You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 2.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 37 of 187 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >
matt_himself Flag Matataland 18 May 14 5.40pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 5.34pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.31pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 5.29pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.03pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 4.32pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 4.17pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 4.07pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 3.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 3.52pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 2.09pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 2.08pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 1.11pm

Yes, lets follow the US libertarian model of trying to eradicate the state when it comes to provision of services for the many, but not forgetting to maximise government support for the most wealthy in the form of huge tax breaks and federal funds for military spending and big business!

So you prefer a government 'that knows best'; you think that countries cannot flourish and prosper unless people conduct their lives in the manner laid down by the higher wisdom of a little group of people - predominately men?

Or let's keep our assets as a nation rather than selling them cheap to politicians mates or foreign companies.


Edited by nickgusset (18 May 2014 2.10pm)

A number of these 'assets' were effectively work nothing because of the work of your comrades in the sixties and seventies. Red Robbo destroyed the car industry in this country with his constant strikes. Same for coal, steel and shipbuilding.

Check your history Gusset. The left have done their best to destroy British industry through the politics of envy.


I think you've forgotten that I wasn't going to respond to you in this thread. But well done for making me smirk at your use of cliché.


Do you ever read the stuff you post?

It is left wing cliche heaven. Just like the post I responded too. I love it that you think 'assets' go to'politicians mates' yet you cannot substantiate this.

You only said you wouldn't reply to my posts because I had you cornered by your own stupidity. I am glad history has repeated itself with this timid offering.

Is there any call for this? If someone has an opinion, they have an opinion. Hurling insults about how stupid you think someone is doesn't seem very reasonable to me. Maybe you should just cut to the chase and start hurling expletives.


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 4.07pm)


1. I am not going to rise to this non-sensical baiting?
2. No insults have been flung. Just observations.
3. You joined on May 12. Why don't you man up and use your previous HoL monicker instead of this one? Are you the same person who set up the username 'Palaceoh' to try and wind me up?


It's like a paranoid playpen around here. This is the first message I've even posted to you isn't it? Unbelievable.


So you avoid the question, ask a question in response to my question and get huffy.

Man up and use your usual HoL moniker.


I can tell you with 100% confidence that I don't have a 'usual HOL moniker'. On top of that I don't know you from adam.

Methinks the lady doth protest too much.

I think you'll find you're the one doing the paranoid protesting. One comment to you and apparently I'm some kind of internet spy sent here solely to annoy you. This is no doubt boring for others and self indulgent on your part. It's an internet forum, mate. There's no need to burst a blood vessel. If it's affecting you so much I'm happy to block you if there's such a feature.

Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 5.34pm)

Should you have nothing to hide, why are you getting so huffy about being questioned about your recent yet spectacularly argumentative so-called introduction into HoL life?

BTW, you ain't bothering me. Amusing me, yes, bothering me, no.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 18 May 14 5.50pm

The TUSC massive rally against oppression:

[Link]

We can see the size of their support is huge and they have done a commendable job in rallying the oppressed masses to their aims.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

luckybuck Flag 18 May 14 5.58pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.40pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 5.34pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.31pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 5.29pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.03pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 4.32pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 4.17pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 4.07pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 3.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 3.52pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 2.09pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 2.08pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 1.11pm

Yes, lets follow the US libertarian model of trying to eradicate the state when it comes to provision of services for the many, but not forgetting to maximise government support for the most wealthy in the form of huge tax breaks and federal funds for military spending and big business!

So you prefer a government 'that knows best'; you think that countries cannot flourish and prosper unless people conduct their lives in the manner laid down by the higher wisdom of a little group of people - predominately men?

Or let's keep our assets as a nation rather than selling them cheap to politicians mates or foreign companies.


Edited by nickgusset (18 May 2014 2.10pm)

A number of these 'assets' were effectively work nothing because of the work of your comrades in the sixties and seventies. Red Robbo destroyed the car industry in this country with his constant strikes. Same for coal, steel and shipbuilding.

Check your history Gusset. The left have done their best to destroy British industry through the politics of envy.


I think you've forgotten that I wasn't going to respond to you in this thread. But well done for making me smirk at your use of cliché.


Do you ever read the stuff you post?

It is left wing cliche heaven. Just like the post I responded too. I love it that you think 'assets' go to'politicians mates' yet you cannot substantiate this.

