You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tube strike
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tube strike


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Stuk Flag Top half 10 Feb 15 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

 


Optimistic as ever

ghosteagle Flag 10 Feb 15 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

Checked this and confirmed that some kinds of diabetes can produce false positive results on breath tests. This doesn't prove he wasn't drunk, but it explains the trade unions have an argument.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 10 Feb 15 4.32pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

Checked this and confirmed that some kinds of diabetes can produce false positive results on breath tests. This doesn't prove he wasn't drunk, but it explains the trade unions have an argument.

Not on that machine, and he failed it twice.

The transport authority said it had explored in detail the suggestion that diabetes could affect the breathalyser result, but concluded that the type of test it used was not affected by acetone, which is produced in the bloodstream of people with the condition.

 


Optimistic as ever

ghosteagle Flag 10 Feb 15 4.37pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.32pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

Checked this and confirmed that some kinds of diabetes can produce false positive results on breath tests. This doesn't prove he wasn't drunk, but it explains the trade unions have an argument.

Not on that machine, and he failed it twice.

The transport authority said it had explored in detail the suggestion that diabetes could affect the breathalyser result, but concluded that the type of test it used was not affected by acetone, which is produced in the bloodstream of people with the condition.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 10 Feb 15 4.40pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.37pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.32pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

Checked this and confirmed that some kinds of diabetes can produce false positive results on breath tests. This doesn't prove he wasn't drunk, but it explains the trade unions have an argument.

Not on that machine, and he failed it twice.

The transport authority said it had explored in detail the suggestion that diabetes could affect the breathalyser result, but concluded that the type of test it used was not affected by acetone, which is produced in the bloodstream of people with the condition.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.


It's not a opinion, it's a conclusion.

 


Optimistic as ever

Pussay Patrol Flag 10 Feb 15 4.43pm

I hope people take this sort of archaic Union practice into account when they talk about renationalising the railways.

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

ghosteagle Flag 10 Feb 15 4.44pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.40pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.37pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.32pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

Checked this and confirmed that some kinds of diabetes can produce false positive results on breath tests. This doesn't prove he wasn't drunk, but it explains the trade unions have an argument.

Not on that machine, and he failed it twice.

The transport authority said it had explored in detail the suggestion that diabetes could affect the breathalyser result, but concluded that the type of test it used was not affected by acetone, which is produced in the bloodstream of people with the condition.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.


It's not a opinion, it's a conclusion.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities subjective opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 4.46pm

Here's an objective view then. The underground system is completely emasculated by a mixture of poor management and extraordinarily dated Union philosophy. I object strongly to the no compulsory redundancies concept resulting in people sitting in their gardens for years.

The Union activists would fight their own shadows. They have a ridiculously cushy life and won't let it go easily. Every chance they get to milk the situation they do so with no feeling of guilt. And they like to make sure management know how powerful they are by calling action on a regular basis, using spurious logics in their - perfectly rational and perfectly selfish - power games.

We all suffer from this monopoly. If this were a market economy instead of a closed shop it would look so very different.

 

ghosteagle Flag 10 Feb 15 4.49pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 4.46pm

Here's an objective view then. The underground system is completely emasculated by a mixture of poor management and extraordinarily dated Union philosophy. I object strongly to the no compulsory redundancies concept resulting in people sitting in their gardens for years.

The Union activists would fight their own shadows. They have a ridiculously cushy life and won't let it go easily. Every chance they get to milk the situation they do so with no feeling of guilt. And they like to make sure management know how powerful they are by calling action on a regular basis, using spurious logics in their - perfectly rational and perfectly selfish - power games.

We all suffer from this monopoly. If this were a market economy instead of a closed shop it would look so very different.

So, your objective view is that you don't like the union. Thanks for the update fella.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 10 Feb 15 4.50pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.44pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.40pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.37pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.32pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

Checked this and confirmed that some kinds of diabetes can produce false positive results on breath tests. This doesn't prove he wasn't drunk, but it explains the trade unions have an argument.

Not on that machine, and he failed it twice.

The transport authority said it had explored in detail the suggestion that diabetes could affect the breathalyser result, but concluded that the type of test it used was not affected by acetone, which is produced in the bloodstream of people with the condition.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.


It's not a opinion, it's a conclusion.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities subjective opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.

They saw the "excuse" coming. Next time they should just shop them to the police and haul them off for a blood test and bit of downtime.

 


Optimistic as ever

ghosteagle Flag 10 Feb 15 4.52pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.50pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.44pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.40pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.37pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.32pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Feb 2015 4.18pm

[Link]

"I'm not over the limit, it's my diabetes."

It's bad enough the RMT defend those who fail breath tests, but to vote for strike action over it (again) is absurd.

Checked this and confirmed that some kinds of diabetes can produce false positive results on breath tests. This doesn't prove he wasn't drunk, but it explains the trade unions have an argument.

Not on that machine, and he failed it twice.

The transport authority said it had explored in detail the suggestion that diabetes could affect the breathalyser result, but concluded that the type of test it used was not affected by acetone, which is produced in the bloodstream of people with the condition.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.


It's not a opinion, it's a conclusion.

Thanks for printing the transport authorities subjective opinion, but i was talking about an objective view.

They saw the "excuse" coming. Next time they should just shop them to the police and haul them off for a blood test and bit of downtime.

Shome mishtake surelly?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 4.53pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.49pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 4.46pm

Here's an objective view then. The underground system is completely emasculated by a mixture of poor management and extraordinarily dated Union philosophy. I object strongly to the no compulsory redundancies concept resulting in people sitting in their gardens for years.

The Union activists would fight their own shadows. They have a ridiculously cushy life and won't let it go easily. Every chance they get to milk the situation they do so with no feeling of guilt. And they like to make sure management know how powerful they are by calling action on a regular basis, using spurious logics in their - perfectly rational and perfectly selfish - power games.

We all suffer from this monopoly. If this were a market economy instead of a closed shop it would look so very different.

So, your objective view is that you don't like the union. Thanks for the update fella.


Funnily enough I didn't say that. It's a very good Union for its members. But I don't think it makes sense for customers to condone closed-shops.

 

ghosteagle Flag 10 Feb 15 4.58pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 4.46pm

Here's an objective view then. The underground system is completely emasculated by a mixture of poor management and extraordinarily dated Union philosophy. I object strongly to the no compulsory redundancies concept resulting in people sitting in their gardens for years.

The Union activists would fight their own shadows. They have a ridiculously cushy life and won't let it go easily. Every chance they get to milk the situation they do so with no feeling of guilt. And they like to make sure management know how powerful they are by calling action on a regular basis, using spurious logics in their - perfectly rational and perfectly selfish - power games.

We all suffer from this monopoly. If this were a market economy instead of a closed shop it would look so very different.

Feeling of guilt? For what pray tell?

 

npn Flag Crowborough 10 Feb 15 5.21pm

At least it finally puts to bed the old "we are striking for the safety of passengers" b0llocks!

Driverless trains? Can't have that - think how unsafe the poor innocent passengers will be (without the bloke at the front to push a lever).

Sh*t-faced driver? Well that's just fine and dandy if he's a union member.


I notice the vote was incredibly close though, and I actually feel sorry for the almost 50% who voted no, and will now be coerced to lose a day's pay for the benefit of someone who broke perfectly sensible rules.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 5.36pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.58pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 4.46pm

Here's an objective view then. The underground system is completely emasculated by a mixture of poor management and extraordinarily dated Union philosophy. I object strongly to the no compulsory redundancies concept resulting in people sitting in their gardens for years.

The Union activists would fight their own shadows. They have a ridiculously cushy life and won't let it go easily. Every chance they get to milk the situation they do so with no feeling of guilt. And they like to make sure management know how powerful they are by calling action on a regular basis, using spurious logics in their - perfectly rational and perfectly selfish - power games.

We all suffer from this monopoly. If this were a market economy instead of a closed shop it would look so very different.

Feeling of guilt? For what pray tell?


You are on your own there pal. Over 3m journeys a day on the Underground. This strike, ostensibly to support one p*ssed bloke (but really just a show of strength), is going to affect people in so many ways. Like missing crucial hospital appointments. And it will cost a fortune. Is it proportionate? Like b*ggery. If management does something unreasonable, the rest of us have recourse to Employment Tribunals. And with the support of a strong Union it's a hard thing to fight.

Clearly management didn't do anything wrong in this case, I have read through the process and it's reasonable and I have no doubt led to the correct outcome.

So, in the end, it has to be the Union that is being unreasonable and - for me - that is all about political power play. And millions suffer in this nasty little game.

I assume you are an RMT official.

 

TUX Flag redhill 10 Feb 15 7.26pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 4.46pm

Here's an objective view then. The underground system is completely emasculated by a mixture of poor management and extraordinarily dated Union philosophy. I object strongly to the no compulsory redundancies concept resulting in people sitting in their gardens for years.

The Union activists would fight their own shadows. They have a ridiculously cushy life and won't let it go easily. Every chance they get to milk the situation they do so with no feeling of guilt. And they like to make sure management know how powerful they are by calling action on a regular basis, using spurious logics in their - perfectly rational and perfectly selfish - power games.

We all suffer from this monopoly. If this were a market economy instead of a closed shop it would look so very different.

''Suffer''? If that's your description of being 'inconvenienced but with plenty of notice' then my mind boggles.
As for the next sentence, if you 'suffer' this badly when being only 'inconvenienced' how the hell will you feel when you're put on a zero hour contract one day due to the 'market economy' that you appear to want?

Be careful what you wish for.


Edited by Moose (11 Feb 2015 9.23am)

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 7.52pm

lol anyone notice the RMT guy's name is Cash...surely a stitch up?

IMO striking is BS in this instance, you can't even take a minute risk having a pissed person driving a train until more testing is complete so this is completely over the top!

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

TUX Flag redhill 10 Feb 15 8.02pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 5.36pm

Quote ghosteagle at 10 Feb 2015 4.58pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 4.46pm

Here's an objective view then. The underground system is completely emasculated by a mixture of poor management and extraordinarily dated Union philosophy. I object strongly to the no compulsory redundancies concept resulting in people sitting in their gardens for years.

The Union activists would fight their own shadows. They have a ridiculously cushy life and won't let it go easily. Every chance they get to milk the situation they do so with no feeling of guilt. And they like to make sure management know how powerful they are by calling action on a regular basis, using spurious logics in their - perfectly rational and perfectly selfish - power games.

We all suffer from this monopoly. If this were a market economy instead of a closed shop it would look so very different.

Feeling of guilt? For what pray tell?


You are on your own there pal. Over 3m journeys a day on the Underground. This strike, ostensibly to support one p*ssed bloke (but really just a show of strength), is going to affect people in so many ways. Like missing crucial hospital appointments. And it will cost a fortune. Is it proportionate? Like b*ggery. If management does something unreasonable, the rest of us have recourse to Employment Tribunals. And with the support of a strong Union it's a hard thing to fight.

Clearly management didn't do anything wrong in this case, I have read through the process and it's reasonable and I have no doubt led to the correct outcome.

So, in the end, it has to be the Union that is being unreasonable and - for me - that is all about political power play. And millions suffer in this nasty little game.

I assume you are an RMT official.

If you put the same effort into those who 'inconvenience YOU/cost YOU' 365 DAYS OF THE YEAR then your argument would stand. But you don't because that would be hard work wouldn't it? Far easier to pick on a few workers than take on the Govt's policies.
You're just p-ssed off because you can't get a train despite having ample warning.
To then throw 'hospital appointments' into the ring is just blah blah blah.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Feb 15 8.04pm

Told by a friend of an rmt member that the story is because of his health the breath test gave a false reading. And rather than test his urine as well for alcohol this was not done. Lu then destroyed the test results. The reason for the strike is procedures put in place by London underground was not followed.

Not sure how true this is. But if London underground havent followed procedures, they've left themselves open...

Edited by nickgusset (10 Feb 2015 8.06pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 8.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Feb 2015 8.04pm

Told by a friend of an rmt member that the story is because of his health the breath test gave a false reading. And rather than test his urine as well for alcohol this was not done. Lu then destroyed the test results. The reason for the strike is procedures put in place by London underground was not followed.

Not sure how true this is. But if London underground havent followed procedures, they've left themselves open...

Edited by nickgusset (10 Feb 2015 8.06pm)


If they didn't follow their own processes then it's likely the employee would win at a Tribunal.

So why should the Union members set themselves up as judge and jury when there is a serviceable process available to this employee?

And no TUX, it won't inconvenience me in the slightest. I don't catch the underground. But it will inconvenience over a million people, some of whom aren't in a position to easily cope.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tube strike