This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote suicideatselhurst at 06 Aug 2015 8.39pm
Quote Mr Palaceman at 06 Aug 2015 8.15pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm
70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now. Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific. Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history. I was unnecessary but inevitable. Once it had been developed, They had to then use it. The Japanese tried to surrender before the bomb was dropped after Russia declared war on Japan. The bomb was dropped to show the Russians what the Allies could do. Secret papers released decades after the war show this. I remember seeing a documentry on the released papers in around 1990. I think it was reported on the BBC at the time.
The Japanese were trying to surrender before war was declared by Russia on Japan. They had hoped that Russia would mediate and that Japan could at least get more favourable terms. There was a window of opportunity for peace that started nearly two months before the bombs were dropped. As too the Japanese goverment being split down the middle, there are always those in every country that would rather die than be defeated and Japanese culture at the time was dominated by those who thought that surrender was always the most shameful outcome of war. However The Supreme War council of Japan, which was made up of The Emperor of Japan, The Prime Minister, The Minister of Foreign Affairs, The Minister of the Navy, The Chief of the Navy General Staff, The Chief of the Army General Staff and The Minister of War, were, none the less, asking for Russia to mediate peace, before Russia declared war on them. The documents and communications regarding Japans attempts at surrender were supressed until long after the war but many have now been released and without too much research, you can read many of them, if you wish. Japan was all but finished, their war was not sustainable and they knew it. The real threat was then seen as Russia. No point in having an Atomic Bomb, without demonstrating what it could do. It could be argued that Japan deserved what they got after the way they conducted themselves in the war from the start. Attitudes towards the Japanese were even worst than those towards the Nazis in this country towards the end of the war. They were seen as a wicked and cruel people, mainly on account of how allied POW's were treated but the truth is that there was an opportunity for peace without dropping the bombs. Whether it was a good or bad idea to drop the bombs in spite of this opportunity is another matter. I think that it was a war that had to be won and any war needs to be concluded at the first favourable opportunity. The problem now is that if the Japanese were trying to surrender and an agreement for peace could have been reached before dropping the bombs, how would that make the Allies look. Hence the documents were supressed for decades. The entire policy of Nuclear deterant in affect for decades after the bombs were dropped was based on the example of what happened to Japan, so it could also be argued that by dropping the bombs on Japan, war with The Soviet Union was avoided and who can say how many would have died had war broken out between The Soviet Union and the Allies. The Soviet Union and NATO both knew the devasting effect of the bomb. Personally, I agree with Kermit, in that the choice of target was wrong but IMO, there were many that wanted to see the effects of the bomb on a city. The rest is history. Who can say how the world would be today if the bombs had not been dropped, better or worst? I for one do not believe it was the right thing to do. Killing 120,000 people and mutilating tens of thousands of others, mainly women and children, in one deadly attack is, IMO, not what we were fighting for but war, tragedy and injustice are always happy bed fellows for all sides involved, whether you be the aggressor or the aggrieved.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
Remember Pearl Harbor!
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 7.51am
Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 10.16pm
Quote matt_himself at 06 Aug 2015 8.19pm
Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am
It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US. They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender. The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known. A heinous act. The Japanese, due to their belief that their Emperor was a God, we're not going to surrender. Bear in mind that up until 1974 there were Japanese soldiers in places like Micronesia still fighting the war and when they were found by locals, they persisted in killing them as they had not had instruction to down weapons. Plus the Japanese human rights record in the war was barbaric. They tortured and raped at will. Chinese, Koreans, Malay, Singaporean, etc., they didn't care. POW's were treated as sub human scum. Additionally, the Japanese weren't afraid to sacrifice hundreds of thousands of their own. The use of nuclear weapons was the last resort but in a situation like that, where you have an enemy who is so intractable, what do you do? Talk and provide humanitarian aid in the hope they bow down?
My old library master had been tortured by the Japs and couldn't speak save for a desperate rasp. They had been brutalized into savagery akin to the Hitler Youth being brainwashed with 'strength through joy' and other zeitgeist phrases. read about the power the Emperor had over the Japanese. The bombs were dropped to save lives as the Emperor employed a scorched earth policy and would rather see his country and people wiped out than surrender. However the bombs changed opinion. Not nice, hope we never have to use them again but ultimately the correct course of action. The US had essentially beaten Japan back to the mainland, its navy was almost incapable of operation and total air superiority could have been achieved within a few days. The US had other options, but it did have a super weapon, that had cost a massive fortune to produce, that no one else in the world possessed. I don't really think the decision was taken for the good of POWs, Japans future, negating the necessity of an invasion, but because it would effectively demonstrate the capability of the US militarily, probably force an unconditional surrender (that was only a matter of time - Japan would probably have accepted a conditional surrender). If Japan was truly committed to a everyman to the death, for the glory of the Emperor, scorched earth policy, then Nagasaki and Hiroshima would have made no difference to that. The US were also quite keen on covering up the full effects of radiation poisioning after the war, and the consequences to those affected by the bombs. I think its hard to escape the conclusion that it remains one of the single most horrific acts of war targeted at a mostly civilian population. I don't think you can really ever get away from the fact that it really was a war crime by any stretch of the imagination; it worked out for the best, probably, all told, but its hard to really justify any situation in which a country deliberately targets and kills at least 80,000 in a single indiscriminate attack.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.