This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
jamiemartin721 Reading 15 Apr 14 12.45pm |
|
|
I suspect its much more to do with the unlawful dismiss claim Moody has against Cardiff than Cardiff trying to get points deducted from us. The premiership has only ever deducted points as far as I can tell when Portsmouth went into administration.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Mapletree Croydon 15 Apr 14 1.18pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Apr 2014 12.45pm
I suspect its much more to do with the unlawful dismiss claim Moody has against Cardiff than Cardiff trying to get points deducted from us. The premiership has only ever deducted points as far as I can tell when Portsmouth went into administration.
Where do you get this from Jamie? According to The Grauniad on 5 December he seems to have signed a Settlement Agreement.
<<The agreement Moody signed when he left Cardiff means that he is unable to go into the circumstances surrounding his exit>>
|
black eagle. south croydon. 15 Apr 14 1.27pm |
|
|
i know what we can do,offer soon to be championship club Cardiff a friendly next season but on one condition.
Tan the man must be palace's bitch for the day and wash our kit and clean the players boots arfter the game.
either that or expect to be counter sued.
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 15 Apr 14 1.35pm |
|
Quote SloveniaDave at 15 Apr 2014 12.26pm
Quote adrian b at 15 Apr 2014 12.24pm
What are the allegations being made by Tan? I have thought of a few that may be the case.
1) Someone blackmailed a Cardiff employee to pass over information. If proved this is criminal. 2) Someone bribed a Cardiff employee to pass over information. Just an internal issue of trust for Cardiff, though not nice to know someone at Palace did this. 3) Someone at Palace bribed Cardiff player(s) to do something during the match to help Palace get a result, like give away a penalty, miss an open goal or something similar. If this is the case the implications are truly horrendous if proved. The way Cardiff played Tan believes this is possible. Some ex-Palace players are at the moment being investigated for something like this, though this of course is nothing to do with what Tan is on about. Cannot think of anything else on this matter that could possibly be a problem, tho' I'll keep my thinking cap on!
Bribery is a criminal offence, not just an internal issue.
I meant, bribery for some inconsequential inside info that may not be of much interest, like who was shagging who or the tea ladies name. If not deemed to affect a result it's just a matter of personal confidence.
|
babylonjohn St Leonards-on-Sea 15 Apr 14 1.42pm |
|
|
Really do think this is a massive storm in a teacup. People who work in football are constantly bandying around line ups, team news, rumours. Why wouldn't they ? Players, journos and scouts all move from team to team and gossip to each other. So what if someone told someone who told someone who told Ian moody what team might be playing...hardly the crime of the century. As has been mentioned, fielding an unregistered player is surely a more serious crime, and this is only punishable by a fine.
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 15 Apr 14 1.51pm |
|
Quote babylonjohn at 15 Apr 2014 1.42pm
Really do think this is a massive storm in a teacup. People who work in football are constantly bandying around line ups, team news, rumours. Why wouldn't they ? Players, journos and scouts all move from team to team and gossip to each other. So what if someone told someone who told someone who told Ian moody what team might be playing...hardly the crime of the century. As has been mentioned, fielding an unregistered player is surely a more serious crime, and this is only punishable by a fine.
That's just dandy, so long as there is nothing more sinestre, which is the point of this thread.
|
barrybigfingers Isle of Wight 15 Apr 14 2.05pm |
|
|
I'm sure Cardiff would have asked Wilf (a Man United player) to give them a few pointers on Palace players strengths and weaknesses.
I cant see how this would be any different to Moody tapping up a Cardiff contact for their planned teamsheet.
Grammar: The difference between knowing your shit and knowing you're shit
|
PalacePhotoMan Wallington 15 Apr 14 2.09pm |
|
|
2 days before the game, Ole Gunnar wotsit said in the paper that he had told Wilf to celebrate if he scored a goal.
That suggests to me that OGS told the World that Wilf would be playing.
So is Tan sueing OGS too?
Zaha, Williams, Murray, Ambrose, Scannell.
A 5-man forward line who scored 3 goals in 10 minutes on 27th September 2011 at .......................
|
paperhat croydon 15 Apr 14 2.17pm |
|
|
isnt it more likely that Bolasie rang Wilf and asked him what the teams were seeing as they're such good mates?
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
blinddodger pattaya 15 Apr 14 2.36pm |
|
|
We play Cardiff, beat them and soon after they sack two members of staff, we play Villa beat them and and soon after they sack two members of staff. Are they going to complain about Moody as well lol.
