This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote legaleagle at 08 Jun 2015 8.51pm
Being open minded,I have to say on this aspect,I'm more with derben,though I think the role of the USSR was the most crucial element in Hitler's defeat. I think the US was pretty crucial to a UK victory over both the Nazis and Japan (as opposed to after many many years a Soviet victory over the Nazis). For example,1940-December 1941,not quite sure where we might have been in the battle of the Atlantic without "lend lease" What might have happened without the USAF daytime bombing augmenting the RAF's far less risky night time bombing? Whether D day would ever have happened/succeeded without the US input? Whether the UK would have retaken its possessions in Asia without the US bombing of Japan and drain on Japan's military capacity in the Pacific.Japan might even have invaded India and precipitated a nationalist uprising. The US was vital to war effort of all the allies, even the Red Army and Russia. Whilst arguably the writing was on the wall for the Nazi's after the failure of Operation Barborossa to deliver a blitzkrieg, the war in the far east was far from won, and the split conflict between Japan and the US, and the UK and Japan required the US intervention to allow Commonwealth forces to re-equip and take hold. It debatable how far the UK could have got without the US in terms of 'liberating europe' certainly Normandy wasn't an option, but its likely that all of Germany, Holland, Belgium and most of France would have likely as not ended up in the Walsaw pact, with the UK probably managing to claim Italy, Norway and Scandinavia, part of France. Likely Spain would have been high on Stalins final list. With Europe under the soviet, the outcome of the cold war might very well have been entirely different.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
. Edited by legaleagle (08 Jun 2015 9.40pm)
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote derben at 08 Jun 2015 8.22pm
Quote ghosteagle at 08 Jun 2015 5.58pm
Quote on me shed son at 08 Jun 2015 5.42pm
Quote ghosteagle at 08 Jun 2015 5.24pm
Quote derben at 08 Jun 2015 5.13pm
Quote ghosteagle at 08 Jun 2015 5.04pm
Quote derben at 07 Jun 2015 10.12pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Jun 2015 9.01pm
Quote Kermit8 at 07 Jun 2015 7.17pm
It's no coincidence that the US has been in some sort of conflict ever since WW2. There are other forces at work aswell as their Army, navy and air crews. It suits certain interests.
Be thankful this superpower is democratic......If it is overidden and a new one takes over...Which may be China....Let's just say your objections...If you're still around maybe somewhat different. Spot on Stirling. I certainly don't think the USA is perfect and think they made huge mistakes in Vietnam and Iraq. It is doubtful that we would have defeated Germany without them and if states like Russia or China had similar overwhelming power post WW2 we would be all living in God knows what sort of totalitarian nightmare. They are democratic and they try to bolster democratic and liberal values.
Churchill didn't think so: ? Yes, Churchill was overjoyed with American intervention as it guaranteed the Brits a seat at the victors table. Still, their intervention was not essential to a German defeat. Maybe not, but without them Nazi Europe would have just been exchanged for Soviet Europe. Prehaps, but not the bone of contention. You think we would have been able to cope with both Germany and Japan without the USA? The Soviet Union would have ended the Axis powers. The meatgrinder of the eastern front essentially did for Germany and its allies One of the key pressures to use the A-Bomb was the entry of the Russians into the Pacific campaign. Had the soviet union included large parts of the industrial, resource rich, parts of Europe and Japan, the outcome of the cold war would have been very different. The US provision of equipment and loans were essential to the British war effort, and its manpower to the Normandy Invasions. Germany would have lost, as would have Japan, ultimately, but the Eastern Bloc might very well have come out on top in the Cold War.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.