You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Victorian poverty
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Victorian poverty


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Apr 15 3.42pm

Also Victorian Poverty might be overstating the case, given that meant a realistic chance of death, prostitution, the workhouse etc.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 07 Apr 15 3.42pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 3.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 2.12pm

Quote elgrande at 07 Apr 2015 2.09pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 10.41am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 9.54am

Quote Pawson Palace at 07 Apr 2015 9.19am

Simple solution.

Scrap cash benefits for energy, food and clothing vouchers.

No excuses then.

To an extent, but then you need to introduce a system by which they are refunded at point of use, and a system to prevent them being sold for cash on a black market that will florish (because invariably a voucher system can't compensate for the fluxtuation in expenditure for example sometimes you need more for clothes).

Plus, occassionally there is money required for other things, such as travel, public transport use, books, car maintenance and other products of life (mobile phone, internet etc).

As such vouchers represent a problem in that they lack a flexibility of cash.

Now I know that other people will disagree about mobile phone and internet etc - but if you want people to find work, these are pretty much essential tools in the modern age. Also things like access to books really make a difference in the prospects of kids in improving their future chances

I've always believed that engery supply like water, should be 'free' to the consumer, to an extent and recovered through taxation.

Some good points Jaimie but why does the solution to poverty always = more money?

As I mentioned at the beginning of the thread, a lot is to do with life skills. The ability to cook from scratch, repair clothes and yes learn to read / write and use a computer. I would much rather see money invested in this than just throwing money at people and not solving the problem.

so right on those points,kids having kids having kids,nothing is taught to the next generation.
Simply because they have not been shown or taught themselves.


I take it you're an expert in haberdashery then?

I'm from an OK background and can't sew a button nor can I do pretty much most DIY stuff around the house and that has nothing to do with (a lack of) wealth

I can just about, because my dad was good at the DIY stuff and I had to do needlework in school (I'm s**t at sowing, but I can just about thread a needle, stitch on a button etc). My poor DIY knowledge is supplimented by Google and a decent book on DIY my dad gave me.

But I also understand that a lot of people don't have access to certain skills, because they've never had an opportunity to learn them or inherit them from their parents or wider family - and without access to those skills their capacity to 'resolve an issue without wealth' is difficult (thanks to Google I can wire a plug with confidence, change fuses etc).

But its pot luck. Other people in my family are at a loss for DIY etc, and consequently they'd have to pay other people to do it, which is where the wealth factor kicks in (because the general rule of life is either you do it, or pay someone else to do it).


If a poor person could do all the things that people who can't do them pay for, they probably wouldn't be as poor. They would hopefully be getting paid do it all as odd job men/women

I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?

We have infinitely more things in the house that can break than say 30 years or even 20 years ago. Knowing how to sew or change a plug won't help them if the car breaks down or the boiler goes. 10 pairs of socks are a about quid in Primark - I really don't think they are the issue

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 3.45pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 Apr 15 3.51pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 3.42pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 3.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 2.12pm

Quote elgrande at 07 Apr 2015 2.09pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 10.41am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 9.54am

Quote Pawson Palace at 07 Apr 2015 9.19am

Simple solution.

Scrap cash benefits for energy, food and clothing vouchers.

No excuses then.

To an extent, but then you need to introduce a system by which they are refunded at point of use, and a system to prevent them being sold for cash on a black market that will florish (because invariably a voucher system can't compensate for the fluxtuation in expenditure for example sometimes you need more for clothes).

Plus, occassionally there is money required for other things, such as travel, public transport use, books, car maintenance and other products of life (mobile phone, internet etc).

As such vouchers represent a problem in that they lack a flexibility of cash.

Now I know that other people will disagree about mobile phone and internet etc - but if you want people to find work, these are pretty much essential tools in the modern age. Also things like access to books really make a difference in the prospects of kids in improving their future chances

I've always believed that engery supply like water, should be 'free' to the consumer, to an extent and recovered through taxation.

Some good points Jaimie but why does the solution to poverty always = more money?

As I mentioned at the beginning of the thread, a lot is to do with life skills. The ability to cook from scratch, repair clothes and yes learn to read / write and use a computer. I would much rather see money invested in this than just throwing money at people and not solving the problem.

so right on those points,kids having kids having kids,nothing is taught to the next generation.
Simply because they have not been shown or taught themselves.


I take it you're an expert in haberdashery then?

I'm from an OK background and can't sew a button nor can I do pretty much most DIY stuff around the house and that has nothing to do with (a lack of) wealth

I can just about, because my dad was good at the DIY stuff and I had to do needlework in school (I'm s**t at sowing, but I can just about thread a needle, stitch on a button etc). My poor DIY knowledge is supplimented by Google and a decent book on DIY my dad gave me.

But I also understand that a lot of people don't have access to certain skills, because they've never had an opportunity to learn them or inherit them from their parents or wider family - and without access to those skills their capacity to 'resolve an issue without wealth' is difficult (thanks to Google I can wire a plug with confidence, change fuses etc).

But its pot luck. Other people in my family are at a loss for DIY etc, and consequently they'd have to pay other people to do it, which is where the wealth factor kicks in (because the general rule of life is either you do it, or pay someone else to do it).


If a poor person could do all the things that people who can't do them pay for, they probably wouldn't be as poor. They would hopefully be getting paid do it all as odd job men/women

I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?

We have infinitely more things in the house that can break than say 30 years or even 20 years ago. Knowing how to sew or change a plug won't help them if the car breaks down or the boiler goes. 10 pairs of socks are a about quid in Primark - I really don't think they are the issue

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 3.45pm)

You are either missing the point or being deliberately obtuse.

1) If they are that poor then actually £1 is a lot and the Primark mentality is part of the problem.

2) We can't keep throwing money at the problem. Whether it is anybody's fault is irrelevant, life skills need to improve, particularly for the poor who in the main tend to be less well educated and will earn less.

3) the more wealthy you are, the more disposable income you have. How you spend it is up to you. Want to get a decorator in, then you do. cant afford it? then you do it yourself. Or do you think that the state should pay for that because as you said, where do you draw the line?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stuk Flag Top half 07 Apr 15 3.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 3.42pm

Also Victorian Poverty might be overstating the case, given that meant a realistic chance of death, prostitution, the workhouse etc.


Too kind. It shows them to be f***ing thick as I stated earlier.

 


Optimistic as ever

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 07 Apr 15 4.03pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 3.51pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 3.42pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 3.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 2.12pm

Quote elgrande at 07 Apr 2015 2.09pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 10.41am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 9.54am

Quote Pawson Palace at 07 Apr 2015 9.19am

Simple solution.

Scrap cash benefits for energy, food and clothing vouchers.

No excuses then.

To an extent, but then you need to introduce a system by which they are refunded at point of use, and a system to prevent them being sold for cash on a black market that will florish (because invariably a voucher system can't compensate for the fluxtuation in expenditure for example sometimes you need more for clothes).

Plus, occassionally there is money required for other things, such as travel, public transport use, books, car maintenance and other products of life (mobile phone, internet etc).

As such vouchers represent a problem in that they lack a flexibility of cash.

Now I know that other people will disagree about mobile phone and internet etc - but if you want people to find work, these are pretty much essential tools in the modern age. Also things like access to books really make a difference in the prospects of kids in improving their future chances

I've always believed that engery supply like water, should be 'free' to the consumer, to an extent and recovered through taxation.

Some good points Jaimie but why does the solution to poverty always = more money?

As I mentioned at the beginning of the thread, a lot is to do with life skills. The ability to cook from scratch, repair clothes and yes learn to read / write and use a computer. I would much rather see money invested in this than just throwing money at people and not solving the problem.

so right on those points,kids having kids having kids,nothing is taught to the next generation.
Simply because they have not been shown or taught themselves.


I take it you're an expert in haberdashery then?

I'm from an OK background and can't sew a button nor can I do pretty much most DIY stuff around the house and that has nothing to do with (a lack of) wealth

I can just about, because my dad was good at the DIY stuff and I had to do needlework in school (I'm s**t at sowing, but I can just about thread a needle, stitch on a button etc). My poor DIY knowledge is supplimented by Google and a decent book on DIY my dad gave me.

But I also understand that a lot of people don't have access to certain skills, because they've never had an opportunity to learn them or inherit them from their parents or wider family - and without access to those skills their capacity to 'resolve an issue without wealth' is difficult (thanks to Google I can wire a plug with confidence, change fuses etc).

But its pot luck. Other people in my family are at a loss for DIY etc, and consequently they'd have to pay other people to do it, which is where the wealth factor kicks in (because the general rule of life is either you do it, or pay someone else to do it).


If a poor person could do all the things that people who can't do them pay for, they probably wouldn't be as poor. They would hopefully be getting paid do it all as odd job men/women

I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?

We have infinitely more things in the house that can break than say 30 years or even 20 years ago. Knowing how to sew or change a plug won't help them if the car breaks down or the boiler goes. 10 pairs of socks are a about quid in Primark - I really don't think they are the issue

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 3.45pm)

You are either missing the point or being deliberately obtuse.

1) If they are that poor then actually £1 is a lot and the Primark mentality is part of the problem.

2) We can't keep throwing money at the problem. Whether it is anybody's fault is irrelevant, life skills need to improve, particularly for the poor who in the main tend to be less well educated and will earn less.

3) the more wealthy you are, the more disposable income you have. How you spend it is up to you. Want to get a decorator in, then you do. cant afford it? then you do it yourself. Or do you think that the state should pay for that because as you said, where do you draw the line?

Yeah I think it's you that is missing the point.

Life skills will only get you so far and will only substitute some of the cost of living life. There are a million things that can break or need replacing in ones life and you cannot expect people to know how to fix them all because they are poor. Being poor might mean them working 12 hour days just to put food on the table - when do you suggest they get down the local carpentry college to brush up? Your suggestion gets to only part of the problem.

Also, well done on chucking a massive strawman in there though. As if I mentioned anything about them getting free decorating.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 4.03pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Apr 15 4.12pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 3.42pm

If a poor person could do all the things that people who can't do them pay for, they probably wouldn't be as poor. They would hopefully be getting paid do it all as odd job men/women

I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?

We have infinitely more things in the house that can break than say 30 years or even 20 years ago. Knowing how to sew or change a plug won't help them if the car breaks down or the boiler goes. 10 pairs of socks are a about quid in Primark - I really don't think they are the issue

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 3.45pm)

Thing is though, 20-30 years ago, the working class was largely comprised of semi and skilled workers, many of who had the capacity to either work extra shifts or do a bit of 'private work' on the side.

The modern era, post industrialism, sees a society where in the working class is typically defined by minimum wage, minimal options for overtime and working in low to no skilled work, and as such closer to the underclass of yester year (who were probably better off given the options for labouring work and farm work).

It also has seen a dearth of skill training in the lower and middle working classes. People don't have the kind of skill thats 'transferable' outside of their occupation.

Low to no skill work, has become somewhat scarce and the wages uncompetative due to changes in working practices and law. My grandfather and Uncle provided a decent living for a wife and three kids working in the Post Office, because the contracts they were employed on provided a reasonable wage and reasonable capacity to earn more from extra shifts. Neither were 'steller' career people or managers etc.

Both owned their own home, and whilst not having extravgent lives, pursed hobbies and interests on disposable income.

Now days, if you worked in a similar role, you'd be lucky to earn enough for one person to live reasonably on.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (07 Apr 2015 4.14pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 Apr 15 4.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 4.03pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 3.51pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 3.42pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 3.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 2.12pm

Quote elgrande at 07 Apr 2015 2.09pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 10.41am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 9.54am

Quote Pawson Palace at 07 Apr 2015 9.19am

Simple solution.

Scrap cash benefits for energy, food and clothing vouchers.

No excuses then.

To an extent, but then you need to introduce a system by which they are refunded at point of use, and a system to prevent them being sold for cash on a black market that will florish (because invariably a voucher system can't compensate for the fluxtuation in expenditure for example sometimes you need more for clothes).

Plus, occassionally there is money required for other things, such as travel, public transport use, books, car maintenance and other products of life (mobile phone, internet etc).

As such vouchers represent a problem in that they lack a flexibility of cash.

Now I know that other people will disagree about mobile phone and internet etc - but if you want people to find work, these are pretty much essential tools in the modern age. Also things like access to books really make a difference in the prospects of kids in improving their future chances

I've always believed that engery supply like water, should be 'free' to the consumer, to an extent and recovered through taxation.

Some good points Jaimie but why does the solution to poverty always = more money?

As I mentioned at the beginning of the thread, a lot is to do with life skills. The ability to cook from scratch, repair clothes and yes learn to read / write and use a computer. I would much rather see money invested in this than just throwing money at people and not solving the problem.

so right on those points,kids having kids having kids,nothing is taught to the next generation.
Simply because they have not been shown or taught themselves.


I take it you're an expert in haberdashery then?

I'm from an OK background and can't sew a button nor can I do pretty much most DIY stuff around the house and that has nothing to do with (a lack of) wealth

I can just about, because my dad was good at the DIY stuff and I had to do needlework in school (I'm s**t at sowing, but I can just about thread a needle, stitch on a button etc). My poor DIY knowledge is supplimented by Google and a decent book on DIY my dad gave me.

