You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Red Nose Day
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Red Nose Day


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Kermit8 Flag Hevon 14 Mar 15 10.10pm

10 million Congolese died under the boot of colonialism through punishing work, illness and neglect in order to make European men rich through plunder.

A fair part of Africa is fvcked up because the colonials fvcked it up before, during and the legacy of after.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Stirlingsays Flag 14 Mar 15 10.15pm

I am disgusted at the professionally offended left's claims that Phillip is a racist. I don't see any proof that he actually is. The reality is that he's a man who grew up in a very different world.

It's the usual slimy slurs by the usual suspects.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Mar 2015 10.15pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 14 Mar 15 10.33pm

Your posts have been very illuminating as to what you might consider not to be racist and inappropriate as a joke in 21st century Britain,but rather just good no problem old jokey banter.I respectfully disagree with you.

nb.Disagreeing with Stirling does not automatically make one "slimy.

What to you might be "slimy slurs" might to others rather perfectly describe some of Philip's highly intelligent and witty outbursts.

For a look at the man's full spectrum of funny jokey humour befitting a senior member of the ruling family,ambassador for Britain, and no doubt a clear indication of our civilised superiority compared to others

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (14 Mar 2015 10.35pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Mar 15 10.41pm

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 10.33pm

Your posts have been very illuminating as to what you might consider not to be racist and inappropriate as a joke in 21st century Britain,but rather just good no problem old jokey banter.I respectfully disagree with you.

nb.Disagreeing with Stirling does not automatically make one "slimy.

What to you might be "slimy slurs" might to others rather perfectly describe some of Philip's highly intelligent and witty outbursts.

For a look at the man's full spectrum of funny jokey humour befitting a senior member of the ruling family,ambassador for Britain, and no doubt a clear indication of our civilised superiority compared to others

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (14 Mar 2015 10.35pm)


Acutally legal....I quite like the idea that anyone disagreeing with me is automatically 'slimy'.

I think we might be onto something here.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Mar 15 11.07pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Mar 2015 10.15pm

I am disgusted at the professionally offended left's claims that Phillip is a racist. I don't see any proof that he actually is. The reality is that he's a man who grew up in a very different world.

It's the usual slimy slurs by the usual suspects.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Mar 2015 10.15pm)

There's no money in it innit!

Slimy slurs? I remember how offended you were when i stated that thatch was mates with Saville, which she was.
The husband of a world leader made xenophobic remarks, which, as the husband of a world leader, even if he thought those things, shouldn't say. You have defended him. Not painting yourself in a good light in my opinion.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 15 8.29am

Quote nickgusset at 14 Mar 2015 11.07pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Mar 2015 10.15pm

I am disgusted at the professionally offended left's claims that Phillip is a racist. I don't see any proof that he actually is. The reality is that he's a man who grew up in a very different world.

It's the usual slimy slurs by the usual suspects.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Mar 2015 10.15pm)

There's no money in it innit!

Slimy slurs? I remember how offended you were when i stated that thatch was mates with Saville, which she was.
The husband of a world leader made xenophobic remarks, which, as the husband of a world leader, even if he thought those things, shouldn't say. You have defended him. Not painting yourself in a good light in my opinion.

Phillip was being called a racist....That's what I regarded as going over the line.

Whether something said is xenophobic or not is a judgement for the individual...Being xenophobic is 'unreasonably fearful of or hating anyone or anything foreign or strange'. That's what you called him....I don't see Phillip as hating or scared of foreigners.

Considering the work that Phillip has and does do around the world working with foreigners, throughout his life, I think the usage of that word is too much.

Phillip is from a different era, which wasn't politically correct and he obviously doesn't fear making jokes about what he sees. I don't see anything malicious in any of them and it's only the lefty professionally offended who pick up on it.

Phillip is Greek in origin anyway......The whole charge is just silly.

Finger pointing at Phillip and crying racist is just immature in my view.


Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2015 9.51am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 15 8.32am

Quote nickgusset at 14 Mar 2015 11.07pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Mar 2015 10.15pm

I am disgusted at the professionally offended left's claims that Phillip is a racist. I don't see any proof that he actually is. The reality is that he's a man who grew up in a very different world.

It's the usual slimy slurs by the usual suspects.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Mar 2015 10.15pm)

There's no money in it innit!

Slimy slurs? I remember how offended you were when i stated that thatch was mates with Saville, which she was.
The husband of a world leader made xenophobic remarks, which, as the husband of a world leader, even if he thought those things, shouldn't say. You have defended him. Not painting yourself in a good light in my opinion.


'Slimy Nick'.....It has a good ring to it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 Mar 15 9.27am

Professionally offended? An amateur argument.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 15 Mar 15 9.48am

Quote MileFan at 14 Mar 2015 11.05am

Quote Mr Palaceman at 14 Mar 2015 5.43am

Quote MileFan at 13 Mar 2015 10.01pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Mar 2015 9.55pm

Quote MileFan at 13 Mar 2015 9.05pm

Quote lloydy at 13 Mar 2015 8.54pm

Quote MileFan at 13 Mar 2015 8.41pm

Quote lloydy at 13 Mar 2015 8.35pm

People trying to help,others,what a strange thing to get that annoyed about.


its annoying because we have people suffering right here in the UK and we send millions to be pissed up the wall in Africa


It's called humanity,they help people here and elsewhere around the world.our local children's hospice benefits from iit as well as people in Africa to piss up the wall.

30 years ago africa was a hellhole now its still a hellhole, why do we bother?


I'm no egalitarian but I do believe it's the right principle for comparatively wealthy humanity to extend help where it can to those born into 'hellholes'.

In real terms we give very little.

We spend far far more on our own underclass....And so we should.....But it's wrong to say we shouldn't help fellow countries.....That's just humanity.

if they want real help bend over and let whites rule, call me racist but blacks always f*ck it up. You just have to look at South Africa. Mandela hailed a hero but since he took ovr crime up economy down etc etc.


Sorry but I had to reply to this post again, as I think for myself and many others on here, your post may just be the gift that keeps on giving and should be a possible contender for the Gold section of this forum.

The funny thing is that I don't think that you are actually being abusive with this post. Ignorant maybe but not abusive.

You haven't called anyone any names but what you are saying is essenstailly that if black people always "f@ck everything up" then really, it would make sense to you that black people should have no right to self determination. Black people should not vote or hold postitons of power, as "blacks always f@ck everything up". It should be left to white people and black people should "bend over" and take what is given to them, by I assume, people like yourself..

I wonder how your comments would sit with say, Bolasie or Zaha knowing that you sit in the stands or even Mark Wright, Salako or maybe Puncheon (who apparently doesn't like to talk to people while he is eating).

I could mention Obama, Martin Luther King, Oprah, Denzil Washington, Muhammed Ali, Bob Marley, Kofi Annan, Pele, Maya Angelou, all from very different walks of life who according to you would just "f@ck everything up".

Then you mention Nelson Mandela (and I wasn't a huge fan myself) but someone who undoubtly has inspired millions of people in his home and around the world.

You point to the South African economy, do you not understand that people do not love the memory of that man the world over because of his economic skill, they love him because of his unselfish stand for the principle of his peoples right to decide their own future.

If you put Mandela next to Cameron, Miliband, Klegg or Farage, they would all just blend into the shadows of nothingness compared to him. Such is the state of our politians today.

They will all be long forgotten in just a few decades, remembered only as a list of names, buried in a Wiki article.

Only Thatcher, (and again I am no fan) in our recent history will get a mention just because she was such a divisive figure in our history and even then only in our history.

Who else of his type could really be held up in history along with him (love him or hate him). Martin Luther King, Ghandi and I'm only talking from a historical view as opposed to a personal view about the man.

The reason I mention these three is that they all changed their countries and the worlds culture and enviroment beyond measure but according to you would just "f@ck everything up" and in truth, maybe they did for people with your views.

I for one am glad they did, I thank them and I'm sure that for a long, long time to come, many others will also. Black and white.

I hope you don't get red carded, because although I think your views, IMO, are silly, absurd, ignorant, I could go on, at least your views are known and can be challenged.

