You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Richard Dawkins Hero


Page 4 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
ChuFukka Flag 12 Jun 15 10.55pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.52pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.48pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.45pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.44pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.28pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.24pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.23pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.16pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.05pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 9.45pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 9.31pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 9.02pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 8.06pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 7.22pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 7.07pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 6.10pm

Quote sa_eagle at 12 Jun 2015 6.05pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.

I read most of the God Delusion (gave up before the finish though). I thought his ideas were poorly argued, almost made me take religion more seriously.

He's a great advert for religion as many look at him and his ilk and realise that religion is far more attractive than he is.

His big failing in his arguments is that he promotes a school of neo-atheism which tends to throw the baby out with the bath water. Traditional atheism is a far more intelligent option in which rather than query clear documented historical events such as the bodily resurrection of Jesus, they would question the meaning of his resurrection. Dawkins et al will simply argue it didn't happen and some even go so far as to argue that Jesus never existed, despite the wealth of evidence to prove that he did.

The other big problem with neo-atheism is that they've rarely read any theological books and as such don't actually understand the arguments they rail against. It's all to easy to dismiss God and religion as a whole if you don't understand the theological underpinnings of the concept of God and religion.


Er, there is zero documented evidence of the resurrection outside of the Bible, which, for obvious reasons, doesn't count. Also, Dawkins (as well as many other atheists) was brought up as a Christian and knows the Bible better than most who claim to believe its contents.

Is there any documented evidence for the 'Big Bang' and that it somehow occurred spontaneously?

There is plenty of scientific, empirical evidence which points to the big bang as the most likely answer to the question of origins. It is obviously a complex topic, as the universe does not owe us a simple answer (in spite of what most religions would have you believe), but the literature is out there should you choose to read it, having been compiled by some of the greatest minds our planet will likely ever see. Funny that there seems to be such a strong correlation between intelligence and acceptance of scientific truth.

Just a bit. But it seems just as likely that some omnipotent being created it than it suddenly springing into existence of its own accord (ie: both very hard to believe).


You can't seriously believe that the existence of an omnipotent being (whose own origins are yet to be explained and for which there is precisely zero evidence) is remotely comparable to a well-established scientific theory with piles of studies reinforcing it?

As I said "both very hard to believe". But can you seriously believe that the universe spontaneously burst into being?

Yes, as that is what the evidence suggests. Equating the two possible explanations is disingenuous.

Also, technically, 'spontaneous' isn't really the correct term, as linear time did not exist prior to the big bang.

What is the correct term then? It just happened? There was nothing at all and then a universe? Doesn't sound very scientific or likely. What evidence?


The time thing is very difficult to get your head around, and there isn't a perfect term as all our language is based around our perception of time as a purely linear entity (which it isn't). The evidence is extensive, and has filled thousands of pages of very dry physics publications which I wouldn't inflict on my worst enemy. A couple of more famous examples are the latent radiation still hanging around after the initial 'event', and the movement of all bodies in space relative to each other which show that they were, at some point, all in exactly the same place.

So the 'event' just happened.


Yes.

Have to say such a blind belief is very similar to religious faith.


I'm not sure how many times I have to use the word 'evidence' before it gets through.

It is a theory, there is no evidence.


About sums up the level of scientific knowledge being shown here. In science, the term 'theory' is only used for well-established principles. What you are thinking of is a hypothesis.

Why is it commonly known as 'The Big Bang Theory' then?


Because it's a well established principle. If it wasn't, it would be the Big Bang Hypothesis.

Edited by ChuFukka (12 Jun 2015 10.55pm)

 

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 10.59pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.55pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.52pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.48pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.45pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.44pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.28pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.24pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.23pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.16pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.05pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 9.45pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 9.31pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 9.02pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 8.06pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 7.22pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 7.07pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 6.10pm

Quote sa_eagle at 12 Jun 2015 6.05pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.

