percentage of positives increases by several hundred percentage it's all explained away in an instant. Or could be go beyond the one tone safety net and say that numbers might be rising amongst students 'and' consequently others too. Hospital numbers will be on the rise too. They aren't students. I doubt they will get to previous highs, and am thankful for it, but there's no getting away from the fact that there is an uptick right now. I'm not saying anything particularly difficult to comprehend.

A stones throw back you were supporting the view that your guess a minute pal Michael Yeadon was pushing when the numbers were low, that the 'pandemic is over' and the government just didn't want to tell people. That aged well. Let's get back in the real world. The numbers are clearly rising and that may well increase community spread and so it's useful to know especially for the vulnerable. The ridiculous thing as stated, is that I'm not even for a nationwide lockdown or anything or that nature, but you're so distressed at anyone saying anything that doesn't entirely mirror your view that you can't help but latch on and disregard points of agreement.

Edited by BlueJay (14 Oct 2020 1.09am)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 14 Oct 20 12.43am

Originally posted by Jimenez

As some one eloquently put it recently the average death toll weekly since March is approx 51 Deaths a week.
Each one tragic in it's own right & especially If it's a friend or family, but & it's a big BUT, It's not a good enough reason to close down the economy

That's certainly something to be thankful for. In all likelihood it will be back into the hundreds per day in a month or two, but that's a policy consequence of dampening down during the lockdown. As grim as it is to think about, it spread to over half of old folks homes, the most vulnerable of settings, and so I doubt the numbers will get as high as they did first time around. Plus there is better access to treatments and those who need to keep their head down know how best to protect themselves.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 20 1.05am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Haha, so even when the percentage of positives increases by several hundred percentage it's all explained away in an instant. Or could be go beyond the one tone safety net and say that numbers might be rising amongst students 'and' consequently others too. Hospital numbers will be on the rise too. They aren't students. I doubt they will get to previous highs, and am thankful for it, but there's no getting away from the fact that there is an uptick right now. I'm not saying anything particularly difficult to comprehend.

A stones throw back you were supporting the view that your guess a minute pal Michael Yeadon was pushing when the numbers were low, that the 'pandemic is over' and the government just didn't want to tell people. That aged well. Let's get back in the real world. The numbers are clearly rising and that may well increase community spread and so it's useful to know especially for the vulnerable. The ridiculous thing as stated, is that I'm not even for a nationwide lockdown or anything or that nature, but you're so distressed at anyone saying anything that doesn't entirely mirror your view that you can't help but latch on and disregard points of agreement.

Yep. Nothing to lose perspective over. It’s an uptick in respiratory virus season including flu funnily enough.

He’s been making the point that there’s nothing to say it’s a 2nd wave.

There’s more falsifying of numbers and now we have them putting out documents they’re bundling flu and Covid together in reports. How do you know they’re not bundling the numbers together? You are aware a Covid test on a hospital patient for anything goes down as an ‘admission’ right?

And many patients that aren’t filling up wards like they’re reporting are discharged after 5 days. So the virus weakening and/or treatments are improving. Could well be both.

None of this points to it being the out of control problem being claimed, or is showing it’s going to be, which is MY’s point, plus that of the lying and falsifying of information and other stuff he’s put to Hancock, whitty and Sage but they’ve avoided him at every turn. Funny that. Ignore a complete crackpot with years in respiratory diseases. Now why would they do that? The web of ?

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 14 Oct 20 1.27am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yep. Nothing to lose perspective over. It’s an uptick in respiratory virus season including flu funnily enough.

And an uptick in covid-19 funnily enough . Testing is accurate enough that we don't need to lump positive covid tests for those with covid symptoms as 'its probably the flu', just because you'd prefer to view it that way.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
He’s been making the point that there’s nothing to say it’s a 2nd wave.

He endorsed a statement based on the falling lockdown numbers that they wouldn't go up. They have and they will, as will deaths somewhat (Covid-19 deaths today the highest since 10th June, near 5000 people in hospital, 760 patients admitted to hospital in the last 24 hours alone, plus numbers of ventilators all highest since May/June time - it's not all 'students testing positive', and 'people with the flu'. Skip back a couple of dozen of pages on here and the very idea that numbers would rise again was laughed at. I'm not obliged to tag along with whatever conspiracy is 'in' this week. The situation is clearly getting worse again. It appears that you've now already decided in advance that increased covid cases or deaths will frequently be miscategorised as the flu, so I don't suppose the positives or the deaths are going to be meaningful to you either way. The mental gymnastics at work to deny the obvious realities of a pandemic..

For what it's worth I don't really think there would naturally be a second wave as such left to its own devices. However, due to a lockdown of months that interrupted the spread, it's clear that it does in effect create what amounts to a second wave of infections, which is what we are seeing now.


I get the desire not to talk up what is happening, but it is possible to go to the opposite extreme. Saying that testing has its uses is not something that needs to be discussed endlessly. Even with its flaws it clearly has its place, and I've explained why. If you want to piece together various fragments that result in you not accepting that whatever the next couple of months hold is anything to do with covid-19 then that's for you. I'm not saying we should have another national lockdown or that deaths will rise to the numbers they did before, but I also do not intend to create an alternate reality of my preference either. As I said, tests have their place, and if you had covid symptoms you would very likely get one for the benefit of your family. It would be foolish not to.

Edited by BlueJay (14 Oct 2020 4.07am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 20 10.08am

What I’m about to post Michael Yeadon’s tweets is pretty much my thinking and how it’s also been influenced or in agreement with Michael Yeadon. I live in down here, and the point that Bluejay made that the intervention has caused a 2nd something is probably likely, in the North. What this spells out is that immunity does hold a lot of water.

The point that the increase in percentages testing positive does of course make sense, but there is the big point that they’re going out searching for as many positives as they can get, and that couldn’t have been more obvious than when they stepped into fully populated student areas. The table proves they’re the highest areas. I wonder how far from 1-20 it goes down? 1-200-300-more student postcodes.

Again, these student areas do not mix with the locals anything like the people reporting and showing the data want them to. They could take it home in December of course, but that stands more chance of happening if they lock them indoors. No chance of that with 2nd and 3rd years. And for immunity it’s no bad thing either. But it’s been used to paint this apocalyptic picture yet again. This is what’s annoying everyone. All elderly people I’ve spoken to aren’t taking risks, and I expect the same in Scotland due to their despot. In the North? Maybe it does depend on the social class/education/intelligence if you like of the person.

I did notice & get the feeling the govt don’t think the elderly people in the poorer places don’t take notice due to intelligence if not opinion. Soap and water and personal space outside of your front door isn’t expensive. Similar on the hygiene with a lot of northerners. We scoff at them and they think we’re softies.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 20 10.08am

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 20 10.09am

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 20 10.10am

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 20 10.11am

 


COYP

Page 361 of 753 < 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic