You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We will go down without Joniesta
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We will go down without Joniesta


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 26 Mar 14 4.57am

TP is on the brink of saving us. Who would have thought that just after IH left? But, the price we're paying is that we will probably never experience the likes of BB, O'Keefe, Joniesta and Gayle featuring regularly under the former Stoke manager. That is a shame. I really really hope he still has no relegation on his CV after this season, but for 2014/15 I would love to see a)a different direction from TP or b) someone that gives our smaller players a decent chance in the first team. And please, send Cameron packing - the sooner the better. PL is not about chasing the ball only - his decision making storming towards the Newcastle goal with the ball at his feet and two players almost free on each side. And the mega chance just fizzled away thru his poor, poor effort. Rant over! Bring on Chelski...

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 26 Mar 14 6.26am

Quote maxipalace at 23 Mar 2014 8.07am

Was worried when he went on loan and thought we lack any creativity.

Most palace fans know how good he is but Pulis hansnt given him a chance. Ince is being given the same treatment

Kiss your 2m bonus goodbye TP

All this crap abt not being good enough for premier league is bollocks. How the fcuk do you know!?


To be honest you've been saying we'll go down since the start of the season for a whole variety of reasons - this is just the latest ill considered opinion. I personally just think you're a troll, trying to stir it up.

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 26 Mar 14 6.40am

Quote Helmet46 at 26 Mar 2014 6.26am

Quote maxipalace at 23 Mar 2014 8.07am

Was worried when he went on loan and thought we lack any creativity.

Most palace fans know how good he is but Pulis hansnt given him a chance. Ince is being given the same treatment

Kiss your 2m bonus goodbye TP

All this crap abt not being good enough for premier league is bollocks. How the fcuk do you know!?


To be honest you've been saying we'll go down since the start of the season for a whole variety of reasons - this is just the latest ill considered opinion. I personally just think you're a troll, trying to stir it up.

Absolutely this. I reckon even the Samaritans would hang up on Maxi.

 


Most certainly not European.

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 26 Mar 14 7.49am

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 1.08am

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 26 Mar 2014 12.56am

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 12.52am

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 26 Mar 2014 12.36am

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 12.33am

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 26 Mar 2014 12.25am

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 12.17am

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 26 Mar 2014 12.10am

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 12.07am

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 26 Mar 2014 12.04am

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 11.38pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Mar 2014 11.11pm

Quote Firegut at 25 Mar 2014 9.01pm

Where would you play JW in this side Maxi? I don't disagree that it's a shame to see him loaned out, just not sure where you see him in this current side increasing our chances of goals.

At attacking mid/behind the striker, he isn't going to be tenacious enough for this side. There's too much of a gap between Jedinak and KG/Ledley. I could see Jonny getting isolated too much and not providing for the striker. For me, the best player we have for that position is Chamakh. Not his 'natural' position maybe, but he impresses me regularly with hold up play and ability to find a decent pass in a very pressurised part of the field.

Problem was, Johnny Williams wasn't making a huge difference back when he was playing for us, and he'd taken a few knocks. Better he gets first team action and confidence, than 20 mins a week if were losing.



He is making a huge difference at ipswich because he is starting and a manager has faith in him. Pulis did neither


And because he is in the league below playing in a play-off chasing side.


Wtf? Check out the player ratings. [Link]


How does that disprove anything I said?


Because your judging a player who hasnt been given a chance by pulis! Your letting the premier league cloud your judgement. Three MOTM's in a row. Derby trying to catch the top two and he gets 9.5 rating. Thats pretty conclusive form. Why are you so cynical?

Because when he has played this season, he's been thoroughly ineffective, as he has been numerous times in the Championship over the last few years.

Let him flourish in the Championship for the rest of the year, and we can reap the rewards in the future. I think it would be genuinely harmful to his progression as a player to recall him now.