I read most of the God Delusion (gave up before the finish though). I thought his ideas were poorly argued, almost made me take religion more seriously.

He's a great advert for religion as many look at him and his ilk and realise that religion is far more attractive than he is.

His big failing in his arguments is that he promotes a school of neo-atheism which tends to throw the baby out with the bath water. Traditional atheism is a far more intelligent option in which rather than query clear documented historical events such as the bodily resurrection of Jesus, they would question the meaning of his resurrection. Dawkins et al will simply argue it didn't happen and some even go so far as to argue that Jesus never existed, despite the wealth of evidence to prove that he did.

The other big problem with neo-atheism is that they've rarely read any theological books and as such don't actually understand the arguments they rail against. It's all to easy to dismiss God and religion as a whole if you don't understand the theological underpinnings of the concept of God and religion.


Er, there is zero documented evidence of the resurrection outside of the Bible, which, for obvious reasons, doesn't count. Also, Dawkins (as well as many other atheists) was brought up as a Christian and knows the Bible better than most who claim to believe its contents.

Is there any documented evidence for the 'Big Bang' and that it somehow occurred spontaneously?

There is plenty of scientific, empirical evidence which points to the big bang as the most likely answer to the question of origins. It is obviously a complex topic, as the universe does not owe us a simple answer (in spite of what most religions would have you believe), but the literature is out there should you choose to read it, having been compiled by some of the greatest minds our planet will likely ever see. Funny that there seems to be such a strong correlation between intelligence and acceptance of scientific truth.

Just a bit. But it seems just as likely that some omnipotent being created it than it suddenly springing into existence of its own accord (ie: both very hard to believe).


You can't seriously believe that the existence of an omnipotent being (whose own origins are yet to be explained and for which there is precisely zero evidence) is remotely comparable to a well-established scientific theory with piles of studies reinforcing it?

As I said "both very hard to believe". But can you seriously believe that the universe spontaneously burst into being?

Yes, as that is what the evidence suggests. Equating the two possible explanations is disingenuous.

Also, technically, 'spontaneous' isn't really the correct term, as linear time did not exist prior to the big bang.

What is the correct term then? It just happened? There was nothing at all and then a universe? Doesn't sound very scientific or likely. What evidence?


The time thing is very difficult to get your head around, and there isn't a perfect term as all our language is based around our perception of time as a purely linear entity (which it isn't). The evidence is extensive, and has filled thousands of pages of very dry physics publications which I wouldn't inflict on my worst enemy. A couple of more famous examples are the latent radiation still hanging around after the initial 'event', and the movement of all bodies in space relative to each other which show that they were, at some point, all in exactly the same place.

So the 'event' just happened.


Yes.

Have to say such a blind belief is very similar to religious faith.


I'm not sure how many times I have to use the word 'evidence' before it gets through.

It is a theory, there is no evidence.


About sums up the level of scientific knowledge being shown here. In science, the term 'theory' is only used for well-established principles. What you are thinking of is a hypothesis.

Why is it commonly known as 'The Big Bang Theory' then?


Because it's a well established principle. If it wasn't, it would be the Big Bang Hypothesis.

Edited by ChuFukka (12 Jun 2015 10.55pm)

Well established principle! Basically what they are saying is, "we don't understand how the universe came into being, so we will just say it happened".

 

ChuFukka Flag 12 Jun 15 11.00pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.59pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.55pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.52pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.48pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.45pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.44pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.28pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.24pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.23pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.16pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.05pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 9.45pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 9.31pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 9.02pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 8.06pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 7.22pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 7.07pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 6.10pm

Quote sa_eagle at 12 Jun 2015 6.05pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.

I read most of the God Delusion (gave up before the finish though). I thought his ideas were poorly argued, almost made me take religion more seriously.

He's a great advert for religion as many look at him and his ilk and realise that religion is far more attractive than he is.

His big failing in his arguments is that he promotes a school of neo-atheism which tends to throw the baby out with the bath water. Traditional atheism is a far more intelligent option in which rather than query clear documented historical events such as the bodily resurrection of Jesus, they would question the meaning of his resurrection. Dawkins et al will simply argue it didn't happen and some even go so far as to argue that Jesus never existed, despite the wealth of evidence to prove that he did.

The other big problem with neo-atheism is that they've rarely read any theological books and as such don't actually understand the arguments they rail against. It's all to easy to dismiss God and religion as a whole if you don't understand the theological underpinnings of the concept of God and religion.


Er, there is zero documented evidence of the resurrection outside of the Bible, which, for obvious reasons, doesn't count. Also, Dawkins (as well as many other atheists) was brought up as a Christian and knows the Bible better than most who claim to believe its contents.

Is there any documented evidence for the 'Big Bang' and that it somehow occurred spontaneously?

There is plenty of scientific, empirical evidence which points to the big bang as the most likely answer to the question of origins. It is obviously a complex topic, as the universe does not owe us a simple answer (in spite of what most religions would have you believe), but the literature is out there should you choose to read it, having been compiled by some of the greatest minds our planet will likely ever see. Funny that there seems to be such a strong correlation between intelligence and acceptance of scientific truth.

Just a bit. But it seems just as likely that some omnipotent being created it than it suddenly springing into existence of its own accord (ie: both very hard to believe).


You can't seriously believe that the existence of an omnipotent being (whose own origins are yet to be explained and for which there is precisely zero evidence) is remotely comparable to a well-established scientific theory with piles of studies reinforcing it?

As I said "both very hard to believe". But can you seriously believe that the universe spontaneously burst into being?

Yes, as that is what the evidence suggests. Equating the two possible explanations is disingenuous.

Also, technically, 'spontaneous' isn't really the correct term, as linear time did not exist prior to the big bang.

What is the correct term then? It just happened? There was nothing at all and then a universe? Doesn't sound very scientific or likely. What evidence?


The time thing is very difficult to get your head around, and there isn't a perfect term as all our language is based around our perception of time as a purely linear entity (which it isn't). The evidence is extensive, and has filled thousands of pages of very dry physics publications which I wouldn't inflict on my worst enemy. A couple of more famous examples are the latent radiation still hanging around after the initial 'event', and the movement of all bodies in space relative to each other which show that they were, at some point, all in exactly the same place.

So the 'event' just happened.


Yes.

Have to say such a blind belief is very similar to religious faith.


I'm not sure how many times I have to use the word 'evidence' before it gets through.

It is a theory, there is no evidence.


About sums up the level of scientific knowledge being shown here. In science, the term 'theory' is only used for well-established principles. What you are thinking of is a hypothesis.

Why is it commonly known as 'The Big Bang Theory' then?


Because it's a well established principle. If it wasn't, it would be the Big Bang Hypothesis.

Edited by ChuFukka (12 Jun 2015 10.55pm)

Well established principle! Basically what they are saying is, "we don't understand how the universe came into being, so we will just say it happened".


This is ridiculous. Please just read some serious literature about the subject if you find it so confounding.

 

reborn 12 Jun 15 11.13pm

The Big Bang is the most convincing argument for a creator I have ever read.

Infinite matter explodes out of nothing?

Sounds like Creationism to me.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

ChuFukka Flag 12 Jun 15 11.20pm

Quote reborn at 12 Jun 2015 11.13pm

The Big Bang is the most convincing argument for a creator I have ever read.

Infinite matter explodes out of nothing?

Sounds like Creationism to me.


Funny how the hordes of geniuses who work on this stuff every day, and understand it to a far higher level than either of us, don't generally come to this conclusion.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 12 Jun 15 11.41pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 11.20pm

Quote reborn at 12 Jun 2015 11.13pm

The Big Bang is the most convincing argument for a creator I have ever read.

Infinite matter explodes out of nothing?

Sounds like Creationism to me.


Funny how the hordes of geniuses who work on this stuff every day, and understand it to a far higher level than either of us, don't generally come to this conclusion.

What I find funny is that I have heard one genius, Stephen Hawking say "Anything that happened before the big bang could not affect what happened after. So we can neglect events before the big bang and say that time began at the big bang". Also, everything has a cause and that sooner or later we must land on something that has no cause, ie, something Eternal.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Mr Palaceman Flag 13 Jun 15 3.40am

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 11.20pm

Quote reborn at 12 Jun 2015 11.13pm

The Big Bang is the most convincing argument for a creator I have ever read.

Infinite matter explodes out of nothing?

Sounds like Creationism to me.


Funny how the hordes of geniuses who work on this stuff every day, and understand it to a far higher level than either of us, don't generally come to this conclusion.


Also, are you not displaying an act of "faith"?

You say that these men of genius, understand to a far higher level and you trust their conclusions, based on the fact that there are many of them, or "hordes", without a full understanding yourself.

Is that not the same as people of another time trusting theologians and scholars of old who knew more and trusting their conclusions.

The difference between then and now is that, now we have more knowledge but less wisdom and knowledge without the wisdom to use it is actually a bane not a blessing.

So has the increased trust in science as the new religion made our lives any happier and if it has not, can how we live our lives now, been seen as progress.

Darwin himself was never an athiest, he was a Christian and if you look up at the night sky, many of the objects you find were named by muslim scholars. In fact the very basis of science and experimentation has it's roots in their need for a greater understanding of not only creation but the creator in particular.

The foundation for their thirst for greater understanding was a firm understanding in the concept of the eternal and what the eternal actually means.

From you previous comments I don't think you have really thought about this and base your comments on the rather narrow parameters of science with a little history, to the exclusion of other tools of contemplation which are available to you and may aid your enlightenment. Tools such as the science of Philosophy, Logic and Theology, all of which have have an important role to play in our understanding of our enviroment and existance.

Experimental Science can only help in the understanding of what can be tested or proven and a belief in this type of science alone leads mankind to attitudes such as..

"Abort it and try again. It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice."

Issues of morality and ethics cannot be dealt with by experimental science and yet Dawkins speaks of morality.

Funny.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

bright&wright Flag 13 Jun 15 5.02am

What I love about religion is things like blasphemy - it's brilliant, it's like they know they are full of sh*t and they do everything they possibly can to stop free thought.

Christopher Hitchins writings on religion are the best.

 


'We are going to make a little bit of history here’ Mr. J. Ertl.

Oliver Flag Bodega Bay 13 Jun 15 7.27am

As a fellow atheist I find Dawkins rather like a religious fundamentalist of any faith. He is tedious, annoying and probably a little dangerous.

 


I have prepared one of my own time capsules. I have placed some rather large samples of dynamite, gunpowder and nitroglycerin. My time capsule is set to go off in the year 3000. It will show them what we are really like.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 15 9.02am

Quote sa_eagle at 12 Jun 2015 6.05pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.

I read most of the God Delusion (gave up before the finish though). I thought his ideas were poorly argued, almost made me take religion more seriously.

He's a great advert for religion as many look at him and his ilk and realise that religion is far more attractive than he is.

His big failing in his arguments is that he promotes a school of neo-atheism which tends to throw the baby out with the bath water. Traditional atheism is a far more intelligent option in which rather than query clear documented historical events such as the bodily resurrection of Jesus, they would question the meaning of his resurrection. Dawkins et al will simply argue it didn't happen and some even go so far as to argue that Jesus never existed, despite the wealth of evidence to prove that he did.

The other big problem with neo-atheism is that they've rarely read any theological books and as such don't actually understand the arguments they rail against. It's all to easy to dismiss God and religion as a whole if you don't understand the theological underpinnings of the concept of God and religion.