Edited by Mr Palaceman (14 Mar 2015 5.46am)

of course you can quote individual examples but as a society as a whole blacks tend to f*ck it up, I 100% stand by that comment.

What a poor response to my post. You didn't address it at all.

You gave the example of South Africa, I replied.

You have singled out black society as a whole, unlike white society? So you are a white supremacist? Please clarify.

There is something else that I noticed about you post.

You stated that blacks should "bend over and let whites rule"

From a psychological point of view, by using those terms, you are talking about the submission and humiliation of black people. They should bend over, submit, allow. You also state this as a precondition to receiving help. "..if they want real help bend over and let whites rule..". I assume this help should come from the likes of you.

You seem to have a deep seated desire to control and dominate, hence the "bend over" terminoligy.

These types of feelings have their root in lack of understanding and fear. You should really try and think about what you post.

None the less, I would still like you to clarify your "Black society" comment.


Edited by Mr Palaceman (15 Mar 2015 9.49am)

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 15 9.49am


Quote nickgusset at 15 Mar 2015 9.27am

Professionally offended? An amateur argument.

As for being an amateur....I like what you did there.....Whatever became of 'amateur wives'?

Those were the days.....Non stick magazines....Professionally non stick.

Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2015 9.57am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Hoof Hearted 15 Mar 15 10.20am

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 10.01pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 9.39pm

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 9.32pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 9.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 11.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 10.40am

You just have to look at places like Zimbabwe.

When it was colonial Rhodesia it prospered by exporting copper and had a great railway system.

Now the railway is fcuked both financially and physically and only survives on handouts from China (in return for the major slice of the copper no doubt).

It may have been un PC by the poster to suggest "blacks" always fcuk up... but the state of Africa kind of backs this statement up unfortunately... corruption, greed, incompetence..... -.-'


Um Hoof,two points (only two because the proposition that black people screw up as a result of being black whereas white people don't since they are white,advanced on his thread,is too too insane to get further engaged with).

1.The copper was/is in the British colony of Northern Rhodesia now known as Zambia,as opposed to the British territory of Southern Rhodesia now known as Zimbabwe,so at least try to have a basic grasp of facts if you are going to advance an argument tending towards a proposition of inherent racial inferiority.

2.Take a look at places like Moldova,Uzbekistan. Note the health of the economies,their corruption etc,the extent to which their rulers f-up. and then take a look at the colour of the skin of the people that rule in those states.Poverty,corruption and repression do not stem from skin colour/race.The logic of your proposition is that we shouldn't vote for black politicians here due to inherent racial lesser ability to "govern" than those of a superior at governing white race.We are indeed headed back to the dark ages (no pun intended).


Edited by legaleagle (14 Mar 2015 4.45pm)


Zambia/Zimbabwe........ North/South Rhodesia....

Makes little difference - it was an example of a major fcuk up that wouldn't have occurred under colonial rule.

I don't think all black people are inferior but in Africa there are a lot of greedy/corrupt/incompetent people (who just happen to be black) now running most countries and sadly running them into the ground.

The worst of the lot is Mugabe.

As for your last point I'd rather vote for that Chukka fella than Balls/Miliband or Prescott.

But he's had the benefit of our education system.

Yup,makes little difference.They all look the same anyway,don't they, so no need to actually know the difference between one country and another.

You are right,"we" didn't f-up under colonial rule in Central and Southern Africa at all.Everything ran perfectly for the rulers and we did very nicely indeed out of it and made a mint and lived in the lap of luxury there.Don't you worry about the majority in Northern and Southern Rhodesia,whose lot was somewhat worse then than now. Read up about it sometime. Who needed corruption to obtain access to wealth and power when we just lauded it and banned any access to it for them full stop?


Do you think they are better off now legal?

There seems to be more poverty, more in-fighting, more famine etc to me.

I don't disagree that GB benefitted immensely from the colonies, but there was order rather than chaos.

Hoof,for what its worth my MA research was into the Central African Federation in the 1950's,which was comprised of Northern Rhodesia,Southern Rhodesia and Nyasaland (now Malawi). The lot of the average person was sh1t. IMO they were somewhat worse off than now and there weren't tv crews then filming a lot reporting things or the internet so it was a pretty isolated part of the world.When push came to shove back in Whitehall the "interests"of the settler always trumped those of the locals,including economically.

There was "order" for the rulers and an appearance of order overall looking from outside since it appeared that way to many here. On the ground,the locals were basically in general terms exploited and shafted something rotten,so "we" set a good example for people to follow...For a local on the ground,I suspect life was viewed as tending more towards the "chaos" end of the spectrum than the "order" end.

I'm being simplistic I know,but life can seem very ordered when the Master and Mistress know their place,as do the cook,maids,houseboys and gardner, especially when there's an iron fist available to back up the velvet glove any time anyone steps out of place and built in legal discrimination to make sure the locals don't get too uppity.Bit like feudalism was here and the deep South in the USA. Lots of poverty in the Southern USA today,but would many say they were better off then...

Edited by legaleagle (14 Mar 2015 10.19pm)

Interesting... you've sort of tried to "top trump me" with your MA studies...LOL

I still feel the way I do though.

I remember the time when the white farmers were driven out of their homes/farms to be taken over by the black farm workers and that wasn't good.

They slaughtered the dairy herd for a quick steak dinner, then didn't utilise the expertise shown to them for decades... animal husbandry, crop efficiency etc... most farms failed and then the famine started.

The likes of Robert Mugabe were allowed to flourish backed by vicious gangs and corrupt officials.

I'm not buying that they were worse off before liberation.

Most of the aid we send ends up as Private Jets, Limousines and flash Palaces sadly.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 15 10.27am

Quote becky at 14 Mar 2015 9.24pm

CEO's salaries.....

Save the Children £163K; British Red Cross £184K; Christian Aid £126K; Oxfam £119K...... bloody expensive all this 'goodwill' isn't it ....


Yeah it is....It should be slimmed down.

Still, it isn't the CEO manning the coin collection boxes.

Charities are manned by countless men and women across the country for free.

Bloody heroes the lot of them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

imbored Flag UK 15 Mar 15 10.27am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 10.40am

You just have to look at places like Zimbabwe.

When it was colonial Rhodesia it prospered by exporting copper and had a great railway system.

Now the railway is fcuked both financially and physically and only survives on handouts from China (in return for the major slice of the copper no doubt).

It may have been un PC by the poster to suggest "blacks" always fcuk up... but the state of Africa kind of backs this statement up unfortunately... corruption, greed, incompetence..... -.-'


Do you view that your black friends in the UK are consumed by corruption, greed and incompetence too? if not, then it isn't an issue of skin colour is it?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 15 10.33am

Skin colour has nothing to do with IQ or the ability to run things successfully.....Which is tantamount to the same thing.

Probably the smartest student I teach at the moment is black and the school is mainly white.....Fine brain he has.

I do agree that different cultures teach different priorities and from a human progression point of view are definitely not equal in worth.

But it's nothing to do with skin colour.

Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2015 10.34am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

imbored Flag UK 15 Mar 15 10.37am

Quote Stirlingsays at 15 Mar 2015 10.33am

Skin colour has nothing to do with IQ or the ability to run things successfully.....Which is tantamount to the same thing.

Probably the smartest student I teach at the moment is black and the school is mainly white.....Fine brain he has.

I do agree that different cultures teach different priorities and from a human progression point of view are definitely not equal in worth.

But it's nothing to do with skin colour.

Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2015 10.34am)


Yes, that's it, these are cultural issues. I can't fathom how anyone can seriously believe that there's legitimacy in lumping all of this stuff on skin pigment.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 Mar 15 10.41am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 15 Mar 2015 10.20am

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 10.01pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 9.39pm

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 9.32pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 9.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 11.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 10.40am

You just have to look at places like Zimbabwe.

When it was colonial Rhodesia it prospered by exporting copper and had a great railway system.

Now the railway is fcuked both financially and physically and only survives on handouts from China (in return for the major slice of the copper no doubt).

It may have been un PC by the poster to suggest "blacks" always fcuk up... but the state of Africa kind of backs this statement up unfortunately... corruption, greed, incompetence..... -.-'


Um Hoof,two points (only two because the proposition that black people screw up as a result of being black whereas white people don't since they are white,advanced on his thread,is too too insane to get further engaged with).

1.The copper was/is in the British colony of Northern Rhodesia now known as Zambia,as opposed to the British territory of Southern Rhodesia now known as Zimbabwe,so at least try to have a basic grasp of facts if you are going to advance an argument tending towards a proposition of inherent racial inferiority.

2.Take a look at places like Moldova,Uzbekistan. Note the health of the economies,their corruption etc,the extent to which their rulers f-up. and then take a look at the colour of the skin of the people that rule in those states.Poverty,corruption and repression do not stem from skin colour/race.The logic of your proposition is that we shouldn't vote for black politicians here due to inherent racial lesser ability to "govern" than those of a superior at governing white race.We are indeed headed back to the dark ages (no pun intended).


Edited by legaleagle (14 Mar 2015 4.45pm)


Zambia/Zimbabwe........ North/South Rhodesia....

Makes little difference - it was an example of a major fcuk up that wouldn't have occurred under colonial rule.

I don't think all black people are inferior but in Africa there are a lot of greedy/corrupt/incompetent people (who just happen to be black) now running most countries and sadly running them into the ground.

The worst of the lot is Mugabe.

As for your last point I'd rather vote for that Chukka fella than Balls/Miliband or Prescott.

But he's had the benefit of our education system.

Yup,makes little difference.They all look the same anyway,don't they, so no need to actually know the difference between one country and another.

You are right,"we" didn't f-up under colonial rule in Central and Southern Africa at all.Everything ran perfectly for the rulers and we did very nicely indeed out of it and made a mint and lived in the lap of luxury there.Don't you worry about the majority in Northern and Southern Rhodesia,whose lot was somewhat worse then than now. Read up about it sometime. Who needed corruption to obtain access to wealth and power when we just lauded it and banned any access to it for them full stop?


Do you think they are better off now legal?

There seems to be more poverty, more in-fighting, more famine etc to me.

I don't disagree that GB benefitted immensely from the colonies, but there was order rather than chaos.

Hoof,for what its worth my MA research was into the Central African Federation in the 1950's,which was comprised of Northern Rhodesia,Southern Rhodesia and Nyasaland (now Malawi). The lot of the average person was sh1t. IMO they were somewhat worse off than now and there weren't tv crews then filming a lot reporting things or the internet so it was a pretty isolated part of the world.When push came to shove back in Whitehall the "interests"of the settler always trumped those of the locals,including economically.

There was "order" for the rulers and an appearance of order overall looking from outside since it appeared that way to many here. On the ground,the locals were basically in general terms exploited and shafted something rotten,so "we" set a good example for people to follow...For a local on the ground,I suspect life was viewed as tending more towards the "chaos" end of the spectrum than the "order" end.

I'm being simplistic I know,but life can seem very ordered when the Master and Mistress know their place,as do the cook,maids,houseboys and gardner, especially when there's an iron fist available to back up the velvet glove any time anyone steps out of place and built in legal discrimination to make sure the locals don't get too uppity.Bit like feudalism was here and the deep South in the USA. Lots of poverty in the Southern USA today,but would many say they were better off then...

Edited by legaleagle (14 Mar 2015 10.19pm)

Interesting... you've sort of tried to "top trump me" with your MA studies...LOL

I still feel the way I do though.

I remember the time when the white farmers were driven out of their homes/farms to be taken over by the black farm workers and that wasn't good.

They slaughtered the dairy herd for a quick steak dinner, then didn't utilise the expertise shown to them for decades... animal husbandry, crop efficiency etc... most farms failed and then the famine started.

The likes of Robert Mugabe were allowed to flourish backed by vicious gangs and corrupt officials.

I'm not buying that they were worse off before liberation.

Most of the aid we send ends up as Private Jets, Limousines and flash Palaces sadly.

Ace trumps were betterer than Top Trumps

 

Hoof Hearted 15 Mar 15 10.43am

Quote imbored at 15 Mar 2015 10.27am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 10.40am

You just have to look at places like Zimbabwe.

When it was colonial Rhodesia it prospered by exporting copper and had a great railway system.

Now the railway is fcuked both financially and physically and only survives on handouts from China (in return for the major slice of the copper no doubt).

It may have been un PC by the poster to suggest "blacks" always fcuk up... but the state of Africa kind of backs this statement up unfortunately... corruption, greed, incompetence..... -.-'


Do you view that your black friends in the UK are consumed by corruption, greed and incompetence too? if not, then it isn't an issue of skin colour is it?


I wonder about Diane Abbott obviously.... but no, it is about education, or lack of it.

That wasn't my best post as I failed to distance myself from an assumption that all black people are those things, which clearly they are not and I apologise for that.

 

imbored Flag UK 15 Mar 15 10.48am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 15 Mar 2015 10.43am

Quote imbored at 15 Mar 2015 10.27am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 10.40am

You just have to look at places like Zimbabwe.

When it was colonial Rhodesia it prospered by exporting copper and had a great railway system.

Now the railway is fcuked both financially and physically and only survives on handouts from China (in return for the major slice of the copper no doubt).

It may have been un PC by the poster to suggest "blacks" always fcuk up... but the state of Africa kind of backs this statement up unfortunately... corruption, greed, incompetence..... -.-'


Do you view that your black friends in the UK are consumed by corruption, greed and incompetence too? if not, then it isn't an issue of skin colour is it?


I wonder about Diane Abbott obviously.... but no, it is about education, or lack of it.

That wasn't my best post as I failed to distance myself from an assumption that all black people are those things, which clearly they are not and I apologise for that.


That's fair enough .

I think the guy posting the original comment is on some kind of wind up. I would hope he doesn't really believe what he's saying.


Edited by imbored (15 Mar 2015 10.49am)

 

legaleagle Flag 15 Mar 15 11.19am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 15 Mar 2015 10.20am

Interesting... you've sort of tried to "top trump me" with your MA studies...LOL

I still feel the way I do though.

I remember the time when the white farmers were driven out of their homes/farms to be taken over by the black farm workers and that wasn't good.

They slaughtered the dairy herd for a quick steak dinner, then didn't utilise the expertise shown to them for decades... animal husbandry, crop efficiency etc... most farms failed and then the famine started.

The likes of Robert Mugabe were allowed to flourish backed by vicious gangs and corrupt officials.

I'm not buying that they were worse off before liberation.

Most of the aid we send ends up as Private Jets, Limousines and flash Palaces sadly.


Yes,I thought about whether I should mention the MA studies since it would just be seen as trying to trump you. But, what is a constant in your posts is your lack of knowledge of the situation of the locals under settler rule in Southern Rhodesia under our "benign" watch.. So, all you do is look at bad things happening now,and contrast them with your general view of "order" under British rule and conclude the locals must be worse off than they were.

I can't and don't defend Mugabe or his henchpeople and support the struggle of the Movement for Democratic Change.But that is a struggle by a populace against repression,just like in Belarus,or Uzbekistan or in Poland pre-1990.What it is emphatically not is a struggle against "black rule" of the country, a consequence of blacks ruling rather than whites,or an example of innate white superiority.

But,just to take the topic of land...how exactly did the white farmers get this land,Hoof? Did they visit the estate agent,make an offer and pay market rate in an "ordered" way?.No,the settlers simply threw the locals off all the best land whether they wanted to move or not,with no compensation,and introduced a legal system giving them "ownership" of it."We" set a great example...just like we did with our introduction of detention without trial because people called for democracy.

As a result of this "stitch up",the land allocated to black people was not only the "worst"land in agriculturally but as of 1969 had a population density of 67 people per sq mile,whereas the white reserved land had a density of 3 people per square mile. It is hopeless to try to evaluate anything that happened about land post independence unless you are aware of what "we" created and the legacy left.

It was overall certainly worse than what happened when some white farmers were thrown off.

As for the "aid" going to the elite,contrast this with almost all the "aid" going to the old elite,the settlers resulting in "limousines" and "flash palaces".;it was worse then in terms of "trickle down".

If we just look at education as an example.

