You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Pulis interested in good football?
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Pulis interested in good football?


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 15 Mar 14 10.16pm

I haven't read every reply on this thread, so apologies.

But the OP was 'is Pulis interested in good football?'. Which is daft as it isn't the right question.

Pulis was bought in to keep us up, not play 'good football'. His job is to keep us up no matter what. Goofball , hoofball, 11 behind the ball...if that's what he thinks will do it, then that's what he is being paid (reportedly) one mill as a bonus to do.

He may well love a fluid, Barcelona style of football, but that ain't the brief. Therefore 'is Pulis interested in good football' ain't the right question.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

neverforgivejoeroyle Flag eastbourne 15 Mar 14 10.26pm

Nobody in their right mind holds up Holloway and his final few months as the holy grail to pretty football,but let's not delude ourselves into thinking that our current method of play is only because of the players Pulis inherited. This is what you get, and will always get under TP. Players like Williams never got a chance under TP because they aren't 6 foot and arent always looking to defend for the whole 90 minutes.
I will always support the Club through and through but don't see having an opinion on whats currently being dished up as being disloyal to anyone involved with Crystal Palace FC.

 

Tstack Flag Rolling Prarie, Indiana 15 Mar 14 10.27pm

Tough to watch the past couple of weeks but those of you wanting TP to be gone for next season need to be reminded of some things... 1) How long did it take us to get a manager in here in the first place? TP wasn't beating down our door to coach here. These aren't his players he's doing a Stoke with. He has the job of keeping us up. He can make us better at playing direct/counter TP football next season with another wave of moneyship cash in our coffers. Yeah, it's really dire stuff we are seeing right now but who honestly thought we would have our destiny in our hands by mid March? I don't like what I'm seeing out there but I understand why I'm seeing it. This truly looks like a case of getting worse before getting better.

 


Oct 26 2002-- Palace 5 Weed 0!!!

cols123 Flag beckenham 15 Mar 14 10.28pm

Quote The Sash at 15 Mar 2014 5.10pm

No, obviously but will this mentality keep us up ???...the more I see of it the more I don't think so

Showing virtually NO attacking intent might get us the odd 0-0 but if the West Broms, Fulhams and Cardiffs of this world decide to take some risks and start getting the odd result it will see us overhauled pretty quickly

After last week and today I think now we will definitely be bottom three unfortunately... something has got to change and Pulis is simply not going to do it

If I was Gayle or Bannen I would simply hand in a transfer request now - if you cant even get 5 minutes at the end with the dross that is going on out there at the moment then you never will


Whilst I haven't read the whole thread I just wanted to pose the question here... how many games have we drawn 0-0 under Pulis....

 

cols123 Flag beckenham 15 Mar 14 10.45pm

7 losses from 17 games thats the pulis effect... if he can keep it up we will stay up. Simple

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 15 Mar 14 11.08pm

I wish people would stop apologising for the TP style by saying it is the type of game that will keep Palace in the prem. It aint.

 

wizlon Flag ... 15 Mar 14 11.11pm

Simple enough, if he's being briefed to keep us up, he'll do it. If the brief says do something else, he'll do it. I've watched a lot of managers over the years, Pulis has got what it takes to be a successful Palace manager. He's hungry and we need hungry, if he keeps us up I think he deserves to be here. If he doesn't manage to keep us up I think it will be as much of a blow to him as it is to us. So is he interested in good football? Well yes I think he is, as for how we're playing now... If it's effective enough to achieve our goals then it's good football. Play on Pulis, play on...

 


HOMO SAPIENS NON URINAT IN VENTUM

c_block_shedevil Flag London 15 Mar 14 11.18pm

He's doing his best to keep us in the league. However whilst he does that instead of watching the football I'm thinking of shopping lists and what to have for dinner - his style is that dull !

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

Palace15eagle Flag London 16 Mar 14 7.53am

The only slight complaint I might have is that when we have the ball, someone like Jedināk can't pass the ball, but I'd rather us get the ball up to the attack quickly than spend 20 minutes pissing about with it before losing it and being caught on the break like Swansea...

 


Your HOL best newcomer of the year 2013.

My twitter account: [Link]

slubglurge Flag welling 16 Mar 14 10.32am

I suppose its a means to an end but it is pretty grim viewing at the moment. If i was a forward player i would never want to play for a club that uses tactics like we do, it would be soul destroying. Ince is a good example, he is a player who was brought here to help improve our chronic lack of goals but is being used in a way that he can't hurt the opposition. If we do go down i don't think anyone in the Prem will shed a tear for us because we will be no loss at all. We can attack, as we proved in 1st half at Spurs, i would rather see us try to score the first goal and then start the tedium. This tactic of just staying in the game and see what happens is fraught with danger. We somehow need to find 3 wins from somewhere and i would rather take risks to win games other than just go for draws because we will lose most of our remainingfixtures 1-0.

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 16 Mar 14 11.05am

Quote c_block_shedevil at 15 Mar 2014 11.18pm

He's doing his best to keep us in the league. However whilst he does that instead of watching the football I'm thinking of shopping lists and what to have for dinner - his style is that dull !

Well, what is for dinner?

 


Most certainly not European.

c_block_shedevil Flag London 16 Mar 14 11.17am

Quote moylerg at 16 Mar 2014 11.05am

Quote c_block_shedevil at 15 Mar 2014 11.18pm

He's doing his best to keep us in the league. However whilst he does that instead of watching the football I'm thinking of shopping lists and what to have for dinner - his style is that dull !

Well, what is for dinner?


Well last week during the Southampton game I decided Thai green curry.

Yesterday in Sunderland it was a choice between fish and chips or a curry.

I ended up getting a chicken kebab and chips though...

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 16 Mar 14 11.45am

Towards the end of his career he had Stoke playing better footie then I have seen us playing in the last 10 years at least. 2 pacey skillful wingers and quality strikers with some quality in the middle of the pitch with the likes of Adam.

Stoke was a fortress and he continually got great results against the best teas in the country arguably some of the best teams in the world were nullified and beaten.

For me that's the dream, yeah if we play like tripe for the rest of the season and stay up by 1 point its the most successful season we have had since the early 90s. Give me 'plastic Arsenal fans' at the Emirates over 'real' Barnsley fans on a tuesday night all day long.

There is another myth about Pulis that he hates youth players!

Bollocks. Had the youngest captain in the league, and developed plenty during his time with Stoke, such as Shotton and he bought Butland etc, the squad had one of the youngest average ages, with more British players in the squad then a lot of other Premiership teams.

Let's not forget, our team is crap, we have heard it all season from managers 'not the most gifted but full of spirit,' that all comes from TP and if he keeps us up it's a miracle and then we will see some major changes.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (16 Mar 2014 11.45am)

 

RainhamEagle Flag Bermondsey 16 Mar 14 12.16pm

Quote coulsdoneagle at 16 Mar 2014 11.45am

Towards the end of his career he had Stoke playing better footie then I have seen us playing in the last 10 years at least. 2 pacey skillful wingers and quality strikers with some quality in the middle of the pitch with the likes of Adam.

Stoke was a fortress and he continually got great results against the best teas in the country arguably some of the best teams in the world were nullified and beaten.

For me that's the dream, yeah if we play like tripe for the rest of the season and stay up by 1 point its the most successful season we have had since the early 90s. Give me 'plastic Arsenal fans' at the Emirates over 'real' Barnsley fans on a tuesday night all day long.

There is another myth about Pulis that he hates youth players!

Bollocks. Had the youngest captain in the league, and developed plenty during his time with Stoke, such as Shotton and he bought Butland etc, the squad had one of the youngest average ages, with more British players in the squad then a lot of other Premiership teams.

Let's not forget, our team is crap, we have heard it all season from managers 'not the most gifted but full of spirit,' that all comes from TP and if he keeps us up it's a miracle and then we will see some major changes.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (16 Mar 2014 11.45am)


Stoke were at their best footballing wise when they reached the FA cup final. They were pretty good to watch then, still direct but very much attacking.

 

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 16 Mar 14 1.04pm

My first comment about TP. I can see the reasons for why he is having Palace play the way they are. Have a solid defence first and second, then try score.

The most frustrating thing for me is when go behind there seems to be a lack of urgency to draw level or when drawing to go ahead. I can fully understand that after going behind the last thing a team wants is to concede again but out style of play stays the same, Is there a plan B?

The most simplistic way I can describe it is, defend, defend then attack with the hope to create and score but then quickly go back to defend again.

I take it this way of playing comes from management not the players taking the decision to play like this.

How much confidence does TP have in Palace that he feels that if we attack for any long spells that the opposition we easily break and walk through our defence and score? Fear before freedom.

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

Bo Lynigel Flag London 16 Mar 14 3.54pm

Quote slubglurge at 16 Mar 2014 10.32am

I suppose its a means to an end but it is pretty grim viewing at the moment. If i was a forward player i would never want to play for a club that uses tactics like we do, it would be soul destroying. Ince is a good example, he is a player who was brought here to help improve our chronic lack of goals but is being used in a way that he can't hurt the opposition. If we do go down i don't think anyone in the Prem will shed a tear for us because we will be no loss at all. We can attack, as we proved in 1st half at Spurs, i would rather see us try to score the first goal and then start the tedium. This tactic of just staying in the game and see what happens is fraught with danger. We somehow need to find 3 wins from somewhere and i would rather take risks to win games other than just go for draws because we will lose most of our remainingfixtures 1-0.

Do you want prem football? War and Peace like comment slug or did you swallow a dictionary?

 

CPFC-NAC Flag London 16 Mar 14 5.14pm

The midfield HAS to be

Jedi Ledley

Puncheon Bannan Bolasie

Get the ball on the floor and start passing a bit like at Man City(fantastic preformance)

 

phillanth Flag London 16 Mar 14 5.48pm

I want us to stay up and I think Pulis is doing the best job possible in the circumstances. I also do not recall us playing all out attacking football in the Championship apart from a couple of months last season. However if we keep playing like we have in last two games we have had it for sure. Having sat through nearly five hours without a goal (I did not go to Swansea), without even many attempts on goal and without being able to pass the ball yesterday, plus the difficult fixtures we have left, I am finding it hard to see how we can stay up.

 

maddog Flag Wiltshire 16 Mar 14 9.43pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 15 Mar 2014 5.17pm

Quote The Sash at 15 Mar 2014 5.16pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 15 Mar 2014 5.15pm

You can't play pretty football in a relegation scrap! Some people on here have no clue.

No-one expects pretty football Penge - just some football now and again would be nice

I think let's re-evaluate next season. If we stay up then we'll buy better players who can knock it about a bit.

These players can play football - I have seen it earlier this season. But we saw very little football from them on Saturday. They struggled to even stand up, kick the ball to a team mate, run with the ball or get the ball anywhere near the opposition's goal. Why was that? It's not that they don't have the ability.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 16 Mar 14 11.18pm

Quote maddog at 16 Mar 2014 9.43pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 15 Mar 2014 5.17pm

Quote The Sash at 15 Mar 2014 5.16pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 15 Mar 2014 5.15pm

You can't play pretty football in a relegation scrap! Some people on here have no clue.

No-one expects pretty football Penge - just some football now and again would be nice

I think let's re-evaluate next season. If we stay up then we'll buy better players who can knock it about a bit.

These players can play football - I have seen it earlier this season. But we saw very little football from them on Saturday. They struggled to even stand up, kick the ball to a team mate, run with the ball or get the ball anywhere near the opposition's goal. Why was that? It's not that they don't have the ability.


Earlier in the season I was to busy watching our team feeling gutted at losing 2 0 every week rather then how we could pass the ball. The bit in Bold how is that Pulis's fault.

Edited by EastEndPalace (16 Mar 2014 11.19pm)

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Pulis interested in good football?