You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Puncheon hate Cardiff?
November 16 2026 12.39pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why does Puncheon hate Cardiff?


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 06 Apr 14 12.29pm

Has someone really been banned for calling the welsh sheep shaggers? Blimey...

Anyone who's set foot in wales will know how much they bang on about hating the English. Who hates the welsh? They're alright really. Bit daft and the wimmins are minging, but I can't imagine anyone having strong feelings for them either way.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

johnno42000 Flag 06 Apr 14 12.30pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Apr 2014 12.20pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Apr 2014 11.40pm

Quote Purleyeagle22 at 05 Apr 2014 11.31pm

Also I think everyone hates Cardiff should be playing Barry in the welsh league really


FFS. First time we played them was 1931 and we have been playing them ever since. We have had brilliant games against them. One of our proper rivals. What the hell is wrong with people on this site. They are a team like us, we have history coming out of our ears. Show them some respect will you. And it it's because they are Welsh that you give them stick, get over yourself. Some of the very best HOL posters are Welsh.

I don't think people dislike them because they are Welsh. I don't anyway. Its because they are a Welsh club playing in and enjoying the benefits of an English league.
Its one of the big corner stones for Celtic & Rangers argument that they want to play in the Premiership. I don't think they belong in the English league any more than Cardiff or Swansea do. Makes no difference to me how long they've been in the English league. They are still Welsh in an English league.


It isn't unique to Welsh teams. There are examples around the world of teams playing in a league in a different country. [Link]

I can't see the rules changing although Desperate Tan may try to get Cardiff playing in the Malaysian league

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Hoof Hearted 06 Apr 14 12.34pm

Quote Happiness Stan at 06 Apr 2014 12.29pm

Has someone really been banned for calling the welsh sheep shaggers? Blimey...

Anyone who's set foot in wales will know how much they bang on about hating the English. Who hates the welsh? They're alright really. Bit daft and the wimmins are minging, but I can't imagine anyone having strong feelings for them either way.


Are they though?

Jenkins.jpg Attachment: Jenkins.jpg (741.84Kb)

 

lankygit Flag Lincoln 06 Apr 14 12.34pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Apr 2014 12.20pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Apr 2014 11.40pm

Quote Purleyeagle22 at 05 Apr 2014 11.31pm

Also I think everyone hates Cardiff should be playing Barry in the welsh league really


FFS. First time we played them was 1931 and we have been playing them ever since. We have had brilliant games against them. One of our proper rivals. What the hell is wrong with people on this site. They are a team like us, we have history coming out of our ears. Show them some respect will you. And it it's because they are Welsh that you give them stick, get over yourself. Some of the very best HOL posters are Welsh.

I don't think people dislike them because they are Welsh. I don't anyway. Its because they are a Welsh club playing in and enjoying the benefits of an English league.
Its one of the big corner stones for Celtic & Rangers argument that they want to play in the Premiership. I don't think they belong in the English league any more than Cardiff or Swansea do. Makes no difference to me how long they've been in the English league. They are still Welsh in an English league.


To be fair to the Welsh clubs in our league we must remember that the club that usually win the Welsh league (TNS, formerly Oswestry Town) are based in Oswestry, Salop, England.

 


Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link]

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 06 Apr 14 12.38pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Apr 2014 12.34pm

Quote Happiness Stan at 06 Apr 2014 12.29pm

Has someone really been banned for calling the welsh sheep shaggers? Blimey...

Anyone who's set foot in wales will know how much they bang on about hating the English. Who hates the welsh? They're alright really. Bit daft and the wimmins are minging, but I can't imagine anyone having strong feelings for them either way.


Are they though?

Yes.

She looks alright, a bit horsey mind. Spend anytime in Wales and you will soon find quality talent is conspicuous by their absence. In conclusion: rough as f***.


 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

elgrande Flag bedford 06 Apr 14 12.41pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Apr 2014 12.02pm

Quote Plane at 06 Apr 2014 9.49am

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Apr 2014 9.39am

Quote Plane at 06 Apr 2014 9.30am

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Apr 2014 9.26am

The Welsh aren't a race, so it's somewhat impossible to be racist to them maplestone. Nationalist perhaps but with Wales I see it as being pretty much like Yorkshire, just a big county. I mean it wasn't even a united country until we took it over.


