You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 37 of 44 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >
npn Flag Crowborough 20 Dec 16 10.09am

Originally posted by 7mins

Right, if you're speaking about separate unions and companies that have had industrial action in other parts of the country then I will bow to your superior knowledge.

But, drivers on southern (and previous incarnations) haven't been on strike in 20years. Which makes you think, that they're not the militants that the Tory government say they are.
I'd also guess that a fair proportion of drivers are Tory voters. Given that train drivers are in the top 10% of earners

You must accept, surely, that to the suffering commuters a strike is a strike is a strike? If the RMT closed down the tubes because closing ticket offices on the underground was 'unsafe' there is more than a little correlation to the RMT closing down the overground because it's unsafe - that's my point. The operator involved is completely irrelevant - it's a train, and the RMT have shut it down, that's all we see.

I've already accepted that I lean towards the union in this particular case, but my point is that the RMT say any change is unsafe - it's their default position, so now that they actually have a very good point, they can hardly be surprised that the general public are not very good at listening to it any more.

 

Part Time James Flag 20 Dec 16 10.30am

The one service that hasn't been disrupted during all this, is this thread.

 




7mins Flag In the bush 20 Dec 16 10.50am

Originally posted by npn

You must accept, surely, that to the suffering commuters a strike is a strike is a strike? If the RMT closed down the tubes because closing ticket offices on the underground was 'unsafe' there is more than a little correlation to the RMT closing down the overground because it's unsafe - that's my point. The operator involved is completely irrelevant - it's a train, and the RMT have shut it down, that's all we see.

I've already accepted that I lean towards the union in this particular case, but my point is that the RMT say any change is unsafe - it's their default position, so now that they actually have a very good point, they can hardly be surprised that the general public are not very good at listening to it any more.


I genuinely don't know if making tube stations staffless at night has a impact on safety.

I think commuters get a raw deal..Southern knew the unions were against the changes, so from the outside looking in, I can't understand their refusal to speak to drivers. Although the dft's Peter Wilkinson speech about smashing the unions now makes more sense.


 

npn Flag Crowborough 20 Dec 16 11.22am

Originally posted by 7mins


I genuinely don't know if making tube stations staffless at night has a impact on safety.

I think commuters get a raw deal..Southern knew the unions were against the changes, so from the outside looking in, I can't understand their refusal to speak to drivers. Although the dft's Peter Wilkinson speech about smashing the unions now makes more sense.


But according to Nick, when the union talks about bringing down the government, that's just rhetoric and not to be taken seriously, yet when the government talk about bringing down the unions, it's to be taken as gospel.

It's that kind of cherry picking of arguments that leads to people just not listening any more - both sides are as bad as each other, which is why when the union says "it's not safe, honest" they're no longer taken at face value.

I just want a train service!

 

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 20 Dec 16 11.35am

Originally posted by npn

But according to Nick, when the union talks about bringing down the government, that's just rhetoric and not to be taken seriously, yet when the government talk about bringing down the unions, it's to be taken as gospel.

It's that kind of cherry picking of arguments that leads to people just not listening any more - both sides are as bad as each other, which is why when the union says "it's not safe, honest" they're no longer taken at face value.

I just want a train service!

Agreed but I think the point is that both can be true. I can well imagine that both the DFT and the leadership of the unions have political motivations. However, I doubt that the average train driver gives much of a stuff about politics, they just want to be able to do their job.

As you say, the union's previous record in crying wolf probably plays against it - as you'll have seen, most of the hostility is directed at the union. Seems they have a reasonable safety case this time though, no oen wants to be the one dragged along a platform by their coat because a driver can't see.

 


A one and a two...

npn Flag Crowborough 20 Dec 16 11.56am

Originally posted by tome

Agreed but I think the point is that both can be true. I can well imagine that both the DFT and the leadership of the unions have political motivations. However, I doubt that the average train driver gives much of a stuff about politics, they just want to be able to do their job.

As you say, the union's previous record in crying wolf probably plays against it - as you'll have seen, most of the hostility is directed at the union. Seems they have a reasonable safety case this time though, no oen wants to be the one dragged along a platform by their coat because a driver can't see.

I totally agree.

BTW thanks - I thought I was failing to get my point across, and you've put it far better than me: I actually believe the union this time, but I totally understand why people won't (or possibly won't even listen) because of the cr@p they've come out with to support action in the past.

I'm not pro-government OR pro-union, I'm pro-getting the bloody thing sorted out!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 20 Dec 16 1.11pm

Originally posted by npn

But according to Nick, when the union talks about bringing down the government, that's just rhetoric and not to be taken seriously, yet when the government talk about bringing down the unions, it's to be taken as gospel.

It's that kind of cherry picking of arguments that leads to people just not listening any more - both sides are as bad as each other, which is why when the union says "it's not safe, honest" they're no longer taken at face value.

I just want a train service!

Hmm its almost as if each different group involved has a different agenda. In truth, none of the Unions really have the power these days to bring down a government without prolonged strike action.

That said, successive governments have proposed and implemented legislation aimed at weakening the influence and power of unions, mostly aimed at breaking their capacity to influence negotiations and represent members.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Dec 16 3.39pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Right, if you're speaking about separate unions and companies that have had industrial action in other parts of the country then I will bow to your superior knowledge.

But, drivers on southern (and previous incarnations) haven't been on strike in 20years. Which makes you think, that they're not the militants that the Tory government say they are.
I'd also guess that a fair proportion of drivers are Tory voters. Given that train drivers are in the top 10% of earners

We haven't had a tory government for 18 years prior to the last general election.

 


Optimistic as ever

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 20 Dec 16 3.41pm

Originally posted by Stuk

We haven't had a tory government for 18 years prior to the last general election.


That reminds me. I forgot to get the chestnuts. Ta.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Kermit8 Flag Hevon 20 Dec 16 3.43pm

Originally posted by Stuk

We haven't had a tory government for 18 years prior to the last general election.

oh, and the Conservatives were the Party of Government from 2010-2015 alongside some other minor lot whose name escapes me now.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Stuk Flag Top half 20 Dec 16 3.53pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Hmm its almost as if each different group involved has a different agenda. In truth, none of the Unions really have the power these days to bring down a government without prolonged strike action.

That said, successive governments have proposed and implemented legislation aimed at weakening the influence and power of unions, mostly aimed at breaking their capacity to influence negotiations and represent members.

They shouldn't be able to even try and bring down a government, they don't represent the majority of people or the majority of voters.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Dec 16 3.56pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

oh, and the Conservatives were the Party of Government from 2010-2015 alongside some other minor lot whose name escapes me now.

You can't be the party of government in a coalition. The clue is in the word.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 20 Dec 16 8.18pm

Originally posted by Stuk

You can't be the party of government in a coalition. The clue is in the word.

They held the balance of power, that must be conceded at least.

But it's merely deflection.

Edited by nickgusset (20 Dec 2016 8.19pm)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Dec 16 12.16pm

I heard today Southern have come up with a solution for drivers, regarding the s***ty CCTV. My ex colleague says it's not a long term solution, but hope it may be enough to suspend strikes, they also wanna tie in the new working practices with a long term pay deal (for the duration of the franchise).

My guess is, Southern may use some kind of agency staff.. or ask drivers to exit cabs at stations and walk back and manually lock the coach doors that are obscured on the CCTV.

Hopefully union will accept this.

Trust between the two is at all time low. Fingers crossed.

 

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 21 Dec 16 1.14pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I heard today Southern have come up with a solution for drivers, regarding the s***ty CCTV. My ex colleague says it's not a long term solution, but hope it may be enough to suspend strikes, they also wanna tie in the new working practices with a long term pay deal (for the duration of the franchise).

My guess is, Southern may use some kind of agency staff.. or ask drivers to exit cabs at stations and walk back and manually lock the coach doors that are obscured on the CCTV.

Hopefully union will accept this.

Trust between the two is at all time low. Fingers crossed.

The CCTV can't be that bad, yes I have seen the shots you posted, as my train driver asked the person in the purple hoodie to either move in or get off the train or he would put the train out of service. Must be shocking CCTV he had

 

gambler Flag Kent 21 Dec 16 1.46pm

Originally posted by steph_eagle

The CCTV can't be that bad, yes I have seen the shots you posted, as my train driver asked the person in the purple hoodie to either move in or get off the train or he would put the train out of service. Must be shocking CCTV he had

Off course they're all of the same standard aren't they. The weather is the same every day. The light is the same 24 hrs a day. It's so simple isn't it. The nasty train drivers are striking and costing themselves a lot of money for nothing aren't they. Of course. Have you told anyone else about this?

 

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Dec 16 2.01pm

Originally posted by gambler

Off course they're all of the same standard aren't they. The weather is the same every day. The light is the same 24 hrs a day. It's so simple isn't it. The nasty train drivers are striking and costing themselves a lot of money for nothing aren't they. Of course. Have you told anyone else about this?

Correct. It's too variable to be a reliable aid to the driver. It seems the company have now accepted that, we'll see how the unions accept the new proposals. My guess they'll want assurances of staff at unstaffed platforms late at night, Southern will arrange agency staff until the units cctv is upgraded.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 21 Dec 16 2.26pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Correct. It's too variable to be a reliable aid to the driver. It seems the company have now accepted that, we'll see how the unions accept the new proposals. My guess they'll want assurances of staff at unstaffed platforms late at night, Southern will arrange agency staff until the units cctv is upgraded.

That I can see as quite a big ask - on my line (obviously I can only speak for what I know) there's nobody on the platform after Oxted. That's nine stations, no staff, one train an hour in each direction (double that in peak times). So that's nine extra staff (minimum), dispatching two trains an hour.

Not disputing the reasons for the requirement, just can't see (assuming that pattern is repeated across other parts of the network) that that will be any cheaper than having a guard on the train (dispatching the train he's on from each station - probably 12 dispatches an hour).

Simple maths says it's cheaper to retain the guards (add into that what you've been saying about safety concerns and it ceases to make any sense at all to me to dispense with the guards)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Dec 16 2.36pm

Originally posted by steph_eagle

The CCTV can't be that bad, yes I have seen the shots you posted, as my train driver asked the person in the purple hoodie to either move in or get off the train or he would put the train out of service. Must be shocking CCTV he had

One cctv camera is good, ergo they are all good.

There are some bad muslims, ergo we should demonise the whole lot of them

 

npn Flag Crowborough 21 Dec 16 3.13pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

One cctv camera is good, ergo they are all good.

There are some bad muslims, ergo we should demonise the whole lot of them

Is there an end of season award for bringing the most unrelated and irrelevant topic round to Islamic fundamentalism?

 

Page 37 of 44 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong