You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Shearer MOTD
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Shearer MOTD


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
linguini Flag UK 30 Oct 16 8.02am

I think he needs to be shown a red card. Probably a nice fella but a very predictable and boring pundit. Seems he will never concede that Zaha is fouled. Yawn...

 

Salford eagle Flag 30 Oct 16 8.25am

Especially when you have Murphy next to him (ex Liverpool) stating it's a definite penalty.

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Oct 16 8.30am

Originally posted by Salford eagle

Especially when you have Murphy next to him (ex Liverpool) stating it's a definite penalty.

Murphy is a real student of the game and a while back I heard that Martin Tyler expressed the view that he would be a manager one day.Maybe he isn't interested in going down that route but would prefer to continue with media work.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 30 Oct 16 8.38am

We all know that the perceived big clubs, never get preferential treatment, but last season a clear dive by Benteke, a Liverpool player was unanimously declared an excellent piece of reffing by all the ex playing pundit fraternity. After watching 12 angles in super slo-mo and zooming in on Benteke's studs they were all happy that contact means foul and well done Liverpool.
Yesterday Wilf was knocked off balance and stumbled over the next defender, yes no contact there, but the original clip just outside the area caused the stumble, but no, he " went down to easily" (the latest meaningless mantra) so no foul apparently.
Second time clear foul, contact, trip, barge, all on Wilf in the area and so far only Danny Murphy has called it fairly. Clear penalty all day long and potentially the third equaliser of an enthralling game and then who knows what happens, especially if Cān walks, which IMO opinion he shouldn't, because not every foul is or should be a booking.
Thirdly the challenge on Benteke, the clearest of all the fouls to me, was a "clumsy" challenge, so clearly clumsy challenges are not fouls, no matter how badly you impede the player. The conspiracy theorist in me believes that two of these would of clearly been given against us, three at Anfield and all the "experts" and boy do I use that term lightly, would of sanctioned every one of them.
It really does seem that a foul on any other player in the league is not a foul on Wilf and for anyone who claims he goes looking for them, well that's his and every other tricky wingers job and he doesn't go down anywhere near as easily as old FFS.

Edited by Dangermouse (30 Oct 2016 8.39am)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Neilsym26 Flag Bromley 30 Oct 16 10.00am

I have to say I don't think I've ever disagreed with anything Danny Murphy has said. I love listening to what he has to say. He seems to always say good things about palace and to be fair most are pretty much justified. Shearer on the other hand seems to be totally the opposite.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Oct 16 10.04am

Originally posted by Neilsym26

I have to say I don't think I've ever disagreed with anything Danny Murphy has said. I love listening to what he has to say. He seems to always say good things about palace and to be fair most are pretty much justified. Shearer on the other hand seems to be totally the opposite.

Danny Murphy has always been a great thinker of the game.As a player he used to read the game brilliantly and Houllier once commented that he reminded him of Platini in this respect.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 30 Oct 16 10.09am

Originally posted by Neilsym26

I have to say I don't think I've ever disagreed with anything Danny Murphy has said. I love listening to what he has to say. He seems to always say good things about palace and to be fair most are pretty much justified. Shearer on the other hand seems to be totally the opposite.

His mrs is also one of my all time faves and smokin hot.

 

Hoof Hearted 30 Oct 16 10.16am

What is Shearer's beef with us?

He NEVER gives us any credit when we win, consistently denies us a penalty in attack and always agrees with all penalties given against us.

Who or what at Palace has p1ssed him off? It can't be just Pardew or Warnock... Shearer has always hated us in my experience.

Murphy made him look a right grumpy muppet last night!

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 30 Oct 16 10.22am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

We all know that the perceived big clubs, never get preferential treatment, but last season a clear dive by Benteke, a Liverpool player was unanimously declared an excellent piece of reffing by all the ex playing pundit fraternity. After watching 12 angles in super slo-mo and zooming in on Benteke's studs they were all happy that contact means foul and well done Liverpool.
Yesterday Wilf was knocked off balance and stumbled over the next defender, yes no contact there, but the original clip just outside the area caused the stumble, but no, he " went down to easily" (the latest meaningless mantra) so no foul apparently.
Second time clear foul, contact, trip, barge, all on Wilf in the area and so far only Danny Murphy has called it fairly. Clear penalty all day long and potentially the third equaliser of an enthralling game and then who knows what happens, especially if Cān walks, which IMO opinion he shouldn't, because not every foul is or should be a booking.
Thirdly the challenge on Benteke, the clearest of all the fouls to me, was a "clumsy" challenge, so clearly clumsy challenges are not fouls, no matter how badly you impede the player. The conspiracy theorist in me believes that two of these would of clearly been given against us, three at Anfield and all the "experts" and boy do I use that term lightly, would of sanctioned every one of them.
It really does seem that a foul on any other player in the league is not a foul on Wilf and for anyone who claims he goes looking for them, well that's his and every other tricky wingers job and he doesn't go down anywhere near as easily as old FFS.