Your not interested in his progression because he has always been thecreal deal. You just cant accept that Pulis has misjudged his ability


But he hasn't. He's always had a hell of a lot of potential, and played excellently in patches, but never particularly consistently.


Rubbish. He has NOT been giving a consistent run under Pulis. In fact he probably hasnt started under him.


Ok, but try this, if you can, think back to the 50+ other times that Williams HAS played for us, and judge him based on that. Not just the fact that he isn't in the team at the moment.

Every time i have seen Williams he always looks dangerous and is fully commited. Read this match report [Link]


Wayne Andrews was fully committed...


I'll ask again, how many goals has he scored for Palace?


 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Mar 14 7.56am

Quote thai-eagle at 26 Mar 2014 4.57am

TP is on the brink of saving us.

Or perhaps on the brink of taking us down.It's really NOT looking good for us at all given our position and the fact that we don't score goals.

Pulis took over when we were in dire straits, 19th with 7 pts and it was always going to be a massive 'ask' to keep us up.


Edited by Willo (26 Mar 2014 7.58am)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 26 Mar 14 8.01am

Anyone got a link to see williams goal from last night? A 30 yarder apparently.

If he carries on this way he'll be back with us after his month loan......just like Pulis planned all along. Genius really.

 

seeweedhater Flag London 26 Mar 14 8.10am

You are joking,genius?

Where is the creativity in his formation/play?

 

so_palace_are_losing Flag Holmesdale Lower, Block F, Row 15,... 26 Mar 14 9.43am

He needs to be in our team. What is with people's obsession with appearances and goals? Williams didn't score or set up a goal against Watford away last year but there is no doubt that he won us the game.

The reality is that our team is struggling to get the ball in the final third, Williams has that ability to carry the ball through the centre, win free kicks and bring attacking players on the ball further up the pitch. It is a no brainer he should come back.

Worse case scenario is he stays at Ipswich, we get relegated, they get promoted and Jonnys a goner.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 26 Mar 14 9.46am

Quote james03 at 26 Mar 2014 3.20am

I have always said JW is a gem of a player and will prove to be the best player we have ever produced - my all time favourite, Kenny Sansom, included.

He is still a young man, learning his craft and trying to put together a string of games. Ipswich have given him the chance to do that and JW has gone there and is proving himself.

To say TP does not rate him is just plain wrong. The lad has just signed a new five year deal and TP has made it clear he will be a big part of his future plans.

Sometime next season we will start to see what JW is really all about. Those who do not believe this lad is one heck of a talent will be eating their words.

You may well be right James, providing he can stay free of injuries. However the OP was about him this season and I think he's not ready yet. He needs to get a run of games, stay free from injuries and get some assists and goals on the board which will prepare him for next season.

So far, so good. Let's see if that's still the same come the end of the season - I certainly hope it is.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 26 Mar 14 9.50am

I'd love to see him back but only if he was actually going to play games.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

so_palace_are_losing Flag Holmesdale Lower, Block F, Row 15,... 26 Mar 14 9.55am

Also is it any coincidence that he is getting rave reviews now he is playing in the centre and not stuck out wide to accommodate favourites and big players

 

Plane Flag Bromley 26 Mar 14 10.15am

Quote so_palace_are_losing at 26 Mar 2014 9.43am

He needs to be in our team. What is with people's obsession with appearances and goals? Williams didn't score or set up a goal against Watford away last year but there is no doubt that he won us the game.

The reality is that our team is struggling to get the ball in the final third, Williams has that ability to carry the ball through the centre, win free kicks and bring attacking players on the ball further up the pitch. It is a no brainer he should come back.

Worse case scenario is he stays at Ipswich, we get relegated, they get promoted and Jonnys a goner.

Are you maxi's brother or son?

 

essetwentyone Flag london 26 Mar 14 10.29am

Quote james03 at 26 Mar 2014 3.20am

He is still a young man, learning his craft and trying to put together a string of games. Ipswich have given him the chance to do that and JW has gone there and is proving himself.

To say TP does not rate him is just plain wrong. The lad has just signed a new five year deal and TP has made it clear he will be a big part of his future plans.

Sometime next season we will start to see what JW is really all about. Those who do not believe this lad is one heck of a talent will be eating their words.

Fully agree with that. Pullis obviously has a planned future for him and this is part of his education just the same as when Wenger loaned out Wiltshire and Ramsey. Joniesta is not going to make a huge difference in our current battle to stay up but he will be great for us in the future.
From a purely financial point of view this succesful loan will only increase his value should we want to sell him but I don't think that's the plan. It's all about Joniesta's development as long as he's not needed by us which isn't the case while we have Bannan. If we suffer an injury crisis then he'll be recalled but otherwise let him help the Tractor Boys and come back to us a better player for next season. Bannan will probably be one of the players that Pullis will clear out in the summer whatever div we are in leaving the path open for Joniesta. Who knows we might even get Wilf back as well after his educational season away ????

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 26 Mar 14 10.45am

Just so disappointing, Palace cannot afford the very best players so develop their own. It's costly, tricky and takes time. When this comes to fruition, we don't use it and sell it on. Not logical. Why have a youth development scheme?

 

Rainforest Flag London England 26 Mar 14 10.50am

What the tractor boys thought of Little Jonny after last night's game against Derby:

[Link]

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 26 Mar 14 11.08am

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 12.38pm

Quote cheswickeagle at 23 Mar 2014 11.32am

What a stupid post.

I don't see why people rate him so highly. Yes he is a talented young player but he is very raw and is yet to prove himself in a big game or over a number of games. Looking back at last season, when he was fit, Jonny never really stood out that much. I can probably only count two or three games where he had a really good game.

It does seem that any fan hates it when a young player from the academy doesn't get played, as if the manager is damaging our academy.

They way we are playing under Pulis means Williams would not have seen a lot of the ball and he isn't the type of player to sit deep and defend so him going on loan doesn't mean that's why we may go down


Mate we are the lowest scores in the league. Anybody who dosent rate Williams knows nothing about football. When he went on loan i feared that we will be in big trouble. Im sticking to my belief we will go down without him.


Your stock standard answer to any old negative drivel you post - to disagree with you means 'you know nothing about football'

No-one has said they dont rate Williams, what they have said is that he has done nothing in the brief chanmces he has had to suggest he would make any difference to us staying up or going down at the moment - and thats correct

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Mar 14 1.01pm

Quote Willo at 26 Mar 2014 7.56am

Quote thai-eagle at 26 Mar 2014 4.57am

TP is on the brink of saving us.

Or perhaps on the brink of taking us down.It's really NOT looking good for us at all given our position and the fact that we don't score goals.

Pulis took over when we were in dire straits, 19th with 7 pts and it was always going to be a massive 'ask' to keep us up.

Edited by Willo (26 Mar 2014 7.58am)

Nah, keeping us up. We were bottom and dead when he took over and restructured us. The improvement has been nothing short of a work of genius. Under Holloway we were going down, and fast. There was no confidence, and no belief and the spate of beatings had destroyed morale.

We might not be pretty, but thats life, they can't all be good looking.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Mar 14 1.07pm

Quote adrian b at 26 Mar 2014 10.45am

Just so disappointing, Palace cannot afford the very best players so develop their own. It's costly, tricky and takes time. When this comes to fruition, we don't use it and sell it on. Not logical. Why have a youth development scheme?

Because you get to have players like Clyne, Watson, Moses and Zaha for several seasons, and pay them a fraction of what you'd have to pay them if you'd bought them from another club (if you could).

Think about Clyne, he played as a first choice right back for us for 137 games, probably leaving on half the going rate for an average right back when he moved on to Southampton.

We probably had a 40k a week player, for four seasons, and I'd be surprised if his wages topped 7k a week with us.

Wilfred Zaha - Clubs like us can only create players like that, we can't really sign them. United pay him 33k a week, I think in his last contract we were paying him less than 10k.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

maxipalace Flag in a box 26 Mar 14 3.40pm

Quote The Sash at 26 Mar 2014 11.08am

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 12.38pm

Quote cheswickeagle at 23 Mar 2014 11.32am

What a stupid post.

I don't see why people rate him so highly. Yes he is a talented young player but he is very raw and is yet to prove himself in a big game or over a number of games. Looking back at last season, when he was fit, Jonny never really stood out that much. I can probably only count two or three games where he had a really good game.

It does seem that any fan hates it when a young player from the academy doesn't get played, as if the manager is damaging our academy.

They way we are playing under Pulis means Williams would not have seen a lot of the ball and he isn't the type of player to sit deep and defend so him going on loan doesn't mean that's why we may go down


Mate we are the lowest scores in the league. Anybody who dosent rate Williams knows nothing about football. When he went on loan i feared that we will be in big trouble. Im sticking to my belief we will go down without him.


Your stock standard answer to any old negative drivel you post - to disagree with you means 'you know nothing about football'

No-one has said they dont rate Williams, what they have said is that he has done nothing in the brief chanmces he has had to suggest he would make any difference to us staying up or going down at the moment - and thats correct


brief chances? - he hasnt started under Pulis ffs. Thats my prediction and im sticking by it. Its dangerous game to just go for a certain type of player and ignore the short, pacey and skillful (Williams, Bannan, Gayle).

i was bored sh**less watching us v man utd and saints. I want to be entertained and i want a player with red and blue blood busting a gut for the team. If i want a aimless load of drivel i can watch eastenders.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 26 Mar 14 3.55pm

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 3.40pm

Quote The Sash at 26 Mar 2014 11.08am

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 12.38pm

Quote cheswickeagle at 23 Mar 2014 11.32am

What a stupid post.

I don't see why people rate him so highly. Yes he is a talented young player but he is very raw and is yet to prove himself in a big game or over a number of games. Looking back at last season, when he was fit, Jonny never really stood out that much. I can probably only count two or three games where he had a really good game.

It does seem that any fan hates it when a young player from the academy doesn't get played, as if the manager is damaging our academy.

They way we are playing under Pulis means Williams would not have seen a lot of the ball and he isn't the type of player to sit deep and defend so him going on loan doesn't mean that's why we may go down


Mate we are the lowest scores in the league. Anybody who dosent rate Williams knows nothing about football. When he went on loan i feared that we will be in big trouble. Im sticking to my belief we will go down without him.


Your stock standard answer to any old negative drivel you post - to disagree with you means 'you know nothing about football'

No-one has said they dont rate Williams, what they have said is that he has done nothing in the brief chanmces he has had to suggest he would make any difference to us staying up or going down at the moment - and thats correct


brief chances? - he hasnt started under Pulis ffs. Thats my prediction and im sticking by it. Its dangerous game to just go for a certain type of player and ignore the short, pacey and skillful (Williams, Bannan, Gayle).

i was bored sh**less watching us v man utd and saints. I want to be entertained and i want a player with red and blue blood busting a gut for the team. If i want a aimless load of drivel i can watch eastenders.


I didnt mention Pulis - He was hardly a first choice under Holloway but we saw him and he looked short of what we need... in his time will hopefully be a good PL player, but he isnt that yet.

His goal for Ipswich was wonderful, but would he get that much space and defenders back off him at this level - of course he wouldnt and thats the key. Its the same logic that gets imbeciles calling for Kwesi Appiah to be given a go because he plays well for Cambridge.

This PL mallarkey is a whole different kettle of fish and although I would love to see creativity and moaned like f*** about our negativity and lack of creativity at Swans, Saints and Sunderland I can also see how Joniesta isnt some magic bullet that would make everything rosy


Anyhoo you stick to what you like it makes no matter to me.


Edited by The Sash (26 Mar 2014 4.01pm)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We will go down without Joniesta