You only said you wouldn't reply to my posts because I had you cornered by your own stupidity. I am glad history has repeated itself with this timid offering.

Is there any call for this? If someone has an opinion, they have an opinion. Hurling insults about how stupid you think someone is doesn't seem very reasonable to me. Maybe you should just cut to the chase and start hurling expletives.


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 4.07pm)


1. I am not going to rise to this non-sensical baiting?
2. No insults have been flung. Just observations.
3. You joined on May 12. Why don't you man up and use your previous HoL monicker instead of this one? Are you the same person who set up the username 'Palaceoh' to try and wind me up?


It's like a paranoid playpen around here. This is the first message I've even posted to you isn't it? Unbelievable.


So you avoid the question, ask a question in response to my question and get huffy.

Man up and use your usual HoL moniker.


I can tell you with 100% confidence that I don't have a 'usual HOL moniker'. On top of that I don't know you from adam.

Methinks the lady doth protest too much.

I think you'll find you're the one doing the paranoid protesting. One comment to you and apparently I'm some kind of internet spy sent here solely to annoy you. This is no doubt boring for others and self indulgent on your part. It's an internet forum, mate. There's no need to burst a blood vessel. If it's affecting you so much I'm happy to block you if there's such a feature.

Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 5.34pm)


BTW, you ain't bothering me. Amusing me, yes, bothering me, no.


Yes mate, sounds like it. I'll completely ignore you in future. That will soothe your paranoia. Be sure to do the same with me.

 

luckybuck Flag 18 May 14 6.04pm

-----

Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 6.14pm)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 18 May 14 6.12pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 5.58pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.40pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 5.34pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.31pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 5.29pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 5.03pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 4.32pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 4.17pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 4.07pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 3.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 3.52pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 2.09pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 2.08pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 1.11pm

Yes, lets follow the US libertarian model of trying to eradicate the state when it comes to provision of services for the many, but not forgetting to maximise government support for the most wealthy in the form of huge tax breaks and federal funds for military spending and big business!

So you prefer a government 'that knows best'; you think that countries cannot flourish and prosper unless people conduct their lives in the manner laid down by the higher wisdom of a little group of people - predominately men?

Or let's keep our assets as a nation rather than selling them cheap to politicians mates or foreign companies.


Edited by nickgusset (18 May 2014 2.10pm)

A number of these 'assets' were effectively work nothing because of the work of your comrades in the sixties and seventies. Red Robbo destroyed the car industry in this country with his constant strikes. Same for coal, steel and shipbuilding.

Check your history Gusset. The left have done their best to destroy British industry through the politics of envy.


I think you've forgotten that I wasn't going to respond to you in this thread. But well done for making me smirk at your use of cliché.


Do you ever read the stuff you post?

It is left wing cliche heaven. Just like the post I responded too. I love it that you think 'assets' go to'politicians mates' yet you cannot substantiate this.

You only said you wouldn't reply to my posts because I had you cornered by your own stupidity. I am glad history has repeated itself with this timid offering.

Is there any call for this? If someone has an opinion, they have an opinion. Hurling insults about how stupid you think someone is doesn't seem very reasonable to me. Maybe you should just cut to the chase and start hurling expletives.


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 4.07pm)


1. I am not going to rise to this non-sensical baiting?
2. No insults have been flung. Just observations.
3. You joined on May 12. Why don't you man up and use your previous HoL monicker instead of this one? Are you the same person who set up the username 'Palaceoh' to try and wind me up?


It's like a paranoid playpen around here. This is the first message I've even posted to you isn't it? Unbelievable.


So you avoid the question, ask a question in response to my question and get huffy.

Man up and use your usual HoL moniker.


I can tell you with 100% confidence that I don't have a 'usual HOL moniker'. On top of that I don't know you from adam.

Methinks the lady doth protest too much.

I think you'll find you're the one doing the paranoid protesting. One comment to you and apparently I'm some kind of internet spy sent here solely to annoy you. This is no doubt boring for others and self indulgent on your part. It's an internet forum, mate. There's no need to burst a blood vessel. If it's affecting you so much I'm happy to block you if there's such a feature.

Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 5.34pm)


BTW, you ain't bothering me. Amusing me, yes, bothering me, no.


Yes mate, sounds like it. I'll completely ignore you in future. That will soothe your paranoia. Be sure to do the same with me.