But I also understand that a lot of people don't have access to certain skills, because they've never had an opportunity to learn them or inherit them from their parents or wider family - and without access to those skills their capacity to 'resolve an issue without wealth' is difficult (thanks to Google I can wire a plug with confidence, change fuses etc).

But its pot luck. Other people in my family are at a loss for DIY etc, and consequently they'd have to pay other people to do it, which is where the wealth factor kicks in (because the general rule of life is either you do it, or pay someone else to do it).


If a poor person could do all the things that people who can't do them pay for, they probably wouldn't be as poor. They would hopefully be getting paid do it all as odd job men/women

I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?

We have infinitely more things in the house that can break than say 30 years or even 20 years ago. Knowing how to sew or change a plug won't help them if the car breaks down or the boiler goes. 10 pairs of socks are a about quid in Primark - I really don't think they are the issue

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 3.45pm)

You are either missing the point or being deliberately obtuse.

1) If they are that poor then actually £1 is a lot and the Primark mentality is part of the problem.

2) We can't keep throwing money at the problem. Whether it is anybody's fault is irrelevant, life skills need to improve, particularly for the poor who in the main tend to be less well educated and will earn less.

3) the more wealthy you are, the more disposable income you have. How you spend it is up to you. Want to get a decorator in, then you do. cant afford it? then you do it yourself. Or do you think that the state should pay for that because as you said, where do you draw the line?

Yeah I think it's you that is missing the point.

Life skills will only get you so far and will only substitute some of the cost of living life. There are a million things that can break or need replacing in ones life and you cannot expect people to know how to fix them all because they are poor. Being poor might mean them working 12 hour days just to put food on the table - when do you suggest they get down the local carpentry college to brush up? Your suggestion gets to only part of the problem.

Also, well done on chucking a massive strawman in there though. As if I mentioned anything about them getting free decorating.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 4.03pm)

At no time have I said that people should be expected to know how to fix everything. Once again, if you had been bothered to read my original posts, I said basic life skills and how they had disappeared in the space of a generation.

As for the strawman, you introduced that with your ridiculous comment regarding people being expected to be capable of doing everything around the house.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Apr 15 4.15pm

Quote Stuk at 07 Apr 2015 3.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 3.42pm

Also Victorian Poverty might be overstating the case, given that meant a realistic chance of death, prostitution, the workhouse etc.


Too kind. It shows them to be f***ing thick as I stated earlier.

hopefully not a sociology or history teacher. If people think violent crime and suicide are a problem in the modern era, they should look a Victorian England.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 07 Apr 15 4.20pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 4.14pm


At no time have I said that people should be expected to know how to fix everything. Once again, if you had been bothered to read my original posts, I said basic life skills and how they had disappeared in the space of a generation.

As for the strawman, you introduced that with your ridiculous comment regarding people being expected to be capable of doing everything around the house.

I have read your original post


Quote
I will qualify the "s***ty" bit. Poor would have been better. The reality is that too many families (both poor and wealthy) don't have the skills to raise a family if it doesn't involve spending money. So when the money stops, people cannot/will not adapt.

Cooking skills, haberdashery etc have almost vanished in a single generation. By today's measure, I grew up in poverty for a large part of my childhood. having meat with a meal would besides a Sunday chicken usually be offal or pigs trotters until I was 12 and got a job on a farm.

Instead of throwing money at the problem improve life skills.
Also bearing in mind the survey was for a teaching Union, the result is Hadley surprising.


Quite clearly you did not write basic once.

There is no strawman from me. I'm highlighting over and over my point that having 'life skills' do not get to the route of the problem and can only mask it. A fixed sock or a repaired zip will save pounds but life is more complex and much more expensive than that.

What justification can you possibly have for suggesting that I think poor people should have their houses decorated on the state?

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 4.23pm)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 07 Apr 15 4.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 4.15pm

Quote Stuk at 07 Apr 2015 3.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 3.42pm

Also Victorian Poverty might be overstating the case, given that meant a realistic chance of death, prostitution, the workhouse etc.


Too kind. It shows them to be f***ing thick as I stated earlier.

hopefully not a sociology or history teacher. If people think violent crime and suicide are a problem in the modern era, they should look a Victorian England.


Unforgivable stupidity, even for a PE teacher.

