You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > This (Cameron protest)
November 22 2026 1.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

This (Cameron protest)


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Apr 16 5.25pm

Great article from Paul Mason
[Link]

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Apr 16 5.25pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Why? What I find strange is a long line of politicians queuing up to give a rent-a-quote condemning Cameron for not for being a crook but because what he did was immoral. Who are they to decide what is or isn't immoral.

As for the public outcry and the Tories being out of touch, most people actually seem quite apathetic to the whole thing. Even some of my lefty friends think it is the wrong fight to pick.

After the MPs we can expect doctors, teachers, emergency services to do the same can we? All paid out of the tax coffers after all.

They probably don't pay tax on their union subs, as I bet they're allowed to deduct them before being subject to tax and NIC...

 


Optimistic as ever

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 12 Apr 16 5.27pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It is an ethical one though. Especially if you've made a pledge to 'get tough on tax avoidance', and then have been found to have engaged in it (which I'm not sure is the case given he paid all outstanding taxes).


It's "marketed tax avoidance" they are after.

Tax avoidance is using an ISA for example or using the married person's allowance.

Marketed tax avoidance is investing in a transaction deliberately designed and marketed to save tax and based on the opinion of a QC, which makes it avoidance not evasion. Take the Chris Moyles "used car dealer" scheme - Stevie Wonder could have told you that was bollocks reading the paperwork.

I don't agree with the normal politics of the author in this - but it offers a good explanation

[Link]


Do I like Cameron - no. But he hasn't done anything wrong. I'd argue Corbyn failing to file one is worse!

He handled it badly, that's the upshot of it - but he still had to pay tax when he wanted to repatriate it.


Edited by robdave2k (12 Apr 2016 5.31pm)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 12 Apr 16 5.29pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Great article from Paul Mason
[Link]

Load of emotive guff.

This whole Cameron situation is pure political positioning. I am no fan of Cameron but he appears to have operated within the law.

I am sure you will come back with a 'moral' angle but as with all things lefty, morals shift and are manipulated for the situation.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Apr 16 5.50pm

Originally posted by Stuk

After the MPs we can expect doctors, teachers, emergency services to do the same can we? All paid out of the tax coffers after all.

They probably don't pay tax on their union subs, as I bet they're allowed to deduct them before being subject to tax and NIC...

You can claim back on tax for union subs. I don't know many who do, but I get lots of emails from different accountancy 'firms' offering to claim on my behalf.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Apr 16 5.54pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

You can claim back on tax for union subs. I don't know many who do, but I get lots of emails from different accountancy 'firms' offering to claim on my behalf.

Funny that, and I bet most do.

There's a few million in tax avoidance there lads, froth away.

6m x £60 p.a on average?

 


Optimistic as ever

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 12 Apr 16 6.01pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Funny that, and I bet most do.

There's a few million in tax avoidance there lads, froth away.

6m x £60 p.a on average?

I doubt any of them are looking to run the country anytime soon.
That for me is the issue. (regardless of party)

 


Time to move forward together.

ghosteagle Flag 12 Apr 16 6.01pm

[Link]

Boyle hits nail on head. Done.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Apr 16 6.04pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Funny that, and I bet most do.

There's a few million in tax avoidance there lads, froth away.

6m x £60 p.a on average?

Isn't it 20% of the above? The same principle a self employed person deducts amounts for tools to do the job, only the amount above is taken at PAYE source.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 12 Apr 16 6.12pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Isn't it 20% of the above? The same principle a self employed person deducts amounts for tools to do the job, only the amount above is taken at PAYE source.


It's only 20/40% of the amount (depending on what rate you pay tax at)

So for a self employed between 29-41% (tax + class iv NI)

for an employee between 20 and 40% of the cost

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Apr 16 6.29pm

Originally posted by robdave2k


It's only 20/40% of the amount (depending on what rate you pay tax at)

So for a self employed between 29-41% (tax + class iv NI)

for an employee between 20 and 40% of the cost

So if we say it's 30% to make the calculation easy:

6,000,000 members pay £60 per year and 30% of that is £108,000,000.

Hardly denting the coffers and isn't much different to insurance for an employed person.

 


COYP

Hoof Hearted 12 Apr 16 6.57pm

The lefties on here might like to compare what Cameron has done compared to Vaz, Blunkett and Mandelson.

Their misdemeanours were worthy of a resignation (or two in some cases).

As I keep saying - Cameron has operated within the law and I cannot understand why this thread is still going?

.... and for balance I'll mention Jeffrey Archer and any other Tory miscreant caught libeling themselves or with their trousers down....

Edited by Hoof Hearted (12 Apr 2016 6.58pm)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Apr 16 7.15pm

Originally posted by -TUX-

I doubt any of them are looking to run the country anytime soon.
That for me is the issue. (regardless of party)

So it's fine for everyone to do except the PM?

Edited by Stuk (12 Apr 2016 7.19pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Apr 16 7.24pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Isn't it 20% of the above? The same principle a self employed person deducts amounts for tools to do the job, only the amount above is taken at PAYE source.

More than a few million though isn't it?

And it's not the same as deducting for tools if you're self employed as the company offsets those purchases against it's tax bill. Union membership is optional not a necessity, which tools have to be to be claimed for.

 


Optimistic as ever

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 12 Apr 16 7.34pm

Originally posted by Stuk

So it's fine for everyone to do except the PM?

Edited by Stuk (12 Apr 2016 7.19pm)

In the context of sending money OUT of the country you wish to govern, for personal gain, then yes. How can that ever be right?
As i've stated before, this stance is ridiculous regardless of Parliamentary 'colours'.

 


Time to move forward together.

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Apr 16 7.48pm

Originally posted by -TUX-

In the context of sending money OUT of the country you wish to govern, for personal gain, then yes. How can that ever be right?
As i've stated before, this stance is ridiculous regardless of Parliamentary 'colours'.

The country hasn't lost the money. It made a profit and was returned here, to the Cameron's bank account. Think of it as an investment that went on holiday.

Every single council, pension fund, charity/church and even us individuals put UK money into overseas funds, banks or investments.

Edited by Stuk (12 Apr 2016 7.49pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Apr 16 7.50pm

Originally posted by Stuk

More than a few million though isn't it?

And it's not the same as deducting for tools if you're self employed as the company offsets those purchases against it's tax bill. Union membership is optional not a necessity, which tools have to be to be claimed for.

£108,000,00 is very small in the scheme of things and I bet hardly anyone claims back around £20 if that's what it is, unless it's the full £60.

If employees were paid gross and then filed their accounts then it would be the same, wouldn't it?

You get your £15,000 gross and then deduct your £60 union subs just as someone self employed would do the same for deducting the cost of a saw from their gross company earnings. So at the end you are not paying the tax to HMRC on the union fees or the saw. Same end result.

And with regards to it being optional, yes you are technically right, but I get the impression that union membership in some industries where you're treated as merely a number or are in very vulnerable employment it is highly essential and you're a fool to save £2 a week not being a member.

 


COYP

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Apr 16 8.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

£108,000,00 is very small in the scheme of things and I bet hardly anyone claims back around £20 if that's what it is, unless it's the full £60.

If employees were paid gross and then filed their accounts then it would be the same, wouldn't it?

You get your £15,000 gross and then deduct your £60 union subs just as someone self employed would do the same for deducting the cost of a saw from their gross company earnings. So at the end you are not paying the tax to HMRC on the union fees or the saw. Same end result.

And with regards to it being optional, yes you are technically right, but I get the impression that union membership in some industries where you're treated as merely a number or are in very vulnerable employment it is highly essential and you're a fool to save £2 a week not being a member.

I'm not saying it's a big deal nor calling for it to be taxed or non-deductible. I'm using it to illustrate a point.

and £108m, if that's what it amounted to, is a lot more than the tax on 30K that people are wetting their knickers about.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Apr 16 8.17pm

What has reclaiming a few quid back on union dues got to do with the Tories using donor money from their benefactors which has been channeled through off shore tax avoidance.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Apr 16 8.30pm

Who's talking about tory donors other than you?

I'm talking about using legitimate tax allowances or schemes whether it's the Camerons or union members.

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > This (Cameron protest)