You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Proportional Representation
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Proportional Representation


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 08 May 15 2.43pm

[Link]

I think we will be hearing more about this from now on. The link shows the result of the election under PR. Notice absence of SNP.

It is difficult to defend a system whereby the combined vote of UKIP and the Greens was around 5m votes - number of seats 2. SNP get 1.5 million votes, number of seats 56.

The PR result suggest to me that there would always be a coalition of either the right or left and that nationalists would squeezed. It would cut the ground from under nationalist claims that they are under constant English rule because the non-nat votes would be more relevant.
thoughts?

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 08 May 15 2.58pm

Under PR the results of the SNP wouldn't be covered, as that would be a Scottish election. Its unlikely that any Proportional System would cover seats in all parts of the UK, rather it would be the constituent countries (NI, Scotland, Wales and England) - Probably with the same number of seats.

Otherwise, the DUP, SDLP, Sinn Fein and UUP, as well as the SNP, would vanish.

The consequence of the UUP, DUP and Sinn Fein would likely result in a return of the UVF, UDA and PIRA campaigns.

Likewise Plydd Cymru would be back to burning holiday homes.

So likely as not, under PR the SNP would have got more or less the same result.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

johnfirewall Flag 08 May 15 3.19pm

Guardian didn't bother running that one then as Tories would've won anyway.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 08 May 15 3.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 2.58pm

Under PR the results of the SNP wouldn't be covered, as that would be a Scottish election. Its unlikely that any Proportional System would cover seats in all parts of the UK, rather it would be the constituent countries (NI, Scotland, Wales and England) - Probably with the same number of seats.

Otherwise, the DUP, SDLP, Sinn Fein and UUP, as well as the SNP, would vanish.

The consequence of the UUP, DUP and Sinn Fein would likely result in a return of the UVF, UDA and PIRA campaigns.

Likewise Plydd Cymru would be back to burning holiday homes.

So likely as not, under PR the SNP would have got more or less the same result.

How so?

They got 50% of the vote and 95% of the seats.

 


Optimistic as ever

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 08 May 15 3.39pm

Quote Catfish at 08 May 2015 2.43pm

[Link]

I think we will be hearing more about this from now on. The link shows the result of the election under PR. Notice absence of SNP.

It is difficult to defend a system whereby the combined vote of UKIP and the Greens was around 5m votes - number of seats 2. SNP get 1.5 million votes, number of seats 56.

The PR result suggest to me that there would always be a coalition of either the right or left and that nationalists would squeezed. It would cut the ground from under nationalist claims that they are under constant English rule because the non-nat votes would be more relevant.
thoughts?

Yep I worked that out earlier on another thread - a far more fair sharing of the national vote and a way to make every vote count.


Edited by The Sash (08 May 2015 3.48pm)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Pussay Patrol Flag 08 May 15 3.39pm

I'm more interested in Cathy Newman - Would, then would again, and keep woulding

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

DanH Flag SW2 08 May 15 3.47pm

We certainly need a more representative system. The Tories having complete control is just bonkers.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 08 May 15 3.49pm

Quote DanH at 08 May 2015 3.47pm

We certainly need a more representative system. The Tories having complete control is just bonkers.

Any one party having complete control is bonkers.

A system stuck in the dark ages..

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

TheJudge Flag 08 May 15 7.02pm

It is farcical that the SNP have 56 seats in Westminster when they polled not many more than the Greens.
It is bad enough that we have Scottish MP's Parliament but they are not representative of Britain and should not have 56 votes. UKIP and the Greens have a far better claim on a parliamentary voice of that magnitude and it is hardly surprising therefore that there is such a groundswell of disaffected people who feel they are being ignored.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 May 15 8.04pm

Quote The Sash at 08 May 2015 3.49pm

Quote DanH at 08 May 2015 3.47pm

We certainly need a more representative system. The Tories having complete control is just bonkers.

Any one party having complete control is bonkers.

A system stuck in the dark ages..

I voted Ukip but I can't bring myself to argue against FPTP.

It's the only system that actually gets things done.....A system where you can truly judge a party because they have had their agenda unrestrained by their opponents.