Edited by Dangermouse (30 Oct 2016 8.39am)

Very good argument .

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 30 Oct 16 10.52am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

What is Shearer's beef with us?

He NEVER gives us any credit when we win, consistently denies us a penalty in attack and always agrees with all penalties given against us.

Who or what at Palace has p1ssed him off? It can't be just Pardew or Warnock... Shearer has always hated us in my experience.

Murphy made him look a right grumpy muppet last night!

Hoof I think you are wrong....only in as much that I think as a geordie he has an ingrained hatred of Pardew

 

Hoof Hearted 30 Oct 16 10.57am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Hoof I think you are wrong....only in as much that I think as a geordie he has an ingrained hatred of Pardew

I agree that he probably hates Pardew, but that has only ingrained his previous disdain for us... as I said even before that with Warnock, where almost every pundit hated us because of Colin's antagonistic persona.

Shearer has bad mouthed since day one of joining MOTD and I'd like to know why?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 30 Oct 16 11.01am

Another point of Motd. They didn't show the flares set off by liverpool fans and thrown into the pitch. If that was palace fans do you think they would have mentioned it? And hos did they get them into the ground, is it just home fNa that are searched.

Edited by spartakev2 (30 Oct 2016 11.03am)

 

Hoof Hearted 30 Oct 16 11.10am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Another point of Motd. They didn't show the flares set off by liverpool fans and thrown into the pitch. If that was palace fans do you think they would have mentioned it?

Oh yes.... Jug Ears Lineker and Baldy Shearer would have campaigned for it like they did for Jedi and Wickham's FA bans for elbowing opponents.

West Ham and Liverpool are given special treatment by BBC/MOTD as regards fans behaviour.... Both club's fans would never get drunk, turn up without tickets, fight, throw coins or generally do anything naughty.

Singing Bubbles and YNWA typifies both clubs as community spirited, fun and friendly paragons of virtue in the minds of BBC/MOTD.

The thought of them throwing bottles at a Man Utd coach full of players or throwing a flare on the pitch?

Preposterous Hogwash!

 

gambler Flag Kent 30 Oct 16 11.17am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Another point of Motd. They didn't show the flares set off by liverpool fans and thrown into the pitch. If that was palace fans do you think they would have mentioned it? And hos did they get them into the ground, is it just home fNa that are searched.

Edited by spartakev2 (30 Oct 2016 11.03am)

Walked past their entrances. They were being searched. And there were a couple of sniffer dogs going through the queues.

Edited by gambler (30 Oct 2016 11.19am)

 

elgrande Flag bedford 30 Oct 16 11.22am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

I agree that he probably hates Pardew, but that has only ingrained his previous disdain for us... as I said even before that with Warnock, where almost every pundit hated us because of Colin's antagonistic persona.

Shearer has bad mouthed since day one of joining MOTD and I'd like to know why?

Parish called him out over comments he made about Wilf a couple of months ago Hoof.
He didn't take it well....bald geordie c***

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

becky Flag over the moon 30 Oct 16 11.36am

Neither did anyone mention the Liverpool player that took off his shirt to celebrate scoring - thought that was still a bookable offence as directed by FIFA - unless they relaxed it this year?

(and which would have meant he was sent off later when he got another card!)

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

elgrande Flag bedford 30 Oct 16 11.47am

Originally posted by becky

Neither did anyone mention the Liverpool player that took off his shirt to celebrate scoring - thought that was still a bookable offence as directed by FIFA - unless they relaxed it this year?

(and which would have meant he was sent off later when he got another card!)

He did get booked becky.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 16 11.52am

Originally posted by Willo

Danny Murphy has always been a great thinker of the game.As a player he used to read the game brilliantly and Houllier once commented that he reminded him of Platini in this respect.

I think it was Houllier who Murphy is p1ssed off with after not being told he wasn't going to feature any more.

 


COYP

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 30 Oct 16 12.11pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

What is Shearer's beef with us?

He NEVER gives us any credit when we win, consistently denies us a penalty in attack and always agrees with all penalties given against us.

Who or what at Palace has p1ssed him off? It can't be just Pardew or Warnock... Shearer has always hated us in my experience.

Murphy made him look a right grumpy muppet last night!

And I noticed that in Shearer's "analysis" two great saves by Mandanda weren't great saves at all - they were just evidence that Liverpool deserved to win by more.

 

bicycle repair man 30 Oct 16 12.19pm

I don't know what the BBC pay Shearer but they could save themselves some money,a cardboard cut -out could do just as good a job.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Shearer MOTD