Dawkins would argue that the onis is to prove that it happened, and that faith in something is not proof. A common misconception is that Dawkins is anti-religious, he isn't, Dawkins issue has always been with the degree of influence over people in general (ie the non-religious and different religeons) that dominant religions are granted.

And he's right, Christianity in, say Ireland, wields its power of influence over non-catholics and is used to dominate them politically. Indeed, Religion holds as much, if not more, influence over social policy and issues as scientific theory on that specific phenomena.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 15 9.06am

Quote reborn at 12 Jun 2015 11.13pm

The Big Bang is the most convincing argument for a creator I have ever read.

Infinite matter explodes out of nothing?

Sounds like Creationism to me.

Which would be fine if that was what the Big Bang was. Firstly there wasn't nothing, there was an absence of the dimension of time and space. Everything that exists in the universe, existed prior to big bang (ie the subatomic particles that construct everything).

The big bang is a transition by which spacetime occurs, resulting in an entropic change in states of matter, as subatomic particles expand into that spacetime.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 15 9.14am

Quote Mr Palaceman at 13 Jun 2015 3.40am

Issues of morality and ethics cannot be dealt with by experimental science and yet Dawkins speaks of morality.

Funny.

Experimental science is basis in empirical philosophy. Most, if not all students, studying any science will learn about ethics.

Also, you can't really study sciences such as psychology and sociology do study ethics, on a very regular basis, quantitatively and qualitatively.

Arguably some of the worlds most famous psychology experiments (the Standford Prison and Milgram's obedience studies are studies of ethics and morality).

Philosophically speaking Morality is a false concept, as existence is experienced subjectively, morality is not determined universally, but consentually through social interaction, as such it isn't really a consistent truth (and thus is really only a form of ethics).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 15 9.15am

Quote Oliver at 13 Jun 2015 7.27am

As a fellow atheist I find Dawkins rather like a religious fundamentalist of any faith. He is tedious, annoying and probably a little dangerous.

There is no little danger about it, fundamentalism is always dangerous if its not seperatist


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jun 15 9.18am

The mistake that people make is that they get too invested in the solution.

Science seeks to explain the natural world but all we can do is look for evidence for natural processes....There isn't a guide book saying how we should interpret them.

The big bang is our current best explanation of how nature started.

It could be wrong...Big bang has difficult areas that not all cosmologists are happy about like inflation...Hell, many scientific theories before it have been refined or completely changed.

However, the point is that science is looking for truth. It is important that the theory with the most consensus be disproved before we discard it.

So for the time being we have the big bang......though personally I think inflation is bulls*** despite the current evidence for it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 13 Jun 15 10.20am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jun 2015 9.06am

Quote reborn at 12 Jun 2015 11.13pm

The Big Bang is the most convincing argument for a creator I have ever read.

Infinite matter explodes out of nothing?

Sounds like Creationism to me.

Which would be fine if that was what the Big Bang was. Firstly there wasn't nothing, there was an absence of the dimension of time and space. Everything that exists in the universe, existed prior to big bang (ie the subatomic particles that construct everything).

The big bang is a transition by which spacetime occurs, resulting in an entropic change in states of matter, as subatomic particles expand into that spacetime.


If I might be so bold, I reject the idea that time was created with the Big Bang.

I am going to be very unscientific and separate time from space. This is no doubt a contradiction in terms or an impossibility or something or other.
But the way I see it, time in the Big Bang Theory can be separated from space if the universe as we know it needed this giant reaction to exist in space.

Time should involve the existence of something not just in terms of its spatial existence but something else, just a being which can be outside of a state of matter. The idea that everything was eternally existent and simply came into existence is to me wholly flawed.

Where did the stuff come from when it wasn't in a state of matter?
The way I see it is that science and particularly physics attempts to explain the world's origins through the most likely and logical scientific methods.
Up to the Big Bang I think this probably has some grounding.

But as to before the Big Bang, there doesn't seem to be a great deal of consensus. As to the question of eternity and the definite existence of stuff that isn't in a state of matter, I can only point to the existence of something supernatural and eternal such as God. I don't see how something can exist at one point and paradoxically exist for what is basically eternity without having any origin.


Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (13 Jun 2015 10.21am)

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

TheJudge Flag 13 Jun 15 10.59am

It is not the detail that is important here but the principal.
We know science gets it wrong. The key point is that the method is correct. Science wants to understand.
By contrast, religion only promotes ignorance. It is ironic because once upon a time I'm sure religion was all about understanding why things are the way they are, but with limited knowledge comes superstition. Religion wants us to remain locked in to superstition and mumbo jumbo. In fact it relies on it.
Even if there were a "god". whatever that means, why would any sensible person want to worship it ? Surely only the stupidest of people can really think that we get judged in some Biblical way when we die.
A "creator" does not equate to a Biblical god and I don't understand why people can't get their head around that.
I don't think that the universe or any part of it was created by intelligent design by the accepted definition, but so what if it was ? It makes no difference to me in my life. It is a profound thing to consider but nothing more. Religion has nothing to do with any of that. At it's worst, religion is a lot of self interested men dressing up in funny hats and making others feel guilty for their own selfish reasons. At best, it is well meaning but deluded.


Edited by TheJudge (13 Jun 2015 11.00am)

 

derben Flag 13 Jun 15 11.15am

Quote TheJudge at 13 Jun 2015 10.59am

It is not the detail that is important here but the principal.
We know science gets it wrong. The key point is that the method is correct. Science wants to understand.
By contrast, religion only promotes ignorance. It is ironic because once upon a time I'm sure religion was all about understanding why things are the way they are, but with limited knowledge comes superstition. Religion wants us to remain locked in to superstition and mumbo jumbo. In fact it relies on it.
Even if there were a "god". whatever that means, why would any sensible person want to worship it ? Surely only the stupidest of people can really think that we get judged in some Biblical way when we die.
A "creator" does not equate to a Biblical god and I don't understand why people can't get their head around that.
I don't think that the universe or any part of it was created by intelligent design by the accepted definition, but so what if it was ? It makes no difference to me in my life. It is a profound thing to consider but nothing more. Religion has nothing to do with any of that. At it's worst, religion is a lot of self interested men dressing up in funny hats and making others feel guilty for their own selfish reasons. At best, it is well meaning but deluded.


Edited by TheJudge (13 Jun 2015 11.00am)

If there is an omnipotent God who created everything, then I should think it just as well to try to keep in with him/her/it.

"At best, it is well meaning but deluded" - could be talking about the new lib/left establishment, although the left parts are often anything but 'well meaning'.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 15 11.18am

He's barking up the wrong tree....Ancient Aliens has all the answers one needs!

If Dawkins is a hero then Giorgio A. Tsoukalos is the Messiah...not a naughty boy!

Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2015 11.18am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

derben Flag 13 Jun 15 11.23am

Quote Lyons550 at 13 Jun 2015 11.18am

He's barking up the wrong tree....Ancient Aliens has all the answers one needs!

If Dawkins is a hero then Giorgio A. Tsoukalos is the Messiah...not a naughty boy!

Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2015 11.18am)

Yes, I like the ancient aliens ideas. Would explain the curious mix of animal and intelligence in man, and the physical design flaws.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Jun 15 11.45am

Quote derben at 13 Jun 2015 11.23am

Quote Lyons550 at 13 Jun 2015 11.18am

He's barking up the wrong tree....Ancient Aliens has all the answers one needs!

If Dawkins is a hero then Giorgio A. Tsoukalos is the Messiah...not a naughty boy!

Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2015 11.18am)

Yes, I like the ancient aliens ideas. Would explain the curious mix of animal and intelligence in man, and the physical design flaws.


Are you a scientologist?

 

Page 4 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero