You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Smoking ban in pub gardens.
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Smoking ban in pub gardens.


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Aug 15 4.20pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 3.06pm
I'm not debating legality. It's health issues that concern me.

Do you think that smoking would be legal if the treasury didn't make such a large amount of revenue from it ?

Do you know how much money the treasury could make of the illegal drugs that are less harmful than tabacco and alcohol. They don't. Smoking is legal because prohibition doesn't work. Didn't work with alcohol in the US, hasn't worked with gambling, didn't work with prostitution and it hasn't worked with drugs.

All it does is create black markets and fund criminal enterprises, resulting in more problems than the substance or activity itself.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Aug 15 4.23pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 3.02pm

Quote so many memories at 14 Aug 2015 1.28pm

The judge.
Look what your missing out on.
I expect you want outside patio heaters banned due to the overwhelming warmth they give us smokers when outside.
Most probably due to extra expense it costs you non smokers to install them.

You can call me Judge if you like but please at least use the correct grammar for "you're".

Seriously. You can't argue for smoking as a smoker.

It is the same as arguing for heroin as a user. Your perspective is skewed by drug addiction.

I'm no longer a smoker. Haven't smoked since January. Only vaping for me.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards so many memories Flag basingstoke 14 Aug 15 4.24pm

Thank you jamiemartin721.
Bit of sanity at last.
Will the judge be behind Arthur stand at half time with the 300+ getting a quick crafty fag in at half time.

 


Get it on-get it in-F**K OFF ALAN HANSEN!!

TheJudge Flag 14 Aug 15 5.34pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 4.23pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 3.02pm

Quote so many memories at 14 Aug 2015 1.28pm

The judge.
Look what your missing out on.
I expect you want outside patio heaters banned due to the overwhelming warmth they give us smokers when outside.
Most probably due to extra expense it costs you non smokers to install them.

You can call me Judge if you like but please at least use the correct grammar for "you're".

Seriously. You can't argue for smoking as a smoker.

It is the same as arguing for heroin as a user. Your perspective is skewed by drug addiction.

I'm no longer a smoker. Haven't smoked since January. Only vaping for me.


Oh just bite the bullet and stop man for heavens sake.


 

TheJudge Flag 14 Aug 15 5.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 4.20pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 3.06pm
I'm not debating legality. It's health issues that concern me.

Do you think that smoking would be legal if the treasury didn't make such a large amount of revenue from it ?

Do you know how much money the treasury could make of the illegal drugs that are less harmful than tabacco and alcohol. They don't. Smoking is legal because prohibition doesn't work. Didn't work with alcohol in the US, hasn't worked with gambling, didn't work with prostitution and it hasn't worked with drugs.

All it does is create black markets and fund criminal enterprises, resulting in more problems than the substance or activity itself.

No. Smoking is legal primarily because a ban would put a massive dent in the treasury income.

I don't advocate a complete ban anyway, just a ban in public places.

Legalising other street drugs is always a debatable topic but one must think of the social and health issues much the same as smoking. The difference is that other drugs are already illegal and so the question of revenue is not a problem.

 

TheJudge Flag 14 Aug 15 5.47pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 1.20pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 1.09pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 12.54pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 12.25pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 13 Aug 2015 8.35pm

Quote pefwin at 13 Aug 2015 8.31pm

Nanny state gaawwwnn mad. Thin end of a mighty wedge.

What happened to people's rights?

I still believe that it should be up to the Landlord whether or not it should be a smoking pub (inside or out). Who let kids into pubs anyway?

These rights are part of a free state.

That argument does not stand up. The majority don't smoke. What about their rights ?

Go inside the pub, where you can't smoke? Outside the risk from secondary smoke is minimal. It doesn't matter what a majority want, if their rights essentially result in an exclusion of another groups rights. The majority are catered for.

And using the argument that 'its for the kids' is a false basis for an economic defense of the majority, as the economic contribution to pubs of number of people who take kids to pubs compared to people who smoke and drink, is minimal.


So I have to alter my behaviour to appease some nicotine addicts ?
What a ridiculous argument. There is no justification for smoking whatsoever. THe government only tolerates it because of the revenue it generates.

Smoking is a blight on society.

You mean the same nicotine addicts who aren't smoking inside, for you rights. Its a reasonable compromise, that smoking in pubs was restricted for health reasons. Smokers have to go outside to lit up, maybe you should met them half way and stay inside if you don't like smokers.

There is no justification for drinking either, but you're still in a pub.



I would also limit drinking as well. Drunkard behaviour in public is also undesirable.

But you go to pubs, which create public drunkenness? Do you consume alcohol in those pubs.


Drinking does not equal drunk. Responsible drinking is fine but in Britain, for some reason, many people seem incapable of acting responsibly.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards so many memories Flag basingstoke 14 Aug 15 5.49pm

Explain public places.
When I'm on walk in countryside, street, waiting at bus stop,(uncovered). f*** me the local council has put no smoking signs up in underpasses.

 


Get it on-get it in-F**K OFF ALAN HANSEN!!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards so many memories Flag basingstoke 14 Aug 15 5.53pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 5.47pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 1.20pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 1.09pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 12.54pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 12.25pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 13 Aug 2015 8.35pm

Quote pefwin at 13 Aug 2015 8.31pm

Nanny state gaawwwnn mad. Thin end of a mighty wedge.

What happened to people's rights?

I still believe that it should be up to the Landlord whether or not it should be a smoking pub (inside or out). Who let kids into pubs anyway?

These rights are part of a free state.

That argument does not stand up. The majority don't smoke. What about their rights ?

Go inside the pub, where you can't smoke? Outside the risk from secondary smoke is minimal. It doesn't matter what a majority want, if their rights essentially result in an exclusion of another groups rights. The majority are catered for.

And using the argument that 'its for the kids' is a false basis for an economic defense of the majority, as the economic contribution to pubs of number of people who take kids to pubs compared to people who smoke and drink, is minimal.


So I have to alter my behaviour to appease some nicotine addicts ?
What a ridiculous argument. There is no justification for smoking whatsoever. THe government only tolerates it because of the revenue it generates.

Smoking is a blight on society.

You mean the same nicotine addicts who aren't smoking inside, for you rights. Its a reasonable compromise, that smoking in pubs was restricted for health reasons. Smokers have to go outside to lit up, maybe you should met them half way and stay inside if you don't like smokers.

There is no justification for drinking either, but you're still in a pub.



I would also limit drinking as well. Drunkard behaviour in public is also undesirable.

But you go to pubs, which create public drunkenness? Do you consume alcohol in those pubs.


Drinking does not equal drunk. Responsible drinking is fine but in Britain, for some reason, many people seem incapable of acting responsibly.


May have something to do with so many people telling us what we can or can't do.

 


Get it on-get it in-F**K OFF ALAN HANSEN!!

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 14 Aug 15 5.53pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 5.43pm


No. Smoking is legal primarily because a ban would put a massive dent in the treasury income.

I don't advocate a complete ban anyway, just a ban in public places.

Legalising other street drugs is always a debatable topic but one must think of the social and health issues much the same as smoking. The difference is that other drugs are already illegal and so the question of revenue is not a problem.

Ecstasy and cannabis have been proven to be pretty much non-harmful. Would raise silly amounts of revenue for the taxpayer if they legalised, taxed and sold. Won't happen though, too politically difficult.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

TheJudge Flag 14 Aug 15 7.15pm

Quote We are goin up! at 14 Aug 2015 5.53pm

Quote TheJudge at 14 Aug 2015 5.43pm


No. Smoking is legal primarily because a ban would put a massive dent in the treasury income.

I don't advocate a complete ban anyway, just a ban in public places.

Legalising other street drugs is always a debatable topic but one must think of the social and health issues much the same as smoking. The difference is that other drugs are already illegal and so the question of revenue is not a problem.

Ecstasy and cannabis have been proven to be pretty much non-harmful. Would raise silly amounts of revenue for the taxpayer if they legalised, taxed and sold. Won't happen though, too politically difficult.


No they haven't.

Edited by TheJudge (14 Aug 2015 7.16pm)

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 15 Aug 15 6.44am

I think The Daily Mash have summed it up quite well...

[Link]

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

TheJudge Flag 15 Aug 15 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 15 Aug 15 10.14am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)


I bet you describe yourself as 'tolerant', don't you?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Aug 15 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 15 Aug 15 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

 

martinb75 Flag Tampere 15 Aug 15 11.04am

I don't smoke but this will be taking it too far.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 15 Aug 15 11.05am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)


You could say that about most things,having a pint in the Pub(not essential) going out for a meal,equals self indulgence.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 15 Aug 15 11.18am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)


If you do label yourself as 'tolerant' (as people like yourself frequently do), then you're just another clichéd comedy leftie and I shall treat all your posts accordingly.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 15 Aug 15 11.28am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)


I'm slightly baffled at you seriously criticising a very obviously satirical article. That being said, it's amusing that you did criticise it for making general assumptions before then claiming that the majority of people don't want to be anywhere near someone who does.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

TheJudge Flag 15 Aug 15 2.37pm

Quote Canterbury Palace at 15 Aug 2015 11.28am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)


I'm slightly baffled at you seriously criticising a very obviously satirical article. That being said, it's amusing that you did criticise it for making general assumptions before then claiming that the majority of people don't want to be anywhere near someone who does.

Satirical or not, it was silly. The irony of people express opinions of that sort about having their lives impinged upon by evil anti smoking laws makes me laugh.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 2.42pm)

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Smoking ban in pub gardens.