You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Putin
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Putin


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Bert the Head Flag Epsom 20 Feb 15 11.46pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Feb 2015 1.43pm

Why won't it happen?

Long range bombers is all they need....That's what they want and that's what Russia are providing.....Knock out that runway and we are fecked.

Complacent defence reviews assume far too much......You can't defend a nation's interests on positive assumptions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2015 1.44pm)

You are really up for a good old war Stirling. You must be desperate to get at those tins of Spaghetti hoops you hid in your cellar in the 80s.

If its wasting them is bothering you that much I'll get a campaign up to buy them off you for the sake of peace in Europe...but I want those Stallone movies thrown in as well and Black Hawk Down and Sniper. They are a bad influence on you.


 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 21 Feb 15 12.05am

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Feb 2015 11.40pm

Quote Bert the Head at 20 Feb 2015 11.32pm

We are not at the meeting. We normally would be. We have always been key players in foreign policy in Europe and yet we are absent from the biggest meeting regarding a threat to peace in Europe since 1945. That is my point. The EU is the main player in Europe now and France and Germany run that. It is a catastrophic failing of the Tories and their half-hearted relationship with the EU.



We aren't there for exactly the reason I said.

Maybe you haven't been reading up on the situation but the UK has been arguing for increased sanctions and along with the US raising the possibility of arming the Ukraine.

We weren't there for exactly the reason the US weren't there.....Not because what we think doesn't matter but because Russia don't want to talk to us because we are playing hard ball.

Good cop, bad cop.

Putin would not have been there at all without the threat to his interests.

EU sanctions. Not British.

If you are not at a meeting you rely on others. I can see why the USA aren't there. They are not in Europe after all. We are. It is not good cop bad cop it is pissing in the tent instead of pissing out of it. The USA will be listening to French and German accounts of the meeting not ours.

But you have hit on an important point that we see ourselves as aligned to USA interest and not Europe.

I'm no fan of Thatcher but she was a states person. Britain would have been represented at the meeting under Thatcher, Major and Blair. All three were Party leaders but British Prime Ministers. That is not to say they were not divisive. But Cameron is just a Tory Prime Minister.


Edited by Bert the Head (21 Feb 2015 12.05am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 1.32am

Quote Bert the Head at 21 Feb 2015 12.05am

EU sanctions. Not British.

If you are not at a meeting you rely on others. I can see why the USA aren't there. They are not in Europe after all. We are. It is not good cop bad cop it is pissing in the tent instead of pissing out of it. The USA will be listening to French and German accounts of the meeting not ours.

But you have hit on an important point that we see ourselves as aligned to USA interest and not Europe.

I'm no fan of Thatcher but she was a states person. Britain would have been represented at the meeting under Thatcher, Major and Blair. All three were Party leaders but British Prime Ministers. That is not to say they were not divisive. But Cameron is just a Tory Prime Minister.


Edited by Bert the Head (21 Feb 2015 12.05am)


Bert the American sanctions are just as bad if not worse for Russia than the EU's.

One without the other is meaningless.

What happens in Europe is of fundamental importance to the US.....Hell they protected Europe from the USSR for all of the latter half of last century....Europe didn't stand a chance on its own.

The US and Europe represent the west...They are hand in glove.

Let's just state it again shall me. The US and the UK were not there because we have been far more aggressive over the Ukrainian situation.

If this comes to war, the EU can't do without us....That's how pathetic their combined military is...Putin is very aware that especially the US but also UK and France are where the military power is. You seriously think that some kind of deal would be done without US and UK involvement?....Lefty wishful thinking..You think that our people and the US aren't actually there.....The figureheads are the surface....There are oceans beneath them.

If you think Putin is there without this united front you are deluded.

If we weren't in the EU we could and would most probably act in concert with the EU on this anyway....Not being in the EU doesn't suddenly mean we aren't European....One is a political and economic union and the other is a geographical fact.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 1.35am

Quote Bert the Head at 20 Feb 2015 11.46pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Feb 2015 1.43pm

Why won't it happen?

