Quote sydtheeagle at 18 Jan 2014 10.19am
Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 6.56pm
syd...to adress your counterpoints...
1...But it's also at least possible that there are fans of Palace who are even better equipped to run the club than they are, but choose not to get involved.
if those people have (lets say) £70m to buy the club then i suppose they can run the club as they like in a better way than cpfc2010...as it stands 2010 own the club, and can do as they wish.
2...of your you are correct there is a halfway house between loftus road and selhurst park...its probably somehwere around the fulham/sunderland mark, which isnt proving that successful and they probably pay somewhere around £40m+ per annum in wages... more than double what we do.
3...to a certain extent i agree with you there...the ideal singing you would break the structure for would be somebody like tom ince who will at least have a high sell on fee in the future so you get your outlay back.
4/5/6...cant disagree...theres a line i believe between how much you have to spend to really give yourself the upper hand above the teams around you, dont forget even if we spend 10m then the teams around us will probably still have better squads, so were realistically spending money to balance the scales, not balance it in our favour.
7...but are we "moral custodians"? we are simply customers of a buisness...if you go to the cinema and watch oceans 11/12/13 your a customer but you dont and wont have any imput into how oceans 14 pans out do you?
i get what your saying but in reality its not our money that brought the club and were not running it! We simply have to accept that...and all the moaning on the forums aint going to change a thing...we are fans/customers of a buisness, and thats the harsh reality. we would all like the buisness to spend £20m on the best talent around but id rather we were sensible.
Braunie:
And to respond...
1. if those people have (lets say) £70m to buy the club then i suppose they can run the club as they like in a better way than cpfc2010...as it stands 2010 own the club, and can do as they wish.
Agreed. But it doesn't mean we shouldn't question them. (By the way, while I respect what CPFC2010 have done, I really don't warm to Parrish at all. Not that it's relevant, just being open. Of the four, he's the one I find the least appealing, persuasive, and articulate. I've never quite understood -- other than Parrish seems to have the biggest ego -- why the others would let him represent them the way he does.)
2...of your you are correct there is a halfway house between loftus road and selhurst park...its probably somehwere around the fulham/sunderland mark, which isnt proving that successful and they probably pay somewhere around £40m+ per annum in wages... more than double what we do.
Yes, I think you have a very good point there. Can't argue with that at all. Interestingly, the most viable and sustainable halfway house model was probably the one created by Tony Pulis at Stoke. With that in mind, isn't it an argument for supporting the pursuit of what he wants?
3. but are we "moral custodians"? we are simply customers of a buisness...if you go to the cinema and watch oceans 11/12/13 your a customer but you dont and wont have any imput into how oceans 14 pans out do you?
I see your point, but aren't we always saying "football isn't film (or whatever)"? I can take this one either way...I can see the arguments that owners own the club and what fans want is irrelevant but I can also see the counter-argument that fans are the true owners of the club and the actual owners are only holding it for them. TBH, I don't have an issue with either perspective but I do think there needs to be consistency. The same person who says "Allam doesn't have a right to ignore Hull supporters and change the clubs name" cannot then turn round say "we have to be grateful to CPFC2010 and never criticise anything they do." And I think there are people on here (not you, but some people) who try to have it both ways. That annoys me.
With regard to your last point: "we would all like the buisiness to spend £20m on the best talent around but id rather we were sensible", I think where we may differ is that I don't being sensible and spending money are mutually exclusive. "Sensible" to me is protecting the value of your investment without taking extreme risks. That means spending more money than may have, but less than would bankrupt you. There is a medium; if we disagree about anything it's probably where that line is.
Good debate, by the way.
Edited by sydtheeagle (18 Jan 2014 10.20am)
syd...
i think its hard for me to see your views about parish...when the 4 people took over CPFC 2010 he was chosen as the figurehead so to speak, and the one who would do the day to day running of the club.
as a result of this we havnt really seen much, or anything of the other owners in the media.
i see him as articlaute, media friendly and sensible.
you could say that right now there arnt many comparisons on the paths our club has taken since the takeover than SJ's 1st few years in charge of the club.
but theres one difference that makes me feel positive about the club in 2010's hands...Parish seems to choose which battles he fights, and isnt quite as "cocksure" as SJ was...when DF upped and went to bolton parish wouldav been well within his rights to kick us a fuss ala brucey to brum, but he didnt...he picked himself up, dusted himself down (im sure his pride was hurt) and got on with it, drew a line in the sand and got holloway in pretty quickly.
when bolton came back for the backroom team...he was mature about it and dealt with the situation properly.
when holloway left, he didnt panic, and wasnt pressured into a decision by fan unrest...he took his time, and i think we can all hand on heart say that the right decision was made in the end.
all in all, im at the polar opposite to you when it comes to parish.
on your note about following stokes blueprint for PL football...again, personally i cant see your POV on this, stoke city never brought players with resaleable value and more often than not brought players who were in their late 20's for high transfer fees and wages...and im pretty sure there isnt one player they signed and sold for a profit during pulis's time at the club...this isnt the way 2010 want to do things, and i dont blame them.
tho later in your post you contradict yourself by saying we should sign players with resale value...which is my preferred method.
spending 9m on a 30 y/o peter crouch wouldnt sit well with me, or 3.9m on cameron jerome from birmingham.
to finish syd...i dont think the sun shines and out 2010's backside, and they arnt perfect...but if were being completely honest...considering they are still reasonably "green" when it comes to football they are doing a brilliant job...and maybe parish doesnt quite have the ego you describe as he acknowledged he doesnt have the skillset yet to run a club on his own so he employed moody to help with the areas he feels he is short on knowledge on...that in my eyes takes more balls than carrying on your own.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
|