You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Anti Pardew fans out!
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Anti Pardew fans out!


Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Part Time James Flag 19 Sep 16 9.24am

So the two extreme poles on Pardew are either saying:

Pro:
He's got two wins now with a team he was more able to construct himself which is when you are able to start evaluating the true ability of a manager

Anti:
He's a streaky manager and we could just so easily go on another losing streak

We've just beaten two mediocre teams, nothing to get excited about yet

But actually, none of us YET have proof for or against any of the things above and we must continue to wait.

In reality we all ought to be open minded (I'm not telling anyone that they have to be though) because time will tell. None of us can rule out the possibility of Pardew moving us onwards and upwards from the 10th place finish the season before last. But on the flip side, none of us can state as a fact that he will.

I am optimistic, but I don't think I could take an extreme stance (pro or anti) at this moment in time.

 




rikz Flag Croydon 19 Sep 16 9.39am

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

And still people aren't happy as it was 'only' Boro & Stoke. Wins are wins, regardless who the opposition is. If you can't enjoy it why bother at all?

With our illustrious history competing at the top of the football pyramid and our huge fan Base can you blame them.

 

Part Time James Flag 19 Sep 16 9.46am

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

And still people aren't happy as it was 'only' Boro & Stoke. Wins are wins, regardless who the opposition is. If you can't enjoy it why bother at all?

Exactly, there is an old expression we used to use when we went clubbing in my youth:

"A mouth's a mouth"

A good analogy I feel.

 




johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 19 Sep 16 9.52am

[quote=Kermit8;Aye

Exactly. And it was the manner of the wins too. All good stuff. Obvious that Pardew hasn't lost the dressing room nor lost the plot. He just needed to buy and tinker a bit and the players themselves needed to up their own personal game. Took him eight months but he is our Super Al and he had earned that period.

And well done Parish for not undermining him or hinting at hte sack ever.

 

cpj Flag Kent 19 Sep 16 9.53am

Great performance yesterday - one of our best since we came up. However, it was against a poor Stoke side bottom of the table who we have now beaten 6 times in 8 games since we came up. Our only other two wins in 2016 were against a Norwich side on the way don and a 'Boro side who have just come up.

Only two wins in the second half of last season was the worst run in the league (bar Villa) and could not just be excused by injuries, and although we got to the Cup Final we failed to win against a very average Man Utd side.

Let's see how we get on in the next few games before the calls for Pardew to be England manager or get an OBE or anything else.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 19 Sep 16 9.56am

I turned to the guy next to me on Saturday when the second goal went in and said that if people want Pardew out, they should be brave enough to chant it when the team is winning not just when losing, then at least they would prove they have at least a little backbone and substance.

 

Part Time James Flag 19 Sep 16 10.35am

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

I turned to the guy next to me on Saturday when the second goal went in and said that if people want Pardew out, they should be brave enough to chant it when the team is winning not just when losing, then at least they would prove they have at least a little backbone and substance.

This made me smile and I think I agree.

Trouble is, it'd probably be seen as an ironic pop at Newcastle.

Where are those know-it-all Geordies that came on here "in peace" at the moment? They could still give this a negative spin if they really fancied. I'd have had more respect for them if they'd come on and said "we know this debate is ill-timed and will get under your skin a bit" because I actually believed they did want a sensible debate to an extent but were lying to us and maybe themselves by trying to make out they weren't also crowing in the process.

 




kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 19 Sep 16 10.37am

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

And still people aren't happy as it was 'only' Boro & Stoke. Wins are wins, regardless who the opposition is. If you can't enjoy it why bother at all?

I don't think anyone hasn't enjoyed the two wins. I think they're saying after 4 seasons in the Prem we should really be expected to beat two, let's face it quite poor sides.

It appears that anyone who has dared to raise concerns over the worst run out of any European team in 2016 is basically being branded as deluded, not a 'real' supporter and not supporting the club. It's almost as deluded as anyone who thinks that our form in 2016 was purely down to injuries alone.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

citizensmudge Flag midlands 19 Sep 16 10.50am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I don't think anyone hasn't enjoyed the two wins. I think they're saying after 4 seasons in the Prem we should really be expected to beat two, let's face it quite poor sides.

It appears that anyone who has dared to raise concerns over the worst run out of any European team in 2016 is basically being branded as deluded, not a 'real' supporter and not supporting the club. It's almost as deluded as anyone who thinks that our form in 2016 was purely down to injuries alone.

Raising concerns would be fine as would saying your piece on the decline in the second half of last season but the relentless negativity and AP bashing is what the problem was.None of us ever said AP was blameless but you lot gave him no credit for anything despite the FA Cup and no relegation.Credit where credits due you are at least still posting whereas a lot of the anti-AP lot are nowhere to be seen.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 19 Sep 16 10.55am

Originally posted by Part Time James

This made me smile and I think I agree.

Trouble is, it'd probably be seen as an ironic pop at Newcastle.

Where are those know-it-all Geordies that came on here "in peace" at the moment? They could still give this a negative spin if they really fancied. I'd have had more respect for them if they'd come on and said "we know this debate is ill-timed and will get under your skin a bit" because I actually believed they did want a sensible debate to an extent but were lying to us and maybe themselves by trying to make out they weren't also crowing in the process.

Reading some of the comments on various posts, seems our own fans are giving it a good go at putting a negative spin on things!

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 19 Sep 16 10.56am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

Raising concerns would be fine as would saying your piece on the decline in the second half of last season but the relentless negativity and AP bashing is what the problem was.None of us ever said AP was blameless but you lot gave him no credit for anything despite the FA Cup and no relegation.Credit where credits due you are at least still posting whereas a lot of the anti-AP lot are nowhere to be seen.

I may be a bit anti AP but I would like to add that at no point in any of my posts have I called for him to be sacked. I said after the spurs game that the Bournemouth, Boro, stoke and Sunderland games were crucial and a return of anything less than 7 points from those 4 games should really result in us reviewing his position.

Anyhow we have 7 points with a game to spare so hopefully now we can kick on and find some decent form over a longer period than just two games. Believe it or not I want him to succeed. I was merely concerned with a run, which in reality was pretty shocking.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Sep 16 11.00am

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

[quote=Kermit8;Aye

Exactly. And it was the manner of the wins too. All good stuff. Obvious that Pardew hasn't lost the dressing room nor lost the plot. He just needed to buy and tinker a bit and the players themselves needed to up their own personal game. Took him eight months but he is our Super Al and he had earned that period.

And well done Parish for not undermining him or hinting at hte sack ever.

Did anyone else notice that when the cries of "...getting sacked in the morning..." towards Hughes started, Pards asked the crowd to stop...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

citizensmudge Flag midlands 19 Sep 16 11.03am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I may be a bit anti AP but I would like to add that at no point in any of my posts have I called for him to be sacked. I said after the spurs game that the Bournemouth, Boro, stoke and Sunderland games were crucial and a return of anything less than 7 points from those 4 games should really result in us reviewing his position.

Anyhow we have 7 points with a game to spare so hopefully now we can kick on and find some decent form over a longer period than just two games. Believe it or not I want him to succeed. I was merely concerned with a run, which in reality was pretty shocking.

I used "you lot" in the broadest sense I wasn't accusing you of specifics despite the fact I remember reading some of your negative crap.There are only a handful of real idiots and they are not currently on here surprise surprise.Like I said before you have my respect for getting involved despite not being a fan of AP it shows you are at least a Palace supporter whatever your viewpoint.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 16 11.11am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I may be a bit anti AP but I would like to add that at no point in any of my posts have I called for him to be sacked. I said after the spurs game that the Bournemouth, Boro, stoke and Sunderland games were crucial and a return of anything less than 7 points from those 4 games should really result in us reviewing his position.

Anyhow we have 7 points with a game to spare so hopefully now we can kick on and find some decent form over a longer period than just two games. Believe it or not I want him to succeed. I was merely concerned with a run, which in reality was pretty shocking.

That's fair. I also didn't want him sacked. That's because it would mean we're doing really sh1t. The time to do it would've been the summer but Parish trusted him to buy big in small quantities rather than the likes of Mutch.

What concerns me is not being able to grind out results and there's a few games coming up that may require that. During our sh1ttest run in history we ground out 1 result. A draw at Swansea away. The others we struggled or threw points down the toilet. Sunderland away, vs Liverpool's 10 men and in the lead being among the worst.

Claims Pardew is suddenly amazing again and we're going to finish much higher than mid-table are plain ridiculous and as ridiculous as thoughts when we were 5th last season. We've got some tough matches coming up after Sunderland away and where we are then may reflect where we are a bit longer term. Possibly a bit below mid-table and. I am happy and realistic with that level.

 


COYP

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 19 Sep 16 11.31am

Originally posted by rikz

With our illustrious history competing at the top of the football pyramid and our huge fan Base can you blame them.

Yes I can.

Football takes place over a season. This is a brand new season and this is where the club should be judged. We had a fantastic transfer window and the team has clicked. Last season is done, over, finished. Instead of four wins in 2016 how about judging two wins in five games?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 19 Sep 16 11.31am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Claims Pardew is suddenly amazing again and we're going to finish much higher than mid-table are plain ridiculous and as ridiculous as thoughts when we were 5th last season. We've got some tough matches coming up after Sunderland away and where we are then may reflect where we are a bit longer term. Possibly a bit below mid-table and. I am happy and realistic with that level.


I'd say you've got that pretty much spot on. I had a look at last term's final table and, if we carry on picking up points at the same rate we are now, we should end up just above or below midway; anything better would be a bonus.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

rikz Flag Croydon 19 Sep 16 1.30pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

That's fair. I also didn't want him sacked. That's because it would mean we're doing really sh1t. The time to do it would've been the summer but Parish trusted him to buy big in small quantities rather than the likes of Mutch.

What concerns me is not being able to grind out results and there's a few games coming up that may require that. During our sh1ttest run in history we ground out 1 result. A draw at Swansea away. The others we struggled or threw points down the toilet. Sunderland away, vs Liverpool's 10 men and in the lead being among the worst.

Claims Pardew is suddenly amazing again and we're going to finish much higher than mid-table are plain ridiculous
and as ridiculous as thoughts when we were 5th last season. We've got some tough matches coming up after Sunderland away and where we are then may reflect where we are a bit longer term. Possibly a bit below mid-table and. I am happy and realistic with that level.

Who's claimed that then, maybe one or two posters, most posters are realistic enough to realise that we could finish anywhere between 8th and 20th, aslong as it's 8th-17th then that's all that matters. Our chances of getting relegated icrease after backing a manager to build a squad over 2 years then replacing him with someone unknown that could backfire massively.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 19 Sep 16 1.49pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Did anyone else notice that when the cries of "...getting sacked in the morning..." towards Hughes started, Pards asked the crowd to stop...

Yeah we saw that - he talked about it bit in the press conference after, said that he had been through it and that Hughes didn't deserve it or something like that.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 19 Sep 16 1.51pm

Originally posted by bexleydave


I'd say you've got that pretty much spot on. I had a look at last term's final table and, if we carry on picking up points at the same rate we are now, we should end up just above or below midway; anything better would be a bonus.

Yes. I see that as a realistic goal. One I would be happy with.

 


@sxp55555

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 19 Sep 16 7.45pm

I don't think many think Pardew is the Second Coming, but he's arguably one of the most successful Managers Palace have had in decades.

Bar Pulis, most Palace managers manage to get relegated from the PL. I'm realistic about what a Manager can achieve, though optimistic the odds are improving.

Blaming Pardew for not being able to land players in January was ludicrous. Parrish landed who he could afford, and who could be convinced to come. Unfortunately it was only Ade.

Apparently now that we sit in 8th we should only be excited if we beat teams above us, because every other team is a poor premier league team that we don't rate. Sigh.

The Pardew-out crowd will be excited that Mark Hughes will soon be available, because he is clearly a much better manager than Pards.

Heck Slaven Bilic or David Moyes might be free soon too, all these better managers....

 

Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Anti Pardew fans out!