1930:compulsory education for whites.By 1975,education for blacks still not compulsory.In 1964,only 64% of blacks of the relevant age group went to primary school.

As of 1971 the average educational spend per black kid was £16.60 whereas it was £160.70 for each white kid.

Nowadays,Zimbabwe has one of the best adult literacy rates in Africa.

Would the locals think educational opportunity,for all the current economic woes, was better or worse now?Would the locals in Zimbabwe like to bring back the "good old days"? I doubt it.


Edited by legaleagle (15 Mar 2015 11.55am)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 15 Mar 15 5.07pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 Mar 2015 11.19am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 15 Mar 2015 10.20am

Interesting... you've sort of tried to "top trump me" with your MA studies...LOL

I still feel the way I do though.

I remember the time when the white farmers were driven out of their homes/farms to be taken over by the black farm workers and that wasn't good.

They slaughtered the dairy herd for a quick steak dinner, then didn't utilise the expertise shown to them for decades... animal husbandry, crop efficiency etc... most farms failed and then the famine started.

The likes of Robert Mugabe were allowed to flourish backed by vicious gangs and corrupt officials.

I'm not buying that they were worse off before liberation.

Most of the aid we send ends up as Private Jets, Limousines and flash Palaces sadly.


Yes,I thought about whether I should mention the MA studies since it would just be seen as trying to trump you. But, what is a constant in your posts is your lack of knowledge of the situation of the locals under settler rule in Southern Rhodesia under our "benign" watch.. So, all you do is look at bad things happening now,and contrast them with your general view of "order" under British rule and conclude the locals must be worse off than they were.

I can't and don't defend Mugabe or his henchpeople and support the struggle of the Movement for Democratic Change.But that is a struggle by a populace against repression,just like in Belarus,or Uzbekistan or in Poland pre-1990.What it is emphatically not is a struggle against "black rule" of the country, a consequence of blacks ruling rather than whites,or an example of innate white superiority.

But,just to take the topic of land...how exactly did the white farmers get this land,Hoof? Did they visit the estate agent,make an offer and pay market rate in an "ordered" way?.No,the settlers simply threw the locals off all the best land whether they wanted to move or not,with no compensation,and introduced a legal system giving them "ownership" of it."We" set a great example...just like we did with our introduction of detention without trial because people called for democracy.

As a result of this "stitch up",the land allocated to black people was not only the "worst"land in agriculturally but as of 1969 had a population density of 67 people per sq mile,whereas the white reserved land had a density of 3 people per square mile. It is hopeless to try to evaluate anything that happened about land post independence unless you are aware of what "we" created and the legacy left.

It was overall certainly worse than what happened when some white farmers were thrown off.

As for the "aid" going to the elite,contrast this with almost all the "aid" going to the old elite,the settlers resulting in "limousines" and "flash palaces".;it was worse then in terms of "trickle down".

If we just look at education as an example.

1930:compulsory education for whites.By 1975,education for blacks still not compulsory.In 1964,only 64% of blacks of the relevant age group went to primary school.

As of 1971 the average educational spend per black kid was £16.60 whereas it was £160.70 for each white kid.

Nowadays,Zimbabwe has one of the best adult literacy rates in Africa.

Would the locals think educational opportunity,for all the current economic woes, was better or worse now?Would the locals in Zimbabwe like to bring back the "good old days"? I doubt it.


Edited by legaleagle (15 Mar 2015 11.55am)


May I play Devils Advocate and ask what is the point of having the best literacy rate in Africa if your country is one of te most corrupt places on Earth, where ownership of property is dictated by the whim of the ruling junta and where said activities have driven the economy and society into the ground?

I don't support minority rule in any country. However, i support the concept of a meritocracy and blaming all the woes of a country or people on colonialism seems to be a kop out. Look at Singapore? They have been independent as long as many African States and have created wealth, employment and a system that rejects corruption. You seem to blame everything on whitey. Why do you do that when there are credible examples of former colonies throwing off the yoke of oppression and embracing change? Zimbabwe hasn't and won't until it faces some brutal, home truths.

Edited by matt_himself (15 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Red Nose Day