Interesting. You edit my response.

I will enjoy picking up you on things in the future do wish you use your regular HoL monicker.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 18 May 14 6.14pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.04pm

What do people feel is the reasoning behind the more notoriously xenophobic elements of the press turning against UKIP recently? Case in point:


The Sun [Link]

Daily Mail [Link]

The press you have illustrated support the Tories and UKIP are eating away at Tory support.

It has nothing to do with 'xenophobia' as you wrongly perceive it.

The press are supporting their mates.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

luckybuck Flag 18 May 14 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself
-----

Move on.

Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 6.16pm)

 

luckybuck Flag 18 May 14 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 6.14pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.04pm

What do people feel is the reasoning behind the more notoriously xenophobic elements of the press turning against UKIP recently? Case in point:


The Sun [Link]

Daily Mail [Link]

The press you have illustrated support the Tories and UKIP are eating away at Tory support.

It has nothing to do with 'xenophobia' as you wrongly perceive it.

The press are supporting their mates.

I didn't say it did. I said that they are notoriously xenophobic, which is true. I was asking a question, not looking to be proved right or wrong. I'm not even in disagreement.

-> [Link]


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 6.23pm)

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 18 May 14 6.23pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 3.22pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 18 May 2014 2.59pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 2.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 2.09pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 2.08pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 1.11pm

Yes, lets follow the US libertarian model of trying to eradicate the state when it comes to provision of services for the many, but not forgetting to maximise government support for the most wealthy in the form of huge tax breaks and federal funds for military spending and big business!

So you prefer a government 'that knows best'; you think that countries cannot flourish and prosper unless people conduct their lives in the manner laid down by the higher wisdom of a little group of people - predominately men?

Or let's keep our assets as a nation rather than selling them cheap to politicians mates or foreign companies.


Edited by nickgusset (18 May 2014 2.10pm)

I'm all for successful British businesses, we should do all we can to allow them to flourish, ie, minimum of government as possible.


like letting them invest where they want, sell where they want and employ who they want? I agree.

Absolutely - and free of all the EU controls and micro 'management'.


what controls exactly did you mean? Health and safety? or the 'controls' which actually allow us to sell throughout the EU without restriction? You haven't read the book yet, have you?

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

luckybuck Flag 18 May 14 6.43pm

Latest ComRes poll

UKIP 35% (+1)
Labour 24% (0)
Con 20% (-2)
Green 7% (+2)
LibDem 6% (-2)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 18 May 14 7.19pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 6.14pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.04pm

What do people feel is the reasoning behind the more notoriously xenophobic elements of the press turning against UKIP recently? Case in point:


The Sun [Link]

Daily Mail [Link]

The press you have illustrated support the Tories and UKIP are eating away at Tory support.

It has nothing to do with 'xenophobia' as you wrongly perceive it.

The press are supporting their mates.

I didn't say it did. I said that they are notoriously xenophobic, which is true. I was asking a question, not looking to be proved right or wrong. I'm not even in disagreement.

-> [Link]


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 6.23pm)

Please describe what 'notoriously xenophobic' is.

Thank you.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

luckybuck Flag 18 May 14 7.24pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 7.19pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 6.14pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.04pm

What do people feel is the reasoning behind the more notoriously xenophobic elements of the press turning against UKIP recently? Case in point:


The Sun [Link]

Daily Mail [Link]

The press you have illustrated support the Tories and UKIP are eating away at Tory support.

It has nothing to do with 'xenophobia' as you wrongly perceive it.

The press are supporting their mates.

I didn't say it did. I said that they are notoriously xenophobic, which is true. I was asking a question, not looking to be proved right or wrong. I'm not even in disagreement.

-> [Link]


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 6.23pm)

Please describe what 'notoriously xenophobic' is.

Thank you.

As I said previously I dont wish to talk with you because apparently it all becomes about you and to hell with the thread. I'd rather discuss the issues and I have a right to decide who I communicate with. It's non question to begin with anyway. Accusing the Daily Mail and The Sun of being xenophobic is about as controversial as accusing The Guardian of being 'right on'. Last reply to you. Thanks.

 

legaleagle Flag 18 May 14 7.41pm

Quote Jimenez at 18 May 2014 2.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 1.11pm

Yes, lets follow the US libertarian model of trying to eradicate the state when it comes to provision of services for the many, but not forgetting to maximise government support for the most wealthy in the form of huge tax breaks and federal funds for military spending and big business!