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 15 Apr 14 2.49pm |
|
|
So Moody supposedly phoned somebody up 2 days before the match and got the team sheet. Firstly I assume Cardiff were training before this crucial match with the potential for injuries ? So can't see having the team that early would make a difference. Not worth the paper it was written on. Secondly if somebody at Cardiff was stupid enough to give him the team then it is an internal Cardiff matter. If they received some benefit for this info then that is a different matter. Sounds like a lot of hot air at the moment and a desperate throw of the dice (like the change of manager at Norwich) from another struggling club.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 15 Apr 14 2.54pm |
|
Quote blinddodger at 15 Apr 2014 2.36pm
We play Cardiff, beat them and soon after they sack two members of staff, we play Villa beat them and and soon after they sack two members of staff. Are they going to complain about Moody as well lol.
When we beat Liverpool I reckon Stevie G and Suarez will be out of the door
This whole story has non event all over it - The Sun went into overdrive and has now quietened - other papers hardly gave it house room..its the desperate ramblings of loon trying any means possible to deflect from his and his managers awful bollocksing of their great opportunity in the PL as it slowly gurgles down the toilet
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|
Mapletree Croydon 15 Apr 14 2.58pm |
|
Quote paperhat at 15 Apr 2014 2.17pm
isnt it more likely that Bolasie rang Wilf and asked him what the teams were seeing as they're such good mates?
No, the club was specific it didn't come from a player.
|
Mapletree Croydon 15 Apr 14 3.02pm |
|
Quote barrybigfingers at 15 Apr 2014 2.05pm
I'm sure Cardiff would have asked Wilf (a Man United player) to give them a few pointers on Palace players strengths and weaknesses.
I cant see how this would be any different to Moody tapping up a Cardiff contact for their planned teamsheet.
Well, because Moody had a contract with Cardiff plus a Settlement Agreement that almost certainly had a clause in it that he couldn't use any inside information to which he was party.
Palace of course would not have that over Wilf, may have had when he first left but it would be out of date by now.
I think this complaint has some merit. If so it seems to me it's a contractual issue and at worst would result in an award of damages to Cardiff. But these are notoriously hard to prove so I doubt they would have any joy.
No idea if there could be a breach of FA rules.
|
GlaziertoEagle Coventry 15 Apr 14 3.09pm |
|
|
Maybe we made a few phone calls to the Villa staff too? That's obviously how we managed to beat them also... [Link]
|
SloveniaDave Tirana, Albania 15 Apr 14 3.11pm |
|
Quote GlaziertoEagle at 15 Apr 2014 3.09pm
Maybe we made a few phone calls to the Villa staff too? That's obviously how we managed to beat them also... [Link]
Conspiracy theorists will have great fun with this now!
Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!
My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.
(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)
|
sydtheeagle England 15 Apr 14 3.17pm |
|
Quote SloveniaDave at 15 Apr 2014 3.11pm
Quote GlaziertoEagle at 15 Apr 2014 3.09pm
Maybe we made a few phone calls to the Villa staff too? That's obviously how we managed to beat them also... [Link]
Conspiracy theorists will have great fun with this now!
Apparently the result of a punch up before the Fulham-Villa game the week before: Culverhouse and Gordon Cowans put in a few rounds.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
The Dolphin 15 Apr 14 3.51pm |
|
|
It is only a worry if there was something in their contract with Ian Moody. However - he got the push I believe so it unlikely he had to sign anything unless he got a big pay-off. If he signed something then it is more likely to be an employment issue than something concerning the Premier League. I suspect this is Cardiff not only clutching at straws but also trying to unsettle a Team above them. If they knew this happened before the game then they should have reported it then - not now. I can't see us having points deducted somehow. It is a side show which Palace seem to be avoiding joining in which is a good sign.
|
Sg Bilko Deurne Holland 15 Apr 14 3.58pm |
|
Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 12.38pm
I guess it is likely that Moody had a confidentiality clause in his contract.
If he breached it, he can be sued.
If the club encouraged that breach, or could have prevented it but did not, then it also could be sued.
Presumably it would be sued for damages, so Cardiff would have to prove the damages. If Cardiff goes down but would have stayed up had it had three more points this could - in theory - become a problem.
Mind you, if Moody was unfairly dismissed that may impact upon this. I am guessing there was a Settlement Agreement in place, it would be interesting to know what it had to say on confidentiality but likely it reinforced the requirement.
Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 12.38pm)
No, he was dismissed pretty unceremoniously so that contract is no longer valid, as Tan is in breach of contract.
|
blind eagle Covington.Tennessee 15 Apr 14 4.17pm |
|
Quote EagleLegend97 at 14 Apr 2014 8.29pm
Look at this way, if Sunderland can field in an inelligible player for 4 games this season and only get fined, it will be absolutely ridiculous if we get anything more than that. And anyway, i really don't see it as a massive issue. If a member of staff at Cardiff did give the teamsheet to Moody, it's their fault. Obviously Moody shouldn't be asking, but it didn't end up being a major factor, neither team changed their starting line up, and regardless we probably would have smashed them anyway. They were awful.
Even if we asked for info on their team selection and somebody gave it to us we did not steal it and I can only see it as being their fault. Sounds all a bit childish to me and I think its a sign of their desperation as they go down.
|