Proportional representation is fairer and more democratic......But it's also a lousy form of government.


Edited by Stirlingsays (08 May 2015 8.05pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Dweeb Flag East London 09 May 15 10.38am

PR will not be an issue until at least 2999, and I do mean that. The form of PR in Scotland was actually designed to keep the SNP out, and that didn't work...

The Tories are not going to bring it in after winning, and almost certainly the next lot wont either... repeat ad nauseum.

I suspect Gaia will have reset the Earth and gotten rid of us pesky humans long before PR gets introduced into Parliament.

 


Taking the bungy jump since 1964. Never to see John Jackson in a shirt again

Sorry to see Lee Hills go, did we ever see Alex Marrow? We did January 2013

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 09 May 15 10.58am

Unfortunately, I think the opportunity to change was missed by the Lib Dems when they formed the coalition government with the Tories. Why on earth they made so little of it when they were in a position of power escapes me.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

derben Flag 09 May 15 11.04am


We had a referendum on changing first-past-the-post and it was overwhelmingly rejected by the electorate.

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 09 May 15 11.18am

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.04am


We had a referendum on changing first-past-the-post and it was overwhelmingly rejected by the electorate.


That was a vote for AV, though. Not PR.

 

derben Flag 09 May 15 11.26am

Quote JL85 at 09 May 2015 11.18am

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.04am


We had a referendum on changing first-past-the-post and it was overwhelmingly rejected by the electorate.


That was a vote for AV, though. Not PR.

Yes, but I very much suspect a referendum on full PR would give a similar result. The issue is very low on most voter's list of priorities.

Minority parties can get elected via fptp. In 1945 there were loads: 6 Independents; 2 National; 1 Common Wealth; 2 Communists; 2 Nationalists; 2 National Independents; 2 Independent Labour; 2 Independent Conservative; 3 Ind Labour Party; 1 Independent Progressive; 2 Independent Liberals.

 

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 09 May 15 11.45am

It just seems a shame that 'minority interests' remain so. They don't get a chance to develop any critical mass under fptp.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

imbored Flag UK 09 May 15 4.08pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.04am


We had a referendum on changing first-past-the-post and it was overwhelmingly rejected by the electorate.


Yes, in part because of a disgusting campaign against it

b.jpg Attachment: b.jpg (57.86Kb)

 

imbored Flag UK 09 May 15 4.08pm

and this..

a.jpg Attachment: a.jpg (259.03Kb)

 

npn Flag Crowborough 09 May 15 4.21pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.26am

Quote JL85 at 09 May 2015 11.18am

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.04am


We had a referendum on changing first-past-the-post and it was overwhelmingly rejected by the electorate.


That was a vote for AV, though. Not PR.

Yes, but I very much suspect a referendum on full PR would give a similar result. The issue is very low on most voter's list of priorities.

Minority parties can get elected via fptp. In 1945 there were loads: 6 Independents; 2 National; 1 Common Wealth; 2 Communists; 2 Nationalists; 2 National Independents; 2 Independent Labour; 2 Independent Conservative; 3 Ind Labour Party; 1 Independent Progressive; 2 Independent Liberals.


I don't agree - I voted against AV, because it's a steaming pile of camel sh*t, but would have voted for true PR in a heartbeat. I don't imagine I'm the only one

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 09 May 15 4.22pm

Of course we should have PR - still based on constituencies.The FPTP system is blatantly unfair and is unsuited to a multi party system that we now have with a wide spread of votes.
Will it happen? Not as long as the governing party has and thinks they can continue to form a majority government.

In 2010 we had - for the first time in many years - a government that received 60+ per cent of the votes.
A government that could truly claim to represent the majority. A government - for some reason always referred to in the media as 'the coalition' as though it wasn't actually a government - that lasted the full term and - whist never satisfying everybody - was kept very near the centre of the political spectrum.

2015 - We are back to a government elected on 40 or so per cent of the votes and due to a modest majority and right wing pressure from within will move well away from the centre ground

So as far as representative government is concerned we have taken a step back.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Proportional Representation