This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
How does Speroni stand?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
laddo london 14 Feb 14 9.07pm |
|
Quote Eagles-Mad at 14 Feb 2014 3.30pm
Quote Eagles-Mad at 14 Feb 2014 3.27pm
[Link]
I don't care what anyone says the save at 2 34 is the best save I have ever seen
Amazing save. I have seen one better in the same goal. Did anyone remember Nigel Martyn's save vs Huddersfield? Literally launched himself accross the entire goal line to save an unmarked Andy Booth who had the simple task of tapping the ball into a practically open goal from four yards out.
To a man every supporter rose to applaud that save including the away section. It was crazy!
laddo
"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist". David Brent.
|
It's only a game Praa Sands 15 Feb 14 9.18am |
|
Quote The Sash at 14 Feb 2014 1.04pm
The first keeper I saw was Tony Burns (who stood in for an injured Paul Hammond) - god knows how many keepers since then but not one has come anywhere near Nigel Martyn
I missed Jacko by a season so never saw him to make a comparison
I recall Tony Burns made his debut for us away to Southend on a Friday night in September '74. Paul Hammond was never my Dad's favourite keeper, particularly in his early career after taking Jacko's place the previous season when Malcolm Allison dropped him. After hearing that Tony Burns was going to play, my Dad decided to make the trip to Southend and saw us win 1-0 thanks to a Nick Chatterton goal I think.
Julian has done brilliantly for us and like many top keepers, gets better with age.
Jacko number 1 for me, with Martyn a close 2nd & Julian 3rd.
Edited by It's only a game (15 Feb 2014 4.38pm)
A stockbroker urged me to buy a stock that would triple its value every year. I told him, at my age, I don't even buy green bananas!
|
Cucking Funt Clapham on the Back 15 Feb 14 11.13am |
|
Quote Blue'n'red at 14 Feb 2014 4.50pm
No one has mentioned Any Woodman????
Or, indeed, Cedric Berthelin.
Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 14 11.17am |
|
Quote Cucking Funt at 15 Feb 2014 11.13am
Or, indeed, Cedric Berthelin.
A Trevor Francis signing from Lens on a 'Free'. Good shot stopper.
|
| Hoof Hearted 15 Feb 14 11.23am |
|
Quote 20 Spaces Isnt Enoug at 14 Feb 2014 3.46pm
Nigel Martyn
John Jackson
Bill Glazier
Julian Speroni
Honourable mention:- Budgie
I've been going to Palace since 1963 and agree with the top 4 here at the moment. Given time Speroni can get to 2nd place I think.
I would say though that Burridge deserves a Dishonourable mention for going to QPR with Venables and deserting our club.
|
7@burnley79 Battersea 15 Feb 14 12.00pm |
|
Quote adrian b at 14 Feb 2014 11.50am
After ten years at Palace and a slow start, how does Jules compare with previous Palace custodians? After the much loved John 'Stonewall' Jackson, the mighty Burridge, the classy £million Martyn and many other good-uns, I'd rate him third or fourth. The new goalie's looking good and could push him. When Jules was understudy to the Hungarian bloke I did think he was a bit flash and only insurance. Now I know he was better. But after years of George Wood and Philips, remembering the young Bill Glazier and massive Geoff Hammond and that amazing character Tony Burns, I really find myself wondering if Jules is perhaps the best of the lot. How do others rate the bloke?
I'm rating your memory Adrian you must be pushing 90. i can only remember back to Burridge..... Big george was pants but loved him nonetheless. Still remember gazza scoring that 40 yarder past him at St James.
|
FinchleyEagle 15 Feb 14 12.07pm |
|
Quote Ian77 at 14 Feb 2014 1.44pm
Salako should be in the top five
Ha ha I remember that game !! Great save at the end.
Martyn is the best keeper we've had that I've seen although his goal kicks often went out of play to the right.
Jules is second only to him although honourable mentions for Suckling and Kiraly.
Edited by FinchleyEagle (15 Feb 2014 12.08pm)
You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue Yours sincerely Mile Jedinak
|
Uphill Bedford 15 Feb 14 12.30pm |
|
|
For us old 'uns there was only one: John Jackson. Catch up with some of the ITV Big Match Revisited re-runs playing for us (and then for Orient when Alison kicked him out) to see what I mean.
In those days the pitches were awful and there was little protection from the referees from thuggish centre forwards. Most keepers these days would wilt in the face of these onslaughts. You just had to be fit, athletic and brave, and Jacko was - in spades.
Palace have had many fine keepers as mentioned but he was the best.
Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders
|
indianapalace85 Bromley 15 Feb 14 12.33pm |
|
|
By using his feet in a standing up motion.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 14 12.38pm |
|
Quote Uphill at 15 Feb 2014 12.30pm
For us old 'uns there was only one: John Jackson. .
I am an "Old un" and I totally agree.
|
alwyn Kent 15 Feb 14 4.32pm |
|
Quote Ian77 at 14 Feb 2014 1.44pm
Salako should be in the top five
Ha Ha - remember that game - but who was sent off?
|
hythemaceagle Hythe Kent 15 Feb 14 5.41pm |
|
|
Anyone remember Tony Millington (Bill Glazier's replacement)?
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 14 6.24pm |
|
Quote hythemaceagle at 15 Feb 2014 5.41pm
Anyone remember Tony Millington (Bill Glazier's replacement)?
Yes - vaguely ! I think he left us for Peterborough.
|
dg1937 15 Feb 14 8.11pm |
|
|
Yes. If I remember rightly he and Jackson played about half the games each in the 64-65 season after Glazier left. I'm pretty sure Millington was a Welsh international. I was a bit young to notice much about his technique but he was a decent keeper I think.
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 15 Feb 14 8.29pm |
|
|
my first palace game was 76 and think there's a lot of rose tinted stuff on here about the old days.
The modern goalkeepers are so much better than those of of this era there is no comparison.
Interestingly the likes of Burridge, Clemence and Shilton were barely. 6ft despite their quality.
IMO Martyn was the best and Jules isn't far away
|
Durban Road Eagle 15 Feb 14 8.41pm |
|
Quote Rachid Rachid Rachid at 15 Feb 2014 8.29pm
my first palace game was 76 and think there's a lot of rose tinted stuff on here about the old days.
The modern goalkeepers are so much better than those of of this era there is no comparison.
Interestingly the likes of Burridge, Clemence and Shilton were barely. 6ft despite their quality.
IMO Martyn was the best and Jules isn't far away
I agree.
Kentish Maid, born Beckenham, Kent; lifelong Palace supporter.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 16 Feb 14 9.02am |
|
|
The Gordon Banks Pele header save is still the best one I've ever seen. A lot of goalies around then didn't even wear gloves and the balls and pitches a lot more slippy. Plus the fact the opposition were allowed to be a lot more physical in their challenges. To make it to a high level they had to be really really good and if they weren't they were soon found out.
Not sure how Jules would have fared back then. Nigel? No problem.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 16 Feb 14 9.28am |
|
|
TBH I'm a little too young to remember the likes of Jackson in his prime although I saw him play for Orient against us although I have of course seen the Banks save. My statement was a bit on the bold side when you consider the very best players of the time
Take your point about the gloves and mud but also think the modern balls make it difficult and there perhaps wasn't the tendency a few years ago to analyse every goal that's scored.
Paul Hammond was in goal for Palace when I first started going. Also agree with comments about Perry Suckling being decent.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Feb 14 10.05am |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Feb 2014 9.02am
The Gordon Banks Pele header save is still the best one I've ever seen. A lot of goalies around then didn't even wear gloves and the balls and pitches a lot more slippy.
I concur with these sentiments.
Harking back to the 'Good old days' I recall goalkeepers marking out their areas by using their boots to make a an indentation in the pitch in line with their posts to help them with their positioning.
|
| Hoof Hearted 16 Feb 14 11.18am |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Feb 2014 9.02am
The Gordon Banks Pele header save is still the best one I've ever seen. A lot of goalies around then didn't even wear gloves and the balls and pitches a lot more slippy. Plus the fact the opposition were allowed to be a lot more physical in their challenges. To make it to a high level they had to be really really good and if they weren't they were soon found out.
Not sure how Jules would have fared back then. Nigel? No problem.
Bonetti got dog's abuse for the WC quarterfinal loss to Germany in 1970, but he wasn't called the cat for nothing.
One afternoon at Stamford Bridge I saw him leap backwards and catch a shot that had gone over his head. It was much better than Banks' save from Pele which was amazing.
English goalkeepers back then were head and shoulders above any other nation.
Sadly Kermy, Scotland's were amongst the worst.
|