You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Do We Change The Team For Cardiff?
November 16 2026 12.39pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Do We Change The Team For Cardiff?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 01 Apr 14 12.05pm

Obviously that old adage, don't change a winning team but we will have a different ethos to the game vs Chelsea. Plus Chamakh is back and prior to the Chrlsea game most were in agreement that he was sorely missed. I personally think we will keep the same team. KG and Ledley deserve to retain their positions.

I do however believe that we will need more attacking instincts against Cardiff. If we invite them forward we will eventually get punished. Thoughts?

 

wainesworld Flag west wickham 01 Apr 14 12.09pm

Personally think he will stay with the same starting 11. Cardiff are not as strong as chelsea going forward, yes I know about the Liverpool game, and are much weaker at the back. Expect Chamakh and Ince to come on with 25 to go and win us the game.

 

sidman Flag London 01 Apr 14 12.10pm

What's more important is that we must play the same style we did against Chelsea.

Although I see they're giving Sunderland plenty of time to rest for their games. I find that interesting.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 01 Apr 14 12.15pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 01 Apr 2014 12.05pm

Obviously that old adage, don't change a winning team but we will have a different ethos to the game vs Chelsea. Plus Chamakh is back and prior to the Chrlsea game most were in agreement that he was sorely missed. I personally think we will keep the same team. KG and Ledley deserve to retain their positions.

I do however believe that we will need more attacking instincts against Cardiff. If we invite them forward we will eventually get punished. Thoughts?

I don't think Cardiff are better than Chelski but will we be as much on our game as against Chelski? Tough one!

Before the Chelski game I would have had Cham back in the team asap but Ledley looked good in the role he played on Saturday, who would be a manager!!

Edited by Plane (01 Apr 2014 12.16pm)

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 01 Apr 14 12.23pm

Cardiff can score goals we struggle to, so think Chamach has to come in. We need to try and win this. Sitting back for a draw could have a negative impact on the team after the Chelsea game.

 

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 01 Apr 14 12.38pm

CJ deserves his place after Saturday, he was imense. Getting closer to hitting the barn door too!

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

jimmyc Flag 01 Apr 14 12.42pm

I can't see Pulis not going with Chammy if he is fit. I think it will be a straight swap for CamJam which is a shame for him because as has been mentioned he terrorized Chelsea.

 

Eggy Flag Sutton 01 Apr 14 12.46pm

I expect the same team, however, I expect a more conservative / defensive mindset.

I think it's clear TP sets us up demanding on the nature of the game. This is a 'must not lose' game, as were Sunderland and Swansea recently, in which we tend to be more contained and try and nick something on the break.

Against the top 10 teams we've tended to be more attack minded, driven by the fact if we lose (as we're expected to), then it doesn't significantly damage us in the 'mini league' at the bottom of the table which matters most to us.

I expect the target is a point, with 3 being a bonus. Just don't lose.

 

skj Flag Bedale, North Yorkshire (Ex-Carsha... 01 Apr 14 1.05pm

I personally think it's a definate no lose match for Cardiff so they will be more inclined to be pushing forward more than usual. I think to adopt a similar strategy as the Chelsea game will hopefully provide us with a few chances.

I'd definately make sure Wardy covers Wilf and that should stop the supply of balls to Bellamy. That's my main concern.

 

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 01 Apr 14 1.16pm

prefer to see the same XI start with a similar game plan, would like to see us go full out for the victory & get the seasons survival over & done with asap rather than dragging it out till the Fulham game.

 


Red & Blue since 73'

PJH Flag Colchester 01 Apr 14 1.20pm

Quote skj at 01 Apr 2014 1.05pm

I personally think it's a definate no lose match for Cardiff so they will be more inclined to be pushing forward more than usual. I think to adopt a similar strategy as the Chelsea game will hopefully provide us with a few chances.

I'd definately make sure Wardy covers Wilf and that should stop the supply of balls to Bellamy. That's my main concern.

This.We'd be delighted with a point, cardiff would feel they're doomed if they don't get all three so they will be all over us like a cheap suit which, as long as we don't concede early, will play right into our new counter-attacking with pace hands.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Apr 14 1.27pm

I don't think the starting XI will change, unless forced to by injury. Even if Chamakh is fit, I suspect he'll be on the bench and introduced, rather than thrown into the thick of it.

Mariappa, Bolaise, Puncheon and Ward all played very well togeather, and really seemed to have clicked.

God alone knows if we'll score.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

FinchleyEagle Flag 01 Apr 14 1.53pm

Absolutely must be the same team and the same approach. Sooner or later Cardiff will have to go for it, and that's when we hit them on the counter.

Tactically, we don't need to score, 0-0 does us fine. So makes sense to draw them in then hit them - although of course actually scoring goals is the problem. Can we ask Chelsea if we can have Terry on loan to play him up front ? Clinical finisher - 1 chance, 1 goal.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

jamescroydon09 Flag croydon 01 Apr 14 2.03pm

kg did have one of the best games i have seen him play but i would bring chamack back i would put ledly inkg place . chamack wins so meny headers and we need to go for the win when we are up aginst the likes of cardiff

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 01 Apr 14 2.03pm

I don't think it will change so Chamakh may be on the subs bench.

However, he needs to get some game time though to get fit so I think we'll definitely see MC at some point.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Apr 14 2.06pm

Quote thechaddyboy at 01 Apr 2014 1.16pm

prefer to see the same XI start with a similar game plan, would like to see us go full out for the victory & get the seasons survival over & done with asap rather than dragging it out till the Fulham game.


The same game plan? Funny. I thought Palace were going to play a team at the bottom away, not the team at the top at home! I think Palace really should adopt the apt tactics for the game they're playing and the side they are up against. Think about it TP!

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 01 Apr 14 2.55pm

If Cardiff throw the kitchen sink at us which they will I think we will be ok. I can see this being another kind of Chelsea games soak up the pressure and then break with pace and exploit the gaps in the back but FFS Palace put them away.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Apr 14 3.01pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 01 Apr 2014 2.55pm

If Cardiff throw the kitchen sink at us which they will I think we will be ok. I can see this being another kind of Chelsea games soak up the pressure and then break with pace and exploit the gaps in the back but FFS Palace put them away.


You don't think Cardiff will be clever and hold back, inviting Palace forward and exploiting the resulting gaps. With speedy players like Zaha and Bellingham up front, I would. After all, they must know Palace need to win as much as them. Or do Palace fall back to their old, misdirected ways of defending negatively and do a Newcastle etc?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 01 Apr 14 3.12pm

Quote adrian b at 01 Apr 2014 3.01pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 01 Apr 2014 2.55pm

If Cardiff throw the kitchen sink at us which they will I think we will be ok. I can see this being another kind of Chelsea games soak up the pressure and then break with pace and exploit the gaps in the back but FFS Palace put them away.


You don't think Cardiff will be clever and hold back, inviting Palace forward and exploiting the resulting gaps. With speedy players like Zaha and Bellingham up front, I would. After all, they must know Palace need to win as much as them. Or do Palace fall back to their old, misdirected ways of defending negatively and do a Newcastle etc?


There's no way Cardiff will hold back, this is make or break for them, their fans won't let them sit back.

And we don't need to win as much as them, their season is over if they don't win this, we're far from that stage.

I'd be very happy with a point.

 

cpfc13 Flag eastgrinstead 01 Apr 14 3.40pm

We need to play against Cardiff like we did at selhurst , defend well , and attack when we can , if we do this again I'm confident of a win . They were one of the worst teams to come to selhurst this season so lets go the same way about it on Saturday
COYP !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Do We Change The Team For Cardiff?