|
An interesting and well argued post Beagle. I would point out though, that I have not "seen sense" re: Akinbiyi's form for us. I have never claimed that based on what we have seen, he warrants a place in the Palace lineup.
My gripe with SK is not about him getting rid of AA: I'm not trying to say that SK should be forced to work with a player he doesn't want. If he doesn't think AA is up to the job or doesn't fit in with his style then he is at liberty to dispense with his services. That is entirely the manager's prorogative. The point I was trying to make though, is that it is bad management to go round in public announcing your lack of faith in any one player (see my points about Ferguson and Houllier earlier in the thread). In my opinion, a good manager keeps quiet and keeps working with the player, trying to build up his confidence. This way, at best you get a confident player who is pushing for the first team, and at worst you get a more salable asset.
I also think it is a moot point about the club sticking by him through his injury, because CPFC will have been contracturally obliged to. You can't just employ a player and then jump ship when he gets a long term injury. I obviously concede the point about AA being on a high wage, but again, that doesn't mean he forfeits his right to be given fair treatment by the fans.
If I may correct a misquote as well: I don't agree that AA has "consistently shown himself not to be '...the quality of striker we need'". I believe that from what we have seen of him, he hasn't shown himself to be the quality of striker we need, but I also believe that 11 starts is not enough of an opporunity to show how good a player he is, and I think the club management are being extremely short-sighted in not acknowledging this.
Quote beagle at 09 Jun 2003 6:30pm
".. in the time that AA has had at Palace I don't think he has shown himself the be the quality of striker we need" - good to hear you've seen sense and are agreeing with us TommyEagle.
you also say "AA's past form suggests that he could do a job for us though". Agreed, but also his more recent form (Leicester, Palace) suggests that he won't. Will he? Won't he? Will he? Wont he? Eeny, meeny, miney, mo, she loves me, she loves me not, ip, dip, sky blue etc etc. Who knows? I dont think he will - but would love to be proved wrong.
As for Kembers 'not fitting in' remark - put yourself in his position. Lets assume that Kember, unlike you TommyEagle, thinks AA won't come good. Lets also assume that he thinks his best years are behind him. What should he do? What sort of manager would he be if he was hanging onto a player he honestly believed wasn't up to the job just because he didn't want to hurt his feelings? We'd be calling for his head for crisakes!!! His job is to build a football team not pussy foot around Akinbuyi's fragile psyche.
You also ask has he been treated fairly by the club? A stonkingly good wage packet for p*sspoor form is more than fair. He joined us, played quite a few games, stuffed his knee up and then spent a long time off getting a knee operation by an expert in the States. The club stuck by him, (did we pay for it as well??) we helped with the post-op rehab - all the time paying him. We've brought him back to fitness. I think the club has been more than fair. As for the fans reaction: we all groan when a player stuffs up a pass or hoofs a ball over the goal. It doesn't matter if its Freedman or AA. For a player, the trick to not getting groaned at all the time is to try and not play like a donkey. AA may have attracted more criticism from some fans than most, but then, as you said TommyEagle, he has consistently shown himself not to be "...the quality of striker we need".
Edited by TommyEagle (09 Jun 2003 8:33pm)
All the confidence in the world, all the confidence in the world!
|