You need to watch yourself vaggie Mapletree is now a mod or he thinks he is as he keeps telling people how to behave on here.


He had a dig at me too the other day

I was right upset I tell thee.

Yeah but you probably deserved it


As I recall he did. And yes, I do think I am a mod. So is everyone. This site is largely self-policing, I am sure if I posted something undeserved Kermit would have come back at me, he has a habit of doing that. Not fair to just leave it all to the Mods, if someone is out of order they should be told before they dig themselves in deeper and get a red card. No idea if Aintree deserved it, I am sure it wasn't just for last night's drunken post.

And yes, you can be racist to the Welsh

[Link]

I reacted last night because there were several people on multiple threads just having a dig generally at the Welsh, as well as specifically at Cardiff, just to be malicious.

And finally, I get really pissed off by people saying that if we are nice to people we are Nigels. In that case for sure I am. When I first starting watching Palace there wasn't fan segregation and it was brilliant. Then the Moan U fans spoiled it for everyone in 1973. From then on the hooligan element took over for a while. But it isn't traditional to have fights between supporters, it was a nasty little blip in our history.

I remember standing on the Holmesdale watching a young teenager in front of me having a razor sharp knife held to his throat by a Millwall fan. I also remember a bloke called Bosco wading into a whole Whitehorse Lane end of Millwall fans on his own (in a clean white jumper, most bizarre). People look back on those days as if they were halcyon, well they weren't. And if anyone implies we should bring them back you can be sure I will react every time.


Sure Bosco is gonna love you for naming him on here.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

johnno42000 Flag 06 Apr 14 12.43pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Apr 2014 12.24pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Apr 2014 12.02pm

As I recall he did. And yes, I do think I am a mod. So is everyone. This site is largely self-policing, I am sure if I posted something undeserved Kermit would have come back at me, he has a habit of doing that. Not fair to just leave it all to the Mods, if someone is out of order they should be told before they dig themselves in deeper and get a red card. No idea if Aintree deserved it, I am sure it wasn't just for last night's drunken post.

And yes, you can be racist to the Welsh

[Link]

For the record Mapletree, you are not a mod so you really don't need to minimod. We have plenty of mods here, they don't really need your help short of posting on a thread that it needs to be merged (whilst giving the name of the thread it needs to be merged with).

Secondly, the Welsh are not a race and therefore you can't be racist to them. You can however, be xenophobic towards them irregardless to what I assume is yet another poorly factchecked Torygraph article.


From the CPS site "A racial group means a group of persons defined by reference to race, colour, nationality (including citizenship) or ethnic or national origins." [Link] .

Man found guilty of 'racially aggravated disorderly behaviour'. [Link]

Edited by johnno42000 (06 Apr 2014 12.44pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

JL85 Flag London,SE9 06 Apr 14 12.46pm

Pretty sure he adopted the celebration after the scathing criticism of his penalty.

On Welsh teams in English Leagues, I respect Cardiff and Swansea for doing it the "hard way".

Its the notion of s***e like Celtic getting a free pass to the EPL that pisses me off. If you want to join, fine - start from the bottom though.

I think, after going into liquidation, Rangers missed a trick not starting fresh in the English Leagues, personally.

Also think the Red Card was harsh. Are we really that hot on racism these days? Was the banning mod welsh?

Edited by JL85 (06 Apr 2014 12.48pm)

 

Kingvagabond Flag London 06 Apr 14 12.54pm

Quote johnno42000 at 06 Apr 2014 12.43pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Apr 2014 12.24pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Apr 2014 12.02pm

As I recall he did. And yes, I do think I am a mod. So is everyone. This site is largely self-policing, I am sure if I posted something undeserved Kermit would have come back at me, he has a habit of doing that. Not fair to just leave it all to the Mods, if someone is out of order they should be told before they dig themselves in deeper and get a red card. No idea if Aintree deserved it, I am sure it wasn't just for last night's drunken post.

And yes, you can be racist to the Welsh

[Link]

For the record Mapletree, you are not a mod so you really don't need to minimod. We have plenty of mods here, they don't really need your help short of posting on a thread that it needs to be merged (whilst giving the name of the thread it needs to be merged with).

Secondly, the Welsh are not a race and therefore you can't be racist to them. You can however, be xenophobic towards them irregardless to what I assume is yet another poorly factchecked Torygraph article.


From the CPS site "A racial group means a group of persons defined by reference to race, colour, nationality (including citizenship) or ethnic or national origins." [Link] .

Man found guilty of 'racially aggravated disorderly behaviour'. [Link]

Edited by johnno42000 (06 Apr 2014 12.44pm)

1.1Prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one’s own race is superior:

Thats from the Oxford English Dictionary.

The quote you provided says it all though to be honest. To me thats saying 'We're allowing the term racism to mean from a race or a nationality' i.e. they're ceding that their definition is incorrect.


Edited by Kingvagabond (06 Apr 2014 12.55pm)

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 06 Apr 14 12.59pm

Calling the welsh sheep shaggers is not remotely racist. It's boring and witless, but it's the same as calling the scots haggis munchers or northerners whippet owners. Real racism is vile, insidious and hateful. I wish people weren't so quick to throw the term round at something vaguely un PC.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Apr 14 1.00pm

Quote elgrande at 06 Apr 2014 12.41pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Apr 2014 12.02pm

Quote Plane at 06 Apr 2014 9.49am

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Apr 2014 9.39am

Quote Plane at 06 Apr 2014 9.30am

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Apr 2014 9.26am

The Welsh aren't a race, so it's somewhat impossible to be racist to them maplestone. Nationalist perhaps but with Wales I see it as being pretty much like Yorkshire, just a big county. I mean it wasn't even a united country until we took it over.


You need to watch yourself vaggie Mapletree is now a mod or he thinks he is as he keeps telling people how to behave on here.


He had a dig at me too the other day

I was right upset I tell thee.

Yeah but you probably deserved it


As I recall he did. And yes, I do think I am a mod. So is everyone. This site is largely self-policing, I am sure if I posted something undeserved Kermit would have come back at me, he has a habit of doing that. Not fair to just leave it all to the Mods, if someone is out of order they should be told before they dig themselves in deeper and get a red card. No idea if Aintree deserved it, I am sure it wasn't just for last night's drunken post.

And yes, you can be racist to the Welsh

[Link]

I reacted last night because there were several people on multiple threads just having a dig generally at the Welsh, as well as specifically at Cardiff, just to be malicious.

And finally, I get really pissed off by people saying that if we are nice to people we are Nigels. In that case for sure I am. When I first starting watching Palace there wasn't fan segregation and it was brilliant. Then the Moan U fans spoiled it for everyone in 1973. From then on the hooligan element took over for a while. But it isn't traditional to have fights between supporters, it was a nasty little blip in our history.

I remember standing on the Holmesdale watching a young teenager in front of me having a razor sharp knife held to his throat by a Millwall fan. I also remember a bloke called Bosco wading into a whole Whitehorse Lane end of Millwall fans on his own (in a clean white jumper, most bizarre). People look back on those days as if they were halcyon, well they weren't. And if anyone implies we should bring them back you can be sure I will react every time.


Sure Bosco is gonna love you for naming him on here.


Doh!

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


johnno42000 Flag 06 Apr 14 1.04pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Apr 2014 12.54pm

Quote johnno42000 at 06 Apr 2014 12.43pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Apr 2014 12.24pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Apr 2014 12.02pm

As I recall he did. And yes, I do think I am a mod. So is everyone. This site is largely self-policing, I am sure if I posted something undeserved Kermit would have come back at me, he has a habit of doing that. Not fair to just leave it all to the Mods, if someone is out of order they should be told before they dig themselves in deeper and get a red card. No idea if Aintree deserved it, I am sure it wasn't just for last night's drunken post.

And yes, you can be racist to the Welsh

[Link]

For the record Mapletree, you are not a mod so you really don't need to minimod. We have plenty of mods here, they don't really need your help short of posting on a thread that it needs to be merged (whilst giving the name of the thread it needs to be merged with).