Your going to have to do better than that? I'm talking about an overblown behemoth which needs trimming. That includes the UK. Do we really need 650 odd MPs.?


Actually, your point, in my opinion, illustrates why so much "anti statist" rhetoric is another example of inappropriately blaming something abstract for a country's woes. The fact we have 635 MP's is a really good thing rather than a negative, ie linking the representative to a relatively small number of voters directly,and the constituency system aids this. The problem is the bankruptcy of the main parties and the moral corruption of the political class. But, say, halving the number of MP's would simply make the elected representatives even more remote from the voters.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 18 May 14 7.46pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 7.24pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 7.19pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 6.14pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.04pm

What do people feel is the reasoning behind the more notoriously xenophobic elements of the press turning against UKIP recently? Case in point:


The Sun [Link]

Daily Mail [Link]

The press you have illustrated support the Tories and UKIP are eating away at Tory support.

It has nothing to do with 'xenophobia' as you wrongly perceive it.

The press are supporting their mates.

I didn't say it did. I said that they are notoriously xenophobic, which is true. I was asking a question, not looking to be proved right or wrong. I'm not even in disagreement.

-> [Link]


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 6.23pm)

Please describe what 'notoriously xenophobic' is.

Thank you.

As I said previously I dont wish to talk with you because apparently it all becomes about you and to hell with the thread. I'd rather discuss the issues and I have a right to decide who I communicate with. It's non question to begin with anyway. Accusing the Daily Mail and The Sun of being xenophobic is about as controversial as accusing The Guardian of being 'right on'. Last reply to you. Thanks.

No. It is not a 'non question'.

You have stated that the Daily Mail and The Sun are xenophpbic. I am asking you to provide evidence of this.

How controvesial is that? It shouldn't be for someone as confident as you are in delivering a message.

Bring it on, sweet cheeks.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

legaleagle Flag 18 May 14 7.57pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 May 2014 1.37pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 12.09pm

Being "anti-EU" has come to encapsulate a code for being disatisfied with life and seeking a convenient "other" to blame it on....Hence, UKIP's mass appeal....as a protest vote.

Maybe its the EU's fault our taxi drivers don't wear uniforms as per UKIP's manifesto at the last elections?!

Blaming all woes on the EU very neatly incorporates many of the "others" people have sought to blame their/"our" woes on over the past few decades: economic decline post empire, loss of Empire, immigration, multi-culturalism.

The EU is very far from perfect (what is?) but, I suspect we need it more than vice versa and if people think leaving would lead to anything other than economic disaster, I fear they are living in dreamland...The figures recently published about how many from Romania and Bulgaria actually chose to come here post 1 January 2014 says it all about the gap between reality and the culture of blaming/fear of the outsider "other" we inhabit.

Go to former Yugoslavia, for example, and you get a stark view of the very real benefits to all (including us) of the EU existing.

Will be interesting to see re next year's general election, if UKIP can sustain their place as a receptacle of the general protest vote...ie all we need for everything in the UK to be hunky dory is no more immigrants and get out of the EU.


This post incorporates not only a caricature of your perception of a Ukip voter and their motivations but for good measure you produce the rather obvious statement that poor countries that get a standard of living boost tend to like the EU.

Errr....Wow, how surprising.

There are only three net contributors to the EU of which we are one....I'm not bleeding surprised poor countries are chuffed.

Your caricature of a Ukip voter is simplistic and certainly doesn't speak for me. I most certainly don't blame the EU for everything but they do share blame for the financial crises (creation of a system that couldn't live with a financial shock).....But on that score they are just typical of politicians everywhere.

The overreach and mistakes the EU makes are really another thread so I won't list them here.

Officially Ukip spoke of projected figures that were possible and still are...The legal agreement Labour signed means any EU citizen can live here (I oppose this...There should be a cap)..The fact that you have gone with....once again with caricaturing what they meant actually shows your willingness to replace reality with half truths.

When I referred to former Yugoslavia, I was actually getting at the benefits of the rule of law and the reduction of nationalism...Its quite a good thing there have been no major wars in W Europe for 70 years or so, isn't it?There, many see EU "restrictions" and "diktats" as something positive, ie health and safety protections, data protection laws,judicial reforms, and at least some banking regulation.Sorry if that interfers too much with the stereotype of "Johnny Foreigner" only seeking monetary gain as soon as we are not looking...

When we speak of "net contributors", lets not overlook the massive contribution to our economy of tariff free access within the EU area. Plus having a bit more clout in world affairs as a part of the EU (ie in trade negotiations with the USA) than alone...

Our financial crisis was in large part due to Maggie and co's deregulation of the financial sector in the 1980's..as a result, and because of having the City as a major world financial centre, we'd have been exposed regardless of the EU...so another example of something blamed on the EU..

Why is immigration seen as such an explanatory factor for all our woes (and consistently has been in some quarters for 100 years)?Shall we call for the repatriation of all the hundreds of thousands of Brits happily now living in EU countries, or is that different because, to paraphrase Mr Farage, they like Germans are ok neighbours whereas Romanians are not...


I accept it may well be you are not the archetypal UKIP voter I admittedly caricatured.

 

legaleagle Flag 18 May 14 8.00pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 7.46pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 7.24pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 7.19pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 18 May 2014 6.14pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.04pm

What do people feel is the reasoning behind the more notoriously xenophobic elements of the press turning against UKIP recently? Case in point:


The Sun [Link]

Daily Mail [Link]

The press you have illustrated support the Tories and UKIP are eating away at Tory support.

It has nothing to do with 'xenophobia' as you wrongly perceive it.

The press are supporting their mates.

I didn't say it did. I said that they are notoriously xenophobic, which is true. I was asking a question, not looking to be proved right or wrong. I'm not even in disagreement.

-> [Link]


Edited by luckybuck (18 May 2014 6.23pm)

Please describe what 'notoriously xenophobic' is.

Thank you.

As I said previously I dont wish to talk with you because apparently it all becomes about you and to hell with the thread. I'd rather discuss the issues and I have a right to decide who I communicate with. It's non question to begin with anyway. Accusing the Daily Mail and The Sun of being xenophobic is about as controversial as accusing The Guardian of being 'right on'. Last reply to you. Thanks.

No. It is not a 'non question'.

You have stated that the Daily Mail and The Sun are xenophpbic. I am asking you to provide evidence of this.

How controvesial is that? It shouldn't be for someone as confident as you are in delivering a message.

Bring it on, sweet cheeks.


As a non-involved in your particular discourse third party, perhaps review coverage in the Mail and the Sun Sept-Dec 2013 re the number of Romanians and Bulgarians about to swamp our country and the seeming view of the national characteristics of their citizens one might have got from reading such coverage?

 

kangel Flag 18 May 14 8.33pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 7.57pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 May 2014 1.37pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 12.09pm

Being "anti-EU" has come to encapsulate a code for being disatisfied with life and seeking a convenient "other" to blame it on....Hence, UKIP's mass appeal....as a protest vote.

Maybe its the EU's fault our taxi drivers don't wear uniforms as per UKIP's manifesto at the last elections?!

Blaming all woes on the EU very neatly incorporates many of the "others" people have sought to blame their/"our" woes on over the past few decades: economic decline post empire, loss of Empire, immigration, multi-culturalism.

The EU is very far from perfect (what is?) but, I suspect we need it more than vice versa and if people think leaving would lead to anything other than economic disaster, I fear they are living in dreamland...The figures recently published about how many from Romania and Bulgaria actually chose to come here post 1 January 2014 says it all about the gap between reality and the culture of blaming/fear of the outsider "other" we inhabit.

Go to former Yugoslavia, for example, and you get a stark view of the very real benefits to all (including us) of the EU existing.

Will be interesting to see re next year's general election, if UKIP can sustain their place as a receptacle of the general protest vote...ie all we need for everything in the UK to be hunky dory is no more immigrants and get out of the EU.


This post incorporates not only a caricature of your perception of a Ukip voter and their motivations but for good measure you produce the rather obvious statement that poor countries that get a standard of living boost tend to like the EU.

Errr....Wow, how surprising.

There are only three net contributors to the EU of which we are one....I'm not bleeding surprised poor countries are chuffed.

Your caricature of a Ukip voter is simplistic and certainly doesn't speak for me. I most certainly don't blame the EU for everything but they do share blame for the financial crises (creation of a system that couldn't live with a financial shock).....But on that score they are just typical of politicians everywhere.

The overreach and mistakes the EU makes are really another thread so I won't list them here.