Long range bombers is all they need....That's what they want and that's what Russia are providing.....Knock out that runway and we are fecked.

Complacent defence reviews assume far too much......You can't defend a nation's interests on positive assumptions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2015 1.44pm)

You are really up for a good old war Stirling. You must be desperate to get at those tins of Spaghetti hoops you hid in your cellar in the 80s.

If its wasting them is bothering you that much I'll get a campaign up to buy them off you for the sake of peace in Europe...but I want those Stallone movies thrown in as well and Black Hawk Down and Sniper. They are a bad influence on you.



The ironic thing is that I don't want war.

That's why we need a strong defence and ensure that we can protect our interests......The bully rarely if ever picks a fight with the strong. Those who shy away from the fight attract it.

We live in a world of finite resources....The weak are damned to the flaws of human nature.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Feb 2015 1.36am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 21 Feb 15 10.47am

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Feb 2015 7.50pm

Quote susmik at 20 Feb 2015 7.38pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Feb 2015 4.43pm

Quote susmik at 20 Feb 2015 3.51pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Feb 2015 1.43pm

Why won't it happen?

Long range bombers is all they need....That's what they want and that's what Russia are providing.....Knock out that runway and we are fecked.

Complacent defence reviews assume far too much......You can't defend a nation's interests on positive assumptions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2015 1.44pm)

Firstly The bombers are very old stock (knackered)
and secondly the island has pretty modern and up to date anti aircraft weapons installed since the war in the 80's. Also the ground troops are not just 20 marines these days!!!


The bombers aren't knackered in terms of effectiveness. They can accommodate pinpoint precision guidance and operate at high altitude.

Anti aircraft isn't going to be effective against high level accurate bombing.

As for ground troops....without air cover they are sitting ducks.

Are you not forgetting about our own jet aircraft in the area?....the bombers would not stand a chance and be shot down before they got anywhere near....You really do under estimate our military capability in the area you really do.

I've already referred to the runway.

We have four planes.....This is twelve bombers.....Besides once the runway receives any hit all the planes are out.

Maybe you're just not thinking it through.


We could send a carrier force! Oh dam haven't got one now - but will have soon - dam - no bloody aircraft on it ! Well done DC

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 21 Feb 15 10.49am

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Feb 2015 8.41pm

Quote susmik at 20 Feb 2015 8.17pm

You surely do not know the area or the domain. I have served there and if you thought about it our aircraft are fast very fast and have up to date weapons that would out do any bombers that try to bomb the airfield. We are so well prepared this time that we should not worry about the islands. The Argies have had planes for years since the Falklands war and as old as the ones that Putin has given them....but they have not tried it yet as they know what we have in the area and will not risk it. The threats they give these days are idle threats and are only given to take the Argie populations mind of the way their finances and country are taking a dive due to the idiot woman in charge at the present time....Have you yourself ever really looked into the situation that now exists in the Falklands with regard to defences we have ??? You might be surprised if you did!


I think you're being massively complacent.

It doesn't matter how fast four planes are against twelve. All it requires is for one bomber to get through and more than that are likely in a simultaneous full on attack.

Also once that air field is damaged the number of troops we have there.....what is it...a thousand? That becomes irreverent once air cover is lost.

Once the air field is damaged we have lost the islands....With no means of controlling the air they could land many more thousands of troops than us and plus they may have old fighters and bombers but once that air field is gone they only need to engage outside of the range of anti aircraft guns and ensure the troops are landed......With no realistic hope of resupply..... modern era generals don't waste troops fighting battles with no hope of victory.

If Argentina want it enough....They have a good chance with these bombers.

Don't you honestly think that we have not got ourselves covered in that eventuality? We are not as stupid as you think we are. I base my facts on what I know and not what I think will happen. We are only a small military force in the area compared to the Argies but we are far superior in what we have with our modern weapons and ships that actually DO float around the area PLUS of course a submarine within distance of cover both for land and air attacks. As I said I have first hand experience of the islands and have marine mates who are serving out there at this present moment. I assure you that the Argies will NOT catch us by surprise.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Hoof Hearted 21 Feb 15 10.57am

This EU thing isn't going very well is it?

