You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Hillsborough Verdict
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Hillsborough Verdict


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 10.30am

Originally posted by hibbystu

I am so glad that it has been proved in a court of law, that no one was pissed and everyone had a valid ticket

Their proof was bins near the gate half full and mainly Vimto, Sprite and other soft drinks with a few lager bottles. They've never heard of a pub then and being stopped from carrying your glass away from the pub by the Police.

And their proof on the tickets was a few waving them on CCTV when going through the gates.

It should've been made public knowledge that certain behaviour happens at football and not just Scousers. But as they had most success and biggest following, the authorities should be well prepared for everything to protect all.

 


COYP

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 27 Apr 16 10.53am

Originally posted by Kermit8

What still is astounding even taking into account the human error element is how close the police viewing box with Duckenfield in it was to the Leppings Lane end. Even Stevie Wonder could have seen that the end pens were just over half full whilst the middle ones were rammed at around 2.45.

Ralph Wiggum could have done a better job.

That though was a sign of the times Kerms...We were herded, penned and generally treated to conditions that they wouldn't allow for cattle...so its packed in and you are pressed against a bloke with chronic dandruff who smells like he has f***ed a horse for 90 minutes...so what ??

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Old Chap Flag Orpington 27 Apr 16 2.17pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

But they do say the law is an ass Stu!

Sadly, because of the previous cover ups by police, government etc and putting ALL the blame on the fans, no one is even allowed to suggest that even one person from Liverpool had a schooner of sherry that day and wasn't holding a valid ticket.

Even the choice of a predominately female jury that would concur with this ridiculous notion was arranged.

Anyhow..... all our lives are a lot safer today as a result of the lessons learned from that awful tragedy.

I think there should be prosecutions for those people that arranged the cover up and the lies, but as for prosecuting Duckenfield? He already looks a broken man to me.

I saw a suggestion on Twitter that Mackenzie should be charged with perverting the course of justice, as the lies he told contributed to the hiding of facts

 


Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Apr 16 2.48pm

To all those standing up for Duckenfield or continuing to imply that LFC fans were in some way culpable for their own deaths, or those of their fellow fans, I urge you to read this comprehensive and detailed article by respected sports investigator David Conn, which lays out the sequence of events which lead to the disastrous police handling of the game, and Duckenfield's part in it. It's quite a long piece, but it will answer many of the questions which have been raised on this thread:

[Link]

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 27 Apr 16 2.51pm

The whole f***ing thing is a sorry mess.

I've been switching off the radio everytime it's being mentioned at the mo.

The BBC fawning over the whole thing is vomit enducing.

What I would say is that there were a number of factors that led to the tragedy...not just the POLICE's actions.

For the Fans to be absolved of any blame whatsoever is laughable...numerous parties had a part to play in this...those ticketless fans that turned up trying to get in forcing the hand of an individual to make the wrong choice...to the stadium not having stewards with keys to the gates.

The ONLY people who should have no part in the blame are the ones that are DEAD.

No matter what happens now it's just fuelled the insatiable need to be seen as 'victims' and to point the finger elsewhere.

There will of course be no end of litigation now as a result.....rather than accepting that The Police messed up and letting it lie there......but there's no money in that is there...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Apr 16 2.56pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Sadly, because of the previous cover ups by police, government etc and putting ALL the blame on the fans, no one is even allowed to suggest that even one person from Liverpool had a schooner of sherry that day and wasn't holding a valid ticket.

Even the choice of a predominately female jury that would concur with this ridiculous notion was arranged.

I think there should be prosecutions for those people that arranged the cover up and the lies, but as for prosecuting Duckenfield? He already looks a broken man to me.

No-one is saying that none of the fans had had a drink, or that everyone had a ticket. That isn't the point and would be ridiculous. The point is the police should've had a plan to deal with it, as it happened often at that time, and the fact they didn't, and the other major mistakes they made, was the main cause of the disaster.

Your point about the jury is deeply offensive, sexist, and frankly contemptible. Where is your proof that having a majority female jury had any bearing whatsoever on the verdict, or that they would somehow be more likely to believe one view or another, or that it was "arranged" that way? It would be illegal to "arrange" a jury in that way and I don't believe you have any evidence whatsoever to back up this view.

As for Duckenfield, of course he should be held accountable. He has admitted he caused the deaths, so should face the consequences. Broken or not, he shouldn't be allowed to get away with 96 deaths which, as he has admitted, were his fault.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 27 Apr 16 3.08pm

Originally posted by Seth

No-one is saying that none of the fans had had a drink, or that everyone had a ticket. That isn't the point and would be ridiculous. The point is the police should've had a plan to deal with it, as it happened often at that time, and the fact they didn't, and the other major mistakes they made, was the main cause of the disaster.

Your point about the jury is deeply offensive, sexist, and frankly contemptible. Where is your proof that having a majority female jury had any bearing whatsoever on the verdict, or that they would somehow be more likely to believe one view or another, or that it was "arranged" that way? It would be illegal to "arrange" a jury in that way and I don't believe you have any evidence whatsoever to back up this view.

As for Duckenfield, of course he should be held accountable. He has admitted he caused the deaths, so should face the consequences. Broken or not, he shouldn't be allowed to get away with 96 deaths which, as he has admitted, were his fault.

Hear, hear.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 3.26pm

Originally posted by Seth

No-one is saying that none of the fans had had a drink, or that everyone had a ticket. That isn't the point and would be ridiculous. The point is the police should've had a plan to deal with it, as it happened often at that time, and the fact they didn't, and the other major mistakes they made, was the main cause of the disaster.

Your point about the jury is deeply offensive, sexist, and frankly contemptible. Where is your proof that having a majority female jury had any bearing whatsoever on the verdict, or that they would somehow be more likely to believe one view or another, or that it was "arranged" that way? It would be illegal to "arrange" a jury in that way and I don't believe you have any evidence whatsoever to back up this view.

As for Duckenfield, of course he should be held accountable. He has admitted he caused the deaths, so should face the consequences. Broken or not, he shouldn't be allowed to get away with 96 deaths which, as he has admitted, were his fault.

Yep. But the issue is as well that the jury and the public believe this is the case yet there is no proof and every single football match and every big game what happened before the gate opened was the nom. The poor parents of most of the dead know their loved ones were sober, they got there early. Some of the other normal stuff has been brushed under the carpet.

If the person in charge on the day had any experience of big football matches it probably wouldn't have happened. The game might have been delayed, there might have been problems outside the ground, more people would've been employed or more turnstyles open, but what went on that day before the gates were opened would've gone on at least 1 semi final and final every season in that decade. It would've been Liverpool, Everton, Man U, Spurs, whoever.

Or they could've just reduced capacity in terraces by 10% or something for away ends for big games or all terraces for semi's and finals.

But I do have an issue with LFC fans turning up today for big games and trying and gaining entry ticketless. Definitely happened at Selhurst. Didn't it happen in Instanbul as well? There are without doubt a minority who are selfish and care free and they need to be shamed.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Apr 2016 3.29pm)

 


COYP

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Apr 16 4.26pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

But I do have an issue with LFC fans turning up today for big games and trying and gaining entry ticketless. Definitely happened at Selhurst. Didn't it happen in Instanbul as well? There are without doubt a minority who are selfish and care free and they need to be shamed.

Of course that's an issue, and isn't confined to LFC fans. However, it had nothing to do with what happened at Hillsborough, as has been proved in court. It's a separate matter and the two shouldn't be conflated. For people to continue to imply a link is wrong and is a deeply unfair to those who died or were otherwise involved, and their families.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

OldFella Flag London 27 Apr 16 4.41pm

Originally posted by Seth

Of course that's an issue, and isn't confined to LFC fans. However, it had nothing to do with what happened at Hillsborough, as has been proved in court. It's a separate matter and the two shouldn't be conflated. For people to continue to imply a link is wrong and is a deeply unfair to those who died or were otherwise involved, and their families.

"Conflated"? SERIOUS wally alert on HOL boards. You bore me so tremendously Seth.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Apr 16 4.51pm

Originally posted by OldFella

"Conflated"? SERIOUS wally alert on HOL boards. You bore me so tremendously Seth.

You appear to have mistaken me for someone who gives an iota of steaming dogsh*t what you think.

If you don't like my posts don't read them. That's what I do with yours, although a "block" function would make life so much simpler when "wallies" like you are in full-on troll mode.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 4.53pm

Originally posted by Seth

Of course that's an issue, and isn't confined to LFC fans. However, it had nothing to do with what happened at Hillsborough, as has been proved in court. It's a separate matter and the two shouldn't be conflated. For people to continue to imply a link is wrong and is a deeply unfair to those who died or were otherwise involved, and their families.

Only it's people from the same club and same city as those demanding justice for the 96 who died. Thousands of people from Liverpool angered at the lies and miscarriage of justice yet there are hundreds who are still behaving in a way that they were accused of in the 1st place.

The people who died were completely innocent, maybe hardly any fans actually got in, maybe they didn't get in before it reached its worst. But people without tickets could have and could still make an incident worse or even cause it to happen in the 1st place. If you said this in the company of people foreign to '80s football or even the odd game of modern football they'll think you're insensitive and prejudiced.

Several clubs tried it on then, now only one club I know of try it on now. Inexcusable and shameless minority.

 


COYP

Mr Palaceman Flag 27 Apr 16 5.11pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yep. But the issue is as well that the jury and the public believe this is the case yet there is no proof and every single football match and every big game what happened before the gate opened was the nom. The poor parents of most of the dead know their loved ones were sober, they got there early. Some of the other normal stuff has been brushed under the carpet.

If the person in charge on the day had any experience of big football matches it probably wouldn't have happened. The game might have been delayed, there might have been problems outside the ground, more people would've been employed or more turnstyles open, but what went on that day before the gates were opened would've gone on at least 1 semi final and final every season in that decade. It would've been Liverpool, Everton, Man U, Spurs, whoever.

Or they could've just reduced capacity in terraces by 10% or something for away ends for big games or all terraces for semi's and finals.

But I do have an issue with LFC fans turning up today for big games and trying and gaining entry ticketless. Definitely happened at Selhurst. Didn't it happen in Instanbul as well? There are without doubt a minority who are selfish and care free and they need to be shamed.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Apr 2016 3.29pm)

Don't you think that LFC fans have been shamed enough?

This was a disgusting case of smearing a community and club by lying Senior police officers and colluding newspapers among others.

I can not think of a more heinous way to treat people who lost loved ones. Fathers and sons, mothers and daughters.

And yet you try and keep the focus on those you call a 'minority', even though the enquiry has concluded that NO FAN WAS TO BLAME. I say again, NO FAN WAS TO BLAME. That's those who had a drink, Not to Blame or those who did not have a ticket, not to blame.

Are you trying to continue the lie? Bringing up Instanbul in relation to this is just another way of deflecting at least some responsiblitiy towards those that have been wronged and were in no way responsible.

From one of your previous posts...

"I agree with the ticketless issue. It may or may not have contributed to what happened"

It did not contribute but still you try to suggest that it did..

I do recognise that you have posted some very good points in this thread, as have others but reading your posts, it seems to me that you offer an excuse to those who acted in a shameful and dishonest way.

I read the previous post that roughly stated that Duckenfield had a tough job and it would have been hard to do that job on the day.

It goes without saying that it was a tough day and you agreed with that post but the subsequent behaviour of Duckenfield was far from human, in fact I would say that it was inhuman, rather like leaving a person dying in the road and leaving the scene to avoid prosecusion.

After reading posts on this subject for many years. I have come to the conclusion that smear campaigns run by papers like The Sun, work. Some were so outraged by the lies printed about a whole community, that even to this day it Sours their view of the fans behaviour on that tragic day.

I'm a fairly hard nosed guy but I must say that I have been truly moved by some of the accounts I have resently heard from those that lost loved ones, extremely upsetting.

As a Palace supporter, I cannot not stand Liverpool fans but it's a game and that is as far as it goes.

I think that the way that the city has handled this tragedy, is testimony to the steadfast spirit and determination for justice of the people of Liverpool.

Now we need those responsible to be held to account.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Apr 16 5.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Only it's people from the same club and same city as those demanding justice for the 96 who died. Thousands of people from Liverpool angered at the lies and miscarriage of justice yet there are hundreds who are still behaving in a way that they were accused of in the 1st place.

The people who died were completely innocent, maybe hardly any fans actually got in, maybe they didn't get in before it reached its worst. But people without tickets could have and could still make an incident worse or even cause it to happen in the 1st place. If you said this in the company of people foreign to '80s football or even the odd game of modern football they'll think you're insensitive and prejudiced.

Several clubs tried it on then, now only one club I know of try it on now. Inexcusable and shameless minority.

Just because they're from the same city makes no difference. The two are separate issues and it's been proved it had no bearing on Hillsborough.

In fact, some of the people in the crush outside were among those who died 10 minutes later, as is detailed in the article I linked to. So it is possible that the dead included some who didn't have tickets. Does that make it their fault, or that of the police, ambulance, SWFC or engineers, as the jury decided?

Yes it's is inexcusable, but it has nothing to do with 96 people going to a football match in 1989 and not coming home again.

I went to football in the 80's, and still do today and am aware of what went on then, and still does now, to a lesser extent. Fans' behaviour can cause incidents or make them worse, but in this case it's been proved not to have contributed to the disaster.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 5.24pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Don't you think that LFC fans have been shamed enough?

This was a disgusting case of smearing a community and club by lying Senior police officers and colluding newspapers among others.

I can not think of a more heinous way to treat people who lost loved ones. Fathers and sons, mothers and daughters.

And yet you try and keep the focus on those you call a 'minority', even though the enquiry has concluded that NO FAN WAS TO BLAME. I say again, NO FAN WAS TO BLAME. That's those who had a drink, Not to Blame or those who did not have a ticket, not to blame.

Are you trying to continue the lie? Bringing up Instanbul in relation to this is just another way of deflecting at least some responsiblitiy towards those that have been wronged and were in no way responsible.

From one of your previous posts...

"I agree with the ticketless issue. It may or may not have contributed to what happened"

It did not contribute but still you try to suggest that it did..

I do recognise that you have posted some very good points in this thread, as have others but reading your posts, it seems to me that you offer an excuse to those who acted in a shameful and dishonest way.

I read the previous post that roughly stated that Duckenfield had a tough job and it would have been hard to do that job on the day.

It goes without saying that it was a tough day and you agreed with that post but the subsequent behaviour of Duckenfield was far from human, in fact I would say that it was inhuman, rather like leaving a person dying in the road and leaving the scene to avoid prosecusion.

After reading posts on this subject for many years. I have come to the conclusion that smear campaigns run by papers like The Sun, work. Some were so outraged by the lies printed about a whole community, that even to this day it Sours their view of the fans behaviour on that tragic day.

I'm a fairly hard nosed guy but I must say that I have been truly moved by some of the accounts I have resently heard from those that lost loved ones, extremely upsetting.

As a Palace supporter, I cannot not stand Liverpool fans but it's a game and that is as far as it goes.

I think that the way that the city has handled this tragedy, is testimony to the steadfast spirit and determination for justice of the people of Liverpool.

Now we need those responsible to be held to account.

I was talking about a minority who conveniently forget what happened when they want to get in for an important match.

I haven't tried to deflect anything from those responsible. Duckenfield, SYPolice, SWFC, The FA who have escaped all responsibility.

I did indeed say ticketless fans didn't cause what happened. I did however say the knowledge that that is what used to happen gave an image of what can cause bad decisions on the day. And in the post you're referring to above, I said,

The people who died were completely innocent, maybe hardly any fans actually got in, maybe they didn't get in before it reached its worst. But people without tickets could have and could still make an incident worse or even cause it to happen in the 1st place. If you said this in the company of people foreign to '80s football or even the odd game of modern football they'll think you're insensitive and prejudiced. Several clubs tried it on then, now only one club I know of try it on now. Inexcusable and shameless minority.

The point is fella is that a minority could cause something to happen again to innocentpeople. But if you excuse people who climb over walls and cause overcrowding in aisles of seating then ok.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Apr 2016 5.31pm)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 5.30pm

Originally posted by Seth

Just because they're from the same city makes no difference. The two are separate issues and it's been proved it had no bearing on Hillsborough.

In fact, some of the people in the crush outside were among those who died 10 minutes later, as is detailed in the article I linked to. So it is possible that the dead included some who didn't have tickets. Does that make it their fault, or that of the police, ambulance, SWFC or engineers, as the jury decided?

Yes it's is inexcusable, but it has nothing to do with 96 people going to a football match in 1989 and not coming home again.

I went to football in the 80's, and still do today and am aware of what went on then, and still does now, to a lesser extent. Fans' behaviour can cause incidents or make them worse, but in this case it's been proved not to have contributed to the disaster.

I know, I read it yesterday. I know that it didn't cause the disaster, but it could cause something to happen again in certain circumstances. Who can be sure? The 3-3 game was last year. Istanbul was 16 years after Hillsborough. But it's excusable after 96 people died because of crushing.

I think I might give up.

 


COYP

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 27 Apr 16 5.31pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I was talking about a minority who conveniently forget what happened when they want to get in for an important match.

I haven't tried to deflect anything from those responsible. Duckenfield, SYPolice, SWFC, The FA who have escaped all responsibility.

I did indeed say ticketless fans didn't cause what happened. I did however say the knowledge that that is what used to happen gave an image of what can cause bad decisions on the day. And in the post you're referring to above,

The people who died were completely innocent, maybe hardly any fans actually got in, maybe they didn't get in before it reached its worst. But people without tickets could have and could still make an incident worse or even cause it to happen in the 1st place. If you said this in the company of people foreign to '80s football or even the odd game of modern football they'll think you're insensitive and prejudiced. Several clubs tried it on then, now only one club I know of try it on now. Inexcusable and shameless minority.

The point is fella is that a minority could cause something to happen again to innocentpeople. But if you excuse people who climb over walls and cause overcrowding in aisles of seating then ok.

Rudi, late coming fans are a problem throughout sports world wide. Here in the USA, where sporting events are "safe," we have the 2nd to 7th fans in baseball. They come in time for the 2nd of 9 innings and leave at the 7th inning stretch, causing all kinds of grief to those around them. At Selhurst we used to call 5 minutes to kick off rush hour for all the fans from both clubs who would start arriving in droves. I can't tell you how many times I was offered 5, 10, 20, even 100 quid to open up a gate for a late coming Palace fan. Seth is right, late comers are a separate issue and the Taylor Report, the HIC and the inquest definitively said had no bearing on the deaths at Hillsborough.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 5.43pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

Rudi, late coming fans are a problem throughout sports world wide. Here in the USA, where sporting events are "safe," we have the 2nd to 7th fans in baseball. They come in time for the 2nd of 9 innings and leave at the 7th inning stretch, causing all kinds of grief to those around them. At Selhurst we used to call 5 minutes to kick off rush hour for all the fans from both clubs who would start arriving in droves. I can't tell you how many times I was offered 5, 10, 20, even 100 quid to open up a gate for a late coming Palace fan. Seth is right, late comers are a separate issue and the Taylor Report, the HIC and the inquest definitively said had no bearing on the deaths at Hillsborough.

Agree with this and the organisation on 15 April 1989 was awful, but I'm referring to a minority who still try to gain entry now after what happened.

I wouldn't blame them IF there were ticketless fans in amongst those let through the gates without trying to force them whatsoever. How was anyone to know what was going to happen or what was happening? It happened before and nobody died, but since 1989 people have died because of crushing. People without tickets adding to capacity can cause crushing, even if we or the jury say is isn't related. If everyone tried to stand in Block B it can cause crushing.

 


COYP

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Apr 16 5.58pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I know, I read it yesterday. I know that it didn't cause the disaster, but it could cause something to happen again in certain circumstances. Who can be sure? The 3-3 game was last year. Istanbul was 16 years after Hillsborough. But it's excusable after 96 people died because of crushing.

I think I might give up.

If you read what I wrote, I agreed it was inexcusable, but is irrelevant to Hillsborough. They shouldn't do it, nor should anyone, but gladly we've come a long way since 1989 and hopefully the result couldn't be the same today.

Think we're just going to have to agree to differ on this one Rudi. I don't think we're far apart, but we're just repeating ourselves. Cheers mate.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 27 Apr 16 6.04pm

Originally posted by Seth

If you read what I wrote, I agreed it was inexcusable, but is irrelevant to Hillsborough. They shouldn't do it, nor should anyone, but gladly we've come a long way since 1989 and hopefully the result couldn't be the same today.

Think we're just going to have to agree to differ on this one Rudi. I don't think we're far apart, but we're just repeating ourselves. Cheers mate.

As am I. Up The Palace!

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Hillsborough Verdict