Secondly, the Welsh are not a race and therefore you can't be racist to them. You can however, be xenophobic towards them irregardless to what I assume is yet another poorly factchecked Torygraph article.


From the CPS site "A racial group means a group of persons defined by reference to race, colour, nationality (including citizenship) or ethnic or national origins." [Link] .

Man found guilty of 'racially aggravated disorderly behaviour'. [Link]

Edited by johnno42000 (06 Apr 2014 12.44pm)

1.1Prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one’s own race is superior:

Thats from the Oxford English Dictionary.

The quote you provided says it all though to be honest. To me thats saying 'We're allowing the term racism to mean from a race or a nationality' i.e. they're ceding that their definition is incorrect.


Edited by Kingvagabond (06 Apr 2014 12.55pm)

From reading the article on the cps site I think the legal definition would include the possibility of being racist towards people from Wales, England, Scotland, Northern Ireland etc.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Apr 14 1.06pm

It's more bigotry I believe.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Kingvagabond Flag London 06 Apr 14 1.11pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Apr 2014 1.06pm

It's more bigotry I believe.

Precisely.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

Beaverwilly Flag Croydon 06 Apr 14 1.30pm

Well this thread escalated quickly and went completely off topic.

Puncheon has been doing that celebration for a while now, can't remember when he first did but he has definitely done it before yesterday. I don't believe it had anything to do specifically with Cardiff or their fans.

 


Whenever I feel the need to exercise, I lie down until it goes away.

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Apr 14 1.34pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Apr 2014 1.11pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Apr 2014 1.06pm

It's more bigotry I believe.

Precisely.


Not that there is much of a difference on the street. Both about haranguing, bullying and exclusion in my book.

Semantics.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 06 Apr 14 1.38pm

Quote collier row eagle at 06 Apr 2014 7.49am

Is it because he mentioned the name welsh that he was red carded?, there have been plenty of posts calling Cardiff fans "sheep shaggers" done it myself, but if it's because he has mentioned the word "welsh" in his post, he has been red carded, seems a bit silly, after all idoes it not come under the banner called banter.? Are the jocks not referred to as tight? And the Irish as thick? And I'm sure the English are referred to all sorts of verbal abuse from our Irish, welsh, and Scottish friends.


Got to say, it's very disappointing if he got red carded just for that.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

TheLastDodo Flag Rye 06 Apr 14 1.41pm

Quote aintree at 06 Apr 2014 12.04am

Quote Mapletree at 05 Apr 2014 11.52pm

Quote Purleyeagle22 at 05 Apr 2014 11.45pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Apr 2014 11.40pm

Quote Purleyeagle22 at 05 Apr 2014 11.31pm

Also I think everyone hates Cardiff should be playing Barry in the welsh league really


FFS. First time we played them was 1931 and we have been playing them ever since. We have had brilliant games against them. One of our proper rivals. What the hell is wrong with people on this site. They are a team like us, we have history coming out of our ears. Show them some respect will you. And it it's because they are Welsh that you give them stick, get over yourself. Some of the very best HOL posters are Welsh.

You think Cardiff fans are showing us respect on their forums? Plus ain't the point of rivalry to give the opposition stick at every opportunity. It part of the game calm yourself.



Probably not fair you get the brunt of my vitriol. Just so much anti welsh sentiment on the HOL tonight and that pisses me off. Some really nasty posts. Tough town but one of our genuine rivals, I put Cardiff in the same bucket as Sheff U, Leicester, Wet Spam and Stoke. Proper teams, proper supporters, a bit yo yo and we keep on bumping into each other.

As such, deserving of respect in exactly the same way as Chelsea and Moan U aren't.


They sold there soul to the devil and there fans today were a joke.
I don't respect them.
f*** um sheep shagging Welsh c***s.


I don't like The Welsh but if this bloke got banned for that then it's a bit of a rum do .

 

TheLastDodo Flag Rye 06 Apr 14 1.42pm

Isn't it.

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 06 Apr 14 2.11pm

If that is the offending post, then frankly it's ridiculous. If anyone is genuinely offended by that they are beyond precious and need to get some perspective.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Puncheon hate Cardiff?