You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > "Pardew's gutting of the dressing room's leaders"
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

"Pardew's gutting of the dressing room's leaders"


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Phil H Flag 04 Jan 17 9.53pm

Interesting article in the Independent today suggests Big Sam has taken on more than he bargained for because of Pardew's "notable tactic" of removing teams' strong characters wherever he manages. This makes sense of AP's streaks because all is fine when it's going well but you need the Jedi's when it's going t1ts up. Like last night. At least Hennessey was doing some yelling.

[Link]

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Jan 17 10.08pm

Jedinak is not the sort of character you can just replace but he was in decline, not a first choice and needed half a dozen games to get match fit.

MacArthur and Ledley had looked our best pairing during 2014-15 IMO.

Speroni's sudden demotion to third choice when he'd had a decent season was bollocks and Pardew and Woodman have looked clueless on the GK front.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 04 Jan 17 10.37pm

Great article I thought... Sam has a massive job on his hands. Trying to galvanise a team that has been pretty poor for 12 months now.

The banners and 'holier than thou' attitude of some Palace fans at his appointment baffles me. People pining for Pardew is nothing short of ridiculous and pathetic. Look at our squad... Threadbare and average... And whose fault is that??

The bloke has had 10 days in the job in what is well known to be the worst 2 weeks of the season with regards to fixture congestion... what did people expect for us to be pinging the ball around like Barca?

This is gonna take time. When you've been s*** for 12 months and a rot has set in you can't just snap out of it. He has got a lot of fixing to do of someone else's damage.

Maybe we should get behind him and the team rather than making ourselves look more like the geordie supporters we love to hate by holding up pathetic banners and the like after 10 days.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 04 Jan 17 10.59pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Great article I thought... Sam has a massive job on his hands. Trying to galvanise a team that has been pretty poor for 12 months now.

The banners and 'holier than thou' attitude of some Palace fans at his appointment baffles me. People pining for Pardew is nothing short of ridiculous and pathetic. Look at our squad... Threadbare and average... And whose fault is that??

The bloke has had 10 days in the job in what is well known to be the worst 2 weeks of the season with regards to fixture congestion... what did people expect for us to be pinging the ball around like Barca?

This is gonna take time. When you've been s*** for 12 months and a rot has set in you can't just snap out of it. He has got a lot of fixing to do of someone else's damage.

Maybe we should get behind him and the team rather than making ourselves look more like the geordie supporters we love to hate by holding up pathetic banners and the like after 10 days.

Couldn't agree with this more. We just have to get behind the team. We have 12 days until our next Premier League fixture. I want to see our fans out in support.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 04 Jan 17 11.08pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Great article I thought... Sam has a massive job on his hands. Trying to galvanise a team that has been pretty poor for 12 months now.

The banners and 'holier than thou' attitude of some Palace fans at his appointment baffles me. People pining for Pardew is nothing short of ridiculous and pathetic. Look at our squad... Threadbare and average... And whose fault is that??

The bloke has had 10 days in the job in what is well known to be the worst 2 weeks of the season with regards to fixture congestion... what did people expect for us to be pinging the ball around like Barca?

This is gonna take time. When you've been s*** for 12 months and a rot has set in you can't just snap out of it. He has got a lot of fixing to do of someone else's damage.

Maybe we should get behind him and the team rather than making ourselves look more like the geordie supporters we love to hate by holding up pathetic banners and the like after 10 days.


Well said. The fact that people genuinely want him back and Sam out after a week in the job is absolutely staggering. The lack of belief, the lack of squad depth, the lack of organisation and the lack of fitness... all Pardew's fault. Just praying that he can keep us up and then really set about fixing it in the summer.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 05 Jan 17 1.50am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Great article I thought... Sam has a massive job on his hands. Trying to galvanise a team that has been pretty poor for 12 months now.

The banners and 'holier than thou' attitude of some Palace fans at his appointment baffles me. People pining for Pardew is nothing short of ridiculous and pathetic. Look at our squad... Threadbare and average... And whose fault is that??

The bloke has had 10 days in the job in what is well known to be the worst 2 weeks of the season with regards to fixture congestion... what did people expect for us to be pinging the ball around like Barca?

This is gonna take time. When you've been s*** for 12 months and a rot has set in you can't just snap out of it. He has got a lot of fixing to do of someone else's damage.

Maybe we should get behind him and the team rather than making ourselves look more like the geordie supporters we love to hate by holding up pathetic banners and the like after 10 days.

Top post!

 


[Link]

timbob Flag 05 Jan 17 2.11am

Very very well put positive post Ken and others

Surprised to see that sam did not make that much effort to connect with the crowd on his first appearance though

Please to see his honesty in the interviews

I agree let's get behind the team / management n be proud be palace by posting constructive and positive views, suggestions.

We as fans need to take responsibility for the way we are perceived by other fans and our own players need motivation especially when their confidence has had a good kicking....!

We need to have a place new players want to come to because the fans support and show solidarity that what we did have a reputation for across the premiership and I'm concerned our unique loyalty 'style' is being lost....!

Solidarity amongst our own is the most efficient psychology to scare away teams and intimidate them as we have done to teams like Liverpool in recent years

Coyp
R.i. P Staffie

 

Brisbane Eagle Flag Brisbane 05 Jan 17 2.15am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle


The Pardew era finished on Christmas Eve. The Swansea game was Sam's marker. It was his chance to set us up in his style but we were sent out as lambs. Three games gone and not a spark shown yet. I still have hope if nothing else to go on.

 

edskan Flag 05 Jan 17 7.05am

I've always thought MacArthur should step up and be captain. He has the drive and energy that needs to rub off on the other players.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Jan 17 8.21am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

The banners and 'holier than thou' attitude of some Palace fans at his appointment baffles me. People pining for Pardew is nothing short of ridiculous and pathetic. Look at our squad... Threadbare and average... And whose fault is that??

I didn't want Allardyce because of his history and I don't see what is wrong with that. No point in going through it all again as it was done to death at the time. The banners like everything else at the moment are a bit w***y but not wanting Sam doesn't equate to wanting to keep Pardew. I know I didn't want either.

There are lots of reported issues around AP wanting to be king but I am sorry this particular piece comes across as a little bias. I like Ed Malyon he is a great source for Palace news Jedinak wasn't the answer he played through most of the 2nd half of the season, as great a leader as he was for us, he couldn't stop the rot. Where we went wrong was not getting an upgrade with similar character in

Paddy Mcarthy, he had played literally one or two games for us in the prem and was shipped out long before Pardew arrived, getting injured or sent off in all his loan spells. To hang that on AP is blatantly unfair

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 05 Jan 17 8.28am

Originally posted by Phil H

Interesting article in the Independent today suggests Big Sam has taken on more than he bargained for because of Pardew's "notable tactic" of removing teams' strong characters wherever he manages. This makes sense of AP's streaks because all is fine when it's going well but you need the Jedi's when it's going t1ts up. Like last night. At least Hennessey was doing some yelling.

[Link]

great article, sums it up perfectly

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

The Dolphin Flag 05 Jan 17 9.22am

I have banged on about this for months and months on here - Pardew not wanting strong chacters in the dressing room - gooness knows why not but only he can answer that.
I repeat what I said when Jedi went - this will prove to be Pardew's single biggest mistake - and so it has proved to be.
Not everyone thought the best of Jedi's game but how we could have done with him recently.
He would have organised, galvanised, won headers we are not winning and tackled properly.
We need a strong defensive midfield player urgently (along with others of course)and yet AP took the Captaincy away from him (without telling him first if the story is to be believed) and then sold him.
What a T***er!

 

Username Flag Horsham 05 Jan 17 9.28am

Originally posted by Phil H

Interesting article in the Independent today suggests Big Sam has taken on more than he bargained for because of Pardew's "notable tactic" of removing teams' strong characters wherever he manages. This makes sense of AP's streaks because all is fine when it's going well but you need the Jedi's when it's going t1ts up. Like last night. At least Hennessey was doing some yelling.

[Link]


The slight problem I have with this theory is that Jedinak was largely poor last year when he did play. It's all well and good saying we need players like that when it goes tits up, but his record with the team in the second half of last season was P19 W1 D7 L11. It was already going tits up last season with him on the pitch and having very little impact.

Speroni? Maybe, but he's still in the dressing room and would be able to influence the team in that way, as Jedinak and McCarthy supposedly did last season? From a performance point of view, I'm not really sure goalkeeping is our biggest issue at the moment.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Beastie Flag 05 Jan 17 9.29am

"this catastrophic performance will guarantee that he is allowed to bring in his own players".

It’s this thought that gives me optimism.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Jan 17 9.32am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I have banged on about this for months and months on here - Pardew not wanting strong chacters in the dressing room - gooness knows why not but only he can answer that.
I repeat what I said when Jedi went - this will prove to be Pardew's single biggest mistake - and so it has proved to be.
Not everyone thought the best of Jedi's game but how we could have done with him recently.
He would have organised, galvanised, won headers we are not winning and tackled properly.
We need a strong defensive midfield player urgently (along with others of course)and yet AP took the Captaincy away from him (without telling him first if the story is to be believed) and then sold him.
What a T***er!

I don't want to sound like I am defending Pardew all the time but Jedinak at the time said Pardew had told him

We kept losing with Jedinak playing last year

The mistake was not getting an upgrade

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 05 Jan 17 9.33am

Pining for players who are past it or others like Gayle who had years to prove themselves and to be one of the first names on the team sheet but failed just shows how awful we have become.

The truth is, on paper at least, the best fifteen players in the squad now are mostly better footballers quality wise than the best fifteen we had three seasons ago.

What they haven't got now is drive, desire and shape. That's why we will get relegated.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


DANGERCLOSE Flag London 05 Jan 17 9.43am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Great article I thought... Sam has a massive job on his hands. Trying to galvanise a team that has been pretty poor for 12 months now.

The banners and 'holier than thou' attitude of some Palace fans at his appointment baffles me. People pining for Pardew is nothing short of ridiculous and pathetic. Look at our squad... Threadbare and average... And whose fault is that??

The bloke has had 10 days in the job in what is well known to be the worst 2 weeks of the season with regards to fixture congestion... what did people expect for us to be pinging the ball around like Barca?

This is gonna take time. When you've been s*** for 12 months and a rot has set in you can't just snap out of it. He has got a lot of fixing to do of someone else's damage.

Maybe we should get behind him and the team rather than making ourselves look more like the geordie supporters we love to hate by holding up pathetic banners and the like after 10 days.

Spot on

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 05 Jan 17 10.07am

Just read this in the I paper. Very well written sensible article. Speroni and delaney I feel are our most natural leaders and with speronis experience and level headed nature he could be a real anchor for the team if utilised properly

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 05 Jan 17 10.11am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

I don't want to sound like I am defending Pardew all the time but Jedinak at the time said Pardew had told him

We kept losing with Jedinak playing last year

The mistake was not getting an upgrade

Interesting , the opposite to Cabaye , who when he does not play we keep winning.

We need to sell Cabaye then maybe we could use his wages to get a Jedinak type player , the McJedly midfield was better than anything that included Cabaye.
If we had a Benteke type forward with McJedly, it would have been very interesting.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 Jan 17 10.12am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Great article I thought... Sam has a massive job on his hands. Trying to galvanise a team that has been pretty poor for 12 months now.

The banners and 'holier than thou' attitude of some Palace fans at his appointment baffles me. People pining for Pardew is nothing short of ridiculous and pathetic. Look at our squad... Threadbare and average... And whose fault is that??

The bloke has had 10 days in the job in what is well known to be the worst 2 weeks of the season with regards to fixture congestion... what did people expect for us to be pinging the ball around like Barca?

This is gonna take time. When you've been s*** for 12 months and a rot has set in you can't just snap out of it. He has got a lot of fixing to do of someone else's damage.

Maybe we should get behind him and the team rather than making ourselves look more like the geordie supporters we love to hate by holding up pathetic banners and the like after 10 days.

In the interests of fairness, I cannot remember a time where our squad had real depth and quality on the bench. We were a bit lucky I think in our first and second seasons in the top flight, to avoid any major injuries to key players (other than Murray in season 1). A few games here and there, but nothing too serious in terms of vital players.

Now we've got problems. Our most experienced team member is our physio!

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > "Pardew's gutting of the dressing room's leaders"