Inviting near bankrupt nations like Greece to join and then having to bail them out.

Inviting nations like Romania to join, whose inhabitants view that as an invitation to travel to London for benefits and prime pick pocket victims.

Then they court former Soviet block countries like the Ukraine to join and express surprise when Putin kicks off about it.

It will end in tears.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 11.05am

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 10.49am

Don't you honestly think that we have not got ourselves covered in that eventuality? We are not as stupid as you think we are. I base my facts on what I know and not what I think will happen. We are only a small military force in the area compared to the Argies but we are far superior in what we have with our modern weapons and ships that actually DO float around the area PLUS of course a submarine within distance of cover both for land and air attacks. As I said I have first hand experience of the islands and have marine mates who are serving out there at this present moment. I assure you that the Argies will NOT catch us by surprise.


Ok then, lets see which of us is right. as essentially If these bombers have been added you think the current defenses are adequate and I don't.

If we increase our forces in the area I'll be right and if forces are kept the same you will. I'll happy to watch the issue.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 11.06am

Quote rob1969 at 21 Feb 2015 10.47am

We could send a carrier force! Oh dam haven't got one now - but will have soon - dam - no bloody aircraft on it ! Well done DC

Yup....But I think that was originally Labour's cock up.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 21 Feb 15 11.12am

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 11.05am

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 10.49am

Don't you honestly think that we have not got ourselves covered in that eventuality? We are not as stupid as you think we are. I base my facts on what I know and not what I think will happen. We are only a small military force in the area compared to the Argies but we are far superior in what we have with our modern weapons and ships that actually DO float around the area PLUS of course a submarine within distance of cover both for land and air attacks. As I said I have first hand experience of the islands and have marine mates who are serving out there at this present moment. I assure you that the Argies will NOT catch us by surprise.


Ok then, lets see which of us is right. as essentially If these bombers have been added you think the current defenses are adequate and I don't.

If we increase our forces in the area I'll be right and if forces are kept the same you will. I'll happy to watch the issue.


I personally think you should apply for a job at the ministry of Defence as they have no doubt forgotten to think about the points you have noted in regard to our defences there. ????

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 11.46am

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 11.12am

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 11.05am

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 10.49am

Don't you honestly think that we have not got ourselves covered in that eventuality? We are not as stupid as you think we are. I base my facts on what I know and not what I think will happen. We are only a small military force in the area compared to the Argies but we are far superior in what we have with our modern weapons and ships that actually DO float around the area PLUS of course a submarine within distance of cover both for land and air attacks. As I said I have first hand experience of the islands and have marine mates who are serving out there at this present moment. I assure you that the Argies will NOT catch us by surprise.


Ok then, lets see which of us is right. as essentially If these bombers have been added you think the current defenses are adequate and I don't.

If we increase our forces in the area I'll be right and if forces are kept the same you will. I'll happy to watch the issue.


I personally think you should apply for a job at the ministry of Defence as they have no doubt forgotten to think about the points you have noted in regard to our defences there. ????


Actually according to reports things are under review.....Quite understandably.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 21 Feb 15 11.55am

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 11.46am

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 11.12am

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 11.05am

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 10.49am

Don't you honestly think that we have not got ourselves covered in that eventuality? We are not as stupid as you think we are. I base my facts on what I know and not what I think will happen. We are only a small military force in the area compared to the Argies but we are far superior in what we have with our modern weapons and ships that actually DO float around the area PLUS of course a submarine within distance of cover both for land and air attacks. As I said I have first hand experience of the islands and have marine mates who are serving out there at this present moment. I assure you that the Argies will NOT catch us by surprise.


Ok then, lets see which of us is right. as essentially If these bombers have been added you think the current defenses are adequate and I don't.

If we increase our forces in the area I'll be right and if forces are kept the same you will. I'll happy to watch the issue.


I personally think you should apply for a job at the ministry of Defence as they have no doubt forgotten to think about the points you have noted in regard to our defences there. ????


Actually according to reports things are under review.....Quite understandably.

They are done on a daily basis as they always have done!!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 21 Feb 15 1.37pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 11.06am

Quote rob1969 at 21 Feb 2015 10.47am

We could send a carrier force! Oh dam haven't got one now - but will have soon - dam - no bloody aircraft on it ! Well done DC

Yup....But I think that was originally Labour's cock up.

Maybe but continued and made worse over last five years by DC & co.

On the subject of defence.
The UK has since 1945 been seen by the US as its number one western military ally. However in recent years it apparent that the UK may still talk the talk but cannot match the words with capability. This was underlined to US by our inability to successfully operate independently in Afghanistan where on several occasion the US had to come to our support. The UK still has some of the best military manpower but in insufficient numbers to do the tasks still expected of them - and poorly /under equipped. Either we want to be among the 'big boys' in which case we must pay the realistic cost or accept that we are now only an average European power and be treated as such on the world stage. Might may not always be right but notice is still taken of those with the biggest stick.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 2.57pm

Quote rob1969 at 21 Feb 2015 1.37pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 11.06am

Quote rob1969 at 21 Feb 2015 10.47am

We could send a carrier force! Oh dam haven't got one now - but will have soon - dam - no bloody aircraft on it ! Well done DC

Yup....But I think that was originally Labour's cock up.

Maybe but continued and made worse over last five years by DC & co.

On the subject of defence.
The UK has since 1945 been seen by the US as its number one western military ally. However in recent years it apparent that the UK may still talk the talk but cannot match the words with capability. This was underlined to US by our inability to successfully operate independently in Afghanistan where on several occasion the US had to come to our support. The UK still has some of the best military manpower but in insufficient numbers to do the tasks still expected of them - and poorly /under equipped. Either we want to be among the 'big boys' in which case we must pay the realistic cost or accept that we are now only an average European power and be treated as such on the world stage. Might may not always be right but notice is still taken of those with the biggest stick.


I'm not sure how the Tories made the original cock up worse as contracts made things impossible really.

As for the rest I think you're spot on.

The defence cuts are not something I agree with.....These are political decisions, political choices.

I've no desire....unlike most of the noisy section of the left....for the UK to be considered as an average EU country.....I think the rush to irrelevance is motivated by a misplaced desire for egalitarianism in everything.

Whereas the reality of the world is that it is a dangerous place that holds with the bully's playground than it does with middle class etiquette.

Protect your interests and hence wealth or lose it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 21 Feb 15 3.42pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 2.57pm

Quote rob1969 at 21 Feb 2015 1.37pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 11.06am

Quote rob1969 at 21 Feb 2015 10.47am

We could send a carrier force! Oh dam haven't got one now - but will have soon - dam - no bloody aircraft on it ! Well done DC

Yup....But I think that was originally Labour's cock up.

Maybe but continued and made worse over last five years by DC & co.

On the subject of defence.
The UK has since 1945 been seen by the US as its number one western military ally. However in recent years it apparent that the UK may still talk the talk but cannot match the words with capability. This was underlined to US by our inability to successfully operate independently in Afghanistan where on several occasion the US had to come to our support. The UK still has some of the best military manpower but in insufficient numbers to do the tasks still expected of them - and poorly /under equipped. Either we want to be among the 'big boys' in which case we must pay the realistic cost or accept that we are now only an average European power and be treated as such on the world stage. Might may not always be right but notice is still taken of those with the biggest stick.


I'm not sure how the Tories made the original cock up worse as contracts made things impossible really.

As for the rest I think you're spot on.

The defence cuts are not something I agree with.....These are political decisions, political choices.

I've no desire....unlike most of the noisy section of the left....for the UK to be considered as an average EU country.....I think the rush to irrelevance is motivated by a misplaced desire for egalitarianism in everything.

Whereas the reality of the world is that it is a dangerous place that holds with the bully's playground than it does with middle class etiquette.

