You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Fifa and the poppy saga
November 22 2026 12.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Fifa and the poppy saga


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Nov 16 10.46am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Jamie, it was the 1st war with the coverage. If not it wouldn't have had so many objectors.

Although this might actually go back in origin to the US Civil War which was the first to have photographic reporting and journalists.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 04 Nov 16 11.07am

Originally posted by Willo

But those who choose NOT to wear one when the rest of the team are adorning them are villified and pilloried. I am thinking of James McClean of WBA.

Mc Clean gets slaughtered every year for it but not a word is said about Robert huth or others that don't

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Nov 16 11.18am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Although this might actually go back in origin to the US Civil War which was the first to have photographic reporting and journalists.

Nothing as powerful as the moving image which is shown during meal times or in tv shops when on your lunch break.

Obviously matters were different with soldiers prepared to blow themselves up to kill a few US soldiers and fight till they and their families die as long as they defend their village and/or political views.

Didn't learn though. Meddling in other cultures and foreign terrain to leave liberate countries thousands of miles away. Now where did that go wrong after Vietnam?

 


COYP

elgrande Flag bedford 04 Nov 16 1.55pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

My grandad got blown up at Vimy Ridge, they patched him up and sent him back to war. Afterwards he said it was an awful waste and deeply resented having been sent to war and losing the use of his leg.

My father got shrapnel wounds at Monte Casino.

It was important to them to remember lost comrades. And they respected the 'enemy's' right to do the same.

To me this is not political, it is remembrance without critique. Decrying the concept is like saying you can't do anything special for the Day of the Dead in Mexico.

It's what we do, it isn't advertising, it isn't political and it's important.

Edited by Mapletree (03 Nov 2016 4.33pm)

My father was at monte casino maple, royal artillery,also scilly and North Africa.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 04 Nov 16 2.07pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

55,280 US Servicemen according to US statistics, of which 40,934 were killed in Action and an additional 122 presumed dead (of which 32 have been confirmed). Of the 55280 1201 were declared dead (MIA's etc).

178 died in Thailand!

An additional 5299 died as a result of wounds received in action (to the 40,934).

The state in the US with the highest number of casualties was California (5575)

[Link]

55,000 is still a lot of men. As I said, the public tolerance for war casualties is low. If the US or Britain lost 55,000 troops now there would be outrage.

Never the less, President Putin is watching so we cannot become soft in the way that Corbynistas would like.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Nov 16 2.25pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

55,000 is still a lot of men. As I said, the public tolerance for war casualties is low. If the US or Britain lost 55,000 troops now there would be outrage.

Never the less, President Putin is watching so we cannot become soft in the way that Corbynistas would like.


In terms of a war its not. That said most of those casualties occurred over a five or six year period. Not compared to between 450-1m VC and NVA deaths. Given the scale of the conflict, the US fatalities are surprisingly low (Of course any single year of that six year period would probably be unacceptable in post-Vietnam US military deployments).

Probably more significant though is the 153,303 Wounded in Action of around 300,000 wounded that required hospital care (Probably the advances in battlefield medicine as a result of WWII and the Korean War meant US fatalities were lower, but serious and significant injuries were higher) and these of course returned home as a permanent testament to the war.

The much shorter, Korean war claimed around 35,000 US servicemen.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (04 Nov 2016 2.26pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 04 Nov 16 2.28pm

my view for what its worth
am ex military, grandad fought in india, great grandfather got gassed on western front...father in law (sadly no longer with us) did loads for the british legion, i wear a poppy..
but not sure where I stand with this story, I can see where FIFA are coming from, again can see the other view...what I dont like is this Daily Mail type vitrol that is starting to appear if you dont conform and wear a poppy, would have thought with all the crap that is going on with Brexit etc the PM would have more important things to be doing then pander to the right wing press. What would happen if say Rooney refused to wear one??

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 04 Nov 16 2.34pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721


In terms of a war its not. That said most of those casualties occurred over a five or six year period. Not compared to between 450-1m VC and NVA deaths. Given the scale of the conflict, the US fatalities are surprisingly low (Of course any single year of that six year period would probably be unacceptable in post-Vietnam US military deployments).

Probably more significant though is the 153,303 Wounded in Action of around 300,000 wounded that required hospital care (Probably the advances in battlefield medicine as a result of WWII and the Korean War meant US fatalities were lower, but serious and significant injuries were higher) and these of course returned home as a permanent testament to the war.

The much shorter, Korean war claimed around 35,000 US servicemen.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (04 Nov 2016 2.26pm)


I think you are missing the point. This is about perception and the detachment of the public from the reality of conflict and an increased pacificism.
The closest my generation has got to war unless they joined the army was maybe worrying that the Falklands war would escalate and conscription would occur.
The historical reality is not the issue.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Nov 16 2.44pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


I think you are missing the point. This is about perception and the detachment of the public from the reality of conflict and an increased pacificism.
The closest my generation has got to war unless they joined the army was maybe worrying that the Falklands war would escalate and conscription would occur.
The historical reality is not the issue.

I think that's probably true, that the reality of war in an increasingly media aware society, is much more pronounced. I think society can be quite 'blood thirsty' in its demands, but quickly shocked into apathy when the bodies start coming home, and the conflict draws out.

Also though I think the Falklands is an oddity in British Deployments, as it was to 'liberate British Territories', even if on hearing of the invasion most people thought the Falklands were off the coast of Scotland somewhere

Conflicts like Afghanistan and Iraq, have a much more abstracted meaning in terms of sacrifice of British Soldiers. We tend to see them as lives lost to pursue political agendas, rather than national security.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 04 Nov 16 3.19pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think that's probably true, that the reality of war in an increasingly media aware society, is much more pronounced. I think society can be quite 'blood thirsty' in its demands, but quickly shocked into apathy when the bodies start coming home, and the conflict draws out.

Also though I think the Falklands is an oddity in British Deployments, as it was to 'liberate British Territories', even if on hearing of the invasion most people thought the Falklands were off the coast of Scotland somewhere

Conflicts like Afghanistan and Iraq, have a much more abstracted meaning in terms of sacrifice of British Soldiers. We tend to see them as lives lost to pursue political agendas, rather than national security.


As I recall someone at Newsnight noticed that the Falklands didn't appear on their big map of the world on the day of the invasion and someone had to hastily add it for that nights edition.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 04 Nov 16 3.29pm

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

my view for what its worth
am ex military, grandad fought in india, great grandfather got gassed on western front...father in law (sadly no longer with us) did loads for the british legion, i wear a poppy..
but not sure where I stand with this story, I can see where FIFA are coming from, again can see the other view...what I dont like is this Daily Mail type vitrol that is starting to appear if you dont conform and wear a poppy, would have thought with all the crap that is going on with Brexit etc the PM would have more important things to be doing then pander to the right wing press. What would happen if say Rooney refused to wear one??

Good post

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 04 Nov 16 4.08pm

yes agree - have to say also that the tabloids reached a new low this morning.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 04 Nov 16 4.11pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

yes agree - have to say also that the tabloids reached a new low this morning.

Particularly The Sun darkening the skin colour of the person who brought the case against the Government - and with a nod to another topic - editing out the poppy she was wearing

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 04 Nov 16 4.13pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Particularly The Sun darkening the skin colour of the person who brought the case against the Government - and with a nod to another topic - editing out the poppy she was wearing

According to some, the sun didn't do that, but the times did lighten her skin tone.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 04 Nov 16 4.19pm

haha - how appalling nothing is beneath them.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 04 Nov 16 4.41pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

According to some, the sun didn't do that, but the times did lighten her skin tone.

After you posted I did some more research and there does seem something unreliable about how skin tone appears - especially in a cut down photo.

Now has the Sun earned the benefit of the doubt by its history of fair reporting or is their front page fair and even handed.....hmmmm

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 04 Nov 16 4.43pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

After you posted I did some more research and there does seem something unreliable about how skin tone appears - especially in a cut down photo.

Now has the Sun earned the benefit of the doubt by its history of fair reporting or is their front page fair and even handed.....hmmmm

Amazes me that anyone buys The Sun. Andrex is softer and doesn't leave you with ink all over your arse

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

johnfirewall Flag 04 Nov 16 5.31pm

It's a shame this will undoubtedly perpetuate the debate over everyone's right to not wear one. I prefer a situation where everyone does whatever the fcuk they want. At least there's now a white poppy. I suppose that's progressive rather than the traditional protest response.

Obviously illogical angle from FIFA when you consider Blatter allowed it.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 04 Nov 16 6.01pm

First casualty [Link]

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

blackpalacefan Flag 04 Nov 16 10.00pm

I've never thought of the poppy as a political symbol. A fuss over nothing from FIFA. They should get their own house in order.

Edited by blackpalacefan (04 Nov 2016 10.01pm)

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Fifa and the poppy saga