 


Optimistic as ever

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 Apr 15 4.43pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 4.20pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 4.14pm


At no time have I said that people should be expected to know how to fix everything. Once again, if you had been bothered to read my original posts, I said basic life skills and how they had disappeared in the space of a generation.

As for the strawman, you introduced that with your ridiculous comment regarding people being expected to be capable of doing everything around the house.

I have read your original post


Quote
I will qualify the "s***ty" bit. Poor would have been better. The reality is that too many families (both poor and wealthy) don't have the skills to raise a family if it doesn't involve spending money. So when the money stops, people cannot/will not adapt.

Cooking skills, haberdashery etc have almost vanished in a single generation. By today's measure, I grew up in poverty for a large part of my childhood. having meat with a meal would besides a Sunday chicken usually be offal or pigs trotters until I was 12 and got a job on a farm.

Instead of throwing money at the problem improve life skills.
Also bearing in mind the survey was for a teaching Union, the result is Hadley surprising.


Quite clearly you did not write basic once.

There is no strawman from me. I'm highlighting over and over my point that having 'life skills' do not get to the route of the problem and can only mask it. A fixed sock or a repaired zip will save pounds but life is more complex and much more expensive than that.

What justification can you possibly have for suggesting that I think poor people should have their houses decorated on the state?

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (07 Apr 2015 4.23pm)


You got me I didn't say basic though at least you will now at least have read that I said lack of life skills is a problem that affects both poor and wealthy. (I should have bloody checked )

I don't think that you said people should have their houses decorated, you made the comment I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?
My response was to illustrate the wealth v skills differential. i.e. some people can afford to have someone do it, some can't. Those that can;t and can't afford a decorator, they have problems (can be transposed to a multitude of things in and around the house.


I disagree that if people were to for want of a better term, get back to basics it wouldn't have a marked improvement in lifestyle. I am not talking about building furniture here but families could quite comfortably save 20-30% of their expenditure with better planning and being thrifty.

Am i a hypocrite? To an extent yes because at the moment both my wife and I have good jobs and we put a value on our free time. If a job around the house is going to take me a long time then better someone else comes in to do it (and probably make a better job of it) however if circumstances were to change, we would have to change with them.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 07 Apr 15 5.04pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 4.43pm


You got me I didn't say basic though at least you will now at least have read that I said lack of life skills is a problem that affects both poor and wealthy. (I should have bloody checked )

I don't think that you said people should have their houses decorated, you made the comment I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?
My response was to illustrate the wealth v skills differential. i.e. some people can afford to have someone do it, some can't. Those that can;t and can't afford a decorator, they have problems (can be transposed to a multitude of things in and around the house.


I disagree that if people were to for want of a better term, get back to basics it wouldn't have a marked improvement in lifestyle. I am not talking about building furniture here but families could quite comfortably save 20-30% of their expenditure with better planning and being thrifty.

Am i a hypocrite? To an extent yes because at the moment both my wife and I have good jobs and we put a value on our free time. If a job around the house is going to take me a long time then better someone else comes in to do it (and probably make a better job of it) however if circumstances were to change, we would have to change with them.

Being thrifty and being able to repair/make stuff around the house aren't one and the same. Going to Lidl instead of ASDA or a charity shop is being thrifty but this does not take 'life skills' so they shouldn't be conflated. Where could a family save 20-30% from their entire expenditure from life skills?

Your original point seems to imply that if people in poverty were able to gain an undetermined set of 'life skills' (listed currently as haberdashery and cooking), they would be able to step out of poverty. I disagree. I don't see how learning life skills could possibly apply to a single mum working 6 days a week and raising 2 kids on her own or how these life skills can help a family plunged into poverty by the main bread winner getting ill and being unable to work.

As for my 'where does it end?' quote. I think it's pertinent... If the boiler breaks and needs replacing it costs money, if the fan belt in their car breaks, it needs replacing and costs money. The life skills will only take the person so far and it ends at the point these things need to be paid for and if you're living month to month or week to week, that money needs to be found or the family goes without heating or the breadwinner can't get to work and the cycle continues and the problems get deeper.

I think that saying 'poor people need to do x or y and they'll be ok' is completely unfair and paints poor people as feckless layabouts who could sort it out by pulling their socks up

Redecorating is not an essential and I've only ever spoke about essentials so I'm still unsure why that was brought up.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 Apr 15 5.11pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 5.04pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 4.43pm


You got me I didn't say basic though at least you will now at least have read that I said lack of life skills is a problem that affects both poor and wealthy. (I should have bloody checked )

I don't think that you said people should have their houses decorated, you made the comment I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?
My response was to illustrate the wealth v skills differential. i.e. some people can afford to have someone do it, some can't. Those that can;t and can't afford a decorator, they have problems (can be transposed to a multitude of things in and around the house.


I disagree that if people were to for want of a better term, get back to basics it wouldn't have a marked improvement in lifestyle. I am not talking about building furniture here but families could quite comfortably save 20-30% of their expenditure with better planning and being thrifty.

Am i a hypocrite? To an extent yes because at the moment both my wife and I have good jobs and we put a value on our free time. If a job around the house is going to take me a long time then better someone else comes in to do it (and probably make a better job of it) however if circumstances were to change, we would have to change with them.

Being thrifty and being able to repair/make stuff around the house aren't one and the same. Going to Lidl instead of ASDA or a charity shop is being thrifty but this does not take 'life skills' so they shouldn't be conflated. Where could a family save 20-30% from their entire expenditure from life skills?

Your original point seems to imply that if people in poverty were able to gain an undetermined set of 'life skills' (listed currently as haberdashery and cooking), they would be able to step out of poverty. I disagree. I don't see how learning life skills could possibly apply to a single mum working 6 days a week and raising 2 kids on her own or how these life skills can help a family plunged into poverty by the main bread winner getting ill and being unable to work.

As for my 'where does it end?' quote. I think it's pertinent... If the boiler breaks and needs replacing it costs money, if the fan belt in their car breaks, it needs replacing and costs money. The life skills will only take the person so far and it ends at the point these things need to be paid for and if you're living month to month or week to week, that money needs to be found or the family goes without heating or the breadwinner can't get to work and the cycle continues and the problems get deeper.

I think that saying 'poor people need to do x or y and they'll be ok' is completely unfair and paints poor people as feckless layabouts who could sort it out by pulling their socks up

Redecorating is not an essential and I've only ever spoke about essentials so I'm still unsure why that was brought up.

We will never agree, I am not saying it will solve 100% of the problems but it would be the difference between the hungry sockless child mentioned in the OPs link and a comparatively more comfortable life with a full stomach. majority of poor people, particularly those in "poverty" are not just financially poor but educationally &/or intellectually poor too. Until that is addressed then the the issue will not only continue but increase

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 07 Apr 15 5.16pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 5.11pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 5.04pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 4.43pm


You got me I didn't say basic though at least you will now at least have read that I said lack of life skills is a problem that affects both poor and wealthy. (I should have bloody checked )

I don't think that you said people should have their houses decorated, you made the comment I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?
My response was to illustrate the wealth v skills differential. i.e. some people can afford to have someone do it, some can't. Those that can;t and can't afford a decorator, they have problems (can be transposed to a multitude of things in and around the house.


I disagree that if people were to for want of a better term, get back to basics it wouldn't have a marked improvement in lifestyle. I am not talking about building furniture here but families could quite comfortably save 20-30% of their expenditure with better planning and being thrifty.

Am i a hypocrite? To an extent yes because at the moment both my wife and I have good jobs and we put a value on our free time. If a job around the house is going to take me a long time then better someone else comes in to do it (and probably make a better job of it) however if circumstances were to change, we would have to change with them.

Being thrifty and being able to repair/make stuff around the house aren't one and the same. Going to Lidl instead of ASDA or a charity shop is being thrifty but this does not take 'life skills' so they shouldn't be conflated. Where could a family save 20-30% from their entire expenditure from life skills?

Your original point seems to imply that if people in poverty were able to gain an undetermined set of 'life skills' (listed currently as haberdashery and cooking), they would be able to step out of poverty. I disagree. I don't see how learning life skills could possibly apply to a single mum working 6 days a week and raising 2 kids on her own or how these life skills can help a family plunged into poverty by the main bread winner getting ill and being unable to work.

As for my 'where does it end?' quote. I think it's pertinent... If the boiler breaks and needs replacing it costs money, if the fan belt in their car breaks, it needs replacing and costs money. The life skills will only take the person so far and it ends at the point these things need to be paid for and if you're living month to month or week to week, that money needs to be found or the family goes without heating or the breadwinner can't get to work and the cycle continues and the problems get deeper.

I think that saying 'poor people need to do x or y and they'll be ok' is completely unfair and paints poor people as feckless layabouts who could sort it out by pulling their socks up

Redecorating is not an essential and I've only ever spoke about essentials so I'm still unsure why that was brought up.

We will never agree, I am not saying it will solve 100% of the problems but it would be the difference between the hungry sockless child mentioned in the OPs link and a comparatively more comfortable life with a full stomach. majority of poor people, particularly those in "poverty" are not just financially poor but educationally &/or intellectually poor too. Until that is addressed then the the issue will not only continue but increase


Wowowowowow

 

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Apr 15 6.15pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 5.11pm

We will never agree, I am not saying it will solve 100% of the problems but it would be the difference between the hungry sockless child mentioned in the OPs link and a comparatively more comfortable life with a full stomach. majority of poor people, particularly those in "poverty" are not just financially poor but educationally &/or intellectually poor too. Until that is addressed then the the issue will not only continue but increase


I've heard this idea before.....I'm not too sure that it is true though.

If 100 percent of the country were educated then you are still going to have the same lack of equality financially.

How would be ratio of well paid jobs within the country change? You might get some more external investment but nothing like enough to ensure everyone lived well.

I'm more towards the idea that while we can better ourselves via good decisions and or luck (birth or right time, right place) it's still a reality that what's possible for you within society plays far more of a role than some people admit to themselves.

All that we need a more 'highly educated' workforce stuff is just one of the excuses that politicians use rather than admit that globalisation is f*cking us in the arse and that's there is little we can do about it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Apr 2015 6.16pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 Apr 15 6.43pm

W

Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Apr 2015 6.15pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 5.11pm

We will never agree, I am not saying it will solve 100% of the problems but it would be the difference between the hungry sockless child mentioned in the OPs link and a comparatively more comfortable life with a full stomach. majority of poor people, particularly those in "poverty" are not just financially poor but educationally &/or intellectually poor too. Until that is addressed then the the issue will not only continue but increase


I've heard this idea before.....I'm not too sure that it is true though.

If 100 percent of the country were educated then you are still going to have the same lack of equality financially.

How would be ratio of well paid jobs within the country change? You might get some more external investment but nothing like enough to ensure everyone lived well.

I'm more towards the idea that while we can better ourselves via good decisions and or luck (birth or right time, right place) it's still a reality that what's possible for you within society plays far more of a role than some people admit to themselves.

All that we need a more 'highly educated' workforce stuff is just one of the excuses that politicians use rather than admit that globalisation is f*cking us in the arse and that's there is little we can do about it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Apr 2015 6.16pm)

There will always be a differential we cannot all reach the same level. The point I am making is not just about formal education though that does play a part. A substantial number of poor people will unfortunately always have a limited potential to increase their income because of their lack of education/skill/aptitude. Even If we we ensured that 100% of the country were educated you would probably only be changing the people who fall into the bottom bracket.

The argument has drifted slightly, going back to the OP I still maintain that a more practical and longer lasting solution to a child going to school sockless and hungry is to improve the life skills of the parents.

On the one hand you have people claiming that benefits aren't enough and half the country need to use a foodbank yet you have others who seem to be able to go on bloody holiday!! Both the union and the Mail have there own agenda but assuming both stories are correct, then there is something mightily wrong with the benefits system. Money alone will not fix it.

I don't understand what is so controversial about trying to give people more help than just a giro.


Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (07 Apr 2015 6.44pm)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

elgrande Flag bedford 07 Apr 15 6.45pm

Well I can totally see what he is trying to say.I think some people just don't want to admit that people could do things to help themselves.

I don't think it's a matter of doing all your own DIY the point trying to made is if you can cook(and I mean cook not put something in the microwave) then you will save money.
Cooking from fresh will always be cheaper than crappy ready meals.
I do agree about the the socks.cheap enough to wear and throw.but shirt/blouse buttons jesus it's not rocket science.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Apr 15 7.32pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 6.43pm

There will always be a differential we cannot all reach the same level. The point I am making is not just about formal education though that does play a part. A substantial number of poor people will unfortunately always have a limited potential to increase their income because of their lack of education/skill/aptitude. Even If we we ensured that 100% of the country were educated you would probably only be changing the people who fall into the bottom bracket.

The argument has drifted slightly, going back to the OP I still maintain that a more practical and longer lasting solution to a child going to school sockless and hungry is to improve the life skills of the parents.

On the one hand you have people claiming that benefits aren't enough and half the country need to use a foodbank yet you have others who seem to be able to go on bloody holiday!! Both the union and the Mail have there own agenda but assuming both stories are correct, then there is something mightily wrong with the benefits system. Money alone will not fix it.

I don't understand what is so controversial about trying to give people more help than just a giro.


Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (07 Apr 2015 6.44pm)


I agree to an extent.....But the 'we can help people to improve their lives' stuff doesn't really fit the truth of what exists in society.

As good old Boris observed. Around fifteen percent of the population have an IQ of around 85.

We can talk about giving people skills and all the rest of it.....It's not really going to work very successfully within a society that is obsessed with intelligence and where the only jobs that exist that pay require experience, skills and everything else..

My old grandad fed his family as a welder.

In the past we had plenty of industrial/farm/factory jobs around where how bright you were was not as important. These jobs have now reduced within the service economy and it's harder to find reasonably paid jobs for that community.

Not only that but we have deemed it ok to bring in lots of foreign competition for what jobs do exist in that section......At what stage did we decide that being born a bit dim meant that your life was basically going to be s***?

They can't even get into the bleeding Army anymore....They are cutting even that route off.

The state should look after its own first, bright, dim or indifferent.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Apr 2015 8.15pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

johnfirewall Flag 07 Apr 15 11.14pm


Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Apr 2015 9.54am

Plus, occassionally there is money required for other things, such as travel, public transport use, books, car maintenance and other products of life (mobile phone, internet etc).

Travelcard, library card, top up voucher?

My car maintenance fund is called an overdraft.

I'm glad you've not gone as far as allocating them beer money though.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 08 Apr 15 10.56am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 5.11pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 07 Apr 2015 5.04pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Apr 2015 4.43pm


You got me I didn't say basic though at least you will now at least have read that I said lack of life skills is a problem that affects both poor and wealthy. (I should have bloody checked )

I don't think that you said people should have their houses decorated, you made the comment I think completely unreasonable to say that poor should know how to do every last thing around the house, just because they are poor. Where do we draw the line?
My response was to illustrate the wealth v skills differential. i.e. some people can afford to have someone do it, some can't. Those that can;t and can't afford a decorator, they have problems (can be transposed to a multitude of things in and around the house.


I disagree that if people were to for want of a better term, get back to basics it wouldn't have a marked improvement in lifestyle. I am not talking about building furniture here but families could quite comfortably save 20-30% of their expenditure with better planning and being thrifty.

Am i a hypocrite? To an extent yes because at the moment both my wife and I have good jobs and we put a value on our free time. If a job around the house is going to take me a long time then better someone else comes in to do it (and probably make a better job of it) however if circumstances were to change, we would have to change with them.

Being thrifty and being able to repair/make stuff around the house aren't one and the same. Going to Lidl instead of ASDA or a charity shop is being thrifty but this does not take 'life skills' so they shouldn't be conflated. Where could a family save 20-30% from their entire expenditure from life skills?

Your original point seems to imply that if people in poverty were able to gain an undetermined set of 'life skills' (listed currently as haberdashery and cooking), they would be able to step out of poverty. I disagree. I don't see how learning life skills could possibly apply to a single mum working 6 days a week and raising 2 kids on her own or how these life skills can help a family plunged into poverty by the main bread winner getting ill and being unable to work.

As for my 'where does it end?' quote. I think it's pertinent... If the boiler breaks and needs replacing it costs money, if the fan belt in their car breaks, it needs replacing and costs money. The life skills will only take the person so far and it ends at the point these things need to be paid for and if you're living month to month or week to week, that money needs to be found or the family goes without heating or the breadwinner can't get to work and the cycle continues and the problems get deeper.

I think that saying 'poor people need to do x or y and they'll be ok' is completely unfair and paints poor people as feckless layabouts who could sort it out by pulling their socks up

Redecorating is not an essential and I've only ever spoke about essentials so I'm still unsure why that was brought up.

We will never agree, I am not saying it will solve 100% of the problems but it would be the difference between the hungry sockless child mentioned in the OPs link and a comparatively more comfortable life with a full stomach. majority of poor people, particularly those in "poverty" are not just financially poor but educationally &/or intellectually poor too. Until that is addressed then the the issue will not only continue but increase

Ouch - The correct, sociological term, is lacking is cultural capital, rather than necessarily lack in education or intellectual capacity. Its being in possession of benefical skills, knowledge and access to facilities (and faculties) to be able to engage in society more successfully.

You're more likely to avoid poverty if your parents are upper working or middle class, not because you're intellectually superior, but that your parents facilitate a greater engagement in the process of educational benefit (access to galleries, books, museums, private education, tutors etc).

People in poverty tend to lack concepts and ideas associated with cultral capital.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Victorian poverty