Protect your interests and hence wealth or lose it.


Mediocrity in all things !

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 5.36pm

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 11.55am


They are done on a daily basis as they always have done!!


Air Commodore Andrew Lambert, of the UK National Defence Association, said: “The Ministry of Defence should be worried.

'It always trots out the mantra of reviewing force levels but the only real solution is to deploy a sizeable force of Typhoons, at least a squadron, to buy us time to formulate a proper reinforcement package.'

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Feb 2015 5.37pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 21 Feb 15 7.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 5.36pm

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 11.55am


They are done on a daily basis as they always have done!!


Air Commodore Andrew Lambert, of the UK National Defence Association, said: “The Ministry of Defence should be worried.

'It always trots out the mantra of reviewing force levels but the only real solution is to deploy a sizeable force of Typhoons, at least a squadron, to buy us time to formulate a proper reinforcement package.'

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Feb 2015 5.37pm)


Review/reviewing = in government speak 'kicking into the long grass.' In other words excuse for doing nothing now!

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 21 Feb 15 8.12pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 5.36pm

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 11.55am


They are done on a daily basis as they always have done!!


Air Commodore Andrew Lambert, of the UK National Defence Association, said: “The Ministry of Defence should be worried.

'It always trots out the mantra of reviewing force levels but the only real solution is to deploy a sizeable force of Typhoons, at least a squadron, to buy us time to formulate a proper reinforcement package.'

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Feb 2015 5.37pm)


He retired from the RAF on 12 October 2003 so is only spouting his own ideas and not that of the present day MOD and I doubt he has access to any up to date military information. You have plucked him out from what he said some 12 or more years ago. Please do not make things sound as bad as you yourself think they are. Try and get some up to date information from somebody who is stationed there or who knows something concrete about the present situation. Not from newspapers and Google!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Feb 15 8.23pm

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 8.12pm


He retired from the RAF on 12 October 2003 so is only spouting his own ideas and not that of the present day MOD and I doubt he has access to any up to date military information. You have plucked him out from what he said some 12 or more years ago. Please do not make things sound as bad as you yourself think they are. Try and get some up to date information from somebody who is stationed there or who knows something concrete about the present situation. Not from newspapers and Google!

This man reached the height in his profession and these people don't leave and not maintain contacts.

It's ridiculous to imply that he doesn't know the defense capabilities of the Falklands or have a worthy opinion on it over a solider serving there.....or indeed you.

People in the MOD are restricted in what they can say so you implying that silence means that these opinions aren't held isn't realistic....Actions will tell us that.

Like I said, I will be happy for MOD actions over this latest development over this next year will prove which one of us is a right plonker.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Feb 15 8.44pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Feb 2015 8.23pm

Quote susmik at 21 Feb 2015 8.12pm


He retired from the RAF on 12 October 2003 so is only spouting his own ideas and not that of the present day MOD and I doubt he has access to any up to date military information. You have plucked him out from what he said some 12 or more years ago. Please do not make things sound as bad as you yourself think they are. Try and get some up to date information from somebody who is stationed there or who knows something concrete about the present situation. Not from newspapers and Google!

This man reached the height in his profession and these people don't leave and not maintain contacts.

It's ridiculous to imply that he doesn't know the defense capabilities of the Falklands or have a worthy opinion on it over a solider serving there.....or indeed you.

People in the MOD are restricted in what they can say so you implying that silence means that these opinions aren't held isn't realistic....Actions will tell us that.

Like I said, I will be happy for MOD actions over this latest development over this next year will prove which one of us is a right plonker.

Quite true, the only real solution the UK has presented in terms of military successes since the first gulf war, has been air campaigns, with 'logistical' ground support. Afghanistan and Iraq arguably have been failures, not necessarily for military reasons either. Politically, the UK lacks the real capacity to 'accept the necessary' that such conflicts require in order to achieve a chance of success (in terms of casualties, publicity and of course reprisals).

The fact is you can't win any war, if your population 'gets the jitters' at casualties in the hundreds.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Putin