Officially Ukip spoke of projected figures that were possible and still are...The legal agreement Labour signed means any EU citizen can live here (I oppose this...There should be a cap)..The fact that you have gone with....once again with caricaturing what they meant actually shows your willingness to replace reality with half truths.

When I referred to former Yugoslavia, I was actually getting at the benefits of the rule of law and the reduction of nationalism...Its quite a good thing there have been no major wars in W Europe for 70 years or so, isn't it?There, many see EU "restrictions" and "diktats" as something positive, ie health and safety protections, data protection laws,judicial reforms, and at least some banking regulation.Sorry if that interfers too much with the stereotype of "Johnny Foreigner" only seeking monetary gain as soon as we are not looking...

When we speak of "net contributors", lets not overlook the massive contribution to our economy of tariff free access within the EU area. Plus having a bit more clout in world affairs as a part of the EU (ie in trade negotiations with the USA) than alone...

Our financial crisis was in large part due to Maggie and co's deregulation of the financial sector in the 1980's..as a result, and because of having the City as a major world financial centre, we'd have been exposed regardless of the EU...so another example of something blamed on the EU..

Why is immigration seen as such an explanatory factor for all our woes (and consistently has been in some quarters for 100 years)?Shall we call for the repatriation of all the hundreds of thousands of Brits happily now living in EU countries, or is that different because, to paraphrase Mr Farage, they like Germans are ok neighbours whereas Romanians are not...


I accept it may well be you are not the archetypal UKIP voter I admittedly caricatured.

Leaving aside the massive Bulkan Wars for now, just because there have been no major wars in the rest of Europe, why is that necessarily because of the existence of the EU?

 

kangel Flag 18 May 14 8.43pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 18 May 2014 6.23pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 3.22pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 18 May 2014 2.59pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 2.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 May 2014 2.09pm

Quote kangel at 18 May 2014 2.08pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 May 2014 1.11pm

Yes, lets follow the US libertarian model of trying to eradicate the state when it comes to provision of services for the many, but not forgetting to maximise government support for the most wealthy in the form of huge tax breaks and federal funds for military spending and big business!

So you prefer a government 'that knows best'; you think that countries cannot flourish and prosper unless people conduct their lives in the manner laid down by the higher wisdom of a little group of people - predominately men?

Or let's keep our assets as a nation rather than selling them cheap to politicians mates or foreign companies.


Edited by nickgusset (18 May 2014 2.10pm)

I'm all for successful British businesses, we should do all we can to allow them to flourish, ie, minimum of government as possible.


like letting them invest where they want, sell where they want and employ who they want? I agree.

Absolutely - and free of all the EU controls and micro 'management'.


what controls exactly did you mean? Health and safety? or the 'controls' which actually allow us to sell throughout the EU without restriction? You haven't read the book yet, have you?

No, I haven't, skipped through the sample pages on Amazon though - can't afford £28 for the thoughts of some pro-EU ivory-towered propagandist. Have read Enoch Powell's speeches and publications on the subject though - spot on as usual.

 

kangel Flag 18 May 14 8.45pm

Edited by nickgusset (18 May 2014 2.10pm)

I'm all for successful British businesses, we should do all we can to allow them to flourish, ie, minimum of government as possible.


like letting them invest where they want, sell where they want and employ who they want? I agree.

Absolutely - and free of all the EU controls and micro 'management'.


what controls exactly did you mean? Health and safety? or the 'controls' which actually allow us to sell throughout the EU without restriction? You haven't read the book yet, have you?


_____________________________________________________

We are of course better placed to set up or own health and safety regulations than having some Commissioner from Albania setting them for us.

If we produce goods that people want to buy at a price that they are willing to pay, then we will trade.

Edited by kangel (18 May 2014 8.47pm)

 

Buzzcock Flag In an underground lair near Bright... 18 May 14 8.48pm

Quote luckybuck at 18 May 2014 6.43pm

Latest ComRes poll

UKIP 35% (+1)
Labour 24% (0)
Con 20% (-2)
Green 7% (+2)
LibDem 6% (-2)


So much for car-crash interviews, UKIP are becoming the Obi Wan Kenobi of politics.
"If you strike me down I will become more powerful than you could possibly imagine".

 


In the woods there grew a tree. And a fine fine tree was he.

Page 37 of 187 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic