You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 37 of 65 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Apr 19 11.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

Be careful what you wish for.

Exactly why we should do it once we know who we’re bringing in. Not before. We have to be a bit ruthless here at times, but keep Roy in while we need him rather than come to an agreement months in advance without us having the safety of knowing we have a good recruit coming in. He of course loves the job.

 


COYP

dave4343palace Flag Copthorne 03 Apr 19 11.18pm

Great to see Dean Gordon in the away end tonight. Was about the only time I smiled all evening.

 


George Courtney, the World Cup referee, everyone is looking at him. When will he blow....?

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 03 Apr 19 11.44pm

Originally posted by Willo

Be careful what you wish for.

More than 1 shot on target in 90 mins

 

The Dolphin Flag 04 Apr 19 7.05am

Time for Roy to go.
I for one cannot bear to watch any more of these turgid displays where nothing changes and where the Manager thinks a small margin defeat to a top team is acceptable.
It shows a lack of ambition, a waste and misuse of resources and a lack of ability to change from something that is clearly not working time and time again.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 04 Apr 19 8.03am

Ideally, I'd like to see Roy retire at the end of the season with a great replacement coming in whom we're already lining up. However, I have absolutely no faith in the board to manage that transition and find a good replacement properly.

Keeping Hodgson another season might sound like a safe bet, because we'd almost certainly stay up, but I think we'll lose Wilf, AWB, maybe Luka and Townsend. Our best players leaving would mean that we'd then have the terrifying prospect of starting the 2020/21 season with a new manager and new key players, and just as I have no faith in the board to replace the manager well, I have even less faith in our player recruitment.

Tricky times. At least Wilf is doing his best to deter any big bids with his performances.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Apr 19 8.57am

Originally posted by Bangell

Ideally, I'd like to see Roy retire at the end of the season with a great replacement coming in whom we're already lining up. However, I have absolutely no faith in the board to manage that transition and find a good replacement properly.

Keeping Hodgson another season might sound like a safe bet, because we'd almost certainly stay up, but I think we'll lose Wilf, AWB, maybe Luka and Townsend. Our best players leaving would mean that we'd then have the terrifying prospect of starting the 2020/21 season with a new manager and new key players, and just as I have no faith in the board to replace the manager well, I have even less faith in our player recruitment.

Tricky times. At least Wilf is doing his best to deter any big bids with his performances.

Good post.

I am happy just staying in the Premier League as I am a realistic hard bitten Palace fan. However if you are a player in demand you may wonder what next season will bring.

I can't blame any of our players if they move on to a bigger club challenging for trophies.

If the Manure come in for AWB I can't see us holding onto him he will walk into that position at Old Trafford unlike City where he might be benched.

I appreciate what Roy has done but our best chance of these players staying is a new manager.

 


One more point

fan Flag Caterham 04 Apr 19 9.28am

Originally posted by dave4343palace

Great to see Dean Gordon in the away end tonight. Was about the only time I smiled all evening.


And Mile Jedinak was there too. oh for someone like him in the present team!

 

The Dolphin Flag 04 Apr 19 9.52am

Was Mile there - wish I had seen him.
Let's get him back on the coaching staff asap!

 

buzby1 Flag Devon 04 Apr 19 9.59am

Roy has done a great deal for us. He stabilised the team, brought some great results and introduced the discipline and rigour we were missing. Without Roy we would probably now be playing in the Championship. We should be very thankful he arrived when he did.

The problem is that he now has nothing more to give. Surely there's a majority of Palace fans who'd agree we've become, on most occasions, cautious and predictable and nolonger a great team to watch. Everyone and anyone can get stale in their job and this is what I fear has happened to Roy. At the end of this season we need to thank him and move on. My worry is that the board and those who control policy aren't thinking of long-term development but only of keeping a steady hold on things. There are a handful of talented younger managers out there we should be looking at. We need to keep the likes of Wilf, Wan Bissaka and Townsend excited, keeping Roy or bringing in another old war horse isn't the answer.

Thank you Roy, now let's move forward into the next phase of Palace development.

 

PatrickA Flag London 04 Apr 19 10.20am

His inflexibility and defensive mindset this season is strange to me because he hasn’t been like this always over his career.
Pulis and Allardyce have reputations as defensive coaches but even they would leave a few players forward to stretch teams and work on attacking set pieces to maximise the rare opportunities.
It’s almost as if Roy is happy to take a narrow defeat against the likes of Chelsea and Tottenham if he can keep the score down.
I have seen most of our games this season and there have really only been a handful of decent attacking performances.
Yes, Roy will keep us up but I think it’s reasonable to question whether he is getting the best out of our attacking players.
Benteke, Ayew, Wickham, Sorloth, Batshuayi are all different types of striker and yet they all struggle under Roy.
It’s too easy just to blame the players and you have to question the system of play.
Why not try something outrageous like play two strikers up front together for more than 10 minutes?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Apr 19 10.39am

Originally posted by buzby1

Roy has done a great deal for us. He stabilised the team, brought some great results and introduced the discipline and rigour we were missing. Without Roy we would probably now be playing in the Championship. We should be very thankful he arrived when he did.

The problem is that he now has nothing more to give. Surely there's a majority of Palace fans who'd agree we've become, on most occasions, cautious and predictable and nolonger a great team to watch. Everyone and anyone can get stale in their job and this is what I fear has happened to Roy. At the end of this season we need to thank him and move on. My worry is that the board and those who control policy aren't thinking of long-term development but only of keeping a steady hold on things. There are a handful of talented younger managers out there we should be looking at. We need to keep the likes of Wilf, Wan Bissaka and Townsend excited, keeping Roy or bringing in another old war horse isn't the answer.

Thank you Roy, now let's move forward into the next phase of Palace development.

I am just respectfully asking which of these managers you have in mind.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Apr 19 10.49am

Originally posted by Willo

I am just respectfully asking which of these managers you have in mind.

Chris Wilder

 

cpj Flag Kent 04 Apr 19 10.53am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Time for Roy to go.
I for one cannot bear to watch any more of these turgid displays where nothing changes and where the Manager thinks a small margin defeat to a top team is acceptable.
It shows a lack of ambition, a waste and misuse of resources and a lack of ability to change from something that is clearly not working time and time again.

This ^^. This season has been one of the worst in living memory for those who only go to home games and I've been going for 35 years! It has just been so dull. Nothing changes - even the bench stays the same virtually every game. Eg we brought back Bakary Sako - who has a great shot, can put in a good cross and has the strength to bully defences - yet we had Ayew on the bench again last night.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Apr 19 11.05am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Chris Wilder

Sheff Utd through and through and could well lead them to promotion to the PL this season.Even if they don't accomplish this, it will be hard to prise him away from the club he loves.

Certainly a manager who likes to attack, deploying overlapping centre-halves !

I recall Wilder the player, slotting into various roles at the back and curling in free kicks from the edge of the area.

 

buzby1 Flag Devon 04 Apr 19 11.52am

Originally posted by Willo

I am just respectfully asking which of these managers you have in mind.

Admittedly there's not many around but three possibilities might be...

Van Bronckhorst at Feyenoord (although last Dutch manager we had wasn't a hit! Good record and might want a Premier League Club.)

David Wagner (Performed a miracle with Huddersfield)

Paul Tisdale at MK Dons (OK, Div Two and a real outsider but he knows how to get teams playing good football and has promise. )

 

A89M Flag Streatham 04 Apr 19 11.56am

We lost Cabaye, RLC last season and never had a recognised striker until January 2019, whilst also spending very little in the transfer windows and Roy has kept us up for the first time without any real fear of the drop. We have created chance after chance at home, the stats suggest the most we have ever had since our time spent in the PL under Parish, beaten the champions on their own ground, gave the 2nd best team in the league a great game at Anfield, whilst playing attractive but tough to beat football and still fans want him gone.

We’re likely to lose Wilf and Wan Bissaka in the summer and I personally think Roy’s way of thinking would suit us perfectly to stabilise us during this transition. Calling for him to leave because he sticks to his organised, hard to beat formation of 442 is ridiculous. Subs could be used more often but honestly, our bench doesn’t scream games changers. We’ve played some of the best football I’ve seen in the PL under Roy even with his ‘negative’ tactics.

This strikes me of Ipswich last season, wanting rid of Mick McCarthy and look where they are now..

 

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 04 Apr 19 12.09pm

Originally posted by A89M

We lost Cabaye, RLC last season and never had a recognised striker until January 2019, whilst also spending very little in the transfer windows and Roy has kept us up for the first time without any real fear of the drop. We have created chance after chance at home, the stats suggest the most we have ever had since our time spent in the PL under Parish, beaten the champions on their own ground, gave the 2nd best team in the league a great game at Anfield, whilst playing attractive but tough to beat football and still fans want him gone.

We’re likely to lose Wilf and Wan Bissaka in the summer and I personally think Roy’s way of thinking would suit us perfectly to stabilise us during this transition. Calling for him to leave because he sticks to his organised, hard to beat formation of 442 is ridiculous. Subs could be used more often but honestly, our bench doesn’t scream games changers. We’ve played some of the best football I’ve seen in the PL under Roy even with his ‘negative’ tactics.

This strikes me of Ipswich last season, wanting rid of Mick McCarthy and look where they are now..

we've played well in a handful of games but that statement is ridiculous

Edited by radsyrendot (04 Apr 2019 12.11pm)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 1.55pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am just respectfully asking which of these managers you have in mind.

Not our job as fans.

Had you heard of the bosses of wolves or soton before they came in?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Apr 19 2.01pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle


Not our job as fans.

Had you heard of the bosses of wolves or soton before they came in?

I only posed the question out of interest as the poster mentioned about some young managers and I was interested to find out if he had any in mind, thats all.

I am not sure about the relevance of the last question based on what I posted but then again I am cerebrally challenged !

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 2.08pm

[Link]

Insightful as ever from HLTCO.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 37 of 65 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread