You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 39 of 44 < 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 >
pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 24 Dec 16 6.24pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

And the rabble rousing 'bring down the Tories' agenda of the Unions has nothing to do with this?

If you were even handed, you would note that both sides are as culpable and as bloodyminded as the other.

And therein lies the problem.

I agree, it has been set up for a fight since the start of the franchise; but the article is about Government intervention, having maintained a stance that Pontius Pilate would have recognised, it seems the façade has slipped.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

matt_himself Flag Matataland 24 Dec 16 6.48pm

Originally posted by pefwin

I agree, it has been set up for a fight since the start of the franchise; but the article is about Government intervention, having maintained a stance that Pontius Pilate would have recognised, it seems the façade has slipped.

Both sides are culpable. Saying that one is worse than the other is misleading.

He unions have heir agenda and the government theirs. The ones who suffer are the commuters.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Dec 16 8.36am

Originally posted by matt_himself

Both sides are culpable. Saying that one is worse than the other is misleading.

He unions have heir agenda and the government theirs. The ones who suffer are the commuters.

Yep, the unions want a level of safety, however the government don't.
Happy Xmas.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 06 Jan 17 11.20pm

Just spoke to one of the managers at Southern. They plan to let the strike next week to go ahead. If cracks appear in the strike, they will offer drivers £££. If no cracks, they will talk to ASLEF.
Although the RSSB accepted the CCTV, there seems to be a problem with getting indemnity insurance for drivers involved with incidents (trap n drag). It seems the CCTV is not up to scratch in certain areas. So Southern have had to put platform staff at a few stations and guards back on trains during hours of darkness at a few stations.

Now, I've never heard of indemnity insurance for drivers involved in trap n drag. This is either Southern protecting themselves against problems they think might arise, or something they are offering drivers to put them at ease, maybe they're worried about being sued. We are living in litigious times.


This begs the question RSSB says it's safe... insurance company says it's not. Who to believe?

Drivers aren't happy with it, the trains Southern use have 15 year old CCTV, the cost to upgrade all Southern's trains is prohibitive, so Southern will offer to upgrade it over time, thus spreading the cost. It's not just the installation, it's a logistical nightmare and they don't have enough fitters to maintain their current stock.

Can't see ASLEF agreeing to this, there is no trust there. What has always been a tricky relationship is now bordering on hatred (from both sides)

DfT who have been unwavering in their support, are now starting to grow inpatient.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 07 Jan 17 7.44am

Originally posted by 7mins

Just spoke to one of the managers at Southern. They plan to let the strike next week to go ahead. If cracks appear in the strike, they will offer drivers £££. If no cracks, they will talk to ASLEF.
Although the RSSB accepted the CCTV, there seems to be a problem with getting indemnity insurance for drivers involved with incidents (trap n drag). It seems the CCTV is not up to scratch in certain areas. So Southern have had to put platform staff at a few stations and guards back on trains during hours of darkness at a few stations.

Now, I've never heard of indemnity insurance for drivers involved in trap n drag. This is either Southern protecting themselves against problems they think might arise, or something they are offering drivers to put them at ease, maybe they're worried about being sued. We are living in litigious times.


This begs the question RSSB says it's safe... insurance company says it's not. Who to believe?

Drivers aren't happy with it, the trains Southern use have 15 year old CCTV, the cost to upgrade all Southern's trains is prohibitive, so Southern will offer to upgrade it over time, thus spreading the cost. It's not just the installation, it's a logistical nightmare and they don't have enough fitters to maintain their current stock.

Can't see ASLEF agreeing to this, there is no trust there. What has always been a tricky relationship is now bordering on hatred (from both sides)

DfT who have been unwavering in their support, are now starting to grow inpatient.


Interesting insight. But, it's ironic that it is so unsafe at the moment due to the overtime ban. There are more people than ever on the platforms and, where I've always felt safe, I don't now with so few trains and so many people pushing and shoving as they try to get on them.
But I guess it's ok to drive a train, suppress ones serious concerns about passenger safety and poor CCTV and create an obvious properly visibly dangerous situation for the people you are professing to protect, during a period of industrial action?
If ASLEF really were serious about safety they'd look at this and make a decision on safety grounds to be all in or all out, or increase strike days rather than this overtime ban (whether fewer trains is a dirty Southern tactic or not - which I feel unlikely). This last month has been really bloody dangerous at London Bridge and East Croydon in rush hour. It's only a matter of time before there is a significant injury and maybe an assault. The mood is ugly. There is now little or no commuting support for either side. I have witnessed someone faint on the train, a punchup and someone take a swing at a Southern Employee just in the last 3 days.
However this gets resolved now, it'll take a very long time for either side to rebuild public support.


Edited by Helmet46 (07 Jan 2017 7.54am)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Jan 17 8.19am

I get your points, but Southern forcing through DOO on January 1st, then admitting on Jan 4th they haven't trained drivers does lend itself to this being rushed in, in a unsafe manner.

Also they insisted the CCTV was fine, but have now said they will upgrade the units with poor quality CCTV and have been unable to insure drivers at certain locations due to poor quality cctv. At these locations Southern have had to restore guards during the hours of 1630-0830. This seems to show that the drivers who said the CCTV was piss poor were right.

The implementation of DOO has been a farce. The manager I spoke to sounded embarrassed by it all, and was worried if him being associated with Southern at the time they f***ed up DOO will leave a professional stain on his CV.

Also Southern are losing drivers, some are taking early retirement others are going to different TOCs. Losing drivers is a financial nightmare. A fully trained driver can save Southern £50,000 a day in fines... cancelling one train costs thousands. Each minute of delay can cost £90 a min. If one train is delayed one min at Hassocks, the train behind will be delayed and the train behind that etc. A 2 min delay can cost Southern nearly 2k. This makes drivers a valuable commodity. Losing drivers will make its way to boardroom level.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Jan 17 8.25am

I think it's a bit rum to say drivers not working overtime is causing dangerous problems. Southern not hiring enough drivers is the reason that there are crowded platforms. It's unfair to expect drivers to give up their days off or risk being blamed for safety issues caused by lack of staff.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 07 Jan 17 1.47pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I think it's a bit rum to say drivers not working overtime is causing dangerous problems. Southern not hiring enough drivers is the reason that there are crowded platforms. It's unfair to expect drivers to give up their days off or risk being blamed for safety issues caused by lack of staff.


There are dangerous conditions because drivers are not working overtime. That is, quite simply, the factual position - irrespective of the reasons why there are not enough drivers.

When they work overtime the platforms are not so crowded and that is part of their contract. They are not working overtime as part of the strike.

 

gambler Flag Kent 07 Jan 17 1.54pm

Originally posted by Helmet46


There are dangerous conditions because drivers are not working overtime. That is, quite simply, the factual position - irrespective of the reasons why there are not enough drivers.

When they work overtime the platforms are not so crowded and that is part of their contract. They are not working overtime as part of the strike.

Working overtime isn't part of a drivers contract.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 07 Jan 17 1.57pm

Originally posted by gambler

Working overtime isn't part of a drivers contract.

Ok - But it is an accepted part of their job and they are only not doing it as part of industrial action.

 

gambler Flag Kent 07 Jan 17 2.04pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Ok - But it is an accepted part of their job and they are only not doing it as part of industrial action.

Maybe he company should look to the future and recruit loads of drivers so this can't happen again. But wait looking to the future doesn't happen in the rail franchise system. Oh well. Can't really blame the drivers for choosing not to work overtime. The company have given them that opportunity.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 07 Jan 17 2.10pm

Originally posted by gambler

Maybe he company should look to the future and recruit loads of drivers so this can't happen again. But wait looking to the future doesn't happen in the rail franchise system. Oh well. Can't really blame the drivers for choosing not to work overtime. The company have given them that opportunity.

You can when they bleat about safety until it suits their agenda.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Jan 17 2.12pm

Originally posted by Helmet46


There are dangerous conditions because drivers are not working overtime. That is, quite simply, the factual position - irrespective of the reasons why there are not enough drivers.

When they work overtime the platforms are not so crowded and that is part of their contract. They are not working overtime as part of the strike.

You are wrong (factually)

Try again.


I'll give you a clue. Overtime isn't part of a drivers contract.

 

gambler Flag Kent 07 Jan 17 2.12pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

You can when they bleat about safety until it suits their agenda.

Nonsense. You can't blame them for safety on their days off. The company have left themselves wide open for this through their penny pinching in relying on overtime.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Jan 17 2.14pm

Originally posted by gambler

Nonsense. You can't blame them for safety on their days off. The company have left themselves wide open for this through their penny pinching in relying on overtime.

^
Correct. Relying on O/T was a deliberate company policy during my employment there.

 

Only 10 a year!! Flag 07 Jan 17 2.15pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Just spoke to one of the managers at Southern. They plan to let the strike next week to go ahead. If cracks appear in the strike, they will offer drivers £££. If no cracks, they will talk to ASLEF.
Although the RSSB accepted the CCTV, there seems to be a problem with getting indemnity insurance for drivers involved with incidents (trap n drag). It seems the CCTV is not up to scratch in certain areas. So Southern have had to put platform staff at a few stations and guards back on trains during hours of darkness at a few stations.

Now, I've never heard of indemnity insurance for drivers involved in trap n drag. This is either Southern protecting themselves against problems they think might arise, or something they are offering drivers to put them at ease, maybe they're worried about being sued. We are living in litigious times.


This begs the question RSSB says it's safe... insurance company says it's not. Who to believe?

Drivers aren't happy with it, the trains Southern use have 15 year old CCTV, the cost to upgrade all Southern's trains is prohibitive, so Southern will offer to upgrade it over time, thus spreading the cost. It's not just the installation, it's a logistical nightmare and they don't have enough fitters to maintain their current stock.

Can't see ASLEF agreeing to this, there is no trust there. What has always been a tricky relationship is now bordering on hatred (from both sides)

DfT who have been unwavering in their support, are now starting to grow inpatient.


I bet they are glad you rushed on here to regurgitate what they told you.

 

Only 10 a year!! Flag 07 Jan 17 2.17pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I get your points, but Southern forcing through DOO on January 1st, then admitting on Jan 4th they haven't trained drivers does lend itself to this being rushed in, in a unsafe manner.

Also they insisted the CCTV was fine, but have now said they will upgrade the units with poor quality CCTV and have been unable to insure drivers at certain locations due to poor quality cctv. At these locations Southern have had to restore guards during the hours of 1630-0830. This seems to show that the drivers who said the CCTV was piss poor were right.

The implementation of DOO has been a farce. The manager I spoke to sounded embarrassed by it all, and was worried if him being associated with Southern at the time they f***ed up DOO will leave a professional stain on his CV.

Also Southern are losing drivers, some are taking early retirement others are going to different TOCs. Losing drivers is a financial nightmare. A fully trained driver can save Southern £50,000 a day in fines... cancelling one train costs thousands. Each minute of delay can cost £90 a min. If one train is delayed one min at Hassocks, the train behind will be delayed and the train behind that etc. A 2 min delay can cost Southern nearly 2k. This makes drivers a valuable commodity. Losing drivers will make its way to boardroom level.

Could also be seen as negotiation and listening to the views of the other side.

 

Only 10 a year!! Flag 07 Jan 17 2.18pm

Originally posted by gambler

Nonsense. You can't blame them for safety on their days off. The company have left themselves wide open for this through their penny pinching in relying on overtime.

I bet they would soon be complaining if more drivers were taken on and the overtime they had got used to in their wage packets suddenly evaporated.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 07 Jan 17 2.22pm

Originally posted by gambler

Nonsense. You can't blame them for safety on their days off. The company have left themselves wide open for this through their penny pinching in relying on overtime.

The only reason they are not working these days is to punish the company (and customers) as part of their industrial action. Let's not pretend otherwise. Sure the company have left themselves open to this but the drivers know the effect this will have on safety.

 

gambler Flag Kent 07 Jan 17 2.30pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

The only reason they are not working these days is to punish the company (and customers) as part of their industrial action. Let's not pretend otherwise. Sure the company have left themselves open to this but the drivers know the effect this will have on safety.

No I'm not pretending otherwise. Of course that's the case.

I'll think we'll have to agree to differ though. In my view it's their days off. If the company don't have enough drivers then it's the company's fault. The passengers safety on the drivers days off can't possibly be their fault.

 

Page